7/15/2005

Commissioners limit eminent domain: The Herald-Zeitung (New Braunfels TX), 7/15/05

By Ron Maloney

Anyone concerned by the June Supreme Court decision upholding New London, Conn.’s right to use eminent domain to condemn land for a shopping center can relax if they live here.

It’s not going to happen in Comal County.

Commissioners voted 4-1 Thursday to repudiate any new power the ruling might offer Comal County to seize land for economic development or commercial purposes.

The June 23 decision that extended eminent domain from public to private use in support of economic development sent shockwaves across the country that reverberated in the very fabric of Texas, a state where property rights are still regarded as paramount to all but the most important needs of the public.

The Texas Legislature is working to define or limit its impact here, and Comal County officials decided they wanted to spell out their view for their own constituents so there is no doubt.

“The bottom line from my perspective, and I hope from this commissioners’ court’s perspective, is that this resolution demonstrates to the public that this court doesn’t plan to expand the limited authority to exercise eminent domain granted us in 1925,” Precinct 2 Commissioner Jay Millikin said. “This is a proactive statement of the intent of this court. In my mind, we do not need to wait for the state or federal Supreme Court or legislatures to tell us what to do.”

Millikin acknowledged the irony of throwing away an opportunity for increased county authority after fighting for years for it in other areas.

“We will not go beyond the authority granted us in the Texas Local Government Code in 1925,” Millikin said.

Millikin made the motion to approve the resolution, which was seconded by Precinct 3 Commissioner Greg Parker.

“We’re taking a symbolic action to show the public that we regard taking of private property in this kind of way is not good for our citizens,” Parker said. “I think it is prudent for us to be proactive in this fight.”

County Judge Danny Scheel told the court that the Texas state Senate had passed a bill just Wednesday prohibiting taking of private property for economic development purposes.

“I don’t think it’s ever been the intention of this court to exercise this kind of power,” Scheel said. “When we were considering the (Mission Valley Mills) TIF [tax increment funding] project, we stated we did not support the taking of any private property to support that development down there.”

Scheel argued that Comal County didn’t need to get involved in the issue — that it would be dealt with by legislators at the state and national levels.

“I don’t think this is something this court needs to get into,” Scheel said. “The Legislature is handling it.”

Precinct 1 Commissioner Jack Dawson strongly disagreed.

“I don’t like what the Supreme Court did, so I’m going to support it,” Dawson said.

The resolution passed 4-1 with Scheel’s being the “no” vote.


The Herald-Zeitung: http://web.herald-zeitung.com

Protesters Decry Eminent Domain Ruling: Hundreds demonstrate: Shore Publishing (Madison CT), 7/15/05

By Stephen Chupaska

Just two weeks after the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in favor of the city in Kelo v. New London, the protest against the taking of homes in Fort Trumbull came full circle.

Chanting "Let Them Stay" and flying the Revolutionary War era "Don't Tread on Me" flag, close to 500 protesters rallied at New London' s municipal building on July 5, where five years ago, the City Council voted to authorize the use of eminent domain to seize the homes of Susette Kelo and the six other property owners.

Some demonstrators who could not find room to stand on the sidewalk in front of city hall watched from outside the Crocker House — which is partly owned by New London Development Corporation President Michael Joplin.

The rally took place before a scheduled City Council meeting, which did not have anything related to the decision or future development on its agenda.

Organized by the Washington, D.C., libertarian lobby group, Institute for Justice, it drew supporters from all over the Northeast and as far away as Kentucky and Texas.

"There has not been a Supreme Court case that has had such universal condemnation," said Scott Bullock, the attorney who argued the case before the high court. "There has been outrage at a time America is so divided."

Jim Perry, of Peterborough, N.H, and member of the libertarian Free State Project, said he drove down for the rally because "private property means private property."

Some took exception to the court's interpretation of the Fifth Amendment, which sanctions the takings clause.

Nine-year city resident Allan Nicklaus said the court went above the "original intent of eminent domain."

Fort Trumbull resident Nield Oldham, who called the rally "very encouraging," reiterated that the property owners were never against the NLDC's plans for the peninsula.

"It could have been an attractive neighborhood," he said. "They got it so wrong; now it's time to do it right."

Also present was state House Minority Leader Bob Ward (R-Wallingford), who said he would work on laws designed to curb the use of eminent domain.

Scott Sawyer, the property owners' local counsel, said he would like to find a way to keep the property owners' homes in Fort Trumbull.

"The city of New London," he said, "can become the city of solutions."

Bullock addressed the City Council at its meeting, but the council did not respond to any of the public comment about the Fort Trumbull development.

"It wasn't on the agenda," Councilor Beth Sabilia said.


Shore Publishing: www.shorepublishing.com

7/14/2005

Connecticut Declares Eminent Domain Moratorium: RedState.org, 7/13/05

By California Yankee

Connecticut's state legislators declared a moratorium Monday on the use of eminent domain in Connecticut. According to The [New London] Day no municipality, not even New London, can go forward with any eminent domain plans until the legislature revises the law to protect the rights of private homeowners.

Governor Rell issued a statement saying she supported the moratorium and urging the legislature to act without delay:
"This issue is the 21st-century equivalent of the Boston Tea Party: the government taking away the rights and liberties of property owners without giving them a voice," Rell said. "But this time it is not a monarch wearing robes in England we are fighting; it is five robed justices at the Supreme Court in Washington."

The state's overwhelmingly Democratic legislature must be taking a lot of heat over the U.S. Supreme Court's decision involving New London, which made it clear that government can seize your home and give it to a large corporation to build a mall, shopping center or office park. A Republican-led proposal to ban the taking of single-family homes for reasons other than public projects such as highways and government buildings was defeated last month.


RedState.org: www.redstate.org

Editor's note: This report has been found in error. Governor Rell has suggested a moratorium and support has been expressed by some members of the legislature, but no specific action has been taken.

Eminent domain law controversial, but not new: (Manchester CT) Journal Inquirer, 7/13/05

By Tom Breen

For nearly 40 years, [Connecticut] state law has allowed the seizure of property for private economic development under the principle of eminent domain.

But only in the last month has the law become a central focus of state politics — ever since the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that the city of New London can take homes in the Fort Trumbull neighborhood for a private development project.

Connecticut politicians, ranging from longtime Republican legislators to "smart growth" advocates in the Green Party, have denounced the ruling and the law that led to it, and have called for immediate changes to the statute.

Such changes are possible since the court ruled that the right to seize property for private development isn't a constitutional right, but can be prohibited by state law.

At least eight states — Maine, Arkansas, Florida, Kentucky, Illinois, Montana, South Carolina, and Washington — already forbid the use of eminent domain for private development except in cases of blight.

Now, Republicans in the General Assembly are calling for a special session of the legislature this year specifically to handle the eminent domain question.

Democrats, meanwhile, have been more circumspect, calling instead for a voluntary one-year moratorium on municipal uses of eminent domain for private development, and plan to schedule public hearings as early as this month.

"In light of the Supreme Court decision, we all should be concerned about the jeopardy that private property owners have been placed in," Sen. Eric D. Coleman, D-Bloomfield, co-chairman of the Planning and Development Committee, said in a statement Tuesday.

"But," he added, "unlike many, I would like to make the right response to the decision rather than merely a quick response. We need to take a comprehensive look at this issue to ensure that eminent domain is used properly in Connecticut."

However, as some point out, the General Assembly has been able to take just such a comprehensive look at the law since Lyndon Johnson was president.

Why the wait?

"This is not something brand new," Wesley Horton, the lawyer who argued on behalf of New London before the Supreme Court, said in a recent interview.

In his work for New London, Horton traced the law back to Public Act 760, known as the Home Rule Act, approved by the General Assembly and signed into law in 1967.

That law, which was modified slightly in 1972, allowed private companies designated as development agencies to "acquire by eminent domain real property located within the project area and real property and interests therein for rights-of-way and other easements," while acting in the name of the municipality.

Although the law has been in place for 38 years, it never has received close to this amount of attention, although some Republicans in the legislature say that's not for lack of trying.

Sen. David J. Cappiello, R-Danbury, said Monday that Republicans have raised bills in the previous two legislative sessions that would modify or scrap the current law, but that those bills never made it to the floor for a full vote.

"I thought it was a little bit disingenuous to wait two years before taking this issue up," he said.

Cappiello has requested a special session, but says his requests have not been answered so far.

"I hope this isn't breaking down along party lines, because this isn't a partisan issue," he said. "In my view, this is about the blatant abuse of government power."

House Minority Leader Robert M. Ward, R-North Branford, introduced both attempts to revise the law and said he thinks Republicans always have considered it a matter of concern.

"Republicans feel it's an urgent matter, but the Democratic leadership feels it's a matter to study for a long time," he said. He added that he believes pressure from Democratic city leaders has led legislative Democrats to move slowly.

While eminent domain may yet break along party lines in the legislature, outside it already has made for some strange political bedfellows.

"I think it's the first time I've found myself on the same side as Clarence Thomas," says Thomas Sevigny, a state Green Party leader who has been active in development controversies since at least the proposal to build an NFL stadium for the New England Patriots in Hartford.

Sevigny, like the Republicans, opposes the law allowing property to be seized for private development, but doesn't find anything odd in the fact that opposition has only now reached critical mass.

"The Supreme Court decision has obviously brought this to light," he said. "Especially when you have people who are saying, "No, we aren't moving.' It provides something for people to rally around."

When two legislative committees do convene their hearings into the question, they will have more than just the Home Rule Act to consider: According to the nonpartisan Office of Legislative Research, eminent domain is referenced in at least 80 statutes.


Journal Inquirer: www.zwire.com

Pol Seeks Eminent Domain Law Change: 1010 WINS (New York NY), 7/13/05

Not enough is being done to protect private property owners facing the seizure of their land by local governments pushing economic development projects, a state Assemblyman said Wednesday in announcing a bill to change New York's eminent domain law.

The bill by Assemblyman Richard Brodsky, a Westchester Democrat, follows last month's 5-4 decision by the U.S. Supreme Court saying cities may bulldoze people's homes to make way for shopping malls or other private development. The ruling gave local governments broad power to seize private property to generate tax revenue.

Brodsky, who has led investigations of industrial development agencies and local development corporations, said while economic growth is a legitimate goal, in many cases local authorities have done more for private companies than public good when seizing property for business development projects.

"You can call this a homeowner protection act," Brodsky said. "In many cases, eminent domain is a necessary part of progress, but when you're taking someone's private property and transferring it to another private owner, we need to be extremely careful and protective."

Under the bill the time property owners have to appeal condemnation decisions would be increased to 90 days from 30 days. Displaced residents would be paid at least 150 percent of the market value of their homes, Brodsky said.

The measure also would require eminent domain be used for economic development purposes only to forward a comprehensive plan developed in public meetings and approved by local legislators.

In the June court decision, Justice John Paul Stevens, writing for the majority, said the New London, Conn. could pursue private development under the Fifth Amendment, which allows governments to take private property if the land is for public use, since the project the city has in mind promises to bring more jobs and revenue.

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said the decision bowed to the rich and powerful at the expense of middle-class Americans.

The issue has been a hot topic around the country.

In Texas, lawmakers have proposed a constitutional amendment that would bar state or local governments from seizing private property mainly for economic development. Lawmakers in many states are now proposing new laws to shield property owners.

In Washington, legislation in the works would ban the use of federal funds for any project getting the go-ahead using the Kelo v. City of New London decision.


1010 WINS: http://1010wins.com

GOP candidates lobby to limit eminent domain: The (Hampton Roads VA) Virginian-Pilot , 7/14/05

By Michelle Washington

Republican candidates for governor, lieutenant governor and attorney general are calling for changes to state laws defining when a government can seize private property.

Sen. Bill Bolling, the GOP candidate for lieutenant governor, and Del. Bob McDonnell, the party’s attorney general candidate, held a telephone news conference this week to call for amendments to state laws and the Virginia constitution.

U.S. Del. Thelma Drake, R-2nd District, joined the conversation, and Republican gubernatorial candidate Jerry Kilgore gave written support.

Their proposals stemmed from the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling in Kelo v. New London, Conn., which allows the government to seize land for economic development under powers known as “eminent domain.”

The U.S. Constitution provides that government may seize land “for public use” if it pays the owners “just compensation.”

In the past, public uses have included schools, roads or military bases.

The Supreme Court’s decision expands the definition of public use and allows governments to seize property from unwilling sellers to create jobs or raise tax collections.

But the court also held that states may limit eminent domain power.

McDonnell, Bolling and Drake said they support amendments to Virginia’s constitution and statutes to limit the definition of “public use.”

As written, the state’s constitution says citizens “cannot be taxed, or deprived of, or damaged in, their property for public uses, without their own consent.”

The constitution does not enumerate public uses. The state’s code says: “The term 'public uses’ ... is hereby defined to embrace all uses which are necessary for public purposes.”

The Republicans in Tuesday’s news conference said “public use” should be better defined.

“Whatever public use means, it will not include the primary purpose of economic development or tax enhancement,” McDonnell said.

Drake said their efforts to define “public use” would not affect land on Granby Street in Norfolk that is being developed as a high-rise condominium. The federal government has said it is interested in the land to expand the Walter E. Hoffman U.S. Courthouse, which sits across the street. A courthouse is clearly a public use, Drake said.

Bolling said the state’s definition of “public use” has always been vague.

“There are legitimate ways to promote economic development,” Bolling said. “Don’t do it by seizing private property against the owner’s will.”


The Virginian-Pilot: http://home.hamptonroads.com

Eminent domain is a tool best left unused: Roslindale * West Roxbury (MA) Transcript, 7/14/05

Editorial

The Supreme Court's recent ruling on eminent domain brought dismay not just to anti-government conservatives, but to lots of others inclined to stick up for the little guy.

On a 5-4 vote, the court upheld the eminent domain taking of several small homes by a New London, Conn., development agency to make way for an upscale hotel/retail/residential complex. The majority ruled that government can seize private property and turn it over to a private developer even if the only public purpose served is economic development and the broader tax base it brings. Conservatives dissented strongly, declaring that the ruling substantially erased the distinction between "public use," which the Constitution allows in eminent domain proceedings, and private profit.

It should be noted, given the current debate over judicial philosophies that the conservative dissenters were the "activist" judges in this case. They were calling for precedents that had allowed similar takings in the past to be overturned. They were seeking to nullify the decisions of at least two legislative bodies in Connecticut.

To use President Bush's formulation, the conservative dissenters - Justices Rehnquist, Scalia, Thomas and O'Connor - were seeking to "legislate from the bench."

But while a stricter interpretation of the Constitution's takings clause has long been a conservative goal, abuse of eminent domain powers has long been a bipartisan practice.

The real divide is between powerful business interests allied with powerful politicians and the property owners standing in the way of their grand plans.

Before entering politics, George W. Bush was involved in a similar enterprise, getting local officials to seize property by eminent domain so his Texas Rangers could play baseball in a new stadium.

Eminent domain is nothing new in Boston. Within days of the Supreme Court ruling, we got a taste of how it might play out in the city.

Mayor Tom Menino, who considers the rebirth of the South Boston waterfront his personal legacy, is dissatisfied with the pace of the development company that owns the 21-acre Fan Pier property. Emboldened by the Supreme Court ruling, City Council President Michael Flaherty called on the city to seize the property under eminent domain and sell it to a developer who is more of a team player.

Menino has other tools to use against the developer, notably the threat to withdraw permits if progress continues to lag, and has resisted Flaherty's call. But you can see the problems with putting a tool as powerful as eminent domain in the hands of the politically powerful.

It's bad enough when a politically-connected developer can get government to seize a home in the way of its bulldozers. The idea that politicians can take private property away from an unfavored developer - who has already sunk millions into the project - and give it to a more favored developer is chilling.

One of the New London homeowners said recently that if someone from the city had come to him with an offer to purchase his property, he'd have listened. But all he got from the city was a notice his property was being seized. Why negotiate when you have the power to take the land now and determine the price later?

Could such a thing happen in West Roxbury and Roslindale? Sure it could, under the right economic situation.

It's that kind of arrogance that makes people of all political stripes regret the court's eminent domain ruling. It's worth noting, however, that the ruling doesn't force any governmental body to abuse eminent domain for private profit. Even New London can still change its mind.

That which is legal is not always wise. Government officials should recognize that eminent domain is one redevelopment tool best left on the shelf.


Roslindale * West Roxbury Transcript: www2.townonline.com/roslindale

Latest property snatch: Missouri: WorldNet Daily, 7/14/05

Local business owners blast City Hall for eminent-domain moves.
Business owners in Maplewood, Mo., fear loss of property.

The latest region worrying about property seizures by the government under eminent domain is the St. Louis suburb of Maplewood, Mo., where city officials are looking at the possibility of improving an area mostly filled with private businesses.

But the idea is drawing plenty of heat from local residents and business owners, who sounded off this week at a packed public meeting.

"I would encourage this council to adopt a resolution declaring Maplewood an eminent domain-free zone," resident Ed Gottlieb said to a wave of applause, according to KSDK-TV.

Locals have begun a campaign called "Save Our Block," putting signs up on buildings to help bolster support against any transfer of property.

While there is currently no concrete new development, the city did issue a request for proposals to develop a section of Maplewood, with the use of eminent domain a possibility. Maplewood is taking bids from developers through July 29.

"They make it sound like Godzilla is coming into Maplewood and tearing out this whole area," Mayor Mark Langston told the St. Louis Post-Dispatch. "Godzilla is not coming into Maplewood."

"I would urge the developers to address relocation, moving expenses, finding someone a new place to move to, lost business, what their property is worth," he added. "Those are all issues that need to be included in the proposals, and I'll be looking for those issues in those proposals. If this is what we do, I want to be fair."

The concern among residents comes in the wake of the recent Supreme Court decision allowing seizure of property from one private group to another.

The case of Kelo v. City of New London, Conn., allows the New London municipal government to seize the homes and businesses of residents to facilitate the building of an office complex that would provide economic benefits to the area and more tax revenue to the city. Though the practice of eminent domain is provided for in the Fifth Amendment of the Constitution, this case is significant because the seizure is for private development and not for "public use," such as a highway or bridge. The decision has been roundly criticized by property-rights activists and limited-government commentators.


WorldNet Daily: http://worldnetdaily.com

County backs limits on use of eminent domain: Atlanta (GA) Journal-Constitution, 7/14/05

By Christopher Quinn

Cherokee County has joined others in Georgia in pushing the General Assembly to pass a law to limit government's power to seize land.

The county commissioners unanimously passed a resolution July 5 calling on the state to restrict the use of eminent domain — when a government forces a landowner to sell to it — if the land is going to be given to a company or another individual for economic development.

The resolution follows a U.S. Supreme Court decision that ruled that New London, Conn., could seize land not only for traditional government projects like roads and schools, but also to turn the property over to private developers when officials decide it benefits the public.

"We felt that the Supreme Court got this one wrong," said commission Chairman Mike Byrd, who introduced the resolution.

"To take someone's home that they have worked for their whole life and give it to someone else for economic development is totally inappropriate."

Commissioner Derek Good said, "Eminent domain should be restricted, in my opinion, to true public purposes like building a road or county facility."

The commission wanted to send a message to its state delegates to take some action, Byrd said.

A growing chorus of state legislators and county governments are pushing for such restrictions.

Though the high court ruled in favor of the city, one of the justices noted that it did not prevent states from writing laws to restrict the legal use of eminent domain.

Cobb leaders have talked of taking action if the state doesn't.

Cobb Chairman Sam Olens said he believes the county could pass local ordinances restricting the use of eminent domain, but it would be better if the state did it so that the law would be uniform from county to county. He will wait to see what the General Assembly does before making any moves, he said.

Vernon Jones, the chief executive officer of DeKalb County, filed a resolution condemning the use of eminent domain for economic development. Jones' resolution will not carry the force of law.

"But we are taking a stand to say we are not going to seize private property for economic development purposes," he said.

He has already talked to state legislators about the issue, he said.

Pressure on General Assembly members to address eminent domain issues has been mounting in recent years. Efforts to limit the use of eminent domain by power companies when siting power lines failed in 2004.

Another bill introduced this year created a unexpected backlash against eminent domain.

Republicans introduced the bill, whose intent was to allow local governments to partner with private businesses to build public facilities. Part of the law would have allowed the businesses to select sites for proposed projects in a process with little public input and ask governments to condemn the property.

It became a shouting point for radio talk jockeys, who predicted the end of private property rights. Newspaper editorials condemned the idea and the secretiveness of the process. A cascade of phone calls and e-mails from constituents hit legislators.

The bill was quickly shipped off to a study committee, and Republican leaders have said it will not be resurrected.

During the session, another bill was introduced in the state Senate that would have prevented governments from using eminent domain for reasons of economic development. It passed the Senate but did not make it out of the House before the session closed.

Senate President Pro Tem Eric Johnson appointed the bill's sponsor, Sen. Jeff Chapman (R-Brunswick), to head up a committee to prepare the law for another run when the General Assembly opens in January 2006.

Chapman plans to hold one or more hearings on eminent domain in late summer.

Olens said with all the political heat generated in the last year, he expects the law to be passed.


Atlanta Journal-Constitution: www.ajc.com

The newest oxymoron: private property rights: [Texas] Corridor Watch, 6/28/05

Last week Texas Representative Frank Corte of San Antonio issued a release saying, "The right to own and use property is inherent to a free society. When a government decides they know how to use private property better than the individual, private property rights cease to exist." CorridorWatch.org couldn't agree more.

Yesterday Representative Corte filed House Joint Resolution (HJR19). Today Senator Bob Deuell filed a companion bill, Senate Joint Resolution (SJR10). If passed these identical Resolutions would put the issue amending the State Constitution on the ballot in November with the following language proposed for addition: "Sec. 17A. A political subdivision of this state may not take private property through the use of the power of eminent domain if a primary purpose of the taking is for economic development."

The Constitutional amendment proposed by HJR19 and SJR10 offer to protect your property rights, but only from political subdivisions of the state such as cities, counties, and special districts. Maybe it's an oversight, but why NOT the state itself. Why would it be okay for the state to take our land for economic development? Why exempt TxDOT and other state agencies from a Constitutional limitation on eminent domain abuse?

If it's wrong for a city; if it's wrong for a county; it is equally wrong for the state; AND, THAT'S WHAT THE CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENT SHOULD SAY.

Lets amend our Texas Constitution to add this language, "Private property shall not be taken through the use of the power of eminent domain if a primary purpose of the taking is for economic development."

SENATOR JOHN CORNYN HAS THE RIGHT IDEA

Yesterday our very own US Senator John Cornyn introduced the Protection of Homes, Small Businesses, and Private Property Act of 2005. If this bill becomes law it will prohibit the use of eminent domain power for economic development by the Federal Government and any State or local government using Federal funds. [The text of the bill is online at:]
Protection of Homes, Small Businesses, and Private Property Act of 2005



Corridor Watch: www.corridorwatch.org/ttc

Woman settles with Hesperia, gives up land: (Victorville CA) Daily Press, 7/13/05

By Kathleen Stinson

The case between the school teacher who owned land in Hesperia [CA] and the city that tried to foreclose on her was settled Monday.

Ellen Zunino owned a 10-acre parcel of land in what is referred to as the "Golden Triangle" area of Hesperia that increased dramatically in assessed valuation, but she said she was unable to pay the assessment.

Under the terms of the settlement agreement, Zunino gave the land to the city without a foreclosure — something she did not want against her name, she said.

She was also paid a financial consideration of less than the real market value of the property, she said.

Before the city established an improvement district in the area — west of Interstate 15 and south of Avenal Street — Zunino's land had an assessed value of $9,800. After the city made some improvements, the city assessed the value of her land at $4.3 million and Zunino was required to pay a $1.2 million assessment on the property.

The city borrowed more than $21 million using the Golden Triangle properties as collateral on borrowed money and spread the burden over the parcels, based on improvements.

Zunino said she tried at one point to sell her land to pay for the assessments but found out it wasn't worth enough.

Facing foreclosure by the city for her inability to pay the steep assessment, Zunino hired attorney Marjorie Mikels, who filed a countersuit against the city of Hesperia for fraud and violation of the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution.

The Fifth Amendment stipulates that a government cannot take private property without just compension. Zunino's suit maintained that the city's large assessments constitute away of taking her property without just compensation.

"The city placed huge assessment liens on the property (that) no reasonable person could afford to pay," Mikels said.

Mikels found a number of property owners in the area who were also being foreclosed on under similar circumstances, she said.

"It's outrageous," Mikels said. "I think we're the only ones who came back with (a countersuit) for fraud charges and the Fifth Amendment."

The fraud claim against the city refers to the alleged unusually high valuation of the property by the city and to the percentage of property owners who protested the district, she said.

The city was supposed to give the property owners 30 days to protest establishment of the proposed improvement district, Zunino said.

Mikels said the 30 days did not apply if 50 percent of the property owners filed protests, unless the matter was overridden by a four-fifth's vote of the City Council. Mikels said the council vote was only three-fifths and that initially there was a 70 percent protest by property owners to establishment of the district.

Mark Devey represented the city of Hesperia in the case. Devey said he had no comments.

Zunino said other cities are trying to do similar things to others, and she refused to sign a confidentiality agreement to not discuss the case with anyone.

"There is not a better time to make people aware of what cities are doing to them," she said, adding that she plans to write articles and essays about eminent domain.


Daily Press: www.vvdailypress.com

7/13/2005

Milford votes limit on eminent domain: The Connecticut Post, 7/12/05

By Frank Juliano

[Milford CT] City officials politely but firmly rejected state suggestions Monday that placing local limits on eminent domain power would be premature.

The Board of Aldermen, sounding at times like the Sons of Liberty in 1775, unanimously approved an ordinance that prevents the city from using its eminent domain power to take owner-occupied housing for private economic development projects.

House Speaker James A. Amann, D-Milford, had asked Mayor James L. Richetelli Jr. to pull the ordinance off the agenda for the aldermen's City Hall meeting, promising that the issue would be dealt with by state legislation.

"All of the aldermen I spoke to wanted to go forward," Richetelli said before the vote. "But we added a line that 'this ordinance shall not conflict with any subsequent state law.'"

The ordinance submitted by Alderman Thomas Beirne, R-5, was drafted in response to the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision in Kelo v. New London upholding the southeastern Connecticut city's right to seize private homes to make way for a luxury office park.

Amann said that more than 75 state laws mention eminent domain or affect its use in some way, and that a comprehensive, consistent approach is needed to clarify how that power should be used.

"Now that the Supreme Court has spoken, it makes sense to take a full look at where we want to go with this as a state," Amann said. "One thing is certain: Connecticut's eminent domain laws will be changing and our municipalities should put any property takeover plans on hold immediately."

But Alderwoman Judith Toohey, R-2, wasn't about to wait for the Legislature. "Where has Hartford been through all of this?" she asked. "It never should have gotten to this point."

Alderman Vincent Ditchkus Jr., R-3, said Milford homeowners were victimized by the eminent domain process in the 1960s, when property was taken in the Silver Sands and Walnut Beach neighborhoods for urban renewal. "It took years for anything to happen, and a lot of people lost their homes for private developments," he said. "We want to make sure it doesn't happen again."

But it was Beirne, invoking the spirit of the Revolutionary War patriots, who got the last word. "In Lexington, Mass., in 1775 we had British soldiers in red coats claiming land for the king," the alderman said. "Now we have judges in black robes doing it, but it's still a fight over property rights."


The Connecticut Post: www.connpost.com

Reforms considered for state's eminent domain regulations: Connecticut Post, 7/12/05

Land grabs by state up for review Municipalities urged to delay plans using eminent domain
By Peter Urban

Connecticut House Speaker James A. Amann on Monday urged municipalities to freeze land takeover plans until the General Assembly reforms the state's eminent domain laws.

"One thing is certain: Connecticut's eminent domain laws will be changing and our municipalities should put any property takeover plans on hold immediately," said Amann, D-Milford.

Democratic leaders of the General Assembly held a press conference at the state Capitol Monday to announce that they intend to hold hearings on eminent domain — the doctrine allowing towns and cities to seize private land for public benefit.

The issue has drawn a feverish response across the country since the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 last month that the city of New London could invoke eminent domain to take property not just for public projects such as roads and schools, but also for private developments that would generate tax revenues.

"We need to let the public know we will address the Supreme Court ruling in a way that will produce legislation that ensures fairness and balance. In the meantime, municipalities should know that this effort is under way so there is no confusion as we go forward," said Senate President Pro Tempore Donald E. Williams Jr., D-Brooklyn.

The General Assembly will hold an informational forum on eminent domain later this month. Leaders of the Judiciary Committee and Planning and Development Committee will organize it.

Rep. Ernest Hewitt, D-New London, said Monday that he opposes changing the eminent domain law to block cities from using it to boost their economy.

"You would stifle towns like New London that have nowhere to go," he said.

Hewitt, a freshman, was on the New London City Council when it voted to take several homes for redevelopment as offices and a hotel.

The city, which occupies 6.5 square miles, has little open space and is home to the U.S. Coast Guard, Connecticut College and Mitchell College — all of which pay no property taxes.

Faced with the need to raise revenues, the city decided to back an economic development plan that required taking several homes. The city offered the property owners the fair market value for their homes, as the law requires, Hewitt said.
"I didn't want to do it. It was the hardest thing to do in my life," he said.

Since the Supreme Court found in favor of New London, Hewitt said he has received a barrage of e-mails from across the country denouncing the decision. None, however, came from the people of New London.

"It tells me the people in this town are for what we did," he said.

Amann said that the legislature may return in a special session to deal with the issue but that has yet to be determined.

Although he plans to wait to hear from the public and experts, Amann said that the state's eminent domain laws should probably be tightened in favor of property owners.

"We need to make it as narrow as possible so that it is used in very rare circumstances," Amann said.

The General Assembly rejected a Republican proposal to change the state's eminent domain statute during a recent special session. Democrats argued that the proposal did not deal with eminent domain comprehensively.

Gov. M. Jodi Rell issued a press statement Monday supporting the hearing and stating that she believes the rights of property owners should come first.

"When government intrudes on our homes, it must have a defensible reason. In the New London case, the reason was not defensible," she said.

Rell also backed House Minority Leader Robert Ward's call for a special session to make changes to the eminent domain laws.

"We should do this right — but we should not let the matter drag on for months," Rell said.


Connecticut Post: www.connpost.com

Rally planned against eminent-domain ruling: Portsmouth (NH) Herald, 7/12/05

Citizens all across the country will rally today against a June Supreme Court decision that gives municipalities wider latitude in determining what property can be taken by eminent domain.

The rally in Portsmouth will take place a 7 p.m. in front of the North Church in Market Square.

"Citizens concerned about the recent Kelo v. New London Supreme Court decision that radically increased the government’s ability to take private property will meet with others all over the New England region to defend private property rights," said regional organizer Jim Perry.

The case involved New London, Conn. The Supreme Court, in a 5-4 vote, agreed the city was within its rights to take by eminent domain homes that were standing in the way of a development officials believed would be beneficial to the economic development of the city.

Justice John Paul Stevens, writing for the majority, said New London could pursue private development under the Fifth Amendment, which allows governments to take private property if the land is for public use, since the project the city has in mind promises to bring more jobs and revenue.

"Promoting economic development is a traditional and long-accepted function of government," Stevens wrote, adding that local officials are better positioned than federal judges to decide what’s best for a community.

He was joined in his opinion by other members of the court’s liberal wing, David H. Souter, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen G. Breyer, as well as Reagan appointee Justice Anthony Kennedy, in noting that states are free to pass additional protections if they see fit.

In a scathing dissent, Justice Sandra Day O’Connor said the decision bowed to the rich and powerful at the expense of middle-class Americans.

In dissent, O’Connor criticized the majority for abandoning the conservative principle of individual property rights and handing "disproportionate influence and power" to the well-heeled.

"The specter of condemnation hangs over all property," O’Connor wrote. "Nothing is to prevent the state from replacing any Motel 6 with a Ritz-Carlton, any home with a shopping mall, or any farm with a factory."


Portsmouth Herald: www.seacoastonline.com

Eminent domain decision prompts action by local legislators: The Clarion (County PA) News, 7/12/05

By Tom DiStefano

In the wake of A U.S. Supreme Court decision allowing eminent domain to be used to foster economic development, the Pennsylvania legislature has introduced bills to limit the practice.

Eminent domain allows government to take land for public use if the landowner is given fair compensation. The power is usually used to acquire land for roads, schools, government buildings, utilities and other public purposes.

In Kelo vs. New London , the Supreme Court ruled that municipalities may take private land by eminent domain and give it to a private entity, with the justification the new owner will pay more taxes, create jobs or otherwise improve the local economy.

But the court noted in its ruling that state legislatures have the power to limit eminent domain for economic development.

Two bills were introduced in the Pennsylvania House of Representatives to do just that.

House Bill 1835, introduced by Rep. Thomas F. Yewcic (D-Cambria/Somerset), amends the rules for municipalities, stating that while municipal governments may take land by eminent domain, they may not turn that land over to “a nonpublic interest,” or use eminent domain to increase the tax base.

The bill would also require the taking to include a reverter clause so title would return to the original owner should the land ever be used for a private purpose.

The bill, with 101 co-sponsors, was referred to the Committee on State Government that same day it was introduced.

Local legislators co-sponsoring the bill include Rep. Fred McIlhattan (R-63), Rep. Scott Hutchinson (R-64) and Rep. Kathy Rapp (R-62).

A similar bill, House Bill 1836 was also introduced by Yewcic. This contains the same provisions as HB 1835, but amends the state’s Eminent Domain Code.

HB 1836 has 100 co-sponsors, including McIlhattan, Hutchinson and Rapp, and is also now in the House Committee on State Government.

A bill which would fund local government to buy blighted land and essentially give it to private owners has been amended to rule out the use of eminent domain.

House Bill 1358 would have the state issue $200 million in bonds and use the money in a grant program. Local governments awarded the grants can purchase blighted property outright or at a tax sale and sell it to private developers for $1 per property.

Municipalities would not be allowed to use eminent domain to purchase blighted properties.

The amendment was added July 1 and the house voted 170 to 27 for final approval.

The bill moved on to the Senate, where it was referred July 2 to the Urban Affairs and Housing Committee.

House Bill 1358 was introduced by Rep. Michael Diven (R-Allegheny) and has 24 co-sponsors, including McIlhattan.

The U.S. Congress has responded to the Kelo decision as well. U.S. Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas) introduced a bill banning the use of federal funds for any state or municipal project using eminent domain for economic development purposes.

A similar bill, barring the use of federal transportation funds, passed the U.S. House.

Liberals and conservatives in Congress are joining forces to enact federal bans on eminent domain for economic development.

Conservative Republicans point to the preservation of property rights and dislike what they see as government interference. Liberal Democrats dislike government taking of property for private interests as unfair to the average citizen and a form of corporate welfare.

Information on legislation in the Pennsylvania General Assembly can be found on the Internet at www.legis.state.pa.us.n


Clarion News: www2.theclarionnews.com

Eminent domain foes vow to fight: Haddon (Haddon Twp NJ) Herald, 7/12/05

By Dan Keashen

In the wake of the U.S. Supreme Court ruling on the use of eminent domain, citizens from all over Southern New Jersey have vowed to take action.

Representatives from across the state gathered last week to put their plans in action to protect home owners. "This is the first real step for us to take back our properties from the abuse of local governments in New Jersey," said South Jersey Our Homes Coordinator Pat Seidman.

Last Thursday night strategies were discussed and residents made commitments to promote equitable property rights at the second meeting of the South Jersey Our Homes Coalition. The Haddon Township meeting brought out a cross-section of advocates from Ventnor to Cramer Hill. Over 40 representatives showed up to discuss the best form of protest and lobbying that can be done so legislatures recognize their plight.

Eminent domain is a clause used during redevelopment to take private property from residents and small business owners. Traditionally the use of eminent domain has been confined to large projects that benefited the entire community like highways, schools, and utility installation. After the U.S. Supreme Court ruling on June 23, municipalities have been given a free pass to use eminent domain for projects that produce higher tax rateables like the construction of luxury condominiums and high end retail.

Cramer Hill, a neighborhood inside Camden City, is under the threat of being razed for a golf course, condominiums, and high end retail. In all, 1,300 homes and 65 small businesses are now under threat by Cherokee Redevelopment Corporation and the City of Camden. Cramer Hill representative, Jose J. Santiago, said the local politicians are trying to get rid of everyone in the neighborhood.

"These are our homes and this is our barrio," said Santiago. "There is no blight here. Nobody has any blight in the neighborhood. A house might need some paint, but that does not give someone the right to take it and tear it down for a golf course." Santiago is trying to unite residents to join the new coalition to push the issue in Trenton. A Pennsauken representative had the same feelings.

Colin O'Brien is a manager at the Stardust in the Pennsauken Mart. "We've been fighting eminent domain for five years, said O'Brien. "When I brought this up years ago people thought I was a conspiracy theorist, but now that it's happening everywhere in the county people understand what we've been dealing with." O'Brien said the group is great way to let local legislatures that people are voting on this subject.

The Pennsauken Mart and several other buildings have been under the threat of eminent domain for years by the Camden County Improvement Authority. County officials wanted to replace the Mart with a plan called the Crossroads, a project that had at its core a 6,500-seat minor-league hockey arena and conference center and would have included a hotel and stores.

Haddon Township Commissioner Kathy Hogan created a document that local officials can sign to show their support. "I want elected officials to vow not to abuse eminent domain," said Hogan. "This is one of our basic rights as an American and [that] abusive, corrupt local officials would dare to take some ones home is disgraceful." She said it's important to know where local officials stand on the subject and to build an alliance with legislatures that are promoting property rights.

Ventnor property rights activist, Richard Gober, said Ventnor Mayor Tim Kreischer, is involved in property owner ethnic cleansing. "They're taking viable expensive properties from people that work in the casinos," said Gober. "These elected officials want to get rid of 250 homes in a predominately Latino area and replace them with 350 luxury condos." He said of the homes in the area are blighted and the redevelopment project in Ventnor is a "total land grab."

Camden Regional Legal Services Attorney Olga Pomar said the group has great promise to make difference in curbing eminent domain abuse, but remained reserved about the prospect to stop it. "It's still too early to say what can and will be done," said Pomar. "I hope that this group can make people understand the subject better and to disseminate information about how eminent domain abuse happens." She said the lobbying effort by the group will be determined by the political climate of the gubernatorial race in November.

Seidman said the second meeting was a success and groups have been coordinated to start the legal and organizing efforts among the communities. "We've been able to get our efforts focused and now we're looking forward to building a bullhorn that will be heard by our local legislatures," said Seidman. "Our elected officials need to know that residents are not going to take this abuse anymore."

The next meeting for the South Jersey Our Homes organization will be on July 21, at 7 p.m. The meeting will be held at the Inn on the Avenue.


Haddon Herald: www.zwire.com

Family’s home in jeopardy in domain battle: Gwinnett (County GA) Daily Post, 7/13/05

By Christy Smith

Georgia cities and counties can exercise eminent domain to condemn property and purchase it for reasons that would be beneficial to the public’s general well-being, such as for road improvements, transportation systems, or a dam to stop spring floods.

The Georgia Constitution defines these privileges.

Buford City Commissioners on Monday voted to begin proceedings in Gwinnett County Superior Court to condemn property at 608 Sawnee Ave. for road improvements.

The property is owned by William T. Yancy, who has operated his business, Yancy Rebuild Service, on the site for 22 years. Yancy rebuilds automotive starters and alternators, and he and his wife live in an apartment in his shop. Several buildings stand on the acreage that are 40 to 60 years old, said Yancy.

Buford city officials have offered to buy the property from Yancy.

“I can’t divulge their price right now, but it’s not enough,” Yancy said.

Yancy is being represented by Attorney Gibson Dean, and he says he is prepared for a court battle. If Buford acquires the property, it will remain as greenspace for the time being, Commissioner Michael Smith said.

The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled to expand the use of eminent domain in the Kelo v. City of New London, Conn., case that allows the city to seize private land for a development of offices, a hotel and conference center.

The Georgia Senate recently examined two house bills regarding eminent domain. Georgia Senate Bill 86, authored by Sen. Jeff Chapman, District 3, passed the Senate in 2005 on a 40-10 vote. It would prohibit using eminent domain for economic development purposes. The House could vote on it next year. SB 30 would have required governments to hold a hearing for condemnation when zoning and land-use decisions affect a property’s use. It did not pass the Senate in 2005.

Several Georgia property owners are fighting the use of eminent domain. Stockbridge Florist and Gifts Inc. is facing condemnation that allows Stockbridge to proceed with its urban redevelopment plan.


Gwinnett Daily Post: www.gwinnettdailypost.com

Impact of eminent domain ruling tempered in Arkansas: Hope (AR) Star, 7/11/05

By Ken Mclemore

Following is the first of two parts regarding the impact in Arkansas of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Kelso v. City of New London.


The old saying that, "A man's home is his castle," has never been entirely true in the absolute sense; but, the recent decision by the U. S. Supreme Court in a Connecticut case appears to have done little to settle that proposition.

U.S. Supreme Court Justice John Paul Stevens, writing for a 5-4 majority of the court, said the application of Connecticut law regarding the public taking of private property (eminent domain) does not conflict with the "Takings Clause" of the Fifth Amendment to the U. S. Constitution where a private, non-profit economic development entity benefits from a city's exercise of eminent domain to the benefit of a third party private developer.

The Court's opinion turned upon a distinction regarding the application of the phrase "public use" in the Constitution, which Justice Stevens interpreted to encompass a "public purpose" which went beyond a necessity for the public to obtain the property involved.

Relying upon a 1954 Washington, D.C., case (Berman v. Parker) and a 1984 Hawaii case (Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff) as they applied a 1798 federal case (Calder v. Bull), Steven's wrote that federal courts should defer to the judgment of legislative bodies in their deliberations as to the need for such plans since "economic development" is indistinguisable from other "public purposes" where the application of eminent domain on the state level is concerned.

"Accordingly, when this Court began applying the Fifth Amendment to the States at the close of the 19th Century, it embraced the broader and more natural interpretation of public use as 'public purpose,'" Stevens wrote.

Hope City Attorney Joe Short said the ruling stems from a basic principle.

"What we're dealing with is the Fifth Amendment to the U. S. Constitution, which says, beyond all the other stuff, is that you can't take somebody's property without just compensation," Short said. "That stems from the law in England, where if the Crown needed a particular piece of property, they just took it and didn't compensate anybody for it; and, so, the theory was that, if the government needed a piece of land or property, they could take it, but they had to pay just compensation to the owner for it; and, that language has carried over to the Arkansas Constitution."

But, Short does not think it will change the manner in which public entities in Arkansas exercise eminent domain.

"How the Supreme Court opinion will affect Arkansas is that the states can generally make it, not necessarily more restrictive, but it has got to be in line with what the U. S. Constitution says," he said. "That case dealt with whether that was a violation of the U. S. Constitution; it might be okay under state law, or can we do it based on the federal law?

"And, the Supreme Court said, 'Sure, as long as it's a betterment for the community as a whole to do that,'" Short said. "As far as changing Arkansas law, it's not going to change it very much because Arkansas has in place statutory language for the state, and municipal corporations more than anything, to take property for public purposes."

Under state statute and case law, those "public purposes" have limited definitions, Short said.

"Generally, they have always been defined as water improvements, sewer improvements, electrical or roads, that kind of thing," he said. "I don't know of a case where there has ever been a condemnation in turn for sale to a private corporation to develop in Arkansas."

Short admits that application of the language has held true in Arkansas to this point.

"Historically, that has been true up to this point," he said. "When they mapped out the route for I-30, there may have been landowners who didn't want to sell, for whatever reason; and, the greater good of the people as a whole would have been served by being able to take that.

"But, from what I understand they were going to do in Connecticut was just to condemn these houses that had been there and people had been there for years, so they could turn it into a convention-type center," Short said.

He said some cases typically occur where property is condemned for public use but not completely developed for that use.

"Let's say they condemn 600 acres for a public park, but only use 200 of it; so, what do you do with the other 400 acres?," he posed. "I guess at that point they would be free to sell it to whoever; but, it seems to me the public park in the Connecticut case was simply, 'Oh, yeah, by the way, we really want this other development, but these folks don't want to sell; so, we're going to make it a public park, and then we're going to do something.'"

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor's dissent to the opinion raises an question to the kind of broad scope for eminent domain which is justified by simple public revenue generation.

"The spectre of condemnation hangs over all property," Justice O'Connor wrote. "Nothing is to prevent the State from replacing any Motel 6 with a Ritz-Carlton, any home with a shopping mall, or any farm with a factory."

Short said such a scenario is unlikely in Arkansas.

"I don't know that any local governmental entity would be big enough to condemn a Motel 6 for the Ritz-Carlton," Short said. "What is the public purpose? Now, if they are going to tack on a public park, that's something different.

"But, let's also talk about what just compensation is," he said. "Just compensation is to compensate you for the highest and best use of that property; and, generally, that is to be set by a 12-person jury."

Short said the "highest and best use" of a property is generally determined by any number of factors, including comparable uses in the area.

"The highest and best use of a property depends upon the characteristics of a property as it lays right now," he said. "If you've got an old piece of property out at the proving grounds not being used for anything, it's highest and best use may be as farm land.

"But, if you've got land in a commercial corridor such as North Hervey Street, then commercial property may have a higher value than farm land," Short said.

He said the economic development concept as a factor is already permissible under Arkansas law.

"It's never been used in Arkansas, to my knowledge, to benefit a private corporation; unless, and I really haven't looked, but, I would think that the governmental entity might well have the power to condemn private property for the construction of an industrial park," Short said. "If you had city-owned land, and the city wanted to develop an industrial park; and, you had one land owner who held title to property that was either surrounded or was contiguous to it, I think the city would have the power to condemn that to make it part of an industrial park; and, as they go along, they could sell that to private individuals for the construction of their plants. I think that could be another public purpose."

Should Arkansas property owners be concerned?

"I'd be hard-pressed to see a city government that would want to take that fight on," Short said.


Hope Star: www.hopestar.com

Eminent domain may become hot button law: Hope (AR) Star, 7/13/05

By Ken McLemore

Following is the second of two parts regarding the impact in Arkansas of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in Kelso v. City of New London.


Eminent domain law may become the new hot button Constitutional law class in law schools around the nation as a result of the U. S. Supreme Court's recent ruling in a Connecticut case; but, as a practical matter, two local attorneys think it will remain cut and dried in Arkansas - unless someone finds a means to test the law in Arkansas.

In Kelso v. City of New London, the U. S. Supreme Court found that the application of Connecticut law regarding the public taking of private property (eminent domain) does not conflict with the "Takings Clause" of the Fifth Amendment to the U. S. Constitution where a private, non-profit economic development entity benefits from a city's exercise of eminent domain to the benefit of a third party private developer.

Hempstead County Attorney John Gilbert Burke, and Hope City Attorney Joe Short both envision one scenario in Arkansas which might fit that scenario.

The announcements in recent months of the development of automotive parts assembly facilities in the Arkansas Delta region near Wynne and Marion have given rise to significant speculation over the siting of a major automotive manufacturer in the region. Both Burke and Short said the prospect of an eminent domain test case stemming from such development could force a new look at Arkansas' eminent domain law.

"Number one, you've got to find a government agency to go through; the city, the county, the state, because you can't just go out and take someone's property," Burke said. "Once that governmental entity does it, your only issue when you go to court is the money. There is no issue whether Hempstead County can take your property; it's just how much money you're due.

"So, you are going to have to address that issue, wherever you start it, circuit court probably; and, you're going to have to raise that as a Constitutional issue in circuit court," he explained. "If the judge says, 'You're right, our Constitution says the government can't do that,' that is the test; but, if the court says, 'No, you're wrong, that can be done,' then, you go up the chain.

"Until this case, we would just not have considered it," Burke said. "But, that example is a good analogy."

Short was more explicit.

"What happens if Toyota wants to come build an auto plant in Arkansas, and they say, 'We want it here;' and, everybody agrees to sell but one guy that's got a 25 or 40 acre plot, that guy doesn't want to sell at any price? You can offer them all the money in the world; what happens?," Short posed. "Can, then, the state come in and condemn it, and say that is for a better purpose than his use?"

Burke points out that, in Arkansas, the exercise of eminent domain has historically been "all about the money," principally because of the relative availability of land in Arkansas, unlike Connecticut.

"Property around here is just too plentiful," he said. "If you want to put in something, all you've got to do is go out and buy the property. It has to be a factor; and, I don't know all of the specifics of that case, but that must have been a very desirable location that you couldn't put down the street, and it had to go there."

He noted a recent case involving a condemnation of land along Springhill Road was typical of the cut-and-dried correlation between condemnation and compensation.

"You have to determine what kind of property you're dealing with," Burke said. "In the Springhill Road case, its highest and best use was agricultural. It had a potential for residential, because of rural residences around it; but, at the time, it's highest and best use was agricultural."

That issue subsequently defined the value which the land owner placed on the property, as compared to the compensation offered by the Arkansas Highway and Transportation Department through the county.

"If you don't like it, your recourse is to take it to court, in this case the county court," Burke said. "In this case there was approximately an half-acre, some trees were cut down, and the land owner was not happy with what he was offered."

Ultimately, the only issue for the local jury to resolve was whether the property was worth more than the $1,500 offered by the state. Burke said the property owner was awarded $3,000.

Burke said the exercise of eminent domain is rare in Hempstead County.

"Mainly, for building a road or a street," he said. "The extension they're doing out on Greenwood, and then Springhill Road; that's typical. You don't really see the City of Hope, or the county, taking property to build structures."

Burke admits to a certain shock at the high court's decision.

"My understanding of that case is that the court has expanded 'public use' to mean, I guess, for the greater good of the public, and for the greater good of the tax base," he said. "And, I find it hard to believe that, if it's not actually a public building or a public road going in, I can't believe they came down like that. The ramifications of that could be huge, I would think.

"To me, you've got the issue of whether you can take somebody's property to put in a shopping mall," Burke added. "And, when you go back to their case, I guess that's feasible, a feasible taking; and, I would hate to have to fight that out.

"I don't see that happening in Arkansas," he said. "But, I wouldn't have thought you'd see it anywhere. I just wouldn't have conceived that the term 'public use' could be expanded that far out and used that liberally."


Hope Star: www.hopestar.com

GOP candidates speak out on eminent domain: Augusta Free Press (Waynesboro VA), 7/13/05

Eye on Virginia

By Chris Graham

Republicans Jerry Kilgore, Bill Bolling and Bob McDonnell took the eminent-domain ball and ran with it on Tuesday, announcing their plan for revisions to state law to protect private-property owners in Virginia from the fear that government is going to take their land and homes from them to clear the way for lucrative private development.

"The Constitution of Virginia is very clear that the General Assembly is given the authority to define what 'public use' means. We've done it, but we haven't done it in a way that clearly protects property rights from actions with the purpose of economic development or revenue enhancement," said McDonnell, the GOP attorney-general nominee.

"This right to private property is so fundamental to our liberties that we believe it deserves constitutional protection in order to give certainty to private-property owners that their land is going to be taken for essentially private uses," McDonnell told reporters on a conference call.

Lieutenant-governor nominee Bolling and gubernatorial nominee Kilgore pledged with McDonnell to support revisions to the state code that would clearly state that tax-revenue enhancements and economic development are not legitimate purposes to allow government action to take private property through eminent domain.

The ticket also expressed its desire to see enacted a constitutional amendment proclaiming that the taking of land for public use "shall not include the taking of private property for the primary purpose of economic development or tax-revenue enhancement."

The strong words from the trio are the latest from politicians from across the Old Dominion in the wake of a controversial Supreme Court decision last month that extends the ability of local-government entities to use eminent domain to condemn properties for the purpose of clearing the way for private, for-profit development projects.

"There really was a sense of shock, not only in Washington, but across the country, because it is such a far-reaching decision that really threatens the principle of private-property rights and private ownership," Bolling said.

"If this decision is allowed to stand, it really does take us down the track of social engineering and land-use planning that I think is very dangerous for our country and our Commonwealth, because it would threaten these foundational principles and private-property rights," Bolling said.

"We must protect private-property owners from unnecessary and unwarranted intrusions on property rights. Taking private property merely to increase the tax revenue of government is not an appropriate use of the eminent-domain power," Kilgore said.


Augusta Free Press: www.augustafreepress.com

Condemnation curbs eyed : Denver (CO) Post, 7/12/05

Lawmaker proposes state amendment to restrict practice

By Chris Frates

A Republican state lawmaker said Monday that he is working on a constitutional amendment to prevent local governments from taking private property to make way for private development.

The move by Rep. Al White of Winter Park comes on the heels of a U.S. Supreme Court decision allowing the practice.

If the amendment makes the ballot in 2006 and passes, it could have sweeping implications for cities and towns trying to encourage private investment in their communities.

"I just think that citizens of Colorado should not be at the mercy of local governments when they determine that they want to take somebody's property so that they can increase the amount of money in the general fund that they can spend on other goodies," White said.

Like White, Republican Gov. Bill Owens disagrees with the court's decision. He has directed his staff to begin researching what legislation may be necessary to place curbs on condemnation, a spokesman said.

Sam Mamet, whose Colorado Municipal League represents 265 of the state's 271 cities and towns, said White's plan is "an overreaction steeped in political rhetoric and devoid of the reality of the situation."

Few cities have condemned private property for redevelopment, and when people have perceived that the power has been used inappropriately, the legislature and court of public opinion have spoken, he said.

The threat of condemnation is more important than its actual use because it brings reluctant property owners to the table, Mamet said.

But Tom Wambolt (twambolt@denver.net), an Arvada resident who fought the condemnation of a lake to build a Wal-Mart, welcomed White's plan.

"Right now, there is really no one voice out there that is speaking for the little man that can raise up and say, 'Hey, you're treading on my land,"' Wambolt said.

Under current law, cities cannot condemn private property solely for a private developer's investment; they have to first prove it is blighted. But the Supreme Court ruling will make such condemnation legal if state law is not updated, said Bob Hoban, a lawyer with the firm Hale Friesen who is helping White draft his proposal.

Mamet said the law firm and partner Allan Hale "make a very nice living suing cities."

"Allan Hale is very motivated, just like others are, by the color of green, because I know what's going on," Mamet said.

Hoban said the firm is motivated by protecting property rights and doesn't sue many cities.

It is not just cities that could lose out.

The amendment would "be a stake in the heart" of plans to build a private toll road between Fort Collins and Pueblo, White said.

But if the private project were taken over by a public transportation authority, it could move forward, White said.

A spokeswoman for toll-road developer Ray Wells did not return a call.


Denver Post: www.DenverPost.com

7/12/2005

Lawmakers [in CT] call for moratorium on eminent domain, study: (New York NY) Newsday, 7/12/05

By Susan Haigh, Associated Press

Democratic leaders of the [Connecticut] General Assembly on Monday urged municipal leaders not to use their eminent domain powers until the legislature has time to consider changing the state's laws on seizing property.

The state lawmakers said they want time to thoroughly examine the issue in the wake of last month's U.S. Supreme Court ruling that found New London had the authority to takes homes in the Fort Trumbull neighborhood for a private development project.

In its ruling, the high court pointed out that states could ban that practice.

"Now that the Supreme Court has spoken, it makes sense to take a full comprehensive look of where we want to go as a state on eminent domain," said House Speaker James Amann, D-Milford.

Two legislative committees plan to hold a public hearing as early as this month, inviting national experts and state and local government officials to testify. Lawmakers would then decide whether to hold a special session, or wait to address the issue during next year's General Assembly.

Democratic legislators said they expect to make some changes in Connecticut law. Eminent domain powers are referenced in 80 state statutes, according to the nonpartisan Office of Legislative Research.

The Democratic leaders of the General Assembly have sent a letter to mayors and first selectmen across the state urging them wait for legislative guidance before seizing any property.

"It's putting the word out there to the municipalities that we're going to act," said House Majority Leader Christopher Donovan, D-Meriden.

House Minority Leader Robert Ward, R-North Branford, is pushing for a special session this summer to consider a one-year moratorium on the use of eminent domain powers. Ward said he has been contacted by property owners from across the nation, concerned about the high court's ruling.

"This is a very simple issue: you're either with the big developer and big government, and against the little guy, or you're for the little guy," Ward said. "I'm for the little guy and that's why we need to change our law now."

Senate Minority Leader Louis DeLuca, R-Woodbury, called the Democrats' plan to study the issue a "toothless moratorium," and an attempt to save political face.

"It's clear that the Democrats are more interested in authorship than in protecting people from having their homes seized," he said in a written statement.

Bill Von Winkle, one of the New London residents whose home is being seized, said he supports the idea of a one-year moratorium.

"Then, after a year, they'll be the ones deciding whether to put us in street, not the Supreme Court," he said.

Milford officials did not wait for the state to take action. Aldermen voted unanimously Monday night to prohibit the city from using eminent domain to take property for private development.

"We recognize that there are legitimate reasons for eminent domain," Milford Mayor James L. Richetelli Jr. said. "But they have to be very specific, and they have to be for a real municipal purpose. Economic development just goes too far."

At least eight states _ Arkansas, Florida, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Montana, South Carolina and Washington _ already forbid eminent domain for economic development unless it is to eliminate blight.

"Now every state is left to go back and consider their own laws," said Rep. Michael Lawlor, D-East Haven, co-chairman of the legislature's Judiciary Committee.

Lawlor said the General Assembly could pass a law that would prevent the city of New London from taking the homes in Fort Trumbull. But, he said lawmakers still need to study the issue.

Republicans proposed legislation that failed during this year's regular and special sessions that would have limited the reach of eminent domain.

Ward is now collecting co-sponsors for a bill that would ban eminent domain for economic development projects.

Gov. M. Jodi Rell, a Republican, said she supports Ward's call for a special session. But she also backed the Democrats' plans for a public hearing and their request to municipalities that they forestall any eminent domain plans.

"When government intrudes on our homes, it must have a defensible reason. In the New London case, the reason was not defensible," Rell said in a written statement.

The project to redevelop New London's waterfront has received tens of millions of dollars in state funding over the years.


Newsday: www.newsday.com

Ventnor redevelopment challenge under way: Press of Atlantic City (NJ), 7/12/05

By Michael Pritchard

The first day of the Hispanic Alliance of Atlantic County's legal challenge to the city of Ventnor's redevelopment plans did not come down to what Superior Court Judge Steven Perskie will be deciding.

It was about Perskie's making it clear what he won't be deciding - such as whether the city can use eminent domain in the plan.

"Whether the city has the authority to enter into a development plan or the authority to use eminent domain is not before me," Perskie said after opening arguments. "What's before me is whether this plan constitutes an unlawful discrimination by design or impact, and if it does what should I do about it? That's all that I will be ruling on."

Perskie, who is hearing the case without a jury, said his remarks were not only aimed at those involved with the suit, but also any interested parties. Since Ventnor first proposed a major redevelopment of the northeast part of the city from Little Rock to Jackson avenues in the late 1990s, the plan has drawn a huge amount of public interest.

A proposal by developers Pulte Homes and Alliance Cos. envisions creating 375 condominiums and townhouses, 55,000 square feet of commercial property along with parking and the creation of a new commercial district. Part of the 28-acre stretch has been targeted for acquisition, including through the use of eminent domain.

Homeowners in the area have already challenged the plan and the use of eminent domain but have been defeated in Superior Court.

The Hispanic Alliance, however, is challenging the plan on the grounds that it disproportionately targets Hispanic residents, especially those who rent.

"This is about deciding who gets to live in a municipality and who doesn't," said Ken Goldman, an attorney for South Jersey Legal Services, which is representing the alliance. "Under the current plan, this proposal will make it harder for lower-income families and minorities to live in Ventnor. This is a thriving, working class area that is being targeted."

Attorneys for the city challenged whether the Hispanic Alliance has cause to bring the action since the alliance does not own any property in the affected area.

Again, Perskie was quick to make his position clear.

"I won't be ruling against them bringing the action," he said. "This is suffused with public interest, and this is a volunteer organization and some of those volunteers live in the area. Whether the group owns property has nothing to do with whether they can bring this suit."

The Alliance opened its case by presenting a sociological study based on 2000 census information to show that the redevelopment plan would have a disparate effect on Hispanic residents. The study shows that while 17 percent of the city's population is Hispanic, nearly 40 percent of those living in the targeted areas are Hispanic.

Lawyers for the city, however, argued that while Hispanics may be affected, that effect does not necessarily have to be negative. Through relocation programs and through programs designed to help families buy their first homes, the redevelopment plan could actually benefit current residents, they said.

The study also uses census data from five years ago and does not take into account the quality of housing and buildings in the area, the city argued.

The report did have a surprising revelation in that for families in the area, the median amount spent on housing was about 23 percent of their income. Federal guidelines for affordable housing are much higher, with families usually putting 30 to 35 percent of their income toward their housing.

Perskie asked the Alliance lawyers if the ultimate redevelopment brings that median number closer to accepted federal standards, would they still have a case?

Goldman acknowledged that if the alliance believed the current plan would meet the federal figure and include affordable housing, they probably wouldn't have filed suit.


The Press of Atlantic City: www.pressofatlanticcity.com

Business damage amendment proposed to FL eminent domain law

Submitted by Dino Paspalakis

Florida law includes statute 163.375 describing conditions for the taking of property by eminent domain for "community redevelopment and related activity," and the payment of "just compensation" to affected parties. I proposed an amendment to the law, which was drafted by my attorney, Jay Small (407)843-4321. Despite an active lobbying effort, the atmosphere at the time was not favorable and the amendment was not enacted. Now, in the wake of Kelo v New London, public awareness of eminent domain abuse suffered by individuals and businesses is creating pressure from voters for legislators to take action and the time may be right for this or other proposed changes.

Statute 163.375 and the proposed amendment (section 2 C — in boldface italics) are as follows:

163.375 Eminent domain.

(1) Any county or municipality, or any community redevelopment agency pursuant to specific approval of the governing body of the county or municipality which established the agency, as provided by any county or municipal ordinance has the right to acquire by condemnation any interest in real property, including a fee simple title thereto, which it deems necessary for, or in connection with, community redevelopment and related activities under this part. Any county or municipality, or any community redevelopment agency pursuant to specific approval by the governing body of the county or municipality which established the agency, as provided by any county or municipal ordinance may exercise the power of eminent domain in the manner provided in chapters 73 and 74 and acts amendatory thereof or supplementary thereto, or it may exercise the power of eminent domain in the manner now or which may be hereafter provided by any other statutory provision for the exercise of the power of eminent domain. Property in unincorporated enclaves surrounded by the boundaries of a community redevelopment area may be acquired when it is determined necessary by the agency to accomplish the community redevelopment plan. Property already devoted to a public use may be acquired in like manner. However, no real property belonging to the United States, the state, or any political subdivision of the state may be acquired without its consent.

(2) In any proceeding to fix or assess compensation for damages for the taking of property, or any interest therein, through the exercise of the power of eminent domain or condemnation, evidence or testimony bearing upon the following matters shall be admissible and shall be considered in fixing such compensation or damages in addition to evidence or testimony otherwise admissible:

(a) Any use, condition, occupancy, or operation of such property, which is unlawful or violative of, or subject to elimination, abatement, prohibition, or correction under, any law, ordinance, or regulatory measure of the state, county, municipality, or other political subdivision, or any agency thereof, in which such property is located, as being unsafe, substandard, unsanitary, or otherwise contrary to the public health, safety, morals, or welfare.

(b) The effect on the value of such property of any such use, condition, occupancy, or operation or of the elimination, abatement, prohibition, or correction of any such use, condition, occupancy, or operation.

(c) In any proceeding to assess compensation for the taking of property, or any interest therein, through the exercise of the power of eminent domain, if the effect of the taking may damage or destroy an established business of more than four (4) years standing, the owner of business shall be entitled to the probable damages to such business which the denial of the use of the property so taken may reasonably cause when the business cannot be relocated to a comparable location in the same market trade area.

(3) The foregoing testimony and evidence shall be admissible notwithstanding that no action has been taken by any public body or public officer toward the abatement, prohibition, elimination, or correction of any such use, condition, occupancy, or operation. Testimony or evidence that any public body or public officer charged with the duty or authority so to do has rendered, made, or issued any judgment, decree, determination, or order for the abatement, prohibition, elimination, or correction of any such use, condition, occupancy, or operation shall be admissible and shall be prima facie evidence of the existence and character of such use, condition, or operation.


Dino Paspalakis: Midwayfuncenter@aol.com

7/11/2005

The Eminent Domain Boomerang: What Goes Around, Comes Around: New Jersey Eminent Domain Law Blog, 7/10/05

By William Ward, Carlin & Ward

“It's not a New London thing, it's a national thing. My great grandparents came to this country as immigrants, worked hard to buy their little houses. The dream is gone. They could take it from you now. The American dream is now shattered.” – Kathleen Moroney, New York resident

In an odd way, the Supreme Court’s eminent domain ruling in Kelo v. New London has turned the tide in favor of the property owner.

On the face of it, property owners were expressing doom and gloom when the 5-4 ruling allowing eminent domain takings for economic benefit was announced. But the public outcry was overwhelming against both the ruling and the Supreme Court. Last week in New London, Connecticut, more than a few New Jersey property owners joined the protest of hundreds on the steps of City Hall as reported in The [New London] Day:
Among them were brothers John and George Mytrowitz of the Mulberry Street Coalition of Newark, N.J., who said they are facing the loss of their family business, an auto body shop that's been in the city for 92 years, to eminent domain.

“They want to take it away and give it to a developer who's connected with city hall officials,” George Mytrowitz said.

“A convicted drug felon, also,” John added.

“They want to take it away and give it to him, and I guess they're all going to get rich off of everybody else's property,” George said.

“We're here in support of Susette Kelo,” John said, “and of anybody that's being abused by this plague of eminent domain across the country.”

The public outcry has resulted in increasing numbers of the New Jersey legislature leaping on board to protect the residential home owner. Will we see legislation preventing takings for economic benefit? And at what price? Thomas Jefferson said, “Government big enough to supply everything you need is big enough to take everything you have…The course of history shows that as a government grows, liberty decreases.”

Assemblyman and attorney Michael Patrick Carroll (R-Morristown) is offering us ACR256 [http://www.njleg.state.nj.us/bills/BillsByNumber.asp] which proposes to limit use of condemnation to traditional public purposes and repeals constitutional provision allowing condemnation and long-term tax exemptions for redevelopment projects.

The Morris Daily Record (July 4) quoted the assemblyman. “There is a lot of argument made in towns like Long Branch, that the local government wants to take away homes in relatively desirable areas to build expensive condos, under the assumption people will pay higher taxes," Carroll said. “This will deprive some number of people of their property.”

The Jersey Reporter (July 5) quoted Assemblyman Louis Manzo (D-Hudson), who has also proposed legislation. "New Jersey is one of the worst abusers of eminent domain laws," Manzo said. "As a result of the Supreme Court's decision, the legislature must act to counter the unwarranted use of eminent domain. These bills will ensure that towns across New Jersey focus on truly blighted areas that are deserving of redevelopment, rather than stretching the boundaries of existing laws for unwarranted condemnation."

The Atlanticville (July 8) reported Assemblymen Michael J. Panter and Robert L. Morgan (D-Mercer/Monmouth) introduced Assembly Bill 4393. Panter said: “Property rights are one of the key liberties that distinguish us from more authoritarian governments. People know their property cannot be taken by others or the government absent an emergency public use like bridges or highways. To take them away for private development in the name of job creation and to add tax ratables means nobody’s home is ever safe as long as an argument can be made that revitalization is needed.”

Meanwhile, we have had discussions with large developers and pointed out that even they are not safe in the present climate. What is to prevent a mega-player making a deal with a municipality for a new super-mall which could wipe out a smaller strip mall in the process? The possibilities are endless and no less frightening when you play it out. No one is safe in the real estate food chain.

After all, doesn’t history repeat itself? So let us review and let us remember the beginning of the eminent domain lesson. This land, which I call my land and which you call your land, was once not our land at all. When the U.S. delegates asked for his signature on one of the first land treaties, the Blackfoot chief said:
OUR LAND IS MORE VALUABLE THAN YOUR MONEY; IT WILL LAST forever. It will not even perish by the flames of fire. As long as the sun shines and the waters flow, this land will be here to give life to men and animals. We cannot sell the lives of men and animals, therefore we cannot sell this land. It was put here for us by the Great Spirit and we cannot sell it because it does not belong to us. You can count your money and burn it within the nod of a buffalo’s head, but only the Great Spirit can count the grains of sand and the blades of grass of these plains. As a present to you, we will give you anything we have that you can take with you; but the land, never.

(Touch the Earth: A Self-Portrait of Indian Existence, compiled by T.C. McLuhan © Simon & Schuster, 1971)



New Jersey Eminent Domain Law Blog: www.njeminentdomain.com

Bad ruling on eminent domain: Daytona Beach (FL) News-Journal, 7/10/05

Letter to the Editor

By Dino Paspalakis, Ormond Beach

The words "Equal Justice Under Law," which are written above the main entrance to the Supreme Court Building, express the ultimate responsibility of the U.S. Supreme Court. It is the final arbiter of law and is charged with interpreting the Constitution so we will have "Equal Justice Under Law."

Needless to say, I was shocked and disappointed at the Supreme Court's majority decision in Kelo v. New London. A proper interpretation of the Constitution would have caused this court to overrule the 1954 decision Berman v. Parker, or at least to qualify that decision as being an extreme case of "slum" and that the power of eminent domain should be exercised only in urgent cases, such as the conditions which existed at the time when Berman was decided.

Instead, the justices changed the meaning of the Constitution. Thus, the clause "No person shall be . . . deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property be taken for public use, without just compensation" now means that your property can be taken if: (1) The taking is for a public use" (traditionally, a school, a road but now any taking that would pay more "taxes" than you are paying) and (2) you're paid "just compensation." (Theoretically just compensation means fair market value, but many states do not pay homeowners for the attorney fees associated with challenging the government's offer so that the underprivileged commonly receive far less compensation, while other states, by statute, exclude "business damages" from the business owner's compensation so that even if the business owner is capable of challenging the government's offer, he will still end up in a far inferior financial position.)

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said it best when she said in her dissent, "Any property may now be taken for the benefit of another private party, but the fallout from this decision will not be random. The beneficiaries are likely to be those citizens with disproportionate influence and power in the political process, including large corporations and development firms. . . . As for the victims, the government now has license to transfer property from those with fewer resources to those with more. The Founders cannot have intended this perverse result."

I guess the words above the main entrance to the Supreme Court Building should now state, "Equal Justice Under Law for the Developers and the Wealthy."


News-Journal: www.news-journalonline.com
Dino Paspalakis is a Daytona Beach Boardwalk businessman who settled with Boardwalk developer Bill Geary before the local case went to court

7/10/2005

No need to rush eminent domain bill: The Birmingham (AL) News, 7/9/05

Editorial

The Alabama Legislature should pass a bill to counteract a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that allows governments to seize private property and turn it over to other private owners for retail developments. No question about that.

But that doesn't mean Gov. Bob Riley should put such legislation in his call for the upcoming special session - though Riley says that's what he intends to do.

A special session should be held only for emergencies. Certainly, the Legislature's failure to pass the state General Fund budget during its regular session qualifies as an emergency. A budget for next year to fund public safety, prisons, child welfare, the health department and other agencies must be in place before the fiscal year starts Oct. 1.

The eminent domain issue, however, is not an emergency. Besides, the more proposals Riley puts into the call, the longer a special session is likely to last. That makes taxpayers spend even more money they wouldn't have to had the Legislature done its job in the regular session. Another danger is that nonemergency bills like this one can be used by lawmakers to delay other, more important bills, like the budget.

Don't forget, either, that Congress also is considering bills to protect property owners.

The ruling last month by the Supreme Court in a Connecticut case was odd. In a 5-4 decision, the court said a local government can confiscate private property and transfer it to another private party for economic development. Before the ruling, eminent domain was used mainly for huge public works projects such as schools, highways and rights of way. Even for those legitimate purposes, eminent domain is something that should be used rarely and only when the greater public good is clearly understood.

To take a home or property against an owner's wishes for a shopping center is another matter. That never should be allowed. Still, the eminent domain ruling does not constitute an eminent danger in Alabama right now.

In the upcoming special session, lawmakers should focus on the emergency at hand: the state's General Fund budget.

The bill negating the Supreme Court's bad decision on taking private property can wait until January. By then, Congress already may have acted, and lawmakers will have a better idea what kind of bill they need to write - or if they even need to write one.


Birmingham News: www.al.com/opinion/birminghamnews