3/30/2005

Boca workers remove truck loads of trash from unkempt home: (South Florida) Sun-Sentinel, 3/29/05

By Luis F. Perez

[Boca Raton] police and firefighters, some in protective gear, sifted through piles of junk Monday outside Albert Schulz's house.

They wanted to make sure the veteran hadn't placed explosives, booby traps or accelerants in the garbage strewn throughout the property.

That was the latest extraordinary measure city officials have taken in the long-running case that has neighbors complaining and the city researching whether it can condemn the house at 600 W. Palmetto Park Road and use eminent domain to take the property. The moves come after years of battles with Schulz to keep his property in the Royal Oak Hills neighborhood clear of debris.

Longtime city workers, elected officials and property rights activists can't recall a municipality using eminent domain to address code violations. City leaders emphasize that taking Schulz's house would be the last drastic step in a nine-year fight to have him clean his property.

"I couldn't find any [similar] reported cases in Florida," said Valerie Hernandez, a property rights lawyer who leads the Pacific Legal Foundation's Atlantic Center in Coral Gables. "But it's clear in the statutes, they have the power to do that."

When the police gave the all-clear, a city-hired crew of five wearing face masks to guard against the rancid smell of rotting food moved onto the property and started carting away two large and six small truckloads of garbage.

Jeff Pasternak, who runs the Delray Beach hauling company the city hired, said Schulz's house was the worst case he has seen.

In the driveway, Pasternak said his workers found boxes of rotting yogurt and Jell-O. He recognized a birthday cake that had turned into a dark mass and a chicken carcass that looked like brown paste. Maggots covered rotting food, and rat droppings were everywhere, he said.

Workers used rakes and pitchforks to sift through the garbage and spook any vermin, Pasternak said.

City officials decided early Monday to move up the date of the cleanup from later in the week because Schulz was arrested Saturday night after allegedly running a stop sign. He was charged with driving without a license and driving an unregistered vehicle, among other charges.

He didn't have his license because on St. Patrick's Day police arrested Schulz, 57, and charged him with driving while intoxicated.

He remained in the Palm Beach County Jail on Monday. His bail is set at $1,000.

"We took this opportunity since he was not going to be around," Assistant City Manager Michael Woika said.

Officials from the state's Department of Children & Families and U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs visited Schulz in jail to check on his mental state and learn whether they could help him, Woika said.

Schulz's case goes back to 1996, when he was first cited for overgrown grass, keeping auto parts and an accumulation of dismantled furniture on his property, and other code violations.

He has since been cited and fined 17 times for junk on his property and owes the city more than $57,000. He will be billed for the cost of Monday's cleanup, as well.

The Palm Beach County Health Department also ordered Schulz to clean up the unsanitary nuisance, but to no avail.

The City Council last week voted to have the city clean Schulz's property. Council members also voted unanimously to ask a court for permission to go onto Schulz's property at any time to clean it.

However, the council's most extreme measure was to ask city staff to look into taking Schulz's property from him if he continues to pile garbage there.

"We want the option available to us," said Mayor Steven Abrams, defending the use of eminent domain. "This is not an aesthetic issue. It's a health and safety hazard."

Nobody is advocating using eminent domain as a tool to correct code violations, Councilman Bill Hager said, but this has been going on for a decade. Neighbors have complained about rats, and the house is within 100 yards of an elementary school.

"We simply cannot tolerate this situation," he said.

Councilwoman Susan Whelchel, who last week proposed using eminent domain, said it is used in only the most egregious cases and would not be used for other code violators.

"There is no slippery slope," she said. "The city of Boca Raton doesn't run around taking property through eminent domain."

She called the Schulz case a lengthy, entangled legal process with no assurance in the end that it would be fixed.

"With eminent domain, the end result is clear," she said.


Sun-Sentinel: www.sun-sentinel.com

Residents sue over eminent domain plan: (South Jersey) Courier Post, 3/29/05

By Luis Puga

A community group and 43 residents of the Bergen Square neighborhood filed a lawsuit in Superior Court claiming the proposed redevelopment plan for that area abuses eminent domain and would add to the city's shortage of affordable housing.

The suit was filed on behalf of the plaintiffs by South Jersey Legal Services Inc., which has filed similar suits against redevelopment plans for residents in the Cramer Hill and Waterfront South neighborhoods.

Olga Pomar, a legal service attorney, said her clients, most of whom are homeowners, are worried about losing their homes through eminent domain. The procedure gives governments the ability to take private property in areas designated in need of redevelopment for compensation.

"Some of my clients are on the (plan's property) acquisition list," she said. "Some are not, but they fear the drastic changes that would happen to their neighborhood and fear that their homes may be added" to the list.

The suit states that, because the city and region face a public housing shortage, eliminating existing public housing in the neighborhood goes against the public good. That contradicts the state constitution, Pomar said.

The complaint also states the redevelopment plan primarily will affect low-income black and Hispanic residents.

The suit names as defendants Randy Primas, the city's chief operating officer, as well as the planning board, city council, the Economic Recovery Board of Camden, the Camden Redevelopment Agency and the state.

Representatives for the planning board and the Economic Recovery Board could not be reached for comment. Lee Moore, spokesman for the Office of the Attorney General, said he could not comment on a complaint his office has not seen.

Primas, who also chairs the CRA's board of commissioners, noted most city neighborhoods are made up of black and Hispanic residents. He called that part of the complaint "ridiculous."

"There appears to be a small group individuals who seem determined to stop development anywhere in the city," Primas said.

That's not so, Pomar said.

"We are trying to make sure redevelopment does not cause low-income families, seniors and other vulnerable people from forcibly losing their homes," she said.

City Council President Angel Fuentes said he feels the plan also had community support during public hearings before council.

"It's really sad to see another lawsuit," he said. "These lawsuits are just people trying to maximize their settlements (for their property's acquisition) and so they will not be displaced outside their neighborhood."

Primas said he feels the series of lawsuits against redevelopment plans could affect developers' interest in the city.

"It just seems awfully frustrating," he said. "We are trying to make things to improve the quality life for residents."


The Courier Post: www.courierpostonline.com

3/29/2005

Virginia Addresses Eminent Domain: Mortgage News Daily, 3/28/05

The Virginia state legislature has passed SB301 which will protect some owner rights when property is seized by the state or its divisions through eminent domain.

Property owners, however, will have to wait a while before they obtain any kind of relief. The bill provides that when property is seized by any state government agency and has not been put to the public use for which is was seized after a period of 15 years, the property owner must be offered a chance to repurchase it. The offering price must be the original sale price plus interest at 6 percent per year. The government may also adjust the price to reflect any improvements it has made to the property. For the sake of the former owner, one can only hope that the improvements were positive, not, for example, a half finished hydroelectric dam or a clear cut hardwood forest.

Governor Mark Warner signed the bill this week and it will go into effect on July 1.


Mortgage News Daily: www.mortgagenewsdaily.com

3/28/2005

Cities' eminent domain rights face test: Whittier (CA) Daily News, 3/27/05

By Sonya Geis

Eminent domain. It's the ultimate exercise in government power over individual property owners. A city can forcibly buy out a homeowner and take over his land, with the argument that the public would benefit more from a shopping mall than a private house.

But that power could be significantly curbed after a U.S. Supreme Court decision this spring. The ruling has a potentially significant impact on how local cities do business.

"Eminent domain is used infrequently, but it's used in key instances that might be the difference in those projects,' said John Shirrey, executive director of the California Redevelopment Association. "A lot of people are waiting with bated breath for the ruling.'

The question before the Supreme Court is whether a city may take property from one set of private owners and turn it over to different private owners, instead of keeping it for public use such as a library or road. Courts have upheld the practice in the past, based on the argument that added tax revenues are a "public good.'

In the Supreme Court case argued last month, Kelo v. City of New London, a Connecticut city attempted to seize the homes of Susette Kelo and her neighbors to add to a large development project built around a Pfizer research facility. The city argued that added tax revenues from the project constitute a "public good' as much as a road. Kelo refused to sell.

The Supreme Court justices could decide the case with a very narrow ruling that would apply only to Connecticut. Or they could take the opportunity to make a sweeping judgment that would affect cities nationwide.

The California Redevelopment Association filed a friend-of-the- court brief in favor of keeping the ruling narrow.

Shirrey points out that under California law, redevelopment agencies may only use eminent domain for economic development purposes on land that has been designated "blighted.'

With a broad Supreme Court ruling, Shirrey said, potentially "we would not be able to undertake use of eminent domain for any economic development project.'

George Lefcoe, a real estate law professor at USC, said he thinks such a sweeping ruling is unlikely.

"This is a very legitimate redevelopment project in New London. It's not a tax grab,' he said. "I'm going to fall off my chair [and] you're going to hear a big thud if they don't uphold existing law in that case.'

Plenty of property-rights advocates hope the Supreme Court surprises the experts.

"I think they should simply ban the practice of taking one person's land and giving it to another. I think it's unlikely they would do that, but I think they should,' said Pasadena attorney Chistopher Sutton. Sutton represents the Hawkins family in an eminent domain fight with Temple City officials.

Sutton, who led a fight against eminent domain in Montebello in the 1980s, said requiring a city to declare an area "blighted" before using eminent domain to hand it over to developers is no great safeguard against government abuse of power.

Loraine Wallace Rowe, chairwoman of the Coalition for Redevelopment Reform in San Jose, agreed. She said the definition of blight has gradually expanded to allow cities to justify using eminent domain even in areas with expensive homes.

"To say, 'We could get more tax money for that property with 20 condos on it than with one house' that basically says that any single-family house could be considered blight,' she said.

City officials defend the use of eminent domain as rare and necessary.

"There are not currently any (imminent domain) cases going on, but you always have that potential out there,' said Jeff Collier, Whittier's community development director. "If they take it away, we lose a powerful tool.'

He also noted that cities can offer tax breaks to the owners of properties taken by eminent domain.

"There are some benefits that can end up helping everybody,' he said.

The Supreme Court ruling is expected in May or June.


Whittier Daily News: www.whittierdailynews.com

New Nevada bill would limit eminent domain proceedings: Las Vegas (NV) Sun, 3/25/05

By Brendan Riley, Associated Press

A new legislative proposal [in Nevada] would restrict the use of eminent domain proceedings of the sort used for the Fremont Street Experience in downtown Las Vegas or the pending efforts to block development of the historic Ballardini Ranch south of Reno.

Sen. Terry Care, D-Las Vegas, author of SB326, said Friday the proposal would limit what he considers over-the-top moves by governments to force ownership changes without just cause.

"It's real simple," Care said. "If government needs for a public purpose to take land, we all understand it. Just don't abuse it."

Care's 2-page bill would bar the use of eminent domain by government agencies to get property for open-space use or for "protecting, conserving or preserving wildlife habitat."

The measure also says an agency could exercise eminent domain powers to get property for a redevelopment project only after making a written finding that "a condition of blight exists for each individual parcel of property" being acquired.

"Nobody asked me to introduce this," Care said when questioned whether developers urged him to introduce SB326. "I've had an interest in eminent domain issues for some time."

Care said that interest began with the Fremont Street Experience case that led to a split state Supreme Court ruling in 2003 against Harry Pappas and his family, whose property was taken for the project in 1993.

Care's bill adopts the dissenting views in the 4-2 ruling. The two dissenting justices said there should have been a formal process to determine whether the area was really blighted.

When he later read news accounts of the Ballardini Ranch controversy, Care said, "I was outraged." He added that he contacted representatives of Minnesota-based Evans Creek LLC to discuss expanding his proposal. The result was the proposed ban on acquisitions for open-space use.

Tim Smith, president of Evans Creek LLC, said Friday he supports Care's bill because it will make clear that Washoe County's efforts to condemn the Ballardini Ranch for open-space use "as a pretext to stop development is an abuse of governmental powers and unlawful."

Evans Creek, which paid $8.5 million for the ranch in 1998, has proposed building nearly 200 upscale homes on part of the property in the Sierra foothills. But advocates of public acquisition say the ranch would provide a link to U.S. Forest Service land and preserve the area for wildlife and recreation.

Steve Walther of Protect Our Washoe, a group trying to preserve the ranch as open space, said the group will oppose the bill even though, as introduced, it would apply to cases filed in the future.

"It wouldn't be good policy to legislate in situations that really belong to local government," Walther said. He added that the Ballardini acquisition wouldn't be simply for open space but for a wide range of outdoor recreational activities along with possible continued use as a ranch.


Las Vegas Sun: www.lasvegassun.com

Fighting City Hall: Business Week, Spring 2005

The Supreme Court will soon rule in a landmark battle over eminent domain

By Susan Garland

Edward Hathcock, owner of Gem Products & Supply in Romulus, Mich., was resigned to moving his six-person cabinet-making business. The county government wanted to build an airport extension on his property, and it was using eminent domain — which lets governments acquire private land for public use, as long as the former owners receive "just compensation" — to claim Hathcock's land.

Then Hathcock discovered that some of the land would be used not for an airport but for a private development. Hathcock and his neighbors sued. "I did not consider [the development] to be public use," he says.

Is it? The Supreme Court heard oral argument on that question on Feb. 22. A group of New London (Conn.) landowners came before the Court to prevent their property from becoming part of a riverfront revitalization project, after losing their case in state court in March, 2004. The Supreme Court's ruling, expected this spring, will probably dictate how eminent domain can be used. A ruling for New London would be "devastating" for small businesses, says Scott Bullock, attorney for the Institute of Justice in Washington, which represents the New London property owners.

Traditionally, municipalities have used eminent domain to make way for roads, schools, and hospitals, and to clear blighted areas. Now, cash-strapped cities are more broadly defining "public use" to include private economic development projects expected to generate higher tax receipts and more jobs. "Eminent domain is a critical tool," says David Parkhurst, principal legislative counsel for the National League of Cities.

In theory, any big business will produce more tax revenue than a small one, so a ruling for New London would mean "any small business could be taken for any development," says Bullock. He says six states have upheld the use of eminent domain for private business development, while nine forbid it. The Institute estimates eminent domain was used to try to seize 10,000 properties for private projects from 1998 to 2002.

Hathcock and his neighbors won their case in July. Now it's up to the Supreme Court to decide if other property owners can hold back the forces of big-time development.


Business Week Online: www.businessweek.com

Developers are lusting after us: Emdo Speak Out, 3/27/05

By Kathy Scruggs

I'm a seasonal owner in a 55-over community along the intracoastal waterway [in Boynton beach FL]. With our almost 42 acres, developers are lusting after us and are being abetted by the very ones who were elected to represent our interest, though shill corporations like the Community Redevelopment Agency. We are, according to the CRA, 'under-utilized' land! All up and down the Intracoastal waterway, older development like ours are being pressured and the fear of losing our homes — homes on which many of us pay a non-homestead tax — to eventual eminent domain.

Government is totally out of control. I remind people that we fought a Revolutionary War over such things and so intent were those who wrote our founding documents to ensure our rights to live in our homes they incorporated our right in the Constitution. Yet, every day, all over the US, the government is allowing lands and private property to be taken, not for some true "public purpose," but to raise more tax dollars, so that wages and benefits of those who work with or for the various government agencies can grow and assure them of future health care and retirement benefits that few of us in private enterprise can ever hope for. Meanwhile our seniors and minorities are thrown away like so much debris because our homes are "undervalued". Where do these people go? Our city commissioner recently suggested building 'affordable' housing on an old city dump for goodness sake!

Despite our being almost 40-years old, condos in my community have been increasing in values. Yet, once pigeon-holed into a CRA or other such redevelopment plan, your tax assessments seldom go up all the better to make the case that we are not paying enough taxes!

We have 840 residents here and are eagerly awaiting the Supreme Court decision re: Kelo vs. New London, Conn.


Kathy Scruggs: waka.scs.1@worldnet.att.net

Emdo Speak Out is an occasional feature of Eminent Domain Watch through which readers can voice their opinions about eminant domain abuse issues. To be considered for inclusion, send your comments to us at krfapt@aol.com.

3/24/2005

Senate weigh on eminent domain: Dateline Alabama (Tuscaloosa AL), 3/24/05

By Kim Chandler

When the City of Alabaster wanted to buy Carrie Spence's land for a shopping mall and city hall site, she didn't have to think long.

"It's our home, and it's paid for. You've been living here all your life and they try to take your land for a Wal-Mart or a Target or whatever. No, get out of here," Spence said.

The city filed a lawsuit against her claiming eminent domain, which lets governments acquire private land for public use, as long as the former owners receive "just compensation." The lawsuit was dropped after other families agreed to sell for a higher price. But policy-makers are grappling with just what constitutes public use and whether cities can condemn private property such as Spence's for retail developments that'd increase the tax base.

A bill pending in the Alabama Legislature says they can't and would prohibit cities from using eminent domain for commercial use.

"Quite frankly, I just think it's wrong to take anyone's private property and give it to a retail establishment," said bill sponsor Rep. Jack Venable, D-Tallasssee.

"Eminent domain is very important. We wouldn't have the interstate highway system if we didn't have eminent domain, but at least that's public use, which is what our constitution intended," Venable said.

Venable said that to his knowledge no Alabama government has taken private property for commercial development.

But he said cases in other states show cities' desire to use eminent domain for land to lure big-box retailers or other commercial developments.

The House of Representatives approved Venable's bill 90-1, sending it to the Alabama Senate for consideration. Some cities argue that eminent domain is a key tool for tackling urban blight: Take it away and you could be left with slums.

"When you've got these run-down areas, one of the ways to clean them up is eminent domain," said Perry Roquemore, executive director of the Alabama League of Municipalities.

Sen. Rodger Smitherman, D-Birmingham, said he plans to tack on an amendment that'd exempt the city of Birmingham. The Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution states that private property shall not "be taken for public use, without just compensation." What exactly defines public use has been a matter for debate.

Other states are grappling with the definition, and the U.S. Supreme Court will soon weigh in. Last year, the court heard the case of a group of New London, Conn., landowners trying to prevent their property from becoming part of a riverfront revitalization project. The Washington-based Institute for Justice, a libertarian group representing the New London holdouts, reported that from 1998 to 2002, there were more than 10,000 threatened or filed condemnations involving private developments.

The Georgia Senate earlier this month approved a bill that would prohibit eminent domain when the use is primarily to improve the tax base or economic development.


Dateline Alabama: www.tuscaloosanews.com

District 3 hopefuls take stand on eminent domain: The (Blue Springs/Independence MO) Examiner, 3/24/05

By Stephanie Howard

Blue Springs City Council candidates in District 3 took a strong stand on eminent domain Wednesday.

Incumbent Ron Fowler and challenger Steven Mooers spoke Wednesday afternoon at the Blue Springs Rotary lunch.

Fowler discussed the eminent domain issue, saying the City Council, just two days prior, had approved using the tool to acquire about 2.75 acres of land for the expansion of Moreland School Road.

Eminent Domain is a tool available to governments in which the government can condemn a piece property for public use.

Fowler, who voted in favor of the issue Monday night, said that was the appropriate use because it went for a road. However, he said he would not support eminent domain to take one business' property to give to another business. He cited the recent tax increment finance proposal on Missouri 7.

"The TIF district grew into something I didn't support," Fowler said. "Yeah, I want redevelopment, but we're not going to use eminent domain for it."

Mooers took a stronger stance, saying he didn't think eminent domain should ever be used. Going back to Monday night's vote, Mooers said everyone should be allowed the right to get what they want for their property.

Likewise, Mooers pointed out many of the farms in the area have been in families for generations.

"If a person wants 10 percent more or 20 percent more for their land to push that road through, the city should come up with it, or they don't get the land," Mooers said. "I don't think the government, at any time, should come in and take that land, for any reason."

The two candidates fielded questions about various city issues and agreed on most questions. Fowler concluded the forum thanking Mooers for keeping the campaign clean and friendly compared to last year's divisive city elections.


The Examiner: www.examiner.net

When government takes what it doesn't own: The Bergen (NJ) Record, 3/24/05

By george Mytrowitz

EMINENT DOMAIN - it's a 1,000-year-old concept that poses a contemporary threat to property owners throughout New Jersey. Rooted in English common law, eminent domain is the right of governments to take your house, your business and your livelihood.

President John Adams so feared the government abuse of property rights that he said: "The moment the idea is admitted into society that property is not as sacred as the Laws of God, and there is not a force of law and public justice to protect it, anarchy and tyranny commence. Property must be sacred or liberty cannot exist."

Adams' concerns for private property are ignored by today's petty political tyrants who abuse the power of government to take what it does not own.

In Carteret, an 84-year-old World War II hero, fighting cancer, faces the prospect of being booted out of his house by the mayor's redevelopment scheme.

In Ridgefield, government officials are considering redevelopment schemes that could destroy existing businesses.

In my own case in Newark, the auto body shop owned by my family for 90 years is being targeted for extinction as a part of the city's effort to condemn 14 acres of our neighborhood.

These are but a few of the scores of injustices being committed today in the name of redevelopment in New Jersey.

The politicians argue disingenuously that the taking of homes and businesses is but a small price to pay for the benefits of redevelopment: "more jobs and lower taxes" for the rest of the town's taxpayers. These presumed benefits are never guaranteed and no studies have ever verified if the promises match reality.

Promising more tax revenue is not the same as lowering property taxes - it's just a chance for governments to acquire and spend more money. Similarly, the promise of jobs is usually a distortion. Often high-paying blue collar jobs are wiped out, replaced by low-paying retail or service jobs. Mechanics in my shop earn three times the minimum wage plus benefits. Those wages will not be matched by the Dunkin' Donuts or Gap store that could replace us.

The real beneficiaries of eminent domain are developers and planners who work with compliant politicians to carve out redevelopment districts and then get the government to do what every developer dreams of - force people to sell their property to them. These schemes amount to nothing more than the massive transfer of wealth from one set of private property owners to a private entity that will make millions on the transfer.

Eminent domain is supposed to be employed for a public use - a school, highway or library. But it is hard to see the public use in taking homes and business and replacing them with newer homes and businesses while allowing friends of politicians to make a fortune.

The corrupt nature of these schemes is obvious. In almost every case the developers and architects favored by the government have made sizable donations to the politicians in the redevelopment area. There is never any open competitive bidding for development ideas.

In Newark, we have, as they say, followed the money. And what we discovered was typical. The development for The Mulberry Street area was voted down by the council in 2003. A few months later, after the developers made sizable donations - exceeding $50,000 - to the mayor and council, the project was resurrected and OK'd by the same city council that had turned it down earlier. One of the developers is a former city council aide seen recently dancing up a storm at Mayor Sharpe James' fund raiser. Eminent domain has become an extension of pay-to-play.

Even in cases where the need for redevelopment is substantiated, why is it only the outside developers who benefit from the plans? Why aren't people like me, people who have stayed in the cities year after year - paying taxes, providing jobs - not allowed to share in the prosperity of the city's renaissance?

Politicians are quick to point out that the law provides for just compensation, and relocation assistance for property taken. That's a joke. In many cases heavy industrial business are tough to relocate. Where, for instance does one move a steel fabrication plant or an auto body shop? How many neighborhoods are amenable to such uses?

The larger economic concern for the state is that eminent domain abuse provides a disincentive for investment in the industrial sector and leads to monolithic development patterns - office and retail space and cluster housing in town after town. Why would anyone invest in a new or existing industrial business that could, at the whim of a mayor and council, be targeted for extinction?

State Sen. Paul Sarlo of Wood-Ridge recently held a committee meeting to address concerns about manufacturing jobs in New Jersey. A good place for the senator to start would be addressing the negative impact of eminent domain on industrial jobs.

With a gubernatorial election looming this fall, now would be the time for any would-be state executive to begin addressing the abuses of eminent domain and their impact on people's lives and livelihoods.


The Bergen Record: www.northjersey.com


George Mytrowitz is the owner of Market Auto Body in Newark and spokesman for the Mulberry Street Coalition - a Newark based citizens group opposed to the city's condemnation of their property.

The Evolution of "Public Use" in Redevelopment: American Planning Association, 3/05

Bettman Symposium

By Stephen Sizemore, AICP

Pending before the U.S. Supreme Court is a case, Kelo v. City of New London, whose decision may significantly alter one of the major tools by which communities facilitate redevelopment and economic development — the power of eminent domain.

In recent years, controversial uses of this power have regularly hit the front pages of national newspapers and news. Whole neighborhoods are being condemned to provide sites for new private development that promises to create new jobs and increase the tax base. Is this an abuse of the power of eminent domain, cruelly taking the homes people grew up in and have staked so many aspects of their lives? Or is it a necessary, yet last-resort, means of assembling land for redevelopment that is crucial to revitalizing the area or the city as a whole?

Under the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, the power of eminent domain is limited to where exercised for a "public use." But what is "public use"? Is it limited to public facilities, like roads and fire stations? Is it any action that benefits the public? Or is it something between? And does it matter whether the condemned property ends up in the hands of another private entity rather than the government?

These are some of the questions that two speakers and a responding panel of legal experts addressed at Sunday afternoon's session in the Bettman Symposium.

Charles Siemon, a Florida attorney with extensive experience with redevelopment, stressed that U.S. society and its laws have always recognized the need for government to have a broad power of eminent domain, and that the courts have wisely stayed away from second-guessing the judgment of state legislatures as to what constitutes a public use for which the power may be used. Most of the nation's cities face a "crisis in redevelopment," where the fracturing of urban property into small parcels poses a major obstacle to redevelopment needed to revitalize the city. If the government lacks a broad power of eminent domain, one property owner can hold out and preclude the assembly of the land needed for redevelopment, stopping redevelopment and the many public benefits it entails. And what difference does it make to a property owner who ends up with the property, and what use it's put to?

Dana Berliner, an attorney with the Institute of Justice in Washington, D.C. (and attorney for the property owners in the Kelo case), presented very different view of what "public use" should mean. She emphasized that government use of eminent domain to take a home or business touches on something that is very personal to the home or business owner, something central to their identity. They suffer injuries that, though often intangible, are very real — and often not compensated for by payment of the property's market value.

And just as it matters to you what a beggar does with the money you give him, it likewise matters to the property owner how their property is used, and for whose benefit. People are more willing to sacrifice their property taken for a public road, police station, or other facility directly serving the community than as the site for private development that may (or may not) indirectly contribute to the community's economic well-being. Planners often just do not understand this or why people object to use of eminent domain. Instead of contributing to conflicts between public purposes and property owners in redevelopment projects, planners should do more to avoid and minimize such conflicts.

Brian Blaesser, an attorney with the Boston office of Robinson & Cole, noted that those in the real estate community, like people from both ends of the political spectrum, are ambivalent about the issue of how public use should be defined. Although they recognize the desirability of economic development and the need to use eminent domain to achieve it, they also are sympathetic to property owners adversely impacted by such use, particularly where it involves a "private-to-private" taking. But sufficient safeguards against abuses in the use of eminent domain already exist in the form of a number of statutory limitations and procedural requirements at the state level. Even so, more work is needed in reviewing and revising these redevelopment statutes — for example, removing high density and diversity of ownership, both important attributes of smart growth, as defining criteria for "blight."

Shelley Saxer, law professor at Pepperdine University, stressed that controlling the abuses of eminent domain requires a higher standard of review. In an amicus brief in the Kelo case, she and other law professors proposed using the standard applicable to exactions: that there be a nexus and rough proportionality between the impacts of condemnation on individual property owners and the need for the condemnation. Paying market value for condemned property often does [not] equate to "just" compensation, given the property owner's relocation costs and emotional loss.

Deborah Rosenthal (an attorney with Cox, Castle & Nicholson in Riverside, California) spoke about APA's recent development of a policy guide on public redevelopment, noting that it was triggered by increasing concerns about possible abuses of the eminent domain power and legislative reactions to those concerns. The policy guide considers eminent domain as one of many redevelopment tools — one to be used as a last resort, through an open public process, to implement a redevelopment plan that conforms to the community's comprehensive plan. When undertaken in the context of a defined plan, and in a manner that respects the psychic values of affected property owners, eminent domain is far less likely to be controversial.

However the U.S. Supreme Court decides the Kelo case, the issue of how the power of eminent domain may or may not be used for redevelopment will continue to be one of great interest and concern to planners.


American Planning Association: www.planning.org

3/23/2005

Toll-road plan bites the dust: Rocky Mountain News (Denver CO), 3/23/05

Senate committee indefinitely delays 'Super Slab' bill

By Kevin Flynn

Lawmakers on the Senate Transportation Committee were greeted by about 750 angry but well-mannered protesters from the plains - many of whom arrived in a school bus convoy from towns such as Peyton, Calhan and Ellicott - and voted 6-1 to postpone House Bill 1030 indefinitely.

That's General Assembly-speak for killing the bill.

"We hope we'll be able to work with the committee to develop some sort of legislation that will protect the landowners' rights," a jubilant Marsha Looper, of Calhan, said after the vote. She was one of many organizers who helped assemble the large public response.

She said the Eastern Plains Coalition, an umbrella for the various groups fighting the toll road, would continue to meet.

It was by far the largest crowd to come to the Capitol on a single bill in the living memories of numerous Statehouse old-timers. Organized in large part over the Internet in just the past three weeks, the crowd represented at least six of the seven counties through which Wells filed a 12-mile-wide, 210-mile-long claim for a superhighway corridor 20 years ago.

After Wells told the committee his highway and express railroad corridor would bring traffic relief to inner cities by removing through trucks and coal trains, those who live out on the plains urged the committee to keep the city in the city and leave the open country alone.

Also riding high was emotion over a private company such as Wells' Front Range Toll Road Co. having the right to condemn private property for the road - an issue not even addressed in the bill, but which Wells has via a 19th century statute that helped open up mining roads

"We're ranchers on the Colorado plains, and now we're forced to take a stand," said an emotional Chuck Kovanda of Keenesburg, recounting how his forebears homesteaded their initial 160 acres, fought battles with Indians and fought in the nation's wars.

"And to make it worse," he said, motioning to Wells behind him, "he's a dude!"

What led to the defeat of the bill, which last month flew through the House 62-3, was concern over such issues as the lack of public input into planning major projects such as the toll road.

Steve Durham, a former legislator representing cable magnate John Malone, told the committee that Malone and his wife bought 65,000 acres of open space in Elbert County with the intent of preserving the area. The toll road would slice through it.

"A project like this was not likely envisioned when the statute was written," said Durham of the 1882 law last revised in 1891. Rules of public projects have changed immensely since then. "This bill completely overlooks the necessity of modern review policies."

A few in the crowd wore cowboy hats and pointed boots - some fresh polished and others dusty. Some wore T-shirts and sweatshirts sporting anti-toll-road slogans. Two hours before the hearing, about 500 of them rallied on the Capitol's west steps to set their resolute mood in granite.

Only about 220 could fit into the Old Supreme Court Chamber, the Capitol's largest meeting room, filling it to overflow capacity. Three spillover rooms were set up on the third floor and the basement with piped-in audio from the hearing.

Given that Wells last month estimated only about 200 property owners might be affected - an estimate he now says is outdated - there were nearly four times that many people out to protest his plan.

Sen. Stephanie Takis, the committee chairwoman, presided firmly over the 5 1/2-hour hearing. After the vote, she said she would ask the joint House-Senate Transportation Legislation Review Committee to take up the contentious issues raised by private toll roads this summer.

Only bill sponsor Sen. Suzanne Williams, D-Aurora, voted against postponing it. Sen. Bob Hagedorn, also D-Aurora, moved for the postponement.

Sen. Tom Wiens, R-Sedalia, asked most of the critical questions of Wells, noting that other private entities with condemnation power, such as utility and communications companies, nevertheless have government regulators overseeing their operations. The private toll road would not.

Wells sat in a front row with a partner and some advisers, arguing near the beginning for the approval of the bill and then listening to dozens of farmers, ranchers, horse breeders, scouting camp leaders and rural residents condemn his 20-year dream of an eastern Front Range bypass route.

Wells remained seated after the vote while others left, and offered no comment.

The bill would have modernized the way tolls are set on private roads and aligned the Wells plan with the rest of the state's toll collection enforcement system. But it also would have authorized more liberal methods of selling off the road's assets, making it more attractive to investors.

Critics were suspicious of the provision and argued that much more public disclosure of the proposal was needed before the first rancher or homeowner was asked to sell out for the road.

Noting that Wells' proposed highway was to run down the center of a two-mile wide open-space corridor, John Byrnes, of Weld County, voiced what many feared with so much territory under corporate control.

"Many of us think the toll road is just a smoke screen for a land grab of biblical proportions," he said.


Rocky Mountain News: www.rockymountainnews.comwww.rockymountainnews.com

Toll project in path of wrath: Denver (CO) Post, 3/22/05

Rapid growth swells corridor's population

By Chuck Plunkett and Jeffrey A. Roberts

Hundreds of people, many waving signs, gathered at the state Capitol in Denver today to protest plans for a $2 billion high-speed toll road running parallel to Interstate 25.

The Senate transportation committee was scheduled to hear public testimony on the issue at 2 p.m. today.

When the mastermind behind the proposed Front Range Toll Road pitched his project to Colorado legislators and the public last month, he suggested its impact would be minimal, affecting only about 200 property owners.

He has grown to regret that representation, which he based on data he amassed nearly 20 years ago, when he first filed with the state for the opportunity to build the system.

Hundreds of residents in dozens of town meetings in the 210-mile project's path have called him on it.

"I shouldn't have used a number," said Ray Wells, who heads the Front Range Toll Road Co.

A Denver Post analysis of 2000 census data - already 5 years old and not accounting for the explosive growth within several areas of the toll road's path - shows that at least 74,000 people live in the project's corridor.

Compared with the Denver metro area, the population is relatively sparse, considering those people live inside an area of about 2,400 square miles. The Post's review - corroborated by an analyst at the Denver Regional Council of Governments - even reveals a handful of vast, wide-open spaces.

But the number and location of people also make it clear that far more than 200 property owners will have to give up their land if the toll road is built.

Wells said his engineers are studying the population, too, but he hasn't updated his estimate of the number of property owners who might fall in the path of his project.

"All I know is, at this stage, I'm very comfortable that we're not going through any subdivisions," said Wells, who has been called "The Godfather" of private, special district developments.

Wells and his investors have earmarked a 12-mile-wide corridor in which he wants to build a 660-foot-wide road and rail system that would combine a four-lane toll road, rail and infrastructure for power and telecommunications.

The toll road and rail system would run from Pueblo to Fort Collins as an alternative to congested Interstate 25.

On Monday, Wells' company released a survey of 12 Front Range counties - including Elbert, Weld, Adams and Pueblo - that shows 51 percent support the project and 18 percent oppose it. "Following a discussion of the toll road," support rose to 69 percent, according to Ciruli Associates, which conducted the survey Wells commissioned March 14-17.

The survey has a margin of error of 4.4 percentage points.

Wells hopes that the state's Senate Transportation Committee today will approve a bill that would streamline how toll rates are set. His opponents plan to fill the committee chambers.

Cable television magnate John Malone, who owns 65,000 acres in Elbert County, sent a letter to the Transportation Committee last week opposing the project.

Malone's property is devoted to raising cattle and preserving open space. On Monday, officials confirmed that Malone has hired a team of lobbyists to oppose the road as planned.

Malone retained Peter Minahan and his firm, Colorado Communique Inc., and lobbyists Steve Durham and Leo Boyle.

When government entities undertake condemnation proceedings, the process is accompanied by financial analyses and public hearings, Durham said. But the toll road bill makes it easier for private entities to pursue what he calls the government's "nuclear weapon" - the power of condemnation - without public scrutiny.

Malone believes there should be a buffer of open space next to densely developed Front Range communities, Minahan said.

"The location of such a major project should not be left to a private enterprise, as it impacts in a very major way the lives, fortunes and environment we share," Malone wrote to lawmakers. "A 'Great Wall' would severely divide the county, adversely affecting lives and property values," he said.

Malone's objections ring true with Jackie Johnson, who raises miniature donkeys and keeps llamas and an adopted mustang on 66 acres in Elbert County.

Johnson and her husband, Milt, bought the property six years ago.

"This is everything to us," Jackie Johnson said.

Many residents in Wells' path question his use of the term "affected." Even if the trucks and cars and trains aren't running through their property, they say, the proximity of such a project would forever alter their quality of life.

Wells argued last week that the area already is experiencing rapid growth, and his road hasn't been the cause.

And, Wells says, the toll project would help alleviate the congestion, rail traffic and pollution of I-25, which runs through a corridor populated by some 2.5 million people.

"It would be absolutely ridiculous if I said there is absolutely nobody that would ever be affected," Wells said.

But not everyone in the path is concerned. Oliver Cook, 55, was born and raised in Elbert County, and he says he could leave it.

The character of the place hasn't been the same for years, he says. There are so many newcomers, and they are so mobile, that he guesses he doesn't know 90 percent of those in his community anymore.

"As long as they give me fair market value," Cook said. "Granted, it's pretty out here, and I wouldn't want to see it destroyed.

"But I can go someplace else that's quiet."


Denver Post: www.denverpost.com

3/22/2005

'Super Slab' plan piques tempers: Rocky Mountain (CO) News, 3/21/05

Some residents say they won't let toll road steal their land

By Kevin Flynn

Many folks on the eastern Plains say the proposed "Super Slab" toll road will steal their rural lifestyle, their homes and their land over their dead bodies.

For most, that's figurative. For a few, it may be literal.

The Super Slab is super controversial in rural communities where residents value independence, private property and the Second Amendment. The plan calls for a $2 billion, privately financed toll road and rail corridor from Fort Collins to Pueblo, parallel to the Front Range.

The idea has been around for 20 years, but it has been generating a lot of heat lately because of a bill in the legislature that would smooth a few bumps in its financing. The bill is scheduled for a Senate committee hearing Tuesday.

Opponents have organized a campaign, largely through the Internet, to kill the proposal. Chief among their concerns is that its private investors have the right of eminent domain - property condemnation - if landowners don't want to sell.

The plan is being spearheaded by Ray Wells, former manager of the Denver Technological Center, and unidentified investors. They want to build a four-lane highway, including plazas for fuel, food and lodging, and a double-track railroad mainline.

The highway is aimed at truckers and motorists willing to pay for an uninterrupted 85-mph-speed-limit road that avoids all urban congestion. The tracks would take interstate coal trains out of Front Range cities, cutting pollution, noise and congestion.

Rep. Richard Decker, R-Fountain, supports the project. That's made him a target of opponents, whose shouts at one community meeting led Decker to walk out.

"I've always come out on what I thought was in the best interests of my constituents," Decker said. "If the project goes forward, I want to see that it's done right."

Along each side of the 660-foot right of way for the road and tracks, developers want a one-mile no-development buffer strip. Wells would pay property owners for so-called conservation rights to that buffer.

That means the owners would retain the land and use of it for farming or ranching, but they would forfeit any right to develop it. The no-build buffer would protect residents from growth, but also would ensure Wells less competition for services along the road.

No one knows yet exactly where the concrete and asphalt would go. In 1985, Wells filed a legal document akin to a mining claim on a 12-mile-wide corridor, starting in Larimer County and slicing through Weld, Adams, Arapahoe, Elbert, El Paso and Pueblo counties.

Wells doesn't own any of the land yet. The claim allows him only to keep anyone else from building a toll road within that corridor.

Opponents are suspicious of the secrecy surrounding the company's investors, and they are hopping mad over a private profit-making entity being able to condemn their land just like the government. The rhetoric matches the tempers.

"These people need to understand that we will not back down, under any circumstances," said Brian Cooper, of Peyton, webmaster of www.superslab.org, which has rallied folks against the proposal.

"Nobody wants to see a bloodbath, but these people don't have a very good pulse on the type of people that live out here. We're loners, and we are patriots. Most of the Colorado militia lives out here.

"I get e-mails from little old ladies saying that they went out and bought a new shotgun, and that's just the little old ladies. Some of what I am hearing from the men is unprintable."

Indeed, the comments section of superslab.org has some ominous messages.

"They'll confiscate my land by 'eminent domain' or whatever the heck they call it, over my dead body," a Peyton man wrote.

"You come try to steal my land and you will find out why we believe in the Second Amendment!" a person from Ellicott wrote.

And from a Calhan writer:

"If they try to take my land away from me and my family by 'eminent domain' it will be their 'eminent demise.' If they step foot on my land, it'll be a new angle on the 'Make My Day' law! You get my drift?"

Most of the opposition is not as strident. Cable magnate John Malone argued that it is bad public policy to allow a private venture to condemn land without the same open public process governments must use.

Malone owns about 65,000 acres of Elbert County open space that he said he wants to conserve.

"Clearly, these plans could be severely impacted by a road project that is purely profit motivated, ignoring other important societal values such as conservation," he wrote in opposition to the plan.

Citizens of Adams, Elbert, Pueblo and Weld counties also are organizing opposition.

Patty Sward, of Elizabeth, said it's unthinkable that a private company could force the sale of property for a roadway that the Colorado Department of Transportation said last fall wasn't financially feasible.

Oddly enough, the consultant Wells used to make his case is the same one who did the CDOT study.

"This private corporation is seeking eminent domain rights over a 212-mile-by-12-mile stretch of Colorado without adequate public hearing, disclosure of business plans or business partners," Sward said.

In Bennett, Cindy Bulinski bought her land seven years ago and built a house on it five years ago.

"Our first gut reaction was that we moved to the country and now they're going to bring the city to us," she said. "This is not good for Colorado growth issues."

Opponents are planning to swarm into Denver on Tuesday for the Senate committee hearing on House Bill 1030. One group is renting buses.

The bill sailed through the House last month, 62-3. The no votes came from Democrats, two from Denver and one from Boulder County.

The bill would have CDOT set the Super Slab's toll rates instead of each county's commissioners. That would provide a single, consistent rate through all the counties.

The bill also would make it easier for Wells' company to sell off its assets, making it more appealing to investors. Opponents mistrust this provision, seeing it as a back-door entry to development.

"You don't make the money off a $10 toll from Fort Collins to Pueblo," said Rep. Paul Weissmann, D-Louisville, one of the lawmakers who voted against the plan. "You make the money from building a Holiday Inn or a Super Wal-Mart along the way."

"It could bring massive growth and urban sprawl," said Rep. Jerry Frangas, D-Denver. "I read some of the stuff about condemnation and thought, 'Well, if they were going to do this in north Denver, I'd sure want someone to stand up for me.' "

Wells has said the project can go forward without the bill.

Sen. Suzanne Williams, D-Aurora, the Senate sponsor of the bill, has lined up a few amendments to address some of the resident complaints.

"They're in response to different questions that we've had," she said.

One change would establish a citizens task force to monitor the project. But the basic concern of residents - property condemnation - is not addressed.

Some opponents think killing the bill would deny Wells the right of condemnation. Not so. He already has that authority under a 123-year-old law that allows private firms that build roads and utilities to condemn land, his spokeswoman said.

The 1882 statute permitted Gen. William Jackson Palmer, the founder of Colorado Springs, to acquire land for his Pikes Peak Toll Road. It's the law that allows companies such as Xcel Energy, Qwest or enterprises that build roads, ditches, reservoirs, pipelines, bridges, tunnels and electric or telephone lines to condemn easements or rights of way from unwilling sellers.

Decker said communities couldn't function without private companies having such rights.

"You can't make a phone call or turn on a light or fill your bathtub without enjoying the benefits of eminent domain used by private companies," he said.

Wells' spokeswoman Ellen Dumm said the plan will receive plenty of public perusal. Wells' contract with investors precludes him from identifying them until after the legislation is passed, she said.

Dumm said the highway will follow the easiest path: the fewest hills, the smallest environmental impact and the most willing sellers.

"There's plenty of ground still available," she said. "There are lots of people out there who want to sell, especially the conservation rights."

But the opposition is dug in for a fight.

"All means of nonviolent action will be taken first," Cooper said. "If all legal avenues are exhausted, but to no avail, then it's no-holds- barred.

"What we are saying is that drastic times demand drastic measures. If we have our land stolen, then we will resort to drastic measures. How drastic remains to be seen."

'Super Slab' slate

Players in the debate:
  • Ray Wells, 71, Castle Rock, former manager of Denver Tech Center and driving force behind the project.
  • Richard Decker, 67, Fountain, state representative for the district that includes eastern El Paso County, where part of the road would go.
  • Brian Cooper, 47, Peyton, webmaster of Superslab.org, a Web site organizing opposition to the project.

Toll road facts:
  • What: "Super Slab," or Front Range Toll Road and freight rail line
  • How much: $2 billion in private funds
  • Where: 210-mile corridor on eastern Plains from Fort Collins to Pueblo, parallel to Interstate 25
  • Why: To take truck, train and other traffic off congested Front Range freeways
  • How: Buying 660-foot path for road and tracks, plus conservation rights to one-mile buffer on each side. Condemnation possible if sellers are unwilling.
  • What's next: State Senate Transportation Committee hearing on HB 1030, which would make some changes to the way private toll roads are done, 2 p.m. Tuesday in the Capitol's Old Supreme Court Chamber



Rocky Mountain News: www.RockyMountainNews.com

3/20/2005

City could take arena land by eminent domain if needed: The (Fargo -Grand Forks ND) Forum, 3/16/05

By Mary Jo Almquist

If downtown business owners refuse to make way for a $40 million arena and events center proposed for their block, Fargo officials may have to use force to move them.

But the city will use eminent domain - a rarely used tactic allowing the government to seize private property for public use - only as a last resort, Fargo City Commissioner John Cosgriff told about two dozen business owners Tuesday.

If voters approve the taxpayer-funded Renaissance Center May 3, the city hopes to negotiate a fair buyout with everyone involved, Cosgriff said.

For example, if a business wants to come back to the block if and when the Renaissance Center is built, that could be arranged, he said. It's also possible that a temporary location could be secured downtown for businesses waiting for the new facility.

But Cosgriff also warned business owners that the process will be political.

"I cannot promise you this is going to be easy," he said.

The buyout process will only be necessary if voters approve a 3 1/2-year extension of the Fargodome sales tax to pay for the arena and events center, proposed for the block bound by First Avenue North, NP Avenue, Broadway and Roberts Street.

Cosgriff, along with Cityscapes Development President Mike Bullinger and Brad Wimmer, chairman of the arena citizen s committee, on Tuesday tried to paint a picture of what could happen if voters approve the project.

Cityscapes and the citizen's group already have met with several civic groups and local government boards.

Paul Dobbins, owner of PD's on First, organized the business owner meeting at his restaurant. These are people who, like Dobbins, would have to relocate if the arena is built. Dobbins said he thinks the project is a great idea.

Cosgriff explained if the vote goes through, the city would be responsible for acquiring and clearing the land. The portion that would be dedicated to the $60 million private office, retail and condominium tower would then be sold back to Cityscapes for development.

That land could generate about $1 million per year in property taxes, compared to the $58,000 being collected today for the entire block, project backers say.

Without the Renaissance Center, it will probably be 20 years before this block fills in, Wimmer said. With the project, it will take about three years, he said.

One building some historians have expressed concern about demolishing is the old bank building at 52 Broadway.

Bullinger said he recently talked with architects and it may be possible to save the building and incorporate it into the design.

Rick Engen, who owns the property, wants to open a nightclub in the space. If his building can be saved, Engen said he would be all for the Cityscapes plan.

Another major property on the block is the fire station, though Fargo Fire Chief Bruce Hoover said he's not concerned about the looming relocation process. Ideally, the city's main fire station should be a little farther south and west anyway, Hoover said.

Not everyone who attended Tuesday s meeting was pleased with what they heard. Property owner Nachhattar Gill is still concerned about the proposal and about Cityscapes Development.

"This is not the right place to build an arena downtown," Gill said. "This is a bad idea."


The Forum: www.in-forum.com



Smart Growth Fargo is a group formed to fight this abuse of eminent domain involving the taking of property and turning it over to a private developer rather than using it for a specific public purpose. For information about Smart Growth Fargo, click here: http://votenomay3rd.blogspot.com

3/18/2005

Eminent domain urged to acquire properties for Heart of Boynton: (South Florida) Sun-Sentinel, 3/18/05

By Ushma Patel

Almost half of the properties involved in the Heart of Boynton's first redevelopment phase may be taken by eminent domain.

After about six months of negotiation, the Community Redevelopment Agency voted Thursday to ask the city to move forward with eminent domain proceedings against 15 of the 31 properties involved in the first phase at Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard and Seacrest Boulevard. The CRA does not have authority to take properties by eminent domain.

Roberts Restaurant, the EZ Market and Triumph the Church of Kingdom of God in Christ are among the 15 properties.

Starting eminent domain proceedings could invigorate a project that began almost four years ago, CRA Director Doug Hutchinson said.

"We need some way to forecast a timetable," he said. "The community's been waiting and watching."

The Urban Group, which is conducting the contract negotiations, said it has made numerous contacts with property owners. Even after the city initiates eminent domain proceedings, the CRA can continue to negotiate with owners.

But some board members were hesitant.

"I'm not in favor of eminent domain for an individual's house, regardless of the greater good of the project," board member Don Fenton said.

All of the properties that serve as homesteads have been taken care of, Hutchinson said.

Of the 16 other parcels involved in Phase 1, the CRA has purchased eight properties, has one contract pending, one is involved in legal proceedings, and six properties are designated as self-assembly areas, meaning they will join with the CRA in the Heart of Boynton redevelopment.

While property owners will get fair-market value for their homes under eminent domain, those who sold to the CRA have gotten better values.

For instance, Thursday the CRA approved the purchase of a home on Northwest Eighth Avenue. The home's assessed value was $53,563, and the fair-market value was appraised at $100,000. The owners received that amount, plus $100,000 to relocate to a comparable home in the area.


Sun-Sentinel: www.sun-sentinel.com

Eminent domain urged to acquire properties for Heart of Boynton: (South Florida) Sun-Sentinel, 3/18/05

By Ushma Patel

Almost half of the properties involved in the Heart of Boynton's first redevelopment phase may be taken by eminent domain.

After about six months of negotiation, the Community Redevelopment Agency voted Thursday to ask the city to move forward with eminent domain proceedings against 15 of the 31 properties involved in the first phase at Martin Luther King Jr. Boulevard and Seacrest Boulevard. The CRA does not have authority to take properties by eminent domain.

Roberts Restaurant, the EZ Market and Triumph the Church of Kingdom of God in Christ are among the 15 properties.

Starting eminent domain proceedings could invigorate a project that began almost four years ago, CRA Director Doug Hutchinson said.

"We need some way to forecast a timetable," he said. "The community's been waiting and watching."

The Urban Group, which is conducting the contract negotiations, said it has made numerous contacts with property owners. Even after the city initiates eminent domain proceedings, the CRA can continue to negotiate with owners.

But some board members were hesitant.

"I'm not in favor of eminent domain for an individual's house, regardless of the greater good of the project," board member Don Fenton said.

All of the properties that serve as homesteads have been taken care of, Hutchinson said.

Of the 16 other parcels involved in Phase 1, the CRA has purchased eight properties, has one contract pending, one is involved in legal proceedings, and six properties are designated as self-assembly areas, meaning they will join with the CRA in the Heart of Boynton redevelopment.

While property owners will get fair-market value for their homes under eminent domain, those who sold to the CRA have gotten better values.

For instance, Thursday the CRA approved the purchase of a home on Northwest Eighth Avenue. The home's assessed value was $53,563, and the fair-market value was appraised at $100,000. The owners received that amount, plus $100,000 to relocate to a comparable home in the area.


Sun-Sentinel: www.sun-sentinel.com

Group holds 1st meeting to fight eminent domain abuse: Atlanticville (Long Branch NJ), 3/16/05

By Christine Varno

A group of residents living in one of Long Branch’s redevelopment zones held the first meeting of its newly formed coalition on Sunday, which the founder said was a “great turn-out”.

“I thought it was a very positive meeting,” said Harold Bobrow, Ocean Boulevard.

The two-hour meeting was held at Bobrow’s home on Ocean Boulevard and was attended by 16 people. Bobrow said four others called and said they were interested but could not make it.

“We had an agenda and we opened every topic up for discussion,” he said.

The following topics were on the agenda; The abuse of eminent domain; The Kelo vs. New London, Conn., case, a case before the Supreme Court where a homeowner is fighting to save her oceanfront home from being taken through eminent domain and redeveloped by a private development company; and the importance of attending the twice-a-month council meetings.

The coalition was formed to accomplish two goals, “to stop eminent domain abuse and to obtain equitable compensation for property if taken,” Bobrow said.

“People are very anxious and do not want to be displaced.”

The next meeting of the coalition is scheduled to be held April 10 at 1 p.m. at 295 Ocean Blvd., Unit 5.

Beachfront South is a 12-acre tract of land that extends from Bath Avenue to Morris Avenue between Ocean Boulevard and Ocean Avenue, which is slated for eminent domain.

In August, K. Hovnanian Shore Acquisitions LLC, Middletown, was designated as the redevelopers of the zone and plan to construct a $300 million project that includes razing the existing neighborhood of approximately 30 properties and constructing five buildings with 350 units in its place.

The new units will range in cost from $400,000 up to over $2.2 million,

At a January council meeting, Mayor Adam Schneider said the city is 80 percent of the way to signing a contact.

Bobrow said he is currently arranging a meeting between the residents of Beachfront South, Mayor Adam Schneider, council President Anthony Giordano and representatives from K. Hovnanian.

“We [Beachfront South] want to be part of the [redevelopment] process,” he said.

Bobrow will present three possible dates for the meeting to the mayor, at which point the mayor will have to schedule the meeting for the date that all representatives can attend.

Bobrow said he intends to give the mayor the dates by the end of the month and is hoping for an April meeting.

“I want input before they sign the final documents,” Bobrow said. “Maybe we can amend, change or discuss various issues.”

“There are certain things that I want to know and I am going to the horse’s mouth for that information.”


Atlanticville: www.atlanticville.gmnews.com

Eminent Domain and Government Giveaways: The Progress Report, 3/18/05

Special Guest Commentary

By Wyn Achenbaum

Can land speculators force entire communities to sprawl inefficiently, without bearing any liability? Does government have the right to seize non-blighted properties and give them to private corporations? Are there better ways to enable development without trampling property rights?

Today we bring you Wyn Achenbaum's first-hand commentary on the big eminent domain dispute called "Kelo versus New London," a case that is being decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.

It seems to me that there are better ways than eminent domain to provide the incentives that will lead the private sector to develop choice land. I've walked the New London, Connecticut, neighborhood involved in the Kelo case (before I was aware of the case). It sits fairly high above the Thames River near Long Island Sound, overlooking Fort Trumbull, which has been restored in recent years. On the other side is the new Pfizer research facility and a manmade lagoon and wetlands, apparently quite carefully planned and planted, some of it on land reclaimed after being the site for a junkyard.

While at one time this area might have been an appropriate place for a neighborhood of single family homes, it appeared to me that that time had passed a decade or so ago. It seemed to me that the path of progress would — if the incentives were logical and the market responsive to signals — have caused the private sector to have redeveloped that site. Such re-development might have been painful to the residents of the neighborhood, but would have put now-choice land to a higher and better use than single-family homes.

But our system wasn't designed to send signals all that well — Connecticut law required properties to be reassessed once every decade (and I've heard that once in early '70s and once in the late 80's was construed to satisfy that requirement). Now assessments are required every 4 years (though my town decided it didn't like the 2003 revaluation and is keeping the 1999 for a few more years).

But if the properties had been reassessed on a regular basis, with market-based values assigned first to the land and the residual being assigned to the existing buildings, the homeowners themselves would have been in a position to make their own rational decisions on whether it was worth it to them to continue to occupy extremely valuable land (and pay the taxes on it), or more to their advantage to accept an offer from someone who was prepared to put it to a higher and better use, and take that equity and buy elsewhere.

I am sympathetic to those who want to occupy their homes forever, but if those homes are located on land that is valuable (because of its views or water access or transportation services, for example) or becomes valuable because of surrounding development, it seems fair that they compensate the rest of us for holding up progress, for continuing to occupy as single-family residences, land which it is now time to develop into something that produces good results for the entire community.

Most of us know of an older home, or perhaps a diner, or something else that was a highly appropriate use for its site — and typical of the neighborhood — 50 years ago, which stubbornly remains in the middle of a neighborhood which has been redeveloped with taller commercial buildings. The home or diner is something everyone else has to walk around, drive around. If that site were well developed, it could prevent the premature development of far less desirable sites on the fringe of town — an acre downtown well developed, can save 10 or so acres on the fringe.

Should we protect the right of elderly people to stay in their homes, at the expense of the rest of the community? Should we protect the right of a young person who shares that home to stay there for an entire lifetime, at the expense of the community? I'm comfortable with the idea of allowing the elderly person to defer payment of the property taxes, with interest-bearing debt accruing against the property until it is sold or transferred. It seems to me to be an acceptable tradeoff, even if it creates potholes in the redevelopment. But his heirs should not inherit it until the lien is satisfied, which will usually mean that at last it will be developed consistent with the neighborhood.

But unless the properties are regularly and correctly assessed, land first and buildings as the residual, we won't have the signals which tell us when it might be time to move on.

In the absence of such a system of regular revaluations and a property tax which is concentrated on land values rather than equally on land and buildings, New London turned to eminent domain. But eminent domain is not the problem here. Lack of appropriate signals is the problem.

I live at the other end of Connecticut, and near me is a beautiful parkway which runs about 40 miles. For most of its length, it is a rather straight highway. But near its westernmost end, the straight road has some huge curves, designed to take it around some properties which the builders of the highway did not seek to acquire via eminent domain after the owners chose not to sell. Every driver who uses the westernmost section of the Merritt Parkway must drive extra miles in order to protect those wealthy 1930s landholders and their successors. I estimate that at least 1.3 billion extra miles have been driven by the general public. Had the builders of the parkway exercised eminent domain, this mileage, and the pollution and expense involved, would have been saved. Instead, the costs are shifted onto every driver and onto the taxpayers who maintain the highway and its services. Eminent domain would, I think, have been an appropriate step to prevent that. Today, the properties are among the most valuable residences in Connecticut, but their owners don't compensate the rest of us for our inconvenience and expense.

Our land, particularly the best-located land, is a common asset on which we are all dependent. Allowing individuals or corporations to occupy it without compensating the rest of us for its value is the underlying problem, and solving that problem through good assessment and rational (that is, land value) taxes is the way to solve it. When we do that, a lot of problems will begin to fall away.

For more background and ideas, see these articles:


The Progress Report: www.progress.org

Eminent Domain and Government Giveaways: The Progress Report, 3/17/05

Special Guest Commentary

By Wyn Achenbaum

Can land speculators force entire communities to sprawl inefficiently, without bearing any liability? Does government have the right to seize non-blighted properties and give them to private corporations? Are there better ways to enable development without trampling property rights?

Today we bring you Wyn Achenbaum's first-hand commentary on the big eminent domain dispute called "Kelo versus New London," a case that is being decided by the U.S. Supreme Court.

It seems to me that there are better ways than eminent domain to provide the incentives that will lead the private sector to develop choice land. I've walked the New London, Connecticut, neighborhood involved in the Kelo case (before I was aware of the case). It sits fairly high above the Thames River near Long Island Sound, overlooking Fort Trumbull, which has been restored in recent years. On the other side is the new Pfizer research facility and a manmade lagoon and wetlands, apparently quite carefully planned and planted, some of it on land reclaimed after being the site for a junkyard.

While at one time this area might have been an appropriate place for a neighborhood of single family homes, it appeared to me that that time had passed a decade or so ago. It seemed to me that the path of progress would — if the incentives were logical and the market responsive to signals — have caused the private sector to have redeveloped that site. Such re-development might have been painful to the residents of the neighborhood, but would have put now-choice land to a higher and better use than single-family homes.

But our system wasn't designed to send signals all that well — Connecticut law required properties to be reassessed once every decade (and I've heard that once in early '70s and once in the late 80's was construed to satisfy that requirement). Now assessments are required every 4 years (though my town decided it didn't like the 2003 revaluation and is keeping the 1999 for a few more years).

But if the properties had been reassessed on a regular basis, with market-based values assigned first to the land and the residual being assigned to the existing buildings, the homeowners themselves would have been in a position to make their own rational decisions on whether it was worth it to them to continue to occupy extremely valuable land (and pay the taxes on it), or more to their advantage to accept an offer from someone who was prepared to put it to a higher and better use, and take that equity and buy elsewhere.

I am sympathetic to those who want to occupy their homes forever, but if those homes are located on land that is valuable (because of its views or water access or transportation services, for example) or becomes valuable because of surrounding development, it seems fair that they compensate the rest of us for holding up progress, for continuing to occupy as single-family residences, land which it is now time to develop into something that produces good results for the entire community.

Most of us know of an older home, or perhaps a diner, or something else that was a highly appropriate use for its site — and typical of the neighborhood — 50 years ago, which stubbornly remains in the middle of a neighborhood which has been redeveloped with taller commercial buildings. The home or diner is something everyone else has to walk around, drive around. If that site were well developed, it could prevent the premature development of far less desirable sites on the fringe of town — an acre downtown well developed, can save 10 or so acres on the fringe.

Should we protect the right of elderly people to stay in their homes, at the expense of the rest of the community? Should we protect the right of a young person who shares that home to stay there for an entire lifetime, at the expense of the community? I'm comfortable with the idea of allowing the elderly person to defer payment of the property taxes, with interest-bearing debt accruing against the property until it is sold or transferred. It seems to me to be an acceptable tradeoff, even if it creates potholes in the redevelopment. But his heirs should not inherit it until the lien is satisfied, which will usually mean that at last it will be developed consistent with the neighborhood.

But unless the properties are regularly and correctly assessed, land first and buildings as the residual, we won't have the signals which tell us when it might be time to move on.

In the absence of such a system of regular revaluations and a property tax which is concentrated on land values rather than equally on land and buildings, New London turned to eminent domain. But eminent domain is not the problem here. Lack of appropriate signals is the problem.

I live at the other end of Connecticut, and near me is a beautiful parkway which runs about 40 miles. For most of its length, it is a rather straight highway. But near its westernmost end, the straight road has some huge curves, designed to take it around some properties which the builders of the highway did not seek to acquire via eminent domain after the owners chose not to sell. Every driver who uses the westernmost section of the Merritt Parkway must drive extra miles in order to protect those wealthy 1930s landholders and their successors. I estimate that at least 1.3 billion extra miles have been driven by the general public. Had the builders of the parkway exercised eminent domain, this mileage, and the pollution and expense involved, would have been saved. Instead, the costs are shifted onto every driver and onto the taxpayers who maintain the highway and its services. Eminent domain would, I think, have been an appropriate step to prevent that. Today, the properties are among the most valuable residences in Connecticut, but their owners don't compensate the rest of us for our inconvenience and expense.

Our land, particularly the best-located land, is a common asset on which we are all dependent. Allowing individuals or corporations to occupy it without compensating the rest of us for its value is the underlying problem, and solving that problem through good assessment and rational (that is, land value) taxes is the way to solve it. When we do that, a lot of problems will begin to fall away.

For more background and ideas, see these articles:


The Progress Report: www.progress.org

3/17/2005

Eminent domain loopholes should be closed: WMVV Radio (Atlanta GA), 3/16/05

Commentary

By Sue Ella Deadwyler

The proposal that [georgia] government use the power of eminent domain to condemn private property for economic development was so bad that, when it was first introduced in S.B. 5, it didn't make it out of committee. But, we have the same song, second verse in S.B. 86 and it's moving toward becoming law. S.B. 86 passed the Senate 40 to 10 last Thursday and is now in the House Judiciary Committee where it needs to stay.

S.B. 86 has loopholes that must be closed before private property owners are secure on their own property. Consider this. S.B. 86 continues the notion that private property can be taken for economic development but says it this way: "[I]n no event shall a public purpose be construed to include the exercise of eminent domain solely or primarily for the purpose of improving tax revenue or the tax base or the purpose of economic development." Note the loophole "solely or primarily" that allows private property to be condemned if government decides to use some other excuse for taking property from those who don't want to sell.

The bill continues, "This shall include condemning property for the purpose of transferring, leasing, or allowing the use of such property to a private
developer, corporation, or other entity solely or primarily to attempt to expand tax revenue, increase the taxable value of the property, or promote economic development." Note that loophole "solely or primarily" again. Also, note that it allows the state to grab land to hand over to private developers, corporations or others. Does that give government the right to condemn more land than is actually needed for authentic public purposes and then sell or lease or give to a private developer the rest of the property? It sounds like that to me. So private property owners could lose their own property, simply, because government wants it transferred to a more prosperous private owner that could provide a more lucrative tax base.

S.B. 86 declares the intent of the General Assembly is that private property rights of residents and businesses should be protected over the interests of private developers and corporations. However, the last time I looked, "should" is a softer word than shall. Shall is a mandate. So, should private property owners be protected? Yes, they should, but shall should've been written instead of should if the General Assembly really intends to protect private property from predators, including government predators that would rather collect big business taxes than settle for lower personal taxes on the same property.

This bill went to the House Judiciary Committee chaired by Representative Wendell Willard. Call him at 404-656-5124 and ask him to keep S.B. 86 in his committee. Not only is it bad news for private property owners, the U.S. Constitution prohibits the use of eminent domain to take private property for economic development. Eminent domain may be legitimately used for public projects such as roads, bridges and public buildings, but not to transfer land to other private owners. Private property ownership is a basic foundation of the free enterprise system and government should stop fiddlin' with it.


WMVV Radio: www.wmvv.com

3/14/2005

More residents take up fight against eminent domain: (Long Branch NJ) Atlanticville, 3/10/05

Beachfront South Coalition forms to oppose taking of homes

By Christine Varno

A Long Branch couple living in one of the city’s oceanfront redevelopment zones is hoping to add to the voices opposing the use of eminent domain by the city.

Harold and Michelle Bobrow, Ocean Boulevard, are scheduled to host the first meeting of the Beachfront South Coalition this weekend at their residence at 295 Ocean Blvd., unit 5, at 11 a.m.

“We are anticipating a number of people will attend,” said Harold Bobrow. “If only two people show, that’s OK too. We will work with whoever shows.”

According to the Bobrows, the new coalition will have two goals, “to stop eminent domain abuse and to obtain equitable compensation for property if taken.”

The coalition is open to all interested parties, including individuals who do not live in the Beachfront South area or any redevelopment zone he added.

“If other people want to join who think eminent domain abuse is wrong, they can come too,” he said.

Beachfront South is a 12-acre tract of land that extends from Bath Avenue to Morris Avenue between Ocean Boulevard and Ocean Avenue, which is slated for eminent domain.

In August, K. Hovnanian Shore Acquisitions, Middletown, was designated as the redeveloper of the zone. Plans call for a $300 million project that includes razing the existing neighborhood of approximately 30 properties and construction of five buildings with 350 units in its place.

The new units will range in cost from $400,000 up to more than $2.2 million.

At a January council meeting, Long Branch Mayor Adam Schneider said the city is 80 percent of the way to signing a contract with the developers.

The Bobrows, who have lived in their home for 15 years, say what is being done is wrong.

“I would have no problem if the city had to take my home for eminent domain to build a school, or a hospital, or even to widen a road for some reason,” Harold Bobrow said. “There are certain things that are for the better of the community.

“Telling me that taking the right of an individual to live in their home so other people can live in more expensive homes, I cannot agree with that. I think that is just wrong.”

The Beachfront South residents are not alone in their feelings.

Another group, MTOTSA (Marine and Ocean Terraces and Seaview Avenue), which is made up of residents living in the city’s Beachfront North, phase II, redevelopment zone, formed a coalition more than a year ago for the same cause.

MTOTSA recently hosted a rally to show support for the plaintiff in an eminent domain case currently before the U.S. Supreme Court. The court has begun hearing arguments in Kelo vs. New London, Conn., a suit in which a homeowner is fighting the taking of her home on the New London waterfront through eminent domain for a private development corporation to redevelop the land.

The Bobrows were among 250 supporters at the local rally on Feb. 20, two days before the Supreme Court began its hearings.

“When you form together you can create a voice and be heard,” Harold Bobrow said.

For that reason, the Bobrows said they are ready to get their neighborhood involved and form a group of residents to meet monthly to fight eminent domain abuse.

One Beachfront South resident, who is the fourth generation living in her Ocean Avenue home, said she has high hopes for the coalition.

“We have been working closely with MTOTSA, but Beachfront South has yet to form a coalition of its own,” Katina Tsakiris said. “I am really happy that Harold is doing this because we have been running on the wake of MTOTSA.”

“We hope to get the word out and end the abuse of eminent domain.”

“We hope [the coalition] will have an impact on the city government and promote public awareness of the abuse of eminent domain,” Michelle Bobrow said.

“As Abraham Lincoln said, ‘If united we stand, divided we fall.’ ”

Harold Bobrow said the couple is trying to do something positive.

“If we can get people together to form a group to fight [eminent domain abuse], then we can have [the city] listen,” Harold said.

“I am not rolling over and playing dead,” he said. “I will not do it. I do not want to sell, and no one should be able to take my home by interpreting the law this way.”


Atlanticville: atlanticville.gmnews.com

Eminent domain use caters to developers: Asbury Park (NJ) Press , 3/10/05

By Kathleen E. Lo Pinto Vignolini, Long Branch NJ

Mayor Adam Schneider claims Long Branch citizens just don't understand the need to use eminent domain to take property. Unfortunately, we understand all too well. No property is safe from being stolen if a developer comes up with a plan for high-end condos and better ratables. Most homes in the affected area were well kept and family owned. Only a few rentals could be called blighted.

Profit for the few comes ahead of, and at the expense of, the many. The city is to blame for the blighted areas by not having enough code inspectors to keep after and penalize landlords.

The developer gives a homeowner, say, $200,000 fair market value, then builds four units there at $300,000 to $450,000 each. Thus he gleans a profit of $1 million to $1.6 million per property. That's when development doubles or triples the "sales value" of all Long Branch homes. Why is that bad? Every time home values increase, the taxes increase. At this inflated rate of growth, who can keep their homes for long?

Schneider's response to the Feb. 20 rally against eminent domain was, "They haven't wanted an honest dialogue ... yet." I take that to mean they haven't caved in to the developer's demands.

Long Branch's slogan is "The Friendly City." Friendly to whom: the citizens who have lived, worked, shopped and paid taxes for generations or to those with enough big bucks to afford living here now? Our rents are atrocious, house prices are perverse and taxes are outlandish. This development project exploits the citizens who have been paying the city's bills for decades.


Asbury Park Press: www.app.com

Supreme Court should rein in eminent domain: Liberty (MO) Sun-News, 3/10/05

Opinions

Under this nation's original property law, the Fifth Amendment, "A man's home is his castle" carried the weight of Scripture, but present laws suggest, "A person's home is his government's, which can buy and sell that home to anyone for a profit."

The situation is an injustice perpetrated upon Northlanders and other people nationwide by the government's unrestrained, oppressive use of eminent domain.

People who used to live around Kansas City International Airport learned that fact the hard way.

Liberty Triangle businesses, churches, charities and home owners are now learning that fact the hard way, too.

When New London, Conn., residents were about to learn the hard way, they rebelled. They united against letting city government bulldoze their houses for private development. They carried their fight to the U.S. Supreme Court, which last week heard both sides of the issue and could render a decision affecting all property owners by fall.

Taking the city's side are groups such as the National League of Cities. They argue that for cities to earn more income to benefit all citizens, cities must be able to take and turn over citizens' houses to private developers.

The argument makes sense at one level. Only a slumlord would defend run-down tenements - buildings with leaky roofs, faulty wiring and rats. Such buildings endanger a community and should be replaced by tax-producing houses or businesses. The law allowed such condemnations for decades and raised little concern until 1954 when the Supreme Court slightly adjusted the Fifth Amendment prohibition against the government's ability to snatch one person's private land for another person's private profit. The court granted cities the right to take non-blighted land, in an otherwise blighted area, so that private businesses could proceed with "urban renewal."

After that subtle change, some state courts and legislatures went wild, eroding the public's right to land ownership - a right Colonists fought for and wrote into the Constitution because the British, also, had a nasty, self-serving habit of taking private property. Five decades of tinkering by the government, and for the government, have brought eminent domain laws to their present tyrannical status, with varying degrees of "taking" allowed from state to state.

In Missouri, ranked by the Institute for Justice as one of the worst states for abusing private property owners, almost anything goes. Missouri courts find the slightest pretext sufficient for a city to take anyone's house, anyone's business. As an example, Kansas City grabbed private land around the airport in the mid-1990s. The city had no plan for how to use the land, just a foggy notion that maybe, someday, the land might be useful. Based on that quicksand foundation, the Missouri Court of Appeals in 1998 stomped on individual property rights and allowed the city to take the land.

"In Missouri, the (eminent domain) challenges have gone nowhere in the state court system, because the courts view it as a legislative decision and the legislature has invested the 'local legislatures' with virtually absolute discretion to declare something blighted as long as they follow the procedures," Stanley Wallach, chairman of the Missouri Bar's Eminent Domain Law Committee, told the Sun.

This means a city may offer a family $200,000 for a house, but if the family believes the house is worth $400,000, too bad for the family. An owner may dicker with city representatives over price, but if the two sides reach an impasse, the city wins. The average person might think, "I'd sue." But as Wallach observed, in all such cases the city has the upper hand because Missouri's court rulings are crystal clear - government rights trump individual rights.

Lopsided favoritism of the government vs. the public's Fifth Amendment right to protection from eminent domain can hurt a community. The Spirit of Liberty building in the Triangle is a case in point. The city wants to raze the building. Doing so would mean In As Much and Love INC, church-affiliated ministries that help the poor, would be left homeless. The situation is tragic and ironic. Liberty City Council, in a bid to help the community, wants to demolish a building that helps the community. Liberty City Council, to raise more tax dollars, has forced community members to start raising money, too - about $3 million to build a new home for the two ministries, which otherwise could be tossed into the street.

Eminent domain makes sense as a means to remove dangerous buildings, and for public projects such as highway construction, but the present use of eminent domain is out of control. According to the Institute for Justice in Washington, between 1998 and 2002, local governments either used or threatened to use eminent domain an incredible 10,000 times.

Unless the Supreme Court rules otherwise, there is no end in sight for what cities can and will do to take private property - homes, businesses, churches. No end nationally. No end in Missouri. No end in Kansas City. No end in Liberty. None.

The Supreme Court, which started on the slippery path of eroding the public's rights in 1954, should reverse the eminent domain trend not only for New London property owners, but for American property owners everywhere.


Sun-News: www.zwire.com