2/24/2005

Eminent domain plan to be revised in National City: San Diego (CA) Union-Tribune, 2/23/05

By Tanya Sierra

A key piece of the [National City CA] downtown revitalization plan was delayed again last night when officials voted to revise the eminent domain expansion proposal.

City officials have been trying for months to double the territory they are able to take over for redevelopment, but each time they are ready to move on the issue, resident concerns stall a vote.

Citizens and council members were worried that eminent domain wouldn't expire for 12 years, that the expansion area wasn't specific enough and that the proposal failed to clearly state that homes would not be condemned.

Community Development Director Ben Martinez will revise the proposal next month. The next vote is scheduled for March 22.

Although cities have used eminent domain for different purposes, in National City it allows city officials to take over any private property that is abandoned or vacant, and property in the redevelopment area zoned for commercial or industrial use.

It has been a contentious topic with residents because most are suspicious of the process. Even though officials have said during public meetings that expanding their authority does not include residential property, written documents about the subject do not say it clearly enough.

Ted Godshalk, a National City resident, asked that the new resolution state high in the document that residences would not be included.

Other speakers wondered why the authority had to last so long.

Councilman Luis Natividad said he was conflicted about the expansion.

"It's difficult for me to vote against an item that is seen as a tool for progress," he said. "I will only support it if it pertains to a specific area to be developed – not a blanket granting of eminent domain on the whole city."

The proposal was to expand eminent domain territory from National City Boulevard and the Harbor District to include Highland Avenue, the city's west side, East Plaza Boulevard, parts of the Eighth Street corridor and parts of 30th Street and Sweetwater Road.

But Councilman Ron Morrison said more specific project areas should be given, and asked whether they could decrease the amount of time they would have power.

"I have a problem with us just throwing out 12 years," he said. "Let's take a look at the time period actually needed."

State law allows eminent domain power to last 12 years, but cities could shorten the time.


San Diego Union-Tribune: www.signonsandiego.com

Riviera Beach may feel ripple effect of Connecticut eminent domain case: Palm Beach (FL) Post, 2/22/05

By Tanya Wragg

Bonnie Larson's father bought their house on West 27th Street [in Riviera beach FL] 65 years ago because he wanted to be close to the ocean.

A restorative artist who worked on cathedrals for a living, he built the fireplace in his home from brick, the closets and shelves from cypress wood and painted an Everglades scene on the dining room walls.

But now, the home Larson holds dear lies within the city's redevelopment boundaries and she is afraid the city will seize it one day using eminent domain.

Larson and about 40 others gathered at Bicentennial Park on Monday, Presidents' Day, to rally and raise awareness of the city's plans for eminent domain.

Today, a group of Connecticut homeowners who may lose their homes to a waterfront hotel and office space will go before the U.S. Supreme Court in Kelo vs. City of New London.

"If the Supreme Court says it's OK in one way or another to take private property, sell to other private people, whether it's a developer or a hotel or whatever, then really no one in this entire country will be safe because no one's home can bring in as much money as a luxury condo," said rally organizer Martha Babson, who lives in the redevelopment area.

Political candidates participating in the rally included Shelby Lowe, who is running for a city council seat in District 5, Vanessa 'Van' Lee, running for District 1, and Bishop Thomas Masters, running for mayor.

While the city is still months, possibly years, away from large-scale redevelopment, it still has the authority to seize property designated as blight. City officials have said they would use eminent domain only as a last resort. Riviera's billion-dollar redevelopment plan includes the condemnation of 1,700 homes and apartments.

People in 13 other states, including Arizona, Illinois and New York, who are or could be affected by eminent domain also hosted rallies Monday.

Peter Colt, president of the Broadway to Silver Beach Neighborhood Association in Daytona Beach helped organize a rally on the boardwalk in Daytona, which has five community redevelopment agencies and 2,262 acres in its redevelopment area.

He said someone donated a replica of the Statue of Liberty to put on display and a poster of Elvis Presley holding a machine gun that read, "Elvis won't be leaving the building."

They served about 700 apple pies, Colt said, because "property rights are as American as apple pie."


Palm Beach Post: www.palmbeachpost.com

Rally charge — 'Eminent domain abuse': The Salt Lake (UT) Tribune, 2/23/05

Anti-Wal-Mart protest: Ogden residents also decry state redevelopment laws

By Kristen Moulton

Residents of a tucked-away downtown neighborhood and other Ogden residents angry at City Hall rallied Monday to protest a plan to bulldoze homes and businesses for a new Wal-Mart superstore.

At the peak of the rally, more than 40 carried signs showing a slash mark through the words "eminent domain abuse" and calling for reform of redevelopment laws. Passers-by honked and flashed protesters thumbs-up signs.

"Something is wrong with this picture," said protester Bill Glassman, an Ogden real estate broker and investor. "Do not take homes and viable businesses away and give [the land] to a big company!"

The Ogden Wal-Mart project has become a symbol for those who believe cities are taking their right to use eminent domain too far when it is used for economic development projects.

Monday's rally was timed to call attention to a Connecticut case before the U.S. Supreme Court today, Kelo vs. New London.

In that case, a city condemned a waterfront neighborhood so a hotel, office building and upscale homes could be built.

In Ogden, Mayor Matthew Godfrey and the City Council want to replace an older, blighted neighborhood with a Wal-Mart, which they contend will bring jobs and sales-tax revenue to the city.

The city is assembling the land, 21 acres north of Union Station and the new transit center on Wall Avenue, for the giant retailer. There are 34 homes and eight businesses in the project area.

Past court cases have upheld cities' right to use eminent domain for economic development when a neighborhood is blighted. In the Connecticut case, the neighborhood was healthy.

Neighborhood residents Christina and Milton Rodriguez were among those carrying signs Monday. They expect to land in court soon because they refused the city's offer for their home and adjacent properties where Christina has lived all her life.

Milton has a fencing business next door, and Christina is able to walk to work at the IRS downtown. Neither wants to move.

Senorina Fernandez, who was raised in the neighborhood and now lives there with her own family, says she, too, expects the city to condemn her home. She has refused offers so far.

"They tell us we'll have better homes, better neighborhoods. They don't know what it's about down here," said Fernandez, toting a sign protesting abuse of eminent domain. "We're here because we want to be. We just want them to go away."

The rally also drew a number of other area residents active in the campaign to reform Utah redevelopment laws.

Steve Huntsman, a North Ogden City Council member who opposed his own council's decision to build a new swimming pool through a redevelopment project, was at Monday's rally.

Huntsman was recently criticized by Ogden leaders for sending a letter to Wal-Mart threatening to expose, via his family's community newspaper, the company's participation in what he considers eminent domain abuse.

"It's wrong and the sad part is it's legal in our state right now," Huntsman said.


Salt Lake Tribune: www.sltrib.com

Eminent domain argued: San Bernardino (CA) Sun, 2/23/05

Supreme Court looks at case of neighborhood

By Nikki Cobb

The Supreme Court struggled Tuesday to balance the rights of property owners against the goals of city officials who want to sweep away old neighborhoods and turn the land over to private developers.

And the outcome could hold ramifications for several San Bernardino County cities and their residents.

Citizens who are suing the town of New London, Conn., say their working-class neighborhood is slated for destruction primarily to build an office complex that will benefit a pharmaceutical company that built its research and development headquarters nearby.

An attorney representing the city, Wesley Horton, told the court the revitalization project will create new jobs and trigger much-needed economic growth. He said increased tax revenue is enough of a legal basis for the city to exercise the power of eminent domain and compel the residents to sell their homes.

If a city wanted to seize property to turn a "Motel 6 into a Ritz-Carlton, that would be OK?' Justice Sandra Day O'Connor asked.

"Yes, your honor, it would be,' Horton replied.

The justices expressed sympathy for the longtime residents. At the same time, they questioned whether they have the authority to stop the town's plans.

The outcome could have significant implications.

In San Bernardino County, cities have wrestled with use of eminent domain.

Rialto might use it to clean up a neighborhood an "eyesore,' in the words of one councilman. Dilapidated apartment buildings would be replaced by new ones, built by a nonprofit agency.

Loma Linda has had pitched battles with residents, particularly in the older northern and central neighborhoods.

Loma Linda officials say they're eliminating blight and want to build low-income housing that will be more aesthetically pleasing. Residents say city officials want more expensive homes and the property tax they bring, or retail shops.

Eminent domain has also raised questions in Redlands, where 200 residents packed a December meeting on the subject.

In Muscoy, land might be taken for a middle school. In Highland, it's highway on-off ramps.

San Bernardino officials are contemplating moving residents from 264 apartments, 173 houses and several businesses and churches for the city's Lakes and Streams Project.

Also in San Bernardino, a reversal of the trend: The school district might take a shopping center through eminent domain to build a new school.

In this case, officials with the San Bernardino City Unified School District consider the move to be for the public good because it would relieve crowding at Lincoln Elementary School, where 1,200 students are crammed into a school built for 600.

In recent years, the city of San Bernardino evicted homeowners and a motel owner to build a new shopping center in its Hub area, between Tippecanoe and Laurelwood.

Across the nation Tuesday, rallies supported the rights of homeowners against the threat of eminent domain.

The Institute for Justice, a nonprofit Libertarian law firm, is representing residents in the case being considered by the U.S. Supreme Court.

"If the Supreme Court decides that the mere possibility of increased tax revenue is a public use under the Constitution, literally no one's home is safe because anyone's small business can make more money as a big box store and anyone's home can make more money as a luxury condominium,' said Steven Anderson, coordinator of the Castle Coalition, the Institute for Justice's nationwide grass-roots project.

In recent years, there have been over 10,000 instances of private property being threatened with condemnation or actually condemned by government for private use, according to the Institute for Justice. The group represents the New London residents who filed the case.

Scott Bullock, representing the neighborhood residents, argued that government cannot take private property from one owner and provide it to another just because the new commercial project will boost finances. The city plans to give the developers a 99-year lease for a dollar a year.

"More than tax revenue was at stake,' Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg replied. "The town had gone down and down' economically.

O'Connor questioned whether the homeowners were asking the court to "second-guess' the governmental power of eminent domain.

The legal arguments concern the Fifth Amendment prohibition against taking private property for public use without just compensation.

The city says it is willing to pay a fair price.

"You are paying for it, but you are taking it from somebody who doesn't want to sell,' Justice Antonin Scalia told Horton, the lawyer representing New London.

Several justices focused on the residents' argument that the court should impose standards for governments to meet when they want to sweep away neighborhoods for economic revitalization.

"A lot of times governments have no clue what they're going to do with the property,' Dana Berliner, co-counsel for the neighborhood residents, said after the court arguments ended.

New London, a town of less than 26,000, once was a center of the whaling industry and later became a manufacturing hub. The revitalization project is a few miles downriver from the U.S. Navy's submarine base in Groton.

The starting point for Tuesday's arguments was a Supreme Court ruling five decades ago that allowed governments to take private property for urban renewal.

The neighborhood's lawyer, Bullock, seized on that case, contending there is a difference between the urban blight of 1954 and the current circumstance of an economically depressed town.

Justice Anthony Kennedy questioned Bullock's position, with the justice saying that economically depressed areas can quickly become blighted areas.

Ginsburg also wondered whether the urban renewal case offers much hope for the neighborhood. She pointed out that the issue in that case involved a department store that was not contributing at all to the blight in the area. The court nonetheless cleared the way for local government to take the department store's property for the renewal project.

Chief Justice William Rehnquist, who is battling thyroid cancer, did not attend the arguments and will be absent for the next two weeks. He has not attended arguments since October. Justice John Paul Stevens was out of town and missed the day's arguments.

The case is Susette Kelo v. City of New London and New London Development Corp., 04-108.


San Bernardino Sun: www.sbsun.com

Eminent Domain's Future Unsure: Columbia (University) Spectator, 2/23/05

The Supreme Court Hears Arguments on CT Case With Implications for Manhattanville

By Erin Durkin

As home owners from New London, CT packed the courtroom here to await a decision on the fate of their dwellings, Manhattanville residents wondered whether the resolution might change the ground rules in the fight against the expansion.

The controversy over eminent domain reached the U.S. Supreme Court yesterday, as the justices listened to arguments in Kelo v. New London, a case whose outcome will define the limits of the government’s power to buy property against the owner’s will for “public use.” The court’s decision may affect how Columbia obtains properties for its expansion.

Historically, eminent domain has been used to acquire land for public projects. More recently, governments have used eminent domain to promote economic development, condemning property and turning it over to private developers to create jobs and tax revenue in economically troubled areas.

In Kelo, a group of New London homeowners challenged the city’s use of eminent domain to forcibly buy their homes for a major development project. The owners argued that the Supreme Court should rule broadly that economic development does not constitute public use under the 5th Amendment.

“Every city has problems and wants more tax revenues,” said Scott Bullock, the homeowners’ lawyer. “Without any limits on the government’s eminent domain power, every home, church, or corner store” would be at risk.

Barring a broad ruling, they asked the Court to overturn the condemnations of their homes on the grounds that in order for eminent domain to be used, economic benefit must be “reasonably foreseeable.” Municipalities must show that proposed economic benefits will actually come about.

The city argued that the court does not have the right to assess whether development is necessary.

“The principle purpose of the takings clause is to provide for just compensation,” said Wesley Horton, attorney for the city. “There is no principled place for a court to make what is essentially a value judgment” about the public worth of the project. He stressed that the proposed project would create jobs in an economically troubled area.

The courts decision could have major implications for the use of eminent domain in Columbia’s expansion.

Attorney Norman Siegel, representative of West Harlem Business Group, a group of Manhattanville property owners unwilling to sell to Columbia and who fear eminent domain will be invoked on their property, filed an amicus curiae brief on behalf of the homeowners. He wrote in the brief that his clients are in “a circumstance similar to the circumstances of petitioners.” He has called for New York officials to suspend use of eminent domain until the Court rules in Kelo.

Columbia maintains that as a private institution, it does not have the power to use eminent domain. “Columbia will continue to negotiate the purchase of properties needed...and manage the overall development process in a way that addresses the needs of individual owners and tenants, meets the University’s objectives and brings economic prosperity to Northern Manhattan and the city as a whole by creating construction and permanent jobs,” said Liz Golden, Columbia’s director of operations, planning, and special projects, in an e-mail. She said it would be speculative to comment on the outcome of the case.

The seven justices present at yesterday’s arguments raised questions about arguments in both sides in the case.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg responded to the argument that cities only use eminent domain for tax revenues, saying that “more than tax revenue was at stake,” since New London “had gone down and down” economically.

Justice Antonin Scalia, who expressed sympathy for the homeowners at several points during the arguments, led the Court in questioning Horton. The city “just wants to take property from people who pay less taxes and give it to people who pay more taxes,” he said.

Asked if this was a fair characterization of his argument, Horton jokingly replied, “If it’s a significant amount” of additional revenue. Justice Sandra Day O’Connor suggested that by that standard, the government could condemn a Motel 6 to make way for a Ritz Carleton.

Participants addressed assembled media in a press conference after the arguments. “I was very encouraged by today’s arguments,” said Susette Kelo, a plaintiff in the case. “I feel [the justices] are sympathetic to the homeowners.”

In reference to individuals losing their homes, Horton said, “Obviously it’s very sad when things like that happen,” but stressed that “to have to deal with a bunch of holdouts makes it more difficult to attract developers.”

Donald Borut, executive director of the National League of Cities, which filed an amicus curiae on behalf of the New London government, agreed. He said in an interview that, should the Court overturn the condemnations, “It would mean that a major tool that cities have used for years to create economic opportunity for citizens would be taken away.”

“The dilemma is you have people who own property ... who don’t want to leave,” Borut said. “You’ve also got 1,500 people who lost their jobs who [want] to work.”

Siegel said he was “cautiously optimistic” after viewing the arguments. He hopes the Court will rule broadly that economic development does not constitute a form of public use. Under such a ruling, he said, “the argument that Columbia has been making up to today — more jobs, more taxes — would be unacceptable for the employment of eminent domain.”

A more narrow ruling overturning the condemnations based on a “reasonable foreseeability” test, Siegel said, would open the door for him to challenge Columbia to provide evidence to back up its projections on expansion-provided jobs and revenue.

Siegel said that even if the Court upholds the New London condemnations, it won’t make things worse for his clients.

Columbia law school professor Tom Merrill said that a broad ruling against the use of eminent domain would “cause some issues for Columbia.” However, he said, “I think it’s unlikely that the Court would go that far.”

“One thing that might make the case different is that Columbia...being a university, has more of a public benefit” Law School professor Warren Briffault said pointing to education and research opportunities Columbia offers.

Siegel acknowledged that “the fact that Columbia is an educational institution makes the issue a little more difficult,” but stressed that “Columbia is still a private entity.”

A decision is expected in June.


The Columbia Spectator: www.columbiaspectator.com

Eminent domain measure put off: Cherry Hill (NJ) Courier-Post, 2/23/05

By Bill Duhart

Hours before the township board of commissioners was scheduled to introduce a measure to seize two private homes by eminent domain to make way for a redevelopment project, the measure was removed from the agenda Tuesday.

After the nearly two-hour meeting, which featured sharp bickering between Commissioner Kathleen Hogan and Mayor William Park, the two continued to trade barbs about why the items were removed.

"I threatened to sue them if they didn't take those items off the agenda," said Hogan.

Park said the item was removed early Tuesday at the suggestion of township solicitor Timothy Higgins and had nothing to do with Hogan's threatened suit. The lawsuit threat does, however, illustrate the level of acrimony among the commissioners, which include Park, Hogan and James Broderick.

Park and Higgins said the measure did not have to be acted on immediately and that more time could now be taken to negotiate with two homeowners whose properties were targeted for acquisition. Park said commissioners wanted "to take another month to take another stab at this."

"I don't think anyone is comfortable doing eminent domain," Park said after the meeting. "But you have to look at the composite picture here and look at what's good for the community."

A standing-room-only crowd of about 100 people attended the meeting. Virtually everyone who spoke in the public portion of the meeting opposed the redevelopment proposal.

The plan is to transform an aging strip of Haddon Avenue, between Crystal Lake and Reeves avenues, into an upscale blend of shops, town homes and apartments. The development is centered around the former Dy-Dee diaper laudry and stretches for a few blocks in each direction.

Resistance to the plan has been spirited. A group of neighbors, township residents and local activist organized a demonstration along Haddon Avenue Monday to draw attention to the Supreme Court case, the Haddon Avenue redevelopment project and a similar project in Westville also utilizing eminent domain.

The power of municipalities to take private property for public use, even against the wishes of the owner, has gotten regional and national recognition recently. The U.S. Supreme court took up a case involving eminent domain Tuesday.

Seizing the properties here represents a significant step forward in the process to transform an aging strip of the Haddon Avenue, between Crystal Lake and Reeves avenues into an upscale, mixed-use area of shops and homes.


The Courier-Post: www.courierpostonline.com

House OKs higher price for eminent domain: Indianapolis (IN) Star, 2/23/05

Bill would make governments pay a premium to obtain property for commercial development

The Indiana House voted Tuesday to make it more costly for government to condemn private property for the sake of commercial development, as the U.S. Supreme Court heard a case that could lead to even more restrictions.

Supporters of House Bill 1063 complained that the wants of developers have trumped the rights of average citizens. They argued that eminent domain laws, which allow the government to buy property against the owners' wishes, have strayed far from their original purpose of making it possible for roads and other necessities to be built.

"We've gone from a public use to a public good," said Rep. David A. Wolkins, R-Winona Lake, the author of the bill. "That's a pretty subjective term."

Wolkins' bill would force cities, counties and other governments to pay a premium for property they condemn to make way for commercial development — such as new subdivisions, shopping centers or manufacturing plants. The bill could affect several projects in Indianapolis, including Mayor Bart Peterson's push to build a new Colts stadium south of the RCA Dome.

City and town officials from throughout Indiana rallied against the bill, which the House passed by a vote of 67 to 29. "The bill makes it more difficult and costly for cities to do economic development," said Evansville Mayor Jonathan Weinzapfel. "I'm not sure what this bill is trying to fix."

Cities already negotiate fairly with property owners, but when such talks fail, Weinzapfel said, cities need a way to improve downtrodden areas.

In Indianapolis, officials say eminent domain helped redevelop the Fall Creek Place neighborhood. City attorney Kobi Wright said the city also is using the process to claim land for the AmeriPlex business park project near the airport and will do so with property near the proposed new Colts stadium if necessary.

Wright said it is not clear whether that project would fall under the scope of the House bill. In any event, he said, eminent domain is a crucial legal tool.

Few things spark more ill will than when a city tries to claim a property that an owner doesn't want to give up. The city's Capital Improvement Board is now sparring in court with the owner of a Downtown parking lot that would be part of an IndyGo transit hub. The two sides remain far apart, representatives for the city and the lot owner said Tuesday.

The House bill forces governmental entities to pay property owners in those cases 150 percent of the property's assessed value or the average of three private appraisals. The owner would receive the higher of those two yardsticks.

The House vote came as the U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments in a case that could have sweeping ramifications for cities. In the case, New London, Conn., is attempting to replace a middle-class neighborhood with new development.

The Washington, D.C.-based Institute for Justice has championed the case. Senior attorney Dana Berliner said cities have transformed eminent domain from something used to clean up blighted areas and pave the way for roads and utilities to a process for putting the most profitable projects at desirable locations.

"The attitude is to do it anywhere, and the driving force behind that has been the private developers," Berliner said. "They should not be using the power of government to get whatever land they want."


The Indianapolis Star: www.indystar.com

How Eminent Is A City's Domain? The Hartford (CT) Courant, 2/23/05

By David Lightman

If New London can seize people's homes so private developers can build a hotel and convention center, what will cities do next? several Supreme Court justices asked during arguments Tuesday.

Can a city decide to get rid of the Motel 6 and put up a Ritz-Carlton, asked Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, because the luxury hotel would produce more taxes?

"That would be OK?" she asked.

"Are we saying you can take from A and give to B if B pays more taxes?" asked Justice Antonin Scalia.

Susette Kelo, sitting in the back of the cavernous court chamber, was encouraged by such questions. Kelo is the lead homeowner in a landmark case that pits a group of New London homeowners against a city that sees their property as crucial to its development plans.

Arguing on behalf of New London, attorney Wesley Horton told O'Connor, "Yes, your honor, it would be" appropriate to replace a lower-cost motel with a plush hotel.

A city, in this example, would be exercising its time-honored right of eminent domain, Horton said. The homeowners countered that what was really at stake for New London was whether developers and the city would make more money.

Seven justices heard the case. Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, who has thyroid cancer, has been absent from the bench since October, and Justice John Paul Stevens did not attend because his plane was delayed.

A ruling is expected in June, and despite Kelo's guarded optimism, it was hard to discern which way the justices were leaning after a lively hour during which six of the seven justices peppered the attorneys with questions. Only Justice Clarence Thomas remained silent.

Kelo left the session pleased, but many other homeowners were less sure. They seemed awed that what began as a dispute with their city had wound up in the nation's highest court.

What unfolded there Tuesday was a drama on two levels.

One involves the plight of the homeowners, who don't want to leave their middle class Fort Trumbull neighborhood.

Many arrived at the court building an hour and a half before the 10 a.m. hearing Tuesday. Some stood smoking cigarettes outside in the cold and worrying whether ordinary folks like them could get a fair hearing.

Ronna Stuller, a New Haven friend and supporter of Kelo and other homeowners, drove 6½ hours to Washington; Amy Hallquist, another friend, took a train. Leading them all was Kelo, a nurse dressed in apricot - the same color as her New London home.

"I'd been to the state Supreme Court, and this was sort of like that," Kelo said quietly after the hearing. `'But it was more formal. There was more security."

The case has the potential to be precedent-setting, shaping eminent domain policy for years to come. It also is the most prominent Connecticut case the court has considered in 40 years.

The Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution bars the taking of private property for public use without compensation; courts have allowed it provided owners are rightfully compensated. But controversy has grown over whether local governments have reached too far, taking property for glitzy projects to rid a neighborhood of lower-income people.

The conflict actually reaches back to the Magna Carta, said Douglas W. Kmiec, professor of constitutional law at Pepperdine University.

Kmiec, who has studied the New London case, noted that since the 13th century, governments have recognized that "eminent domain and securing private property must coexist. Neither can be absolute."

But, Kmiec added, "courts have engaged in a balancing act" for years.

Scott G. Bullock, attorney for the Institute for Justice, a civil liberties firm, argued the case for Kelo and her allies. He agreed that government has the authority to condemn blighted areas and to take other property to meet an obvious public need.

But, Bullock said, "there have to be limits." To simply take property to build the tax base by improving private profits is not necessarily a proper use of eminent domain.

Some justices seemed uncomfortable with that notion. "You want me to make a distinction between blight and economic purpose?" asked Justice Anthony M. Kennedy.

"Do you really want the courts in the business of weighing evidence to see if a hospital will be successful or a road will be successful?" asked O'Connor. Bullock said there could be reasonable standards for taking property. In a 1992 railroad case, Kennedy said it was crucial that "the condemning authorities [be] rational in their positions that some public purpose is served."

The justices were equally tough on Horton, bringing up the question of whether it was proper for a government to condemn a lower-price property so something more glamorous - and tax-producing - could replace it.

Horton argued that "there is a democratic process" that would subject such a change to careful scrutiny, including hearings and regulatory reviews. Cities could not simply make such changes on a whim.

Nonetheless, Scalia seemed concerned that New London wanted private property for a private developer's use in a case where the homeowners did not want to leave. Kelo, he said, "does not want to move. You're just giving it to some private individual who's going to pay more taxes."

The questioning left many of the New London spectators confused as to what the justices would decide. A decision is expected before the court ends its current term, probably in June.

"If nothing else," said Hallquist, "it was interesting to see both sides get their butts chewed a little. I don't know where this decision is going. I'm just going to leave it up to God."


The Hartford Courant: www.courant.com

2/23/2005

Public use or abuse of power?: The Dallas (TX) Morning News , 2/19/05

Landowner, council at odds over use of eminent domain

By Wendy Hundley

For more than a dozen years, Xavier Hernandez has sold icy treats from a small shop on the edge of the old Canyon Creek Shopping Center.

Last week, the Richardson City Council approved a measure that could force him to sell his property for the II Creeks project, an upscale retail and residential development going up on adjacent land.

City officials said the eminent domain action benefits Richardson by boosting the economy and revitalizing a dying retail center.

"Economic development is a public purpose," City Manager Bill Keffler said.

But Mr. Hernandez sees it differently. "It's unbelievable that they can force me to sell so somebody else can make a profit," he said. "It's un-American."

On Tuesday, the U.S. Supreme Court will hear arguments to determine whether seizing property for a private developer is unconstitutional.

The Kelo vs. New London case involves homeowner Susette Kelo in New London, Conn. The city sought to seize all the land in Ms. Kelo's neighborhood so a private developer could build a hotel, homes and offices to complement a new nearby Pfizer Corp. plant.

If this use of eminent domain is upheld by the Supreme Court, "no one's home or small business is safe in this country," said Steven Anderson, coordinator for the Castle Coalition, a national organization fighting what it believes is the abuse of such powers.

He considers Kelo vs. New London one of the foremost property rights cases in 50 years.

Eminent domain has traditionally been used to acquire private property for parks, roads and other projects that benefit the public.

That began to change in 1954, when the Supreme Court ruled in Berman vs. Parker that private property could be taken to revitalize blighted urban areas.

"Since that case, the floodgates have opened," Mr. Anderson said. "The government is trying to take land that truly isn't blighted."

The Castle Coalition is supporting Arlington property owners who fear their land will be seized for the new Dallas Cowboys stadium.

In Richardson, City Council members said last week that they struggled with the decision to authorize condemnation of the Hernandez property.

"But they were trying to look at the long-term public good," said Michael Wanchick, an assistant city manager. "We're not unsympathetic to Mr. Hernandez."

Nevertheless, the city attorney believes Richardson is on firm legal ground, Mr. Wanchick said. "Clearly we have a right to do this under state and federal laws."

There's little doubt that the new II Creeks project will revitalize the old Canyon Creek Shopping Center. In the 1960s and '70s, it was a thriving retail site with a theater, restaurants, a bank and doctors' offices.

Over the years, the development at the intersection of Lookout Drive and Custer Parkway was eclipsed as businesses moved into high-traffic malls or along busy thoroughfares.

The final blow came three years ago, when a Tom Thumb store, the anchor tenant, closed.

The city tried unsuccessfully to find interested developers until last year, when three homeowners in the nearby Canyon Creek neighborhood decided take a chance on the old retail center.

Their vision for the $40 million II Creeks project will replace the vacant storefronts and empty parking lot with upscale retail stores and town homes selling for as much as $575,000.

Richardson officials say II Creeks is a model redevelopment that will create jobs, pump up the city's sagging tax base and generate new sales tax revenue.

It will also provide upscale housing for employees at the new $3 billion Texas Instruments semiconductor plant and the $85 million engineering and research facility at the University of Texas at Dallas.

"We wanted to do everything we could to support redevelopment," Mr. Wanchick said. "There is a lot of support for [II Creeks] in the Canyon Creek neighborhood."

He tried to serve as an intermediary between II Creeks and the Hernandez family but was unable to negotiate a settlement.

The Hernandez property is valued at $47,158 on Collin County tax rolls. A certified appraiser hired by the city set the market value at $94,000. The family has said a potential buyer once offered $375,000, but Mr. Wanchick said the city is not aware of any such proposal today.

The owners of II Creeks offered to buy the three-tenths of an acre site for $125,000 and provide four years of free rent elsewhere in the development.

"It appears the landowner is unwilling to sell the land at a fair and reasonable price," Mr. Keffler said at last week's City Council meeting, where the eminent domain resolution was approved 6-to-1.

City officials said they hope that the action prompts the property owners to reach a compromise and that condemnation wouldn't be necessary. Mr. Wanchick said the city is looking for other Richardson locations for the snow cone shop.

Mr. Hernandez, whose family owns six seasonal TC Shaved Ice locations in the Dallas area, said the Custer Road site is profitable, with an established customer base.

He said the $125,000 offer wouldn't allow him to buy another piece of land, construct a new stand and rebuild the business.

"If you're going to force me out, at least compensate me for what it's worth," he said.

"It doesn't make sense that I have the property and they're setting the price."


Dallas Morning News: www.dallasnews.com

Condemn-Nation: Slate, 2/22/05

This land was your land, but now it's my land.

By Dahlia Lithwick

I've witnessed some weird moments at oral arguments over the years, but I'm thinking absolutely nothing could compare with the sight I beheld today: In the midst of argument in Kelo v. New London — a critically important case about the government's right to condemn private land and give it to private developers — the lawyer for the city of New London, Conn., pulls out an actual prop. In response to a query from Sandra Day O'Connor as to whether there's a concrete development plan for what would replace the handful of homes being condemned, Wesley W. Horton hauls out a big poster board with the whole proposed community laid out. Condos here, marina here, yank out this crappy little Victorian house and the health club will go there, he enthuses.

My heart begins to pound. I want in on this deal. And O'Connor looks like she does, too.

With the exception of a yellow pad, I have never seen a visual aid of any sort used at oral argument. Advocates really should use them more — diagram all four prongs of the Lemon test; color-code the three levels of constitutional scrutiny. After all, these justices aren't getting any younger and with Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist out again today, and his usual replacement, John Paul Stevens, absent because of a canceled flight, we are down to just seven this morning. It's starting to look a bit like The Bachelor, Week 5.

But to start at the start: The Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution allows local government to use "eminent domain" powers to condemn private property. The only requirement is that owners are given "just compensation" and that the land in question go to a "public use."

In the working-class neighborhood of Fort Trumbull, Conn., the local government has some big plans. Not a monorail, but adjacent to and complementing a brand new $300 million research facility for the pharmaceutical giant, Pfizer, there would be condos, health clubs, a luxury hotel, shops, and other assorted mega-stuff. Most of the folks in town agreed to sell, but seven families, owning 15 homes, refused. They like their crumbly Victorians. So when the state tried to condemn their property, they sought injunctions.

Traditionally, the "public use" requirement in eminent domain cases allowed the local government to condemn property to build railroads, or bridges, or highways. But in a 1954 case, Berman v. Parker, the Supreme Court found that "public use" could include condemning blighted neighborhoods to build better ones. Fort Trumbull isn't blighted, but since the Michigan Supreme Court decided its famous Poletown case in 1981 — razing hundreds of homes to build a GM plant — many jurisdictions have insisted that increased tax revenues and the prospect of new jobs was "public use" enough to justify nabbing land that subsequently became Costcos, shopping malls, and fancy office buildings. New York used eminent domain to improve Times Square and build the World Trade Center. The Connecticut Supreme Court agreed with New London that seizing homes for purposes of private economic development was permissible. The homeowners appealed.

Scott G. Bullock represents the homeowners, and his first words to the court strike terror in the heart of anyone who looks into their backyard and sees the ghostly outline of the Target housewares section looming over the trees: "Every home, church, and corner store would produce more tax revenue if it was turned into a shopping mall," he says. There can be no limit to what the state can condemn if the only requirement is that the proposed project improve the tax base.

Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg points out that the city is depressed; what's wrong with efforts to "build it up and get more jobs?" Bullock says the condemned land in Berman was "blighted," but this land is merely depressed. O'Connor, never one to tip her hand too early at argument, asks Bullock "What standard should we use to second-guess the legislature?" Bullock insists that once condemned land is passed off to private developers, it's no longer going to "public use." Justice Anthony Kennedy interrupts to observe that "everybody knew private developers were the beneficiaries" when slums were condemned in Berman.

Bullock replies that the Berman taking was justified since it was removing blight. Kennedy retorts that in five years New London will be blighted instead of just depressed, and would eminent domain be acceptable then? Bullock says the entire public benefit of a project cannot "depend on private parties making a profit." Kennedy and David Souter both observe that this is precisely what happened when land was condemned for railroads.

O'Connor again seeks articulation of the test these homeowners are proposing, and Bullock supplies her with: "The government cannot take property just so the new owners can put it to better use." He wants the court to implement two requirements in eminent domain cases: some proof that the proposed future use is truly likely to happen, and his backup test — that there be "minimum standards" showing actual benefits to taxpayers.

Souter concedes that there could be truly bad faith condemnation of land — say, when the mayor, a Democrat, condemns Person A's land and gives it to Person B, also a Democrat. But Souter sees no evidence of bad faith in New London. They are legitimately attempting to revive a declining economy. O'Connor adds: "Do you really want the courts to be in the business of judging whether a hospital will be successful or a road well-constructed?"

Wesley Horton represents the city of New London, and even before his to-scale chart comes out, it's clear that his enthusiasm for this development knows no bounds. He's a hopper, as well as a pointer, and he tends to chuckle at his own jokes. But he makes the point that this condemnation is no different than any of the innumerable ones that were deemed constitutionally sound in the past.

Justice Antonin Scalia asks what difference it makes that New London is depressed. What if a city acknowledged that it wasn't doing badly, but just wanted to condemn land to attract new industry? He describes Horton's position as: "You can always take from A and give to B, so long as B is richer." And O'Connor offers this concrete example: What if there's a Motel 6 but the city thinks a Ritz-Carlton will generate more taxes? Is that OK?

Yes, says Horton.

"So you can always take from A and give to B if B pays more taxes?" asks Scalia.

"If they are significantly more taxes," says Horton

"But that will always happen. Unless it's a firehouse or a school," protests Kennedy.

Here is where O'Connor asks about the specific plans for the homes before the court, and Horton pulls out his Pareto-optimal town-planning schematic, and everyone on the bench briefly contemplates buying a new condo in Fort Trumbull, Conn.

Justice Stephen Breyer asks why the courts cannot just demand some "reasonableness" standard for proposed "public use" projects. Horton says that standard is too high. Breyer points out that this is a "specific constitutional provision designed to protect minorities from the actions of majorities," and maybe a higher standard is warranted.

"We're paying for it!" Horton exclaims, noting that no one is taking anything from these minorities.

"But you're taking it from someone who doesn't want to sell. She doesn't want your money," retorts Scalia.

And Kennedy muses that "it seems ironic that 100 percent of the premium for this new development goes to the developer and not the property owner" (who is entitled only to the "fair market value" of her home and not a share in the marina's future revenues). Breyer agrees that the real problem here isn't the "public use" issue but rather whether this represents just compensation.

It doesn't look like the good folks of Fort Trumbull will garner many votes today at all — save for that of Justice Scalia, who channels the many libertarian amici in this case when he repeats that you can constitutionally condemn land and give it to a private entity — a railroad or public utility. "But you can't give it to a private corporation just because it might increase taxes."

Horton replies that giving the people of New London jobs is just as important as giving them a railroad.

Horton then concludes: "I have just four words this court should consider … but I'm not going to say them because I see my red light is on" (which amounts to 15 additional words). When Bullock stands for his rebuttal, Kennedy asks whether he knows what the four words were that Horton might have used.

Bullock does not. So a new Fort Trumbull gym membership to the first Frayster who can win this case (for either side) in just four words. Let me start you off:

"But we're libertarians, stupid."

"What would Rehnquist say?"

"You can't stop progress."

"Grande or Venti, sir?"


Slate: slate.msn.com

Private land vs. public control: The Philadelphia (PA) Inquirer, 2/23/05

Phila. area is watching as justices weigh Conn. eminent-domain case

By Stephen Henderson

The Supreme Court yesterday appeared sympathetic toward a group of New London, Conn., homeowners fighting to keep their land, but the justices seemed equally skeptical of their own power to keep the city from seizing the property to create an upscale development.

It is the first significant case on eminent domain, the power of the government to condemn property for redevelopment, to reach the high court in years.

The case is being closely watched in the Philadelphia area. On Monday, protesters gathered in Ardmore in Montgomery County and Westville and Haddon Township in South Jersey to oppose plans to use eminent domain to seize private property and then develop condominiums, shopping centers or other projects.

The justices fired relentless questions at a lawyer representing the New London residents about why he thought the court should be involved in the eminent-domain dispute and how he would have them distinguish between proper and improper property seizures.

But they also questioned the city's position that it could use eminent domain to condemn any property to have it developed into something that produces more tax dollars or creates more jobs.

"Say you have a Motel 6, and the city wants to turn it into a Ritz-Carlton," Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said. "Is that sufficient reason?"

Wesley W. Horton, the lawyer representing New London, said it was. As long as the first owner is compensated, and the city determines there is a public benefit in upgrading the use of the land, the Constitution's protections against improper seizures do not apply, he said.

Scott Bullock, a lawyer with the Institute for Justice, which is representing the New London residents, said Horton's standard could threaten all private property owners.

"Every home or church could be replaced by a Costco, a shopping mall or private building that would produce more tax dollars," Bullock said. "This is about limiting eminent domain to public use."

Over the years, the Supreme Court has deferred to the decision-making of elected state and local officials.

The court said in 1954 that it was legal for urban renewal to encompass non-blighted commercial buildings in a blighted neighborhood. In 1984, the court upheld a Hawaii law that broke the grip of large landowners, with property being taken and then resold to others.

The New London residents say taking property from one private owner and giving it to another who will pay more taxes is not covered under the public-use requirement in the Fifth Amendment.

New London, which is backed by many other cities, counters by saying economic development is a legitimate public purpose. New London, a town of less than 26,000, once was a center of the whaling industry and later became a manufacturing hub.

If the court sides with the Connecticut residents, it would cast doubt over projects around the country involving land for waterfront entertainment districts, high-rise office buildings, big-box stores, and even baseball stadiums.

Justice Antonin Scalia seemed more moved yesterday by the sense of impending loss by the homeowners. Even though the New London residents will be compensated for their property, "what this lady wants is not money," Scalia said of Susette Kelo, who brought the suit against New London. "It's her home."

Hers is an "objection in principle," Scalia said.

Other justices struggled to define how the court could draw lines between what was or was not for the public benefit and which kinds of developments could justify property seizures.

O'Connor admitted that the court's prior decisions on this issue left little room for "second-guessing" the power of eminent domain.

"I guess I'm not sure what role there is for us here," she said.

Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist, who is battling thyroid cancer, did not attend the arguments in the case, Susette Kelo v. City of New London and New London Development Corp. Justice John Paul Stevens was out of town and missed the day's arguments.


The Philadelphia Inquirer: www.philly.com

2/22/2005

Homeowners fight eminent domain decision: WSFB TV3 (CT), 2/22/05

Imagine you've finally paid off your mortgage, then you're charged rent for the land you thought you owned!

That's what's happening to seven homeowners in New London's embattled Fort Trumbull neighborhood.

Mathey Dery says, "My first thoughts are these are our homes. We don't owe anybody to live here."

Matt Dery's family has called Fort Trumbull their home for four generations.

"This property has been mortgage free since 1958," he says. "My parents are in their mid 80's. They live here, they want to collect rent from them. They want to collect rent from us on our own home and also wanted our tenants to pay them."

The neighborhood was taken over thru eminent domain by the New London Development Corporation. They won a long battle last winter when the state Supreme Court ruled in their favor for the right to seize property.

Now, the city's development arm is asking the Dery's and other homeowners to pay use and occupancy fees.

A nearly $230,000 figure is now owed by the Dery's. That's $76,633 over the past three years or $6,386 a month.

"I guess if we stay here a few more years we're going to have to give them our furniture and a couple of dogs," Dery says.

Eyewitness News made several attempts to talk with the NLDC about the occupancy fee issue, but they gave no comment.

This eminent domain war is not over. According to homeowners, the occupancy fee issue is just another skirmish which they vow to fight.

As previously reported, the NLDC is holding in escrow the money to buy the property from the seven owners.


WSFB TV3: www.wfsb.com

Taking sides on eminent domain: The Philadelphia (PA) Inquirer, 2/22/05

Foes see a loss of rights. Others say it is needed at times to secure redevelopment's benefits. U.S. justices are to hear a case today.

By Wendy Ruderman

Residents from three towns in the region took to the streets yesterday, rallying against what they call an unholy alliance between local governments and developers.

The protesters in Ardmore in Montgomery County and Westville and Haddon Township in South Jersey are upset at politicians using their power to seize private property and give it to developers seeking to profit from building condominiums, shopping centers or other projects.

"I was under the impression that the right of home ownership and the right to protect your property was granted to us in the Constitution, but I've since learned that it's not. It's a privilege granted to us by local government," said George Baker, whose Westville home on Big Timber Creek sits in the path of a potential waterfront development.

The battle over eminent domain, the government's long-held right to take private property in the interest of public good, is making headlines across the country.

Today, the U.S. Supreme Court is scheduled to hear arguments in a case pitting Connecticut residents against officials wanting to boost tax revenue with more upscale homes and shops.

Critics say politicians should not be in the real estate business - especially not when developers donate to political campaigns.

Public officials counter that most redevelopment does not involve hostile property takeovers, but that those that do are necessary for revitalization.

If developers profit in the process, so be it.

Collingswood Mayor M. James Maley, a redevelopment lawyer, said he wanted the developer "to make money, but I want him to make money in a way that improves the community of Collingswood."

Collingswood, once troubled by crime and neglected properties, has become a kind of poster child of redevelopment, with trendy shops and restaurants. So much so that mayors across the region want to duplicate its Cinderella story, which did involve some eminent domain.

Maley, with the Marlton law firm of Parker McCay, is a consultant on more than two dozen redevelopment projects in the region.

Elected officials said critics were overlooking dozens of redevelopment success stories in the region that had not involved taking people's homes.

"Redevelopment is not synonymous with eminent domain," said Louis Bezich, a former business administrator for Camden County whose Haddonfield consulting firm, Public Solutions, was hired to help drive redevelopment in economically depressed towns along the White Horse Pike, including Barrington.

A few years ago, Barrington obtained the 2.6-acre Custom Metal Arts site on Gloucester Pike through tax foreclosure and courted redevelopers using financial incentives. The vacant building was refurbished and is now occupied by SAR Automotive Equipment, a distributor and installer of garage lifts.

Once an area is declared a redevelopment zone, local officials can harness a variety of powerful tools, such as eminent domain. They also can select a developer without competitive bidding, grant long-term tax exemptions and abatements, issue bonds to pay for the project without a public referendum, and more.

In many cases, the developer provides the financial backing for a project that would otherwise fall to taxpayers. Under the Westville proposal, the developer, Fieldstone Associates of Doylestown, is expected to shoulder the estimated $40 million cost.

In Haddon Township, Fieldstone is proposing housing and retail space in the long-vacant Dy-Dee Diaper Service building on Haddon Avenue. The township would issue $5 million in bonds, and the developer would pick up the rest.

Without financial incentives to sweeten deals, many developers wouldn't look twice at most proposals, redevelopment supporters said.

"The government needs to be involved to help make it happen, because it is obvious that the private marketplace is not doing it," Maley said.

The problem is, town officials across the nation find themselves giving away more and more, said Dan Emerine of the Smart Growth Network, a federally funded coalition of organizations dedicated to tackling sprawl.

"A lot of times, jurisdictions compete against each other, and eventually everyone loses because it creates a race to the bottom in terms of providing tax incentives to encourage economic development," Emerine said.

While many experts agree that redevelopment is often a good thing, some say the system invites corruption and cronyism.

And too much redevelopment could create intense competition to attract a limited number of retailers and consumers, dooming some projects.

At the heart of the debate is who benefits most.

Among those making money from the redevelopment boom are politically connected consultants, bond counsels, bond underwriters, engineers and architects, union workers, and developers.

"I am making money. That's why I work," Maley said. "Some people will get financial benefits out of it, absolutely. The question is: Is there a greater public good that is served by accomplishing the redevelopment?"

Westville resident Alan Peters thinks so.

"We'll reap the benefit of it eventually," said Peters, who estimated that the value of his waterfront home, which is not part of the redevelopment proposal, would increase by as much as $50,000.


The Philadelphia Inquirer: www.philly.com

Eminent Domain Stirs Wal-Mart Controversy in Ogden: KSL TV5 (Salt Lake City UT), 2/21/05

By John Daley

A new Wal-Mart store is once again stirring controversy, this time in Ogden. The fight's over a tool governments use called "eminent domain."

That means property owners can be forced to sell.

The city of Ogden sees this new Wal-Mart as a key to downtown revitalization, bringing in 7,000 shoppers a day. But some property owners refused to sell, and are now fighting the city's attempt to use "eminent domain" to acquire the land.

The property is within a few blocks of Ogden's struggling downtown 21-acres now occupied by 34 homes and eight businesses. Most property owners agreed to sell to the city's redevelopment agency.

But when the city moved to use eminent domain to acquire the others, that sparked a revolt from the likes of Dorothy Littrell, who bought land in the neighborhood just so she could sue the city on constitutional grounds.

Dorothy Littrell/ Property Owner: "I am not going to sit by and let it happen without screaming all the way down."

Milton Rodriguez/ Property Owner: "We've spoken to them and they don't want to listen to the people around here. It's all about the money."

Cris Rodriguez/ Property Owner: "I think the city leaders are looking down here and they're not seeing people or businesses. They're seeing dollar signs."

But Ogden's mayor, Matthew Godfrey, says eminent domain was used only as a last resort, when a few property owners refused to sell.

He says: "We don't like to do this. We feel bad about the people who don't want to sell, but I think it's in the greater good that we redevelop this area."

The city and some property owners simply can't agree on what's a fair price. Protesters call it a case of Robin Hood in reverse — stealing from the poor and giving it to the rich.

Bill Glasmann/ Wal-Mart Opponent: "We've got a Wal-Mart what, maybe 15 blocks to the north of us, and 30 blocks to the south of us. And now they want to put a big box down here at the expense of these people."

Tom Owens/ Wal-Mart Opponent: "It's wrong. It's fundamentally wrong to kick people out of their homes and give them less than it's worth, because they got the power to do it through eminent domain, and then give that to the biggest company in the world."

I spoke with another resident of the neighborhood who says he's happy to sell his land and thinks he's getting a higher price than he could have without Wal-Mart coming.

If the city prevails in court, construction could begin later this year.


KSL TV5: http://tv.ksl.com

Eminent Domain or Legalized Robbery? : MensNewsDaily, 2/22/05

by Pete Jensen

This originally started as a blog entry, but the more I read about it, the madder I get.

Good reader, I like that computer you are using to read this. In my opinion, however, you aren’t really using it to the maximum potential for the good of everyone. You use it for games, and for net surfing, and little else of consequence. I, on the other hand, could use it in a variety of ways to generate jobs, income, and taxes for the betterment of all.

So, nice guy that I am, I am going to take your computer. Don’t worry, though. I will give you “fair market value” for the system. Of course, I will be the arbiter of fair market value, and the point of appeal if you don’t like it.

Now, I am willing to bet dollars to doughnuts (Unless you are one of those spineless arch-lefties who read me because you love the abuse) that if I showed up on your doorstep with such a spiel and a writ of confiscation that I’d be leaving with more than I bargained for, namely, a fat lip. I know if my abode and castle were set upon by the federales in the name of more taxes for them, I’d be tempted to leave them a little present (A breeder reactor) as a last great act of defiance and a way of saying “F**k your canoe!”*

But this is precisely the reasoning that the tyrants who are in control of many of our esteemed governmental institutions use when they decide that Megamart or the International Widget Factory could generate more money for their coffers than you with your simple home. They decide on a “fair market value” (Which always seems to be within the budgeted amounts – strange.) and assign it to you, then evict you at gunpoint and level your home in favor of putting up some development, or Superstore, or factory. Never mind that you may be a fourth generation owner of that property, or it may contain many memories for you or your children. You don’t need it anymore. Big Brother says so. And surely Brutus is an honorable man….

Today, Tuesday, the 22nd of February 2005, the United States Supreme Court will be hearing arguments in the case of Kelo et al. vs. City of New London. In this case, as in many others since the infamous Michigan Poletown decision, the land is being seized for private development, as opposed to public use, with the specious rationale that more tax dollars into the city coffers is “for the good of all.”

Poletown, for those not in the know, was a landmark eminent domain decision by the Michigan Supreme Court that allowed a massive government thieving of private property in Detroit during the 1981-1982 recession. The outcome of that case resulted in the government condemnation, seizure, and bulldozing of 1,400+ homes, 144 businesses, and 16 churches in the Poletown neighborhood on Detroit's Lower East Side so General Motors could build an assembly plant. This was enacted because GM threatened to pull up stakes and move that operation out of Detroit if the city didn’t capitulate to their demands. This little piece of government sanctioned corporate extortion has since been overturned, but it has provided for years many states and municipalities with the ammo to steal homes and businesses and turn around and transfer that land to bloated and moneyed developers in the name of providing “Mo’ Money, Mo’ Money, Mo’ Money!” for their unbalanced budgets, and short-sighted, harebrained legislation and boondoggles.

It’s cases like this that underline why I am not a capitalist, but a free-marketer; while I perfectly support the right of people to make money and even (gasp!) keep the fruits of their labor, the middle-class schmoe has as much right to his small slice of the pie as some mega-corporation, and deserves the right to extend an abrupt upward thrust of his middle finger to any such corporation trying to pressure him out of his house and land. Eminent Domain is one thing when used to build a needed military installation, or to create an easement for utilities and such, but such things fall under public use. The ostensible reason for private money is so that a big company like General Motors can upgrade an existing piece of land, run utilities to it, and thus make it theirs, and all the profits deriving from it as well. It’s not to let them attach like a lamprey to the public teat so Da Gubbmint can pay pennies on the dollar for private land and turn around and resell it to GM at bargain basement prices.

It’s crap. Pure crap.

Make no mistake, folks. When your ancestral home can be descended on by bean counters; a home which is not a pig-sty, is lived in, and which you do so lawfully and with title, when you are made an “offer” for someone else’s definition of fair market value, when you can be forced to take it, and run out by the sheriff so that the city fathers can sell it off to Gadgets-R-Us for the sake of enriching the city coffers, you have no property rights. It becomes tyranny. It’s intolerable, and is a make-or break single issue that should decide your vote every fall.

One of the few legitimate functions of government is to secure the rights of property, and furthermore it is the most fundamental of the rights in a free society; without the right to the fruits of your labors the rest of your liberty is in dire peril. This is the same attitude by which your property can be seized for a crime even without due process, without an indictment, and without a conviction. This is the same attitude by which the government mandates the breakup of families. This is the same attitude by which busybodies in their ivory towers tell you who you must or may not associate with, hire, fire, or let into your private clubs. And if let unchecked, it will not become smaller. This is what leads to being told what you are forbidden or are compelled to read, to watch, to learn, or to be employed at.

Since Poletown, this has been used by companies across American to leverage economic blackmail across the country. Once it is made clear that if the local government does not act, an established company will go elsewhere, municipalities have slavishly complied and driven thousand from their homes and businesses, often given a pittance of compensation for the sake of mandating sales to that company because the company is unwilling to pay a fair market value for prime real estate. The right thing for the SCOTUS to do would be to empower cities and towns to stand up to such extortion by removing the capability for them to deprive citizens of their property, and to correct the grave imbalance of power which they have abused and proven themselves unworthy of.

Turn a jaundiced eye eastward this day to Washington, my friends, and watch; and let your elected representatives know that they are being watched, and that if the Supreme Court refuses to act, you will in turn expect them to act.

For all you know, your house is next.

*Okay, for those who don’t know the joke, it’s a 3 missionaries captured by cannibals who tell them they will kill them, eat them, and make canoes out of their skins - but they get a last wish. The first two are conventional: Gourmet meal, night with a gorgeous woman, but the last wants a fork, whereupon receiving it he begins stabbing himself while shouting “F**k your canoe!!!”


mensnewsDaily: www.mensnewsdaily.com

Supreme Court justices hear eminent domain arguments: The (New London CT) Day, 2/22/05

By Pete Yost, Associated Press

Supreme Court justices expressed serious doubts Tuesday whether the court has the authority to protect some residents in New London, Conn., who face losing their homes to the city's ambitious program for economic revitalization.

Susette Kelo and several other homeowners filed a lawsuit after city officials announced plans to bulldoze their residences to clear the way for a riverfront hotel, health club and offices. The residents refused to move, arguing it was an unconstitutional taking of their property.

The case's outcome will have significant implications for so-called eminent domain actions.

Scott Bullock, representing the neighborhood residents, argued that government cannot take private property from one owner and provide it to another just because the new commercial project will give a boost to the city's finances.

"More than tax revenue was at stake," said Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg. "The town had gone down and down" economically.

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor questioned whether the homeowners were asking the court to "second-guess" the power of eminent domain.

Chief Justice William Rehnquist, who is battling thyroid cancer, did not attend the arguments and will be absent for the next two weeks. He has not attended arguments since October.

There have been over 10,000 instances in recent years of private property being threatened with condemnation or actually condemned by government for private use, according to the Institute for Justice. The group represents the New London residents who filed the case.

The issue revolves around whether a government is serving a public purpose when it uses its power of eminent domain to take land. The Fifth Amendment prohibits taking private property for public use without just compensation. The New London case is not about the amount of compensation being offered, but whether the government can take the property at all.

Over the years, the Supreme Court has deferred to the decision-making of elected state and local officials.

The court said in 1954 that it is legal for urban renewal to encompass non-blighted commercial buildings in a blighted neighborhood. In 1984, the court upheld Hawaii's land reform law that broke the grip of large landowners, with property being taken and then resold to others.

More recently, many cities and towns have been accused of abusing their authority, razing nice homes to make way for parking lots for casinos and other tax-producing businesses.

New London, a town of less than 26,000, once was a center of the whaling industry and later became a manufacturing hub. More recently the city has suffered the kind of economic woes afflicting urban areas across the country, with losses of residents and jobs. City leaders say the private development will generate tax revenue and improve the local economy.

"The undisputed facts regarding the steady deterioration of New London's economy from the 1970s onwards demonstrate the dire need for such a development project," the city told the court.

The New London neighborhood that would be swept away includes Victorian-era houses and small businesses that in some instances have been owned by several generations of families.

Among the New London residents in the case is a couple in their 80s who have lived in the same home for over 50 years.

City officials envision a commercial development that would attract tourists to the Thames riverfront, complementing an adjoining Pfizer Corp. research center and a proposed Coast Guard museum.

The case is Kelo v. City of New London, 04-108.


The Day: www.theday.com

New London Plaintiffs Get Day in Court on Eminent Domain: Commercial Property News, 2/22/05

By Therese Fitzgerald

United States Supreme Court justices showed skepticm today for the plaintiffs’ position as they began their review of an eminent domain case in New London, Conn.

According to Associated Press reports, Justice Ruth Bader Ginsberg noted that the properties in question were being seized not just for tax revenue but to boost the local economy and provide jobs, while Justice Sandra Day O'Connor asked if the plaintiffs were petitioning the Court to "second-guess" eminent domain.

In the case of Susette Kelo, et al v. City of New London, Conn., et al., The Connecticut Supreme Court found it to be constitutional for the New London Development Corp. to condemn the homes of the plaintiffs — a group of homeowners who refused to sell — for the purpose of economic development. A private developer wants to build a waterfront hotel, conference center, office space and luxury condominiums in the Fort Trumbull neighborhood, near a new Pfizer plant.

The fifth amendment to the Constitution gives governments the right to seize private property for public use in exchange for just compensation. And it is the compensation, rather than the government's right, that is typically argued in court.

But, recently, as governments have become more aggressive in taking property for economic development purposes, private parties are arguing the government's rights to eminent domain and some are winning. Last July, in a legal decision that is impacting other decisions, the Michigan Supreme Court reversed a key 20-year-old decision in County of Wayne v. Hathcock. The court had previously upheld that it was a proper public use for Wayne County to clear an entire Detroit city block and turn it over to General Motors Corp. for an auto plant.

"It's a fundamental issue about under what circumstances the government has the right to take private property," said Caroline Harris, a land use attorney with Jenkens & Gilchrist P.C. "I hope the Supreme Court confronts the issue head-on."


Commercial Property News: www.cpnonline.com

2/21/2005

The end of eminent domain abuse: Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn, 2/21/05

Opponents of eminent domain abuse today braved snowy conditions to gather at City Hall steps and celebrate tomorrow’s landmark Supreme Court hearing of Kelo v. City of New London — a case that will determine whether it’s legal for states to confiscate private property and give it to other private interests for reasons of “economic development.”

“Eminent domain has run amok in this country,” noted Civil Rights Attorney Norman Siegel told the crowd, arguing that private development for private profit does not meet the Constitution’s test for eminent domain. Brandishing a copy of the brief he filed with the Supreme Court on behalf of clients Develop Don’t Destroy Brooklyn (DDDb) and the West Harlem Business Group, Siegel said, “The Supreme Court’s decision will change the landscape in New York City. I call upon the Mayor and the Governor to suspend all use of eminent domain until the United States Supreme Court has spoken.”

In filing their “amicus curaie” (friend of the court brief) in support of the New London homeowners who are suing to keep their property, DDDb and the West Harlem Business Group joined over a hundred organizations such as AARP, the National Association of Homebuilders, the NAACP and the Southern Christian Leadership Conference.

The community leaders, residents, and political officials who stood on City Hall steps today said loudly and clearly that proposed developments by Bruce Ratner in Brooklyn and Columbia University in West Harlem cannot use eminent domain to condemn and demolish the homes and businesses of hundreds of citizens. DDDb spokesperson Daniel Goldstein said, “Bruce Ratner—with the vigorous support of Pataki, Bloomberg, and Markowitz—wants to level a neighborhood that includes my home and hundreds of others. In West Harlem, Columbia University also wants to destroy a community so they can expand. We will not stand by and let this happen!”

Goldstein’s vow was echoed by City Councilperson Letitia James, and by the West Harlem residents who spoke today: Nellie Hester Bailey (President, Harlem Tenants Council), Jordi Reyes Montblanc (Chairperson of West Harmen’s Community Board 9, which passed a unanimous resolution condemning eminent domain abuse), Harlem footprint resident Hamidullah Al-Amin (Coalition to Preserve Community) and Maritta Dunn (Manhattanville Area Consortium of Businesses).

Joe Wright, representing the Institute for Justice, which will argue for Kelo to the Court, concluded, “Individual rights are sanctified in the Constitution and are fundamental requirements for man’s life. The Founders in this respect were ingenious. They said these rights are “inalienable” which means that they cannot be violated or regulated by anyone, at any time, for any purpose whatsoever.”

“We believe the Supreme Court will make the right decision,” Goldstein stated. “If they do not, it’s open season on every property owner in America.”


Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn: www.dddb.net

DDDb leads a broad-based community coalition, fighting for development that will unite our communities instead of dividing and destroying them.

Download the DDDb amicus brief at:
www.dddb.net/public/DDDBamicusbrief.pdf

Eminent domain hits home: Asbury Park (NJ) Press, 2/21/05

Marchers Don't Want Houses Taken for Redevelopment

By A Scott Ferguson and Justin Vellucci

Roughly seven years after losing his home in the city to eminent domain, Robert Hilton marched down Ocean Avenue on Sunday in hopes his neighbors would never meet the same fate.

"Eminent domain is everything that's rotten about New Jersey government," said Hilton, as he joined protesters in Long Branch to oppose the process by which the government acquires private land for a public use. "Eminent domain in New Jersey has been turned into a political patronage program."

At separate rallies in Long Branch, Neptune and Asbury Park, scores of concerned citizens slammed "land grabbing" on behalf of developers.

The protesters also voiced support for Kelo vs. City of New London in Connecticut, a U.S. Supreme Court case expected to be heard Tuesday, in which property owners are challenging the government's taking of their nonblighted homes for "economic development."

Yvonne Braime, an activist with Neighbors United for Neptune, set the day's tone early Sunday morning as she spoke through a bullhorn to a small crowd gathered outside the Neptune Municipal Building on Neptune Boulevard.

"We're not alone in this fight," said Braime, whose group is fighting a proposed development on West Lake Avenue in the Midtown section. "We understand that we have to fight to get the resolution that we want. I have a smile on my face today because we are happy about this protest."

The purpose of Sunday's rallies, organizers said, was to call attention to the use of eminent domain on behalf of private developers. Braime and her group hope the Supreme Court justices side with the property owners, which could mean the end of eminent domain for these type of developments.

Dorothy Argyros, the leader of Neighbors United, thinks developers and their allies would continue to use any means possible to take what they need for their projects.

"They want our valuable seaside land and they want it cheap," Argyros said.

Neptune Township Committeeman James W. Manning Jr. said his biggest concern was not with the concept of development but the specific means of promoting it.

"My issue is not against revitalization but against eminent domain," said Manning, who attended a Sunday rally and has opposed the West Lake Avenue development. "A profit-making enterprise should not use the tool of eminent domain. You can still have progress without eminent domain."

While rallies started Sunday with about 25 people in front of the Neptune Municipal Building, scores of vocal protesters, many of them carrying signs, formed a line that stretched for blocks as they walked down Ocean Avenue from Broadway nearly to the Monmouth Beach boundary.

Katina Tsakiris said she was thrilled to take part in the march. For her, it meant the issue of eminent domain was coming to a head.

"We've been living with this over our heads for 10 years," said Tsakiris, who is the fourth generation in her family to live in a Victorian home on Ocean Avenue that may be acquired through eminent domain. "We're happy things are moving because we can start fighting."

In between shouts of "No way! We stay!" Long Branch resident Tim Ryan contended officials were bending eminent domain rules by claiming that certain parts of the borough's beachfront need to be redeveloped.

"It's a beautiful neighborhood — it's not blighted," Ryan said. "(Officials) want tax revenue (from new development) at the expense of the person who's been here a long, long time."

JoAnne LaRosa, said she is a member of a proud family who would not blink in the face of an attempted land-grab.

"(Our house) has been in our family since 1944. They want to take it," she said. "We're not giving it up."

At the Neptune rally, Asbury Park City Councilman John J. Hamilton Jr. tackled another side of the issue, focusing on problems his city has had with developments in the past several years. In addition to raising rents for Asbury Park's longtime residents, Hamilton said, these development projects have not done enough to give back to the city's schools.

"We have to get out and get other people to join us," Hamilton told the group. "We have to make it our problem. We want to build our cities, but we want to be proud of them."

There were a number of development projects throughout the city where eminent domain had been used to force people out, Hamilton said.

Longtime Asbury Park resident George Kary has been fighting a number of eminent domain issues for the past 20 years. He is trying to save his home and his mother's house on Sixth Avenue.

"It's starting to come down to the wire now, but we're not leaving," Kary, 50, said. "We've got to make noise."


Asbury Park Press: www.app.com

High court to weigh eminent domain: Pittsburgh (PA) Post-Gazette, 2/21/05

By Michael McGough

When the U.S. Supreme Court returns to the bench tomorrow, it will hear arguments in a case that could lead to new rules on when government can seize private property from its owner and turn it over to another party in hopes of creating jobs and increasing tax revenue — a common "public use" far removed from the highways and bridges that were the traditional purpose of eminent domain.

In the audience will be a man for whom this is a landmark case in more ways than one. Bill Von Winkle owns three buildings in the Fort Trumbull area of New London, Conn., which the city and a development agency have sought to acquire by eminent domain for an elaborate redevelopment plan anchored by a Pfizer pharmaceutical company research center.

Von Winkle, who closed a delicatessen he operated in one of his buildings but continues to rent apartments on his property, is confident that he and eight other property owners will prevail in the Supreme Court.

"How could we possibly lose this?" Von Winkle said in an interview. "You can't do what they're doing. If Pfizer wants property, they've got to buy it, not steal it."

Actually, Von Winkle and the other property owners would receive payment for their property under Connecticut law and the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, which says private property may not be "taken for public use without just compensation."

The question before the Supreme Court is whether the redevelopment of Fort Trumbull, which the city believes will invigorate the economy of New London, is a "public use" that overrides the owners' right to hold on to their land if they choose.

For Scott G. Bullock, the lawyer for the New London property owners, the answer is obvious: "This is a clear abuse of eminent domain. If they can take these properties, any neighborhood is up for grabs."

Bullock is an attorney for the Institute for Justice, a Washington-based libertarian public interest group well-known in Pittsburgh for its opposition to Mayor Tom Murphy's plans — later abandoned — to use eminent domain to assemble property for the redevelopment of the Fifth and Forbes retail area Downtown.

In interviews and in the institute's brief to the Supreme Court, Bullock argues that the New London case should be an easy one because — as is not the case with other uses of eminent domain — New London did not assert that the neighborhoods it seeks to condemn are "blighted." The redevelopment took place under a state law designed to revitalize older commercial and industrial areas.

"To petitioners, like most Americans, their homes are their castles," the institute's brief says. "In this case, they face the loss of the homes and neighbors they cherish through the use of eminent domain not for a traditional public use, such as a road or public building, nor even for the removal of blight. Rather, respondents — a local government and a private development corporation — seek to take petitioners' 15 homes to turn them over to other private parties in the hope that the city may benefit from whatever trickle-down effects those new businesses produce."

Supported by city governments — not including Pittsburgh's — and environmental organizations, New London argues in its brief that "employing the power of eminent domain to revitalize a municipality's economy satisfies the public use requirement. This is especially true in urban settings, in which the problem of land assembly often acts as a barrier to economic revitalization."

(The Bush administration has declined to take sides on the matter, which given the federal government's own past use of eminent domain is being interpreted as a victory for the property owners.)

Who's right? In 1954, the high court upheld the use of eminent domain by Congress for an urban renewal program in the District of Columbia.

Writing for the court, Justice William O. Douglas said, "We do not sit to determine whether a particular housing project is or is not desirable. The concept of the public welfare is broad and inclusive."

New London also cites a 1984 case in which the high court upheld Hawaii's use of eminent domain to condemn large tracts of leased residential property so it could break up an "oligopolistic pattern of landownership" left over from Hawaii's days as a monarchy.

New London and its allies insist that under these precedents Connecticut has the discretion to decide what a public purpose is without a federal judge second-guessing that decision.

Not surprisingly, the Institute for Justice reads the two Supreme Court precedents differently. Both, they said, limited the definition of "public use" to "the elimination of the undesirable conditions, not the land's subsequent use."

Although the Institute for Justice's preferred outcome would be for the court to rule that the trickle-down benefits of economic development never constitute a "public use," its brief offers the justices a fallback position: that even if such economic benefits can be a public use in some circumstances, the New London condemnations would not qualify because there is no "reasonable certainty" that the desired economic benefits will actually occur.

However the Supreme Court rules, experts on property law see this as a significant case, although one in which the court is unlikely to revoke the discretion it has given local governments to use eminent domain in "blighted" areas.

"Unless the Supreme Court uses this as a vehicle for revisiting [its 1954 ruling], the practical effect of a decision for the property owners would be small," said Paul Rosenzweig, senior legal research fellow at the Heritage Foundation's Center for Legal & Judicial Studies. "But I wouldn't underestimate the political effect of a decision in their favor. City councils will hesitate before ascribing blight to situations in which it didn't apply."

"This is an important case no matter how you look at it," agreed Laura S. Underkuffler, a property-law expert at Duke University.

"We've been operating, under a basic hands-off policy [regarding eminent doman] for a long time. Any incursion on that bedrock principle would be significant."

Underkuffler said she believed the court would rule narrowly in favor of the New London property owners.

"My guess is that the court will probably decline to craft some broad principle and will instead say that under the facts of this case this is not a public use," she said.

The willingness of the court to go further in reining in eminent domain may depend on how conservative justices resolve a tension between their support for property rights and their view that federal courts should not be "activist."

"This is a case where judges are being asked to trump legislative decisions," Underkuffler said, something conservative justices usually are reluctant to do.

Landmarks line eminent domain's path

It has been 50 years since the U.S. Supreme Court adopted an expansive view of the power of eminent domain in the case of Berman v. Parker, in which it upheld the condemnation of private property by the federal government as part of an urban renewal plan in the District of Columbia.

But the scope of eminent domain and the definition of the "public use" for which it may be employed have continued to generate controversy both in federal and state courts, whether the legal argument has focused on the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution or comparable provisions in state constitutions.

Some recent landmarks in the continuing legal debate:

  • 1981 — In Poletown Neighborhood Council v. City of Detroit, the Michigan Supreme Court upholds a plan under which private property is condemned to allow for the expansion of a General Motors plant. The majority opinion says that "eminent domain is to be used in this instance primarily to accomplish the essential public purposes of alleviating unemployment and revitalizing the economic base of the community. The benefit to a private interest is merely incidental."
  • 1984 — In the case of Hawaii Housing Authority v. Midkiff, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously rules that the state did not violate the "public use" requirement by using eminent domain to transfer ownership from a small group of landowners to their tenants.
  • 2004 — In County of Wayne v. Hathcock, the Michigan Supreme Court overrules its holding in the Poletown case, calling the earlier decision "a radical departure from fundamental constitutional principles." In this case, dealing with a proposed acquisition of property near Detroit Metropolitan Airport, the court says that "Wayne County intends to transfer the condemned properties to private parties in a manner wholly inconsistent with the common understanding of 'public use' at the time our Constitution was ratified."
  • 2005 — This month, the Institute for Justice asked the Ohio Supreme Court to protect the vacant home of a couple in the city of Norwood who left the premises after lower courts ruled that the city did not exceed its authority in using eminent domain to acquire property for the expansion of a shopping mall.




Pittsburgh Post-Gazette: www.post-gazette.com