7/17/2005

Eminent domain vote by fiscal court is troubling: Bowling Green (KY) Daily News, 7/17/05

Editorial

We take the strongest exception to a recent Warren County Fiscal Court vote that provided for the use of eminent domain to take Matt Baker’s property to provide access to Beech Bend Park if it could not be purchased.

The county would be wise to look at the restraint the Bowling Green City Commission used last week when it approved the first reading of an ordinance to restrict the use of eminent domain except for public use and public projects. This would prohibit its use to benefit private developers.

The contrast in approach between these two governmental bodies couldn’t be more stark.

Kentucky law permits the taking of property by eminent domain for public use or if the property falls within an area that has been designated as blighted.

No one has argued that Baker’s property is blighted, nor will that argument be raised.

To argue that the property is being seized for public use when the primary beneficiary of that seizure is a private enterprise distorts in a grotesque way our forefathers’ view of what constituted public use.

The founders of our nation recognized that our rights and freedom came from our Creator, rather than being provided by a “benevolent” government, and “that to secure these rights, governments were instituted among men.”

The Bill of Rights was erected as a firewall to protect citizens from abuses by government.

Not withstanding that, a majority of fiscal court seems agreeable to a highly questionable use of eminent domain.

We certainly understand the importance of Beech Bend Park to the city and county. It brings thousands of tourists and millions of dollars into our community. Benefits flow to tourism-related businesses and taxes to local governments.

But does the importance of Beech Bend to the community rise to a level sufficient to justify the taking of an individual’s property to benefit a private enterprise? We think not.

Nor does the fact that former Kentucky Court of Appeals Judge Matt Baker is unpopular with many in the tourism industry and some others in the community over the stand he has taken regarding the disputed road justify the taking of his property.

The question of property ownership is now resolved pending appeal. Logan County Circuit Judge Tyler Gill carefully weighed all the evidence and based on that evidence, determined that the 228 feet of road in dispute was the property of Matt Baker and his relatives who own property on the other side of the road.

It is appropriate for the county to make an effort to reach agreement with Baker to purchase his property, but it is not appropriate to ride roughshod over Baker’s Fifth Amendment rights.

We commend Magistrate Cedric Burnam for his principled stand against this proposed action by fiscal court.

Magistrate Doc Kaelin abstained because of a possible conflict of interest.

If Warren County Fiscal Court is really interested in assisting Beech Bend, and we have no doubt they are, they should also look at widening Beech Bend Road as well as improving the county-owned portion of the roadway into the park.


Bowling Green Daily News: www.bgdailynews.com

Pacific Avenue property owners challenge eminent domain action: Santa Cruz (CA) Sentinel, 7/17/05

By Shanna McCord

Ron Lau and his family, in a fierce fight to hold on to the downtown property they’ve owned since 1969, vow to appeal their eminent domain case all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court.

"There are no words to describe how this feels. It’s totally unforgivable. We’re outraged," said son Eric Lau. "We have a right to own our property. We don’t break any laws, we pay taxes and there’s three businesses running there."

After years of watching Ron Lau fail to develop the 1547 Pacific Ave. plot, the City Council voted unanimously on June 7 to seize the property that was crushed nearly 16 years ago in the Loma Prieta earthquake. Through the years a large chunk of the site has sat empty and become what city officials call a "blighted hole in the ground," covered with graffiti and weeds.

The Redevelopment Agency began formal eminent domain proceedings Tuesday by filing for condemnation of the site in Santa Cruz County Superior Court — the first step in taking title of the land in an overall ordeal that could drag out several years.

Attempting to ward off the eminent domain — the power of government to condemn private property and seize title for public use, provided owners receive fair compensation — Ron Lau transferred the decision-making authority of the land to his two children Eric and Lani Lau, both of Santa Cruz. The irrevocable power of attorney, they hope, sways city officials to let the family keep the property and put their own project there.

The power of attorney, which Eric Lau said he and Lani signed Wednesday, strips Ron Lau — a devout environmentalist — of having any say of what happens at the site.

"Me and my sister are very different from our father," Eric Lau said. "We share his values to a large degree, but we are very, very practical business people."

Eric Lau, 36, owner of Oswald, an upscale restaurant located on the now-condemned property, and Lani Lau, 38, a certified nurse midwife, say they plan to develop the site in the same fashion as city-picked developer Bolton Hill — mixed use that includes retail and housing.

But they have no solid plans.

"How close are we?," Eric Lau asked. "We’re talking to a number of people and considering many offers. If the city were to give us a chance, we could build it faster than Bolton Hill could do it considering they’ll be tied up in a lawsuit for the next five years."

The 20,000-square-foot lot, on the north end of Pacific Avenue between Lulu Carpenter’s and World Savings Bank, has been appraised at $1.6 million.

Before the earthquake, the site was home to Bookshop Santa Cruz, now located across the street.

Several development proposals by Ron Lau since the earthquake have never made it beyond the drawing board. Frustrated that nothing has been built on the property, the city Redevelopment Agency agreed to take the land and sell it to local developer Bolton Hill, which envisions building a towering complex of condominiums, shops, a restaurant and parking.

Law of the land
The Laus plan to use the eminent domain ruling by the U.S. Supreme Court in June to bolster their case, despite the 5-4 decision making it easier for local governments to force property owners to sell out and allow private economic development when officials decide it would benefit the public.

However, if the public benefit is "merely a pretext" for selling to a "favored insider," according to the Laus’ attorney, William Markham, eminent domain is not allowed. Markham said he can convince the court that Bolton Hill is the "Redevelopment Agency’s crony and favored insider."

Markham, a former Capitola resident and Bay Area real estate lawyer who now practices in San Diego, described the Supreme Court ruling as "the very kind of central planning authority they used to have in the Soviet Union."

"The city should give the Laus one chance, one decent chance to develop their property," he said. "We recognize that Ron Lau is not the appropriate person to negotiate this development. "It’s appropriate now to give irrevocable and absolute authority to Eric and Lani Lau.

"Taking should be an absolute last resort."

Louis Rittenhouse, a former councilman who owns the other empty hole on Pacific Avenue resulting from the 1989 earthquake and is often criticized for not moving faster on his proposed project, disagrees with the city’s decision to condemn the Laus’ property.

"Is this the end of the city just because there’s a hole in the ground? No," he said. "If something isn’t built, it’s not like a number of underprivileged kids won’t be fed. I don’t see the urgency."

Still, Rittenhouse said his situation is vastly different from Ron Lau’s and he’s simply waiting for businesses to sign a lease before putting a building on the site.

"We have spent hundreds of thousands of dollars for design plans approved by the City Council," he said. "We just need tenants. Ron has no plans."

Rittenhouse refused to disclose details about which possible businesses might move in.

"We’re having discussions with a number of entities," Rittenhouse said. "Nothing has born any fruit yet."

Eric Lau said city officials haven’t dealt with the two vacant plots fairly and he feels there’s a "double standard here."

"That’s not to say I want them to condemn his property," Lau said. "But looking for a tenant is essentially what we’re doing. What everyone in the development business is doing is looking for a tenant."

Cindy Geise, owner of the Mission Street Italian restaurant Avanti, said the city’s move to seize Lau’s property makes her nervous about what could happen in the future.

"How can that be blight when there’s three viable businesses and a parking lot on the property?" Geise asked. "It’s scary for everybody. Property owners have the right to determine when they’re going to develop on their property."

Moving on
Redevelopment Agency Director Ceil Cirillo said she would like to resolve the Lau case without going to court, but the agency is not in a position to back out of the deal because of its contractual obligation to Bolton Hill — a deal unanimously backed by City Council.

"We’ll talk with (the Laus) about whether there’s an opportunity to resolve the ownership issue without going through a whole eminent domain," Cirillo said. "The Laus have been longtime members of this community and I want to be supportive of their interests."

Bolton Hill representatives say they’re bracing to follow eminent domain to the end and take ownership of the property. They say 18 months of public hearings and last-minute pleas from Lau to the City Council is enough.

Up to now city officials have been extremely patient with the "recalcitrant" downtown landowner, who ignored repeated offers by the city to purchase the property, said Norman Schwartz of Bolton Hill.

"I made a commitment to the elected officials and to many people in the community who want to see that property developed," Schwartz said. "We’ve spent a considerable amount of money to get this far. I feel an obligation to move forward."

If the city is successful with eminent domain, three businesses currently housed on the site — Oswald, Asian Rose Cafe and Artforms — would be forced to relocate.

Bolton Hill would pay for the cost to uproot and relocate the businesses.

"I’m looking at locations and investigating that whole relocation process," Eric Lau said. "To say I feel slighted is the understatement of the century."


Santa Cruz Sentinel: www.santacruzsentinel.com

Eminent domain protections mulled: (Loveland CO) Daily Reporter-Herald, 7/17/05

State lawmakers plan bills

By John Fryar

At least two state lawmakers plan to propose limiting local governments’ ability to seize private property to create sites for private development.

Sen. Lois Tochtrop, D-Thornton, said she intends next year to reintroduce a measure she failed to get approved in the Legislature’s 2004 and 2005 sessions — a proposed law that would restrict urban renewal agencies’ power to declare areas “blighted” and then subject them to condemnation proceedings.

Rep. Al White, R-Winter Park, wants to go even further.

Rather than just passing a new state law, White said, the Legislature should ask voters in 2006 to amend the Colorado Constitution to prohibit government agencies from using eminent-domain powers to condemn property and then turn it over to a private developer.

But Sam Mamet, associate director of the Colorado Municipal League, insisted that further legislation is not needed in this state after last year’s Legislature adopted a law imposing new conditions and requirements on the use of urban-renewal condemnation powers.

White said, “The citizens and small businesses in this state deserve protection from potentially abusive municipalities and corporations.”

White said Colorado property owners “should be confident that their rights won’t be violated simply because a city can make more money by using their land for a shopping complex or a hotel building.”

Tochtrop and White both said a June 23 U.S. Supreme Court decision firmed their determination to tighten up Colorado’s urban-renewal and eminent-domain laws.

The nation’s high-court justices, in a 5-4 ruling, upheld the authority of New London, Conn., to use its eminent-domain power to seize property from owners unwilling to sell, in order to proceed with an economic development project.

White warned that that ruling could allow local governments in Colorado to condemn any land if they decide its redevelopment would increase tax revenue, regardless of whether that property is actually “blighted.”

White said there is “a reasonable time and purpose” for government agencies to use eminent-domain powers “for necessary public-related activities,” such as when acquiring sites for government buildings, parks or libraries, or when assembling right of way for transportation improvements.

However, “I think we’ve seen in our country, certainly in our state, a tendency of local governments to use eminent domain simply for increasing revenues,” White said.

The Supreme Court majority suggested in its ruling that states can still impose their own restrictions or prohibitions on the use of eminent domain, even if Connecticut laws at the time did not bar New London from using an economic-development rationale to justify condemning property there.

Tochtrop failed last year to pass a bill that would have removed “economic liability” as one of the factors an urban renewal authority can use when declaring an area to be blighted.

This year’s unsuccessful Tochtrop bill could have blocked local governments from putting certain vacant properties or productive agricultural lands into an urban-renewal district.

The Colorado Municipal League, which opposed Tochtrop’s 2004 and 2005 bills, is also expected to oppose the measures she and White are proposing for next year’s legislative session.

CML’s Mamet said, “The Legislature dealt with this issue very comprehensively” in 2004.

“When they had the opportunity to specifically prohibit condemnation for redevelopment purposes, they rejected it,” Mamet said.

Mamet said, “The fact of the matter is, very few municipalities ever use condemnation for economic development-related purposes.”

He said that when it comes to eminent domain, “municipal leaders fully understand what the rules are, both legally, and more importantly, in the court of public opinion.”


Loveland Daily Reporter-Herald: www.lovelandfyi.com

Encinitas councilman defends restricting the use of eminent domain: North County (CA) Times, 7/16/05

By Adam Kaye

Despite skepticism from a colleague, [Encinitas] City Councilman Jerome Stocks on Friday defended his plan to restrict the city's use of the right known as eminent domain.

Stocks says his proposal would protect property owners from a 5-4 U.S. Supreme Court decision last month that expands eminent domain power so cities can take property from one private owner and sell it to another.

In most cases, governmental agencies use eminent domain powers to take property needed for public projects. Laws require the government to pay fair market value for the land and in some cases, cover relocation expenses and other costs.

At its meeting last week, the council voted unanimously to draft an ordinance that would forbid condemning private property and selling it to another private owner without a two-thirds vote of the city residents.

In casting his vote, Councilman James Bond expressed his misgivings.

He said he had taken an oath to uphold all laws. The ordinance would probably fail the test of time, and a future city council could rescind it, he said.

The proposed ordinance was a "feel-good notion," Bond said, and if someone has a better lawyer and more money, it would lose a challenge in court.

Stocks brushed off Bond's skepticism in an interview Friday.

"The Supreme Court gave local governments the absolute and direct ability to condemn private property for economic benefit," he said. "Just because (Bond) doesn't see the threat the way I do doesn't mean the threat doesn't exist."

The court's decision stemmed from a case involving some Connecticut homeowners who refused to sell their land for private development supported by the city of New London.

California cities can condemn private property for public projects, such as road or sewer construction.

Cities may not take private property for the sake of economic development, however, and the court's ruling does not change that, said Steve Deitsch, a Riverside attorney specializing in eminent domain law.

In California, only redevelopment agencies can take land from one private owner and sell it to another, he said.

A city council can form a redevelopment agency to capture increased tax revenue to pay for public improvements, foster economic development and eliminate blight.

Encinitas recently considered forming a redevelopment agency in Leucadia but shelved the idea after residents objected. The possibility of condemnations underscored their concerns.

Redevelopment agencies can condemn private property only if a plan approved when they are formed allows it, Deitsch said.

"I don't believe that the (Connecticut) case gives any greater authority to California cities," he said. "California law is clear on this subject. It allows only redevelopment agencies to acquire private property for land assembly to eliminate blight."

Stocks disagreed.

"This ruling says you don't need to find blight, and you don't even need a redevelopment agency," he said. "The city can just do it for economic reasons."

Stocks said he is not alone in seeking to raise safeguards against the court decision.

State Sen. Tom McClintock, R-Thousand Oaks, and Sen. Dean Flores, D-Shafter, have introduced a state constitutional amendment that would prohibit governments from seizing private property for anything other than public use, according to The Associated Press.

The council last week appointed Stocks and Councilwoman Christy Guerin to a subcommittee to write an ordinance with City Attorney Glenn Sabine.

Stocks on Friday said a draft of the ordinance should be finished in late August or September. He said he would explore language requiring a vote of the people to rescind the law.

Encinitas has used eminent domain eight times, and five of them were to expand Leucadia Boulevard and Quail Gardens Drive. Five of the condemnations were by consent of the property owners.

Stocks floated what he called the Encinitas Private Property Rights Act of 2005 at a press conference last month, one week after the Supreme Court ruling.

Any ordinance Encinitas enacts would not prevent restrict "legitimate" uses of eminent domain for public projects, he said.


North County Times: www.nctimes.com

New outcry over eminent domain won't stop roadway: Stamford (CT) Advocate, 7/17/05

By Joy L Woodson

Multimillion-dollar plans for a new city road and housing are moving forward even as the Legislature plans to deliberate on eminent domain and some municipalities scratch rules that allow seizures of residential properties.

Last month, the U.S. Supreme Court decided in a 5-4 vote to allow New London to bulldoze private homes for a commercial developer, Massachusetts-based Corcoran Jennison Co. The company also has a major residential and retail development in downtown Stamford.

Stamford Mayor Dannel Malloy said the only current development that is using eminent domain to take properties is the Urban Transitway, a $49 million six-lane thoroughfare project in the South End. However, the land is being used directly by the city for public use, not a private developer such as in New London.

"The debate, the judgment and the case have no impact," Malloy said.

The Legislature plans to re-examine the state's 80 eminent domain rules. Some legislators have asked municipalities to hold off on developments. Milford passed an ordinance Monday night that bans the municipality from using eminent domain to take owner-occupied homes for private development.

It is premature to consider the court decision's possible effects on future projects, such as those surrounding the city's Mill River Corridor, Malloy said.

"We'll cross that bridge when we get to it," he said.

Stephen Osman, chairman of the Urban Redevelopment Commission, said the Urban Transitway and Corcoran Jennison's Park Square West near Curley's Diner are moving ahead. However, there could be long-term effects on city development, he said.

"Eminent domain is an important way to rehabilitate a city, but it must be used judicially," he said. "Property rights are sacrosanct, and I don't believe that any one should ride herd over them if it doesn't serve the purpose of the city and the people in the city."

The URC has negotiated with many business and homeowners for their properties, and relocation is ongoing.

"The Urban Transitway is a classic case of eminent domain," said city Rep. Harry Day, R-13. "Nobody likes eminent domain. You prefer not to use it, but it has always been OK for a public use such as a road. . . . I would strongly disagree with holding up the Urban Transitway."

Corcoran Jennison has designed around Curley's Diner, which appealed and won a state Supreme Court case in 2002 that prohibited the URC from declaring the diner blighted for redevelopment. Osman said the commission could have sought a new blight judgment but didn't.

In making its decision, the Supreme Court said states have the power to restrict the authority to seize property. State lawmakers said they will set up public hearings in response to the court's invitation.

Osman said there are no plans to wait on the Legislature's hearings before moving forward on the Park Square West layout. No other projects apparently are affected by the Supreme Court ruling, he said.

Stamford city Rep. John Zelinsky, D-11, suggested the Board of Representatives discuss eminent domain and consider Milford's ordinance. Members of the board's Steering Committee have informally decided to hold off and see what action the state Legislature takes.

Board of Representatives President David Martin, D-19, said there isn't time to get an ordinance passed before the November election, when all 40 seats are up. He said he supports waiting until the new board is sworn in this December.

"It's a complex legal topic and we're probably not going to be able to tackle that successfully in the next couple of months," Martin said. "If you look at the calendar, I think you'd see we'd run of time before we accomplished our objective or we would rush something through we would regret."

"If the state doesn't come up with something constructive, we'll revisit this topic this time next year or maybe sooner," Martin said.

Other land-use officials in Stamford and city representatives disagreed with the court ruling but hoped it would have no adverse impact on Stamford.

City Rep. Patrick White, D-1, called the ruling horrendous. Although he said he has objected to the scope of the transitway, it's not the same as what's happening in New London. He said he hoped the decision wouldn't give developers who are "champing at the bit" the power to squash residents' rights.

"There are some instances historically where it has been necessary to use eminent domain for a road, a school or some other public use," he said. "There are times when it is necessary, but not in New London."


Stamford Advocate: www.stamfordadvocate.com

Eminent domain reins: Albany (NY) Times Union, 7/17/05

Editorial
A Westchester legislator proposes a bill to protect the rights of property owners

House Majority Leader Tom DeLay should listen to Assemblyman Richard Brodsky, D-Westchester. Mr. DeLay is convinced that the House should undermine a recent Supreme Court ruling on eminent domain. That's the wrong remedy. Mr. Brodsky proposes the right way to protect property owner rights -- through state legislation.

The high court's 5-4 ruling last month set off an immediate and ill-informed reaction by advocates of private property rights. They denounced the ruling, which upheld the right of New London, Conn., to seize some homes through eminent domain and give the property to commercial developers for a sweeping waterfront project. The door was open, the critics warned, to seizing homes at will to accommodate private developers seeking to build everything from a cheap motel to an expansive shopping mall. Then the House got into the act by approving, largely at Mr. DeLay's behest, legislation that would deny certain federal funds to any locality that used eminent domain for the benefit of a profit-making venture.

But there are two good reasons why such apprehension is unwarranted. First, the high court's ruling made it clear that eminent domain could be used only for a public purpose. Building a big box store or a motel would hardly meet that standard. Second, the best safeguard against abuse by developers, or local officials eager to do business with them, has always rested with the state legislatures, which have the power to establish the standards under which property may be seized.

Mr. Brodsky's proposal would invoke that power wisely. He would give property owners more time — 90 days instead of the current 30 — to appeal condemnations. The bill also specifies that property owners who are displaced must be paid at least 150 percent of the market value of their homes, as a safeguard against developers seeking to turn a quick profit by buying up properties in declining neighborhoods. The key protection, though, is a requirement that would limit the use of eminent domain to comprehensive economic development plans that have been discussed in public meetings and approved by local legislators.

These are sensible requirements that will not hinder economic development in a community. At the same time, they will thwart abuse by developers and politicians who might be tempted to strike deals in private. The Legislature should put Mr. Brodsky's bill high on its list for approval in the next session.


Times Union: http://timesunion.com

Eminent domain stretched too far: Montgomery (AL) Advertiser, 7/17/05

Editorial

The concept of eminent domain, in which government can take private property for a public use, always has been controversial. But it is still necessary, because there are times when the public good overrides private concerns.

However, the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling that allows local governments almost unfettered power to seize private property simply to promote economic development goes way too far.

In a 5-4 decision, the justices said local governments have broad powers to condemn people's homes through eminent domain to make way for shopping centers or other private development simply to generate increased tax money for the cities.

Under that interpretation, a local government can seize your home just so some developer can build some mega-mart on the site. The 5th Amendment to the U.S. Constitution prohibits your property form being taken "without just compensation," so you would have to be paid a fair price. But you could lose your home nonetheless.

In a state such as Alabama, most people think the concept of private property rights was handed down by Moses right after he delivered the Ten Commandments. (Or maybe even as part of the Ten Commandments; remember the part about not coveting thy neighbor's house or his field?) So we don't expect to see a rush to invoke this newly enshrined right. But it could happen even here.

For instance, a few years ago in Alabaster, just south of Birmingham, city officials tried to invoke eminent domain to take over private land near Interstate 65 for use as a large shopping center, including a Wal-Mart Supercenter. But landowners fought the effort, the price for their land was jacked up, they sold and the attempted takeover became moot.

Recognizing a good political issue, elected officials and political wannabes as well are falling all over themselves trying to get credit for closing the eminent domain avenue opened by the recent court ruling. The public can rest assured that the Alabama Legislature will end this expanded eminent domain right. Frankly, lawmakers should have passed earlier this year a bill sponsored by Rep. Jack Venable of Elmore County that would have addressed the issue.

But care needs to be taken that a remedy, although much needed, doesn't go too far.There are some legitimate reasons for using eminent domain even when a commercial enterprise is a prime beneficiary -- railroads or power-generating dams, for instance. Both examples can greatly benefit the general public, but there is no denying they also help private enterprises make money.

But well-written legislation that preserves the right of eminent domain for such purposes while limiting it for retail establishments is sorely needed.

That is especially true for large retail establishments that are notorious for taking advantage of public incentives, only to move on to a new site in a few years at the slightest shift in retail buying patterns. While alternative uses are sometimes found, in many other instances they leave behind empty buildings and seas of pavement that hurt the community, with a negative impact over the long haul that might offset completely the influx of tax revenue they generated while new.

While many politicians have been excoriating Supreme Court justices for their eminent domain ruling, in fairness it should be noted that what they basically did was say that the U.S. Constitution did not limit this expanded use of eminent domain, pointing out that the individual states had every right to do so. You would think that some "conservative" ideologues would applaud this as a states' rights decision and a refusal of a federal court to expand federal powers beyond what is enumerated.

Regardless, the Supreme Court decision shifts the pendulum too far from individual property rights. The Alabama Legislature needs to shift it back to where it was.


Montgomery Advertiser: www.montgomeryadvertiser.com

Eminent domain possible in farm buyout: Des Moines (IA) Register, 7/16/05

Pleasant Hill officials are ready to force the sale of a family's land for a school expansion

By Amanda O'Toole

The farm plot near Northeast 80th Street and Iowa Highway 163 has been in Jean Schmidt's family for more than 80 years.

Her father bought the land about 50 years ago. Before that, great-aunts and great-uncles raised hogs and chickens and grew corn and soybeans.

Schmidt, 69, didn't know much about the phrase "eminent domain" until a few weeks ago.

"I'd sort of heard of it," she said. "I found out it means you really don't have any rights."

Pleasant Hill city leaders are prepared to legally take Schmidt's 130 acres so Southeast Polk school officials can put up a new building to ease the district's growing pains. The process, called eminent domain, means that government has the power to force land sales when property is considered necessary for public improvements. The U.S. Supreme Court broadened that power last month to let cities seize property for private development.

The law is the law. Schmidt knows that.

All that's left is to put a price on her family's legacy, and that's where the real disagreement lies. Schmidt says the land is worth $1.5 million. City officials have been told the figure is closer to $860,000. They will prepare what will be the final offer.

"It's like a slap in the face," Schmidt said. "This was my retirement package."

School officials first approached Schmidt last fall. They wanted 42 acres.

"It's all about location, location, location," said Southeast Polk Superintendent Tom Downs. "This isn't about picking on one family farmer."

Schmidt was mulling the offer when city leaders stepped in and said they wanted to buy the entire farm.

Pleasant Hill would sell about 10 acres to the school district. About 30 acres would be leased to the schools for a parking lot. A sports complex and park are planned for the remaining 90 acres. The complex and park would share a parking lot with the new high school. A bond referendum is scheduled for February.

Enrollment in Southeast Polk schools has steadily increased for the past decade. It is the 14th-largest district in the state. The high school, built in 1963, was designed for 1,000 students. Enrollment topped 1,350 last year, and districtwide numbers are expected to grow by at least 200 each of the next five years.

"They could find other land," Schmidt said.

School officials said they looked elsewhere, but the Schmidt farm is perfect, in part because of its access to city services.

Downs said school and city officials are sensitive to Schmidt and her family's history, but the move makes economic sense for the community as a whole - the definition of eminent domain.

City officials will not divulge how much they are willing to pay, but the offer is more than $860,000, City Administrator Bob Fagan said.

"We hope we don't have to use eminent domain," he said.

Downs points out that Schmidt intended to eventually sell the property.

But Schmidt said she wanted to make that decision on her own time.

"In 1963, the state came in and took out the farmhouse, the hog house, the chicken house and the water tower to build the highway," Schmidt said. "It was very upsetting to my father to have that all wiped out.

"And this has become very upsetting to me."


Des Moines Register: http://desmoinesregister.com

Eminent Domain Is Not Simple: Town Times (Middlefield CT), 7/16/05

From The State Capitol

By Tom Gaffey, State Senator

Last month's Supreme Court ruling allowing New London to go forward with its power of eminent domain to seize private property for the purpose of economic development trespasses onto legal ground where I don't believe government has any business whatsoever. There is already a strong, swiftly moving, bipartisan effort among my colleagues to tighten Connecticut state laws to prohibit what I consider to be such over-reaching in the future.

Let me be clear: in my opinion the principle behind eminent domain statutes is a sound one. Throughout the history of both Connecticut and the United States important public works projects are the result of judicious use by government of eminent domain to adequately compensate landowners for property that is then transformed into things like railroads, highways and comparable, public sector development.

The difference in this New London case is that the city intends to seize privately-held property (albeit with compensation for the owners at fair market value), and transfer it through a quasi-public agency expressly set up for the project, the New London Development Corporation (NLDC), for another private development, all in the name of economic development.

Regardless of the extent to which investment in economic development projects is for the greater public good, and there are many, many instances when this is the case, the New London plan is for the purported tax benefits of the planned development where the greater good is not guaranteed and only projected, and in the private sector besides.

This important distinction in the New London proposal is the reason the legal challenge to it progressed through state and federal courts and wound up on the docket of the highest court in the land. And in my opinion, none of this yet adequately addresses the matter of what could be described as money laundering through the NLDC to benefit a private developer.

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, who wrote the dissenting opinion in the narrowly divided (5-4) decision, succinctly described the major problem with the New London plan. "Any property may now be taken for the benefit of another private party, but the fallout from this decision will not be random," she wrote. "The beneficiaries are likely to be those citizens with disproportionate influence and power in the political process, including large corporations and development firms."

With this ruling my fear going forward is that homeowners statewide are at risk anytime officials of a municipal government decide there are potential economic or employment benefits from changing the character of a neighborhood from residential to commercial or industrial for a shopping center or business park or comparable project. In my mind this sets a very dangerous precedent.

In the wake of this decision, I'm eager to work with my legislative colleagues to revisit Connecticut's eminent domain statutes and work toward tightening their provisions. I'm confident we can do so while preserving their original, and justifiable, intent.

I don't, however, believe this should be attempted in a knee-jerk reaction to the June 23rd ruling, as some have suggested. In my view, we have a first-rate committee process through which members of the public can weigh in through public hearings, staff members can do the extensive research a complex issue like this one requires, and legislators can assess and debate the content of a bill as it moves through. I'm confident, and I expect, we will achieve this in a timely fashion.


Town Times: www.towntimes.com

Ensign hopes to curb eminent domain ruling: Parumph Valley (Parumph NV) Times, 7/16/05

Supreme Court Decision Rankles Nevada Delegation

By Steve Tetreault

Sen. John Ensign said late last week that he is forming a bill to blunt the Supreme Court ruling two weeks ago that expanded government's power to seize private property.

The measure would position the Nevadan near the front of a movement in Congress seeking to negate the landmark land-use decision.

Ensign, R-Nev., said he is writing legislation that would bar the use of federal grants and tax breaks on property acquired for economic development through eminent domain authority broadened by the court.

"The general principle is to try to take away any tax advantages for (eminent domain), and federal funding," Ensign said. "There are a lot of avenues to attack to do that."

Under the approach that Ensign is developing, a city, for instance, could not spend federal wastewater grants to extend sewer lines to property acquired through a forced sale made possible by the court's decision, according to advisers. It could also not tap mass transit funding to add a bus line to a new office complex on "taken" land.

Private individuals or companies benefiting from forced land sales would be denied tax deductions and credits for the improvement of land obtained through condemnation.

Ensign said he is researching the implications of strongly worded legislation. "What we would have to do is draft ours in a way where you could make exceptions to it," he said.

A sweeping bill would place Ensign in the company of property rights champions and advocates for city-dwellers who launched bids last week to negate the Supreme Court's decision in Kelo v. City of New London.

The court in a 5-4 ruling on June 23 broadened municipal powers to force the sale of private property for redevelopment, saying that economic development was a permissible "public use."

New London, a waterfront city in Connecticut, was permitted to force out the owners of 15 homes that had been holding up the development of office buildings and housing near a research center being built by Pfizer Inc., the pharmaceutical company.

Redevelopment advocates who said it would spur the re-growth of decaying cities and more orderly growth in suburbs praised the ruling.

Property rights boosters and advocates for city-dwellers and low-income people called the ruling an assault on constitutional protections embodied in the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment.

Dana Berliner, an attorney for the conservative [Editor's note: it's libertarian] Institute for Justice who has researched eminent domain issues, said many sizable developments resulting from land takings utilize federal funding, "Whether it is infrastructure or economic development money."

"Withdrawing federal money from projects that take people's homes and businesses for private development will certainly send a strong message to states and local governments who are counting on eminent domain as a tool," Berliner said.

Rep. James Sensenbrenner, R-Wis., said he is introducing a bill with Rep. John Conyers, D-Mich., which is similar to what Ensign is developing. He said he plans to hold hearings on it this summer in the House Judiciary Committee, of which he is chairman.

"What all of us want to make sure happens is that federal government money will not be used to finance taking somebody's property from them to build a strip mall or a hotel," Sensenbrenner said at a news conference.

Sen. John Cornyn, R-Texas, has submitted a bill that would narrow the definition of "public use" for land takings.

Meanwhile, other Nevada lawmakers have expressed unease over the court's ruling.

Rep. Jim Gibbons, R-Nev., has sponsored the Sensenbrenner bill.

"This Congress has a responsibility to uphold the Constitution and the rights of the American people to own property and not to worry that it will be taken for a greater 'private' good," Gibbons said.

Rep. Jon Porter, R-Nev., said the Kelo decision "represents a dangerous precedent that flies in the face of property rights" and he would back legislation "to constructively prevent this scenario from becoming widespread."

Rep. Shelley Berkley, D-Nev., said she was inclined to support withholding federal funds in order to discourage forced sales "but the devil is in the details."

"I would be concerned about overreaching," she said.

House Democratic leader Nancy Pelosi of California said she would oppose any bill that would withhold federal dollars "for the enforcement of any decision of the Supreme Court, no matter how opposed I am to that decision."

At least eight states - Arkansas, Florida, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Montana, South Carolina and Washington - already forbid the use of eminent domain for economic development unless it is to eliminate blight. Other states either expressly allow private property to be taken for private economic purposes or have not clearly decided the issue.

In Nevada this year, the Legislature added new requirements that governments must satisfy before they can condemn private property for redevelopment. Under new laws, two-thirds of an area sought for seizure must be blighted as measured by four out of 15 factors such as inadequate sanitation.

Also, if land taken through eminent domain is not developed in 15 years it must be offered back to the original owner for the price that owner was paid.

There were more than 10,000 instances of private property being threatened with condemnation or actually condemned by government for private use between 1998 and 2002, according to the Institute for Justice.

An institute study concluded New York, Missouri and Kansas were the worst states for owners who want to avoid property condemnation for private parties.

Idaho, Montana, New Mexico, South Dakota and Wyoming were the best.


Parumph Valley Times: www.pahrumpvalleytimes.com

Legislators will look at state eminent domain laws: Benton County (AR) Daily record, 7/16/05

By Gary Lookadoo

Prompted by a U.S. Supreme Court decision, a state legislative panel will take a look at state laws regarding eminent domain, said state Sen. Kim Hendren, R-Gravette.

In Kelo v. New London, several homeowners brought to the U.S. Supreme Court their challenge of a decision by New London, Conn., to use eminent domain to take their homes and allow for a planned economic development.

In a recent 5-4 vote, the court found New London’s plans constitutional. Eminent domain may be used for nearly any "public purpose," including economic redevelopment, under the federal constitution, the court majority found.

Soon after the decision was announced, some state legislators from Benton County — including state Reps. Shirley Borhauer, R-Bella Vista; Mike Kenney, R-Siloam Springs; and Hendren — took strong exception to the court decision. "I believe in eminent domain when it is for the public good. But I don’t think the Supreme Court should have done that to say, "OK, I’ve got a couple of million dollars and I thought I’d like to put some private industry somewhere. Where did you say you live?" Borhauer said.

They wanted to examine and, if necessary, change Arkansas law and regulations to discourage the state from too broadly applying its eminent domain power, Hendren and Kenney said soon after the decision. "(I) asked the (Legislative) Council to research that in the state of Arkansas and see what we need to do … (and) where the state fits with our current laws," Hendren said soon after the court decision.

On July 15, state lawmakers adopted a proposal for an interim study of the state’s eminent domain laws, Hendren said. "The eminent domain/condemnation procedures (study) … went to the legislative Agriculture and Economic Development (Committee)," Hendren said.

With interim studies, lawmakers examine issues between biennial legislative sessions. New state laws often follow completion of interim studies.


Benton County Daily Record: http://nwanews.com

NJ Deputy Mayor starts campaign for elected officials to pledge an end to eminent domain abuse

Kathy Hogan, Deputy Mayor of Haddon Township NJ, has started a statewide campaign for elected officials to pledge an end to eminent domain abuse. The pledge is a promise to:
  1. oppose any efforts by the government to use the power of eminent domain for private redevelopment, and
  2. support legislation and other efforts to ensure that citizens are protected from the governmental exercise of eminent domain for private development.


Elected officials can accept the pledge
  • via email:
    KathyHogan1@comcast.net,

  • or by surface mail:
    Kathy Hogan, Deputy Mayor of Haddon Township,
    7 MacArthur Blvd., N-806,
    Haddon Township, NJ 08108.

Illinois Bill HB4091 would limit eminent domain powers in the state

Bill HB4091 has been introduced into the Illinois General Assembly by representative Eileen Lyons; it is co-sponsored by representatives Ron Stephens, Bill Mitchell, Jim Sacia, Ruth Munson, Aaron Schock, Dave Winters, and Patricia Reid Lindner. The measure, which amends the Statute on Statutes with a new Section 10, would become effective immediately, It would require all takings under the power of eminent domain to be for a "qualified public use." In particular, it
  • provides that it is a "qualified public use" to exercise the power of eminent domain for the acquisition of property for public ownership and control;
  • prohibits the exercise of the power of eminent domain for private ownership or control, including for economic development, unless it is specifically and
    expressly authorized by law by the General Assembly;
  • preempts home rule powers.


Specific provisions include:
  • Neither the State, a unit of local government, nor a school district may take or damage property by the exercise of the power of eminent domain unless it is for a "qualified public use", as defined under this Section.
  • It is a "qualified public use" to exercise the power of eminent domain for the acquisition of property (i) for public ownership and control by the State, a unit of local government, a school district, or any combination of those entities and (ii) for a public purpose.
  • It is not a "qualified public use," however, to exercise the power of eminent domain to acquire property for private ownership or control, including for economic development, unless acquisition of property for private ownership or control is (i) for a public purpose and (ii) specifically and expressly authorized by law enacted by the General Assembly on, before, or after the effective date of this amendatory Act of the 94th General Assembly.
  • "Private ownership or control" shall be liberally construed to prevent the use of long-term leases, options to purchase, and other mechanisms intended to defeat the purpose of this Section, which is to limit the acquisition of property by eminent domain when it is primarily for the benefit and use of private entities.
  • This Section is a limitation on the exercise of the power of eminent domain.


According to a report in the 7/16/05 Lincoln Courier, state Senator Steve Rauschenberger earlier indicated he planned to introduce a bill that would make it more difficult for local governments to use condemnation powers enabling them to clear private land for developers. Rauschenburger concept would be to require local governments to submit such plans to the Illinois attorney general then seek legislative approval.

The Courier also noted that Senator Susan Garrett has said she will conduct hearings — starting in Chicago on July 20 — to examine ways "to better protect the rights of Illinois property owners."


Information contributed by Walter & Joan McElligott: wmcauth07@yahoo.com

7/16/2005

No, we are not safe from eminent domain! Crime & Federalism, 7/15/05

By Timothy Sandefur

The redevelopment bureaucrats are beginning their counterattack in the wake of the outrage over Kelo. Their spin is that Kelo makes no difference to Californians, because California has a law that limits eminent domain to cases of “blight.”

But this is just the sort of hairsplitting nonsense that gives lawyers a bad name. Sure, the California Redevelopment Act (Health & Safety Code, § 33000, et seq.) requires a city to declare a neighborhood blighted before it can use eminent domain, but look at the criteria that the law establishes for a blight designation (§ 33031):

Factors that…substantially hinder the economically viable use…of buildings [include]:
  • substandard design, inadequate size given present standards and market conditions, lack of parking, or other similar factors.
  • Adjacent or nearby uses that are incompatible with each other and which prevent the economic development of…the project area.
  • The existence of subdivided lots of irregular form and shape and inadequate size for proper usefulness and development that are in multiple ownership.

Factors like these are vague and subjective, and requiring the development barons to write a declaration of blight is a meaningless protection for homeowners; it’s just a procedural hurdle that bureaucrats find it easy to jump over.

And what if they declare property blighted when it’s not, like Ahmad Mesdaq’s cigar store in San Diego? Remember, he went to court to challenge the designation, and the trial court said that he was not allowed to introduce any evidence to challenge the city’s decision to take his property. The Court of Appeal affirmed and the Supreme Court denied review.

Worst of all, the condemnation lords claim that they only use eminent domain as “a last resort.” They love this phrase, but of course they use it as a last resort. A thief only hurts you if he “has to,” right? If you hand over your property, nobody will get hurt. Of course, the redevelopment czars “resorted” to eminent domain 223 times in five years for the benefit of private parties.

Whatever you do, don’t let the bureaucrats lie to you. Kelo put the seal of approval on government programs that take property from those who have less wealth and political influence and give it to those who have more wealth and political influence. It’s a massive injustice that no procedural paperwork is going to help. Eminent domain abuse is a threat to every American, including Californians.


Crime & Federalism: http://federalism.typepad.com/crime_federalism

Timothy Sandefur is an attorney with the Pacific Legal Foundation: tmsandefur@gmail.com

7/15/2005

Three diverse Letters to the Editor: The (New London CT) Day, 7/15/05

Look At All The Facts In Eminent-domain Ruling

By Alan Moger, Waterford CT

I have always enjoyed reading The Day, but feel this time it is failing in reporting both sides of the story regarding eminent domain.

I believe the following are facts that The Day frequently omitted from its pieces on the Supreme Court ruling:
  • The Supreme Court ruling says that each state makes the laws regarding eminent domain and we are not telling Connecticut that its law is wrong.
  • The seven houses in question are in an industrial/commercial zoning section of New London, not residential.
  • Six of the seven homeowners have not lived in the houses in more than 18 months.
  • The homeowners say it is not about money, but in 1999 each one wrote a letter stating they would sell for a certain price.
  • The legislature of the state of Connecticut gave $75 million to the New London Development Corp. for this project after approving the entire plan after a lengthy study.

The Supreme Court has said the laws of Connecticut allow the NLDC to use eminent domain to take the properties. If the people of Connecticut don't like it, change the laws.


No Closure Until There's Eminent-domain Justice

By W R Antonowicz, Ledyard CT

The recent decision by the United States Supreme Court on eminent domain has greatly disturbed the domestic tranquility of our country. The Day's editorial titled “It's time to move ahead,” published June 26, is misleading and erroneous. There can never be closure unless social justice is served.

As we the people understand it, New London's problem is a small land area of 6 square miles, and almost half of that property is tax-exempt. That means New London is losing almost half of potential tax income. Why then, would the city take property from tax-paying citizens such as Susette Kelo and put a tax-exempt Coast Guard museum on it?

So why doesn't New London condemn tax-exempt properties such as Mitchell College and put in a giant waterfront hotel, marina and spa, and surround it by high-priced condominiums? That is prime waterfront land that can be returned to the tax base of New London, and would make more sense instead of taking private property already being taxed.

But then again, isn't this all wrong? The Fifth Amendment specifically says “private property taken for public use.” Public use means the property should be tax-exempt. The danger here is that with the collusion of unscrupulous lawyers, politicians and contractors, any property could be taken if it promises to provide a higher tax base, which is in effect, a license to steal.

The Institute for Justice should request an appeal and demand that any property taken for public use remains that way, a tax-exempt property.

In the meantime, the New London Development Corp. should seize the Mitchell College campus by eminent domain. That's where the big tax dollars are.


Eminent Domain Story Includes Fair Treatment

By Sandra Clarke Oney, New London CT
(The writer is a member of New London Development Corp)

Six years ago, Connecticut's governor, legislators, attorneys and architects reviewed proposals for the Fort Trumbull peninsula and chose the best plan for New London.

They also paid the costs of accomplishing that plan.

The city and New London Development Corp. purchased some 70 properties. NLDC conducted two appraisals of each property and provided the higher of the two to the homeowners. The appraisals were considered very generous by realtors, but a few “residents” wanted more, and the process of acquiring their properties through the courts began.

After five years of litigation, the courts all found in favor of New London and NLDC.

Now the state is considering rewriting eminent-domain laws, first scheduling public meetings, reviewing nearly 80 statutes and creating the new bill. Then officials schedule sessions to discuss the bill and then they might vote on it.

They are also considering pre-dating this bill to stop New London from moving forward.

New London has waited five years and now waits again.

The few remaining Fort Trumbull “residents” are also waiting. Some reside on the peninsula while others left long ago and are collecting rents for these properties. They have lost their case in court but are hoping that these latest circumstances may assist them in demanding even more money.

The state should first consider if it is correct to repeal this plan.

The Day has faithfully reported on the “residents' stories,” but has failed to report on the demands they are making.

What began as a project to help New London has become a matter of national controversy, and the people who are most critical of New London don't know the full story.

Like Paul Harvey, I ask, “When will The Day tell ‘the rest of the story'”?


The Day: www.theday.com

Council seeks eminent domain resolution: Friendswood Journal (Friendswood TX), 7/15/05

By Tom Jacobs

The city has directed its legal advisors to draft a resolution stating that Friendswood won't engage in property condemnation for economic development purposes, in the wake of concerns about a massive new development on the city's east side and a U.S. Supreme Court ruling in favor of such a practice.

A number of residents, some living in the West Ranch area where a developer is planning an 800-acre special management district, and others who are keeping an eye on city activities, filled City Council chambers on Monday to see what the council would do.

Council members did take the unusual step of actually engaging residents who spoke about the matter. Following state law, the council normally doesn't respond to any comments from the audience on items not on the agenda, but on Monday they voted to waive such a restriction since a matter had been included among their business to discuss a possible city position on condemnation, or eminent domain.

The issue was addressed for almost 45 minutes during a workshop session before the regular meeting, during which city attorney John Olson said the council could consider a resolution pledging to not use eminent domain to acquire property, but that resolution would not be binding on future councils, or if this council had a change of mind and revoked it. Only amending the city charter to include such a practice would embed it in city law, Olson said. Friendswood's city charter can be reviewed and amended every five years, a date that's still five years off.

Two weeks ago, the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 in favor of a Connecticut city that wanted to condemn and acquire some residential properties for transfer to a private business. The vote was along political lines, with the most conservative judges in the minority.

The ruling has sent a wave of worry across the state and the country, with Texas legislators even considering a statewide law on the matter.

Eminent domain in the past has been used in situations where a government needs a particular piece of property for a project deemed in the best interests of the public, such as a road, a drainage facility or land for a new school.

In their Connecticut ruling, the majority of Supreme Court justices took the view that economic development, especially in areas that are experiencing stresses on their tax stream and that want to diversify and build their tax base, can be deemed in the best interests of the public.

But that was small comfort for some Friendswood residents, particularly those who live between the heart of the city and neighboring League City. Friendswood Development Corp., a major developer who is not affiliated with the City of Friendswood, came to the city earlier this year with plans to develop its West Ranch holdings north and south of FM 518. FDC proposed that a management district be created to oversee the development and levy taxes on commercial portions of it.

In the original draft of legislation creating the management district (such districts shave to be authorized by the Texas Legislature), the West Ranch Management District had included among its authorities the right of eminent domain.

Several long-time residents in the area looked at preliminary plats for the project, a mix of high-end residential and light business uses, and said they saw their properties pictured in retention ponds and in the path of other utility projects. They brought their concerns to the city as well as local legislators, who had the language removed from the proposed bills in the House and Senate.

Two weeks ago, Councilman Tracy Goza put the matter before the council for consideration, either in the form of a resolution or some other action to guarantee property owners that their land would not be taken for use by a private concern.

Monday's action was the first official consideration of Goza's proposal.

Olson said that Friendswood has rarely used its condemnation powers, even for vital needs. The last time he said he could remember the city taking such action was to secure easements in the 1970s.

Eminent domain usually is a last resort, after the city has exhausted all other avenues such as financial negotiations with a property owner, the city attorney said.

Even with city assurances that such a practice might never happen in Friendswood, a number of residents have been left with the jittery feeling that homes they have occupied for decades could be taken from them, as is happening in New England.

"I never thought I would have to stand before seven people who turn our lives upside down," said 75-year-old Betty Felts, who lives in the West Ranch area.


Friendswood Journal: www.zwire.com

Towns won't hurry to invoke eminent domain: Windsor-Hights (Hightstown NJ) Herald, 7/15/05

Editorial

Powerful interests on all sides of the issue have wasted no time weighing in on the U.S. Supreme Court's recent ruling upholding the right of government to use the power of eminent domain to spur economic development.

Builders, developers, urban mayors, smart-growth advocates and others have hailed the 5-4 ruling as a major victory for taxpayers, whose burdens will henceforth be relieved by the addition of big, bright, shiny new ratables to the tax base. Moreover, the quality of life will improve dramatically as badly neglected neighborhoods are transformed into attractive new developments that lure people — and money — back from the affluent suburbs.

Libertarians, homeowners' associations, virtually every blog on the Internet and a slew of Washington-based nonprofits, including a surprising number of environmental groups, are appalled. For all practical purposes, they say, the Supreme Court has destroyed the very concept of private property rights. The ruling has all but invited local government officials to send in the bulldozers and start knocking down private homes owned by people they happen not to like, and replace them with ones constructed by powerful interests who contribute to their political campaigns.

While our personal favorite in the vitriol department was this sarcastic mock headline culled from the Internet — "D.C. Mayor to Bulldoze Ruth Bader Ginsburg's Home for Homeless Shelter" — most of the criticism has lacked both cleverness and humor. Instead, the New London, Conn., case has occasioned another of those ideological outbursts that have a way of generating a lot more heat than light. And, in the process, both sides have greatly oversimplified the likely effects of the ruling.

For example, nobody should expect our cities to suddenly rise from the ashes, or overburdened property-taxpayers to enjoy overnight relief, because local governments will be inspired by this ruling to start invoking the power of eminent domain. In many states, local governments do not have this power; in others, there are very explicit limits on its use. More important, in the real world, the circumstances that warrant the use of this power are extremely limited — it is for this reason that local governments, in fact, rarely employ it.

On the other hand, the notion that local government might now go out and start invoking this power, willy-nilly, to promote private development is preposterous. Both the majority opinion and Justice Anthony Kennedy's concurring opinion made clear that this power may not be used simply to help a private developer, that it must be part of a comprehensive redevelopment plan in which the public interest is paramount.

In some cases, such a plan cannot be carried out without eminent domain. Baltimore had to use it to build its Inner Harbor. New York couldn't have revitalized Times Square without it. But in other cases, eminent domain isn't necessary for economic development to occur, and government is wise not to exercise it.

Will the Supreme Court decision have an impact? Absolutely. Will it be a major impact? We suspect not.


Windsor-Hights Herald: www.windsorhightsherald.com

California attempts end run around eminent domain: Inman News (Emeryville CA), 7/15/05

Bill would limit government ability to seize real estate

Members of California's senate and assembly have introduced bills that would place a constitutional amendment on the ballot reducing the impact of the U.S. Supreme Court's recent decision on eminent domain.

California Senator Tom McClintock, R-Simi Valley, introduced bill SCA 15 and Assemblymember Doug LaMalfa, R-Richvale, introduced Assembly Constitutional Amendment 22, which mirrors SCA 15.

Both bills seek to put a constitutional amendment on the state ballot. One part of the proposed amendment states, "Private property may not be taken or damaged for private use."

It further states, "Private property may be taken by eminent domain only for a stated public use…Property taken by eminent domain shall be owned and occupied by the condemner or may be leased only to entities that are regulated by the Public Utilities Commission."

The move is an attempt at an end run around the recent U.S. eminent domain decision in Kelo v. City of New London, in which the U.S. Supreme Court ruled that local governments can seize individuals' homes and businesses against their will to make way for shopping malls and other private economic development.

In a 5-4 ruling, the court said government agencies can take private property for economic development, and even transfer it to another private party.

The ruling was a loss for residents of New London, Conn., who petitioned against the use of eminent domain, arguing that cities have no right to take their properties unless the projects have a clear public use, such as roads or schools, or to improve blighted neighborhoods, the AP reported.

Justice John Paul Stevens wrote the court opinion, affirming that New London's proposed disposition of petitioners' property qualifies as "public use." Stevens was joined by Justices Anthony Kennedy, David H. Souter, Ruth Bader Ginsburg and Stephen G. Breyer.

Justice Sandra Day O'Connor wrote a dissenting opinion, arguing that cities should not be able to uproot families with unlimited authority to accommodate developers. She was joined by Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas, and the Chief Justice William H. Rehnquist.


Inman News: www.inman.com

Encinitas to curb its power of eminent domain: San Diego (CA) Union-Tribune, 7/15/05

By Angela Lau

The [Encinitas] City Council voted unanimously Wednesday night to restrict the city's power to take private property.

The council formed a subcommittee of council members Jerome Stocks and Christy Guerin to draft an ordinance and to report back at an unspecified date.

The decision came in the aftermath of the recent U.S. Supreme Court decision that gives cities power to take private property to help private developers assemble land for economic development.

The fear of eminent domain resonates deeply among Leucadia residents, who recently fought off a city proposal to form a redevelopment agency – which often possesses eminent-domain power – to rebuild the community's drainage system.

Wednesday night, Stocks – who initiated the discussion – suggested that the council pass a law requiring a public vote with a majority greater than two-thirds to approve any city condemnation of private property for private projects.

"I want to render it virtually impossible," he said.

Gene Chapo, a member of the Self-Realization Fellowship in Encinitas, urged the council to pass such a law.

"The Self-Realization Fellowship is the largest contiguous land owner in the city. Probably not a day goes by when the (fellowship) is not approached by developers," Chapo said.


San Diego Union-Tribune: www.signonsandiego.com

Eminent domain fight: The Brooklyn (NY) Papers, 7/15/05

By Jess Wisloski

In response to the Supreme Court’s ruling last month affirming the right of governments to take private property in the name of economic development, bills are gaining momentum in both the House of Representatives and U.S. Senate that would bar federal tax dollars from being used for projects that employ eminent domain.

The legislation could cut affordable housing subsidies to developer Bruce Ratner’s proposed Atlantic Yards plan, which proposes to build a 19,000-seat basketball arena and 17-tower office and residential complex at the intersection of Flatbush and Atlantic avenues, and which threatens the use of eminent domain for up to 13 acres of private property.

Ratner and his major supporters, who include the mayor and governor, have said the massive development would bring in new tax revenues for the public good, although Ratner executives have long claimed that the area of Prospect Heights where they want to build is blighted, and therefore qualifies for eminent domain regardless of the Supreme Court ruling.

On June 30, conservative-leaning Republicans in the House responded in force to the Supreme Court ruling, which was led by the high court’s liberal voices. Ninety-three congressmen thus far have co-sponsored the Private Property Rights Protection Act of 2005 — drafted by Republican F. James Sensenbrenner, Jr., of Wisconsin — which would forbid allocation of federal funds, many of which go to state and local municipalities for development incentives, to be used for any project employing eminent domain.

Both the House and Senate are considering nearly identical bills that would prevent funding, like the kind that has been committed in the form of tax-exemptions and subsidized mortgages to Ratner for development of affordable housing units, from use for economic development. Only the House has had a hearing, before its Judiciary Committee.

“No state or any political subdivision of a state shall use economic development as a reason for exercising its power of eminent domain if federal funds would contribute in any way,” the bill states, and further threatens to render any violating agency ineligible for federal funding.

The bill defines “economic development” as any activity “including increased tax revenue” that does not involve using the seized property in a “substantial part” for public use.

The bill could stifle federal funding for local and state development corporations seeking incentives such as tax breaks, tax abatements, subsidies and initiatives if those entities put forth projects that required the condemnation of private land.

As reported by The Brooklyn Papers following a May 19 commitment between the city and Ratner in a Memorandum of Understanding, officials from the Housing Development Corporation, a city housing fund that finances development projects, committed $67.5 million in subsidies. An article this week in the New York Sun estimated as much as $76 million in taxpayer-funded subsidies.

The Housing Development Corporation (HDC) would be offering Ratner 1-percent tax-exempt mortgages for the construction of the project’s moderate-income units, financing up to $45,000 a unit to subsidize their construction, said HPD’s commissioner, Shaun Donovan.

Forest City Ratner did not return calls seeking comment for this article.

At the Judiciary Committee’s June 30 hearing, Sensenbrenner, the bill’s sponsor, said that “any property may now be taken for the benefit of another private party.

“Government now has license to transfer property from those with fewer resources to those with more. The Founders cannot have intended this perverse result,” Sensenbrenner said.

“American taxpayers should not be forced to contribute in any way to the abuse of government power,” he said before asking members to co-sponsor the bill to “assure the American people that we will not allow churches, homes, farms and other private property to be bulldozed in abusive land grabs that solely benefit private individuals whose only claim to that land is that their greater wealth will increase tax revenues.”

Karen Johnson, a spokeswoman for Brooklyn Rep. Edolphus Towns, said that although the Democrat was opposed to the Supreme Court’s ruling, he hadn’t yet looked at the bill.

“He didn’t like what the Supreme Court justices did,” Johnson said, but mentioned the affinity of Sensenbrenner to far rightwing causes, and feared the bill might have ulterior motives. “There might be better bills that will be drafted [of the same ilk],” she added.

Rep. Vito Fossella, a Bay Ridge-Staten Island Republican who thus far is the lone member of New York City’s congressional delegation to co-sponsor the bill, this week told The Brooklyn Papers, “What the Supreme Court took away in our Constitutional rights, the Congress must now restore.

We must slam the brakes on any attempt by government to seize our homes and small businesses for private developers to build hotels, supermarkets or office buildings.”

Neither Rep. Nydia Velazquez nor Rep. Major Owens returned calls for comment by press time, but Owens has taken a strong position against the Ratner plan and its reliance on eminent domain.

“My thing is this — if the bill broadly talks about economic development, I would oppose it, because I don’t believe in doing a broad brush like that,” said Chris Owens, the congressman’s son and chief aide, who is expected to run for his retiring father’s seat in 2006.

“I don’t want to see the abuse of eminent domain either, but you have to be very careful on how you approach these things.

“You don’t want to be in a situation where you can’t do anything, but you don’t want to abuse eminent domain, either.”


The Brooklyn Papers: www.brooklynpapers.com

Corzine, Forrester against eminent domain abuses: Trenton (NJ) Times, 7/15/05

By Tom Hester

The U.S. Supreme Court's recent ruling allowing local government to seize people's homes for private development wriggled its way into the gubernatorial campaign yesterday, with both major candidates announcing plans to combat it.

Republican Doug Forrester named a task force to study the decision and recommend how New Jersey can change its laws to protect homeowners.

"We're dealing here with fundamental rights," Forrester said.

Democrat Jon Corzine didn't wait for a task force report. Less than two hours after Forrester unveiled his plan at the State House, Corzine released a statement proposing seven changes to state law he said would protect homeowners from eminent domain abuse.

"There should be no taking of homes for economic development except in rare and exceptional circumstances and then only with adequate safeguards to ensure that the process is fair and transparent," Corzine said.

The Supreme Court decision allowed states to set their own rules on eminent domain.

Forrester said the task force would report to him on what changes the state could make to protect citizens.

He said the ruling is particularly troubling for New Jersey, where he said corruption and political influence could play roles in eminent domain proceedings. He called this a "sinister element" and cited Petty's Island, a South Jersey Delaware River island, as an example.

Environmentalists want the island preserved, but officials, including influential Democrats, support seizing the property for redevelopment.

Forrester said the task force would be headed by Candace Straight, a Republican insider who once ran for Essex County executive and was a co-chairwoman of the New Jersey Republican State Committee. Forrester said her broad public service experience qualifies her to lead the task force, which will include several Republican legislators.

Corzine proposed changing state law to limit government's ability to taking homes for economic development, requiring municipalities to explore alternatives to eminent domain, delaying condemnation until a trial and appeals are completed and eliminating no-bid developer contracts and awarding contracts to campaign donors.

He also proposed requiring homeowners who lose their homes receive compensation beyond fair market value, require redevelopment housing plans to include affordable housing for families and senior citizens and commercial plans to include such housing and giving the state public advocate authority to monitor eminent domain.


Trenton Times: www.nj.com

Appeal to MN Supreme Court Seeks “One last chance for justice, 7/15/05

News Release

Danny Orttell, a 25 year resident of Oak Grove [MN], claims his entire Lake George neighborhood was deemed blighted and then bulldozed via Eminent Domain under the false pretense that a low to moderate income senior apartment complex would be built there.

In order to prove the “public’s purpose” in the taking of Mr. Orttell’s home, neighborhood, and the Shoreside restaurant/bar, the city of Oak Grove and the Anoka County Housing and Redevelopment Authority originally proposed that the 54 unit senior apartment structure be built entirely on the old neighborhood property. This proposal was made public in 2001. Orttell’s adjoining 7.2 acre tree nursery was also taken as an extension of the project.

Orttell contends that building the senior complex on his old neighborhood site was never feasible because of its proximity to the lake. The density of the structure requires that it be built 500 or more feet from the shoreline. “I believe the initial site plan was only used to successfully take the West Lake George properties,” Orttell says.

The plan was later radically revised placing the structure completely outside the doomed neighborhood site. One top project official even testified during Orttell’s first Eminent Domain hearing appeal that the revised senior complex could be built in its entirety on the 7.2 acre tree nursery parcel, without requiring the use of the original lakeside neighborhood properties whatsoever.

The fact is, the senior complex is being constructed solely on the 7.2 acre nursery parcel taken by the city. And since the bulldozers pulled out over a year ago, after leveling the village by the bay known as Paradise, no construction or development has ever taken place there. Now that the dust from the rubble has cleared, the very desirable lakeside properties are being sold to private developers. Such sales directly violate original Eminent Domain rules (prior to 06/23/05, the date of the US Supreme Court’s newest decision) concerning the “public’s purpose.” It seems Oak Grove’s hidden agenda was more about social cleansing than it was best serving the public. Only 1 of the 54 apartments will be subsidized, the rest will be unaffordable to any low to moderate income retiree.

In an attempt to mask this atrocity Oak Grove attorneys now claim that the taking of the ill-fated neighborhood was necessary in order to run utilities to the senior complex. Orttell claims, however, that utilities have always been run along boulevard right-of-ways. The senior complex is now being built at the furthest possible point from Lake George within the project area, completely off the old neighborhood site, and only a few feet from existing utility supplies. This being the case, it becomes highly questionable whether the residential demolition and forced relocation of 16 residents and 2 family-owned businesses was ever necessary.

In early arguments regarding the project, Orttell offered to sell vacant land directly across the road from the project area to the city of Oak Grove. Despite the millions of dollars the city could have saved by this more sensible solution, Orttell’s offer was ignored.

Many sources close to this matter allege that several city officials including the Mayor and one council member have voiced their strong dislike for Orttell from the beginning, virtually launching a smear campaign against him. Orttell contends this constitutes a biased vote on the decision to proceed with the project. Under the rules of democratic procedure, this would nullify that vote. The majority of Oak Grove residents were opposed to the project.

“They can think or say what they will about me. I’m no angel, but I am a taxpaying, registered voting citizen, and I’ve always been a fighter,” Orttell says. “Though this has taken far more than one man’s toll on my physical, mental, and financial stability, I will continue to fight for what I believe is right, and against what I think is wrong, and given the US Supreme Court’s decision on June 23, 2005 — virtually handing local government full rein over Eminent Domain, we as Americans should fly our flags at half-mast this Labor Day for the freedom we have lost.”


Danny Orttell: dannyorttell@hotmail.com

Eminent domain raises the stakes: (Long Island NY) Newsday, 7/14/05

Opinion

By Brian S Stoler

Wrestling with whether the Constitution allows an economically distressed city to acquire private property to reverse its economic decline, the U.S. Supreme Court has just reaffirmed the right of a municipality to redistribute private property.

The justices made it clear that local governments, including Long Island's, do indeed have the powers to make choices for us - choices that could involve the relocation of citizens when their property can be used for a better public purpose.

The decision was sparked by the question of whether New London, Conn., could use eminent domain to achieve its goal of economic revitalization at the expense of uprooting homeowners from their homes and communities. Rather than pass judgment on the city's basis for the acquisition of private property, the court deferred to the judgment of city officials.

The court ensured that the use of eminent domain will be expanded dramatically, limited only by a politician's concern about how such a taking could affect his job tenure. Still, the court made it clear that a local government does not have carte blanche when exercising eminent domain and that the Constitution insists property owners be compensated for such taking. Yet the underlying reason for the public unease with this decision is that the homeowners being displaced may not be "getting just compensation" but rather "just getting compensation."

This issue already is being played out on Long Island. The ability of Gyrodyne, a former defense company with 314 acres in St. James, to put its property to profitable use has been stymied because of the possible exercise of eminent domain by Stony Brook University - which wants to use the land for a technology center.

But one need not own a real-estate holding company to find his land has just come under the shadow of condemnation. Envision these scenarios. You buy your waterfront-view, Victorian-era dream home and make substantial improvements. Or you still reside in the house purchased by your family more than a century ago. Yet the Supreme Court has made it clear that as long as just compensation is paid, a local government can acquire your dream home or uproot you and your family. But until there is a philosophical and legal change concerning the assessment of compensation, homeowners will be "just getting compensation."

Still, municipal government seldom moves quickly. Redevelopment projects include an open process to ensure that the public knows what the consequences of the decision will be and who is making those decisions. Perhaps it is this last point that will serve as the great equalizer for the protectors of property rights. Government officials have to answer to the electorate. Thus, even if a local legislature believes that a certain economic development project is in the best interests of the community, if the community disagrees, the community could have the last word on Election Day.

A prime example of this impact can be found in the Town of Hempstead. The town, faced with the opportunity to acquire property that would serve to improve the community at the expense of one business owner, did not hesitate. Hempstead condemned the Oceanside Motel because it was a purported haven for drugs and prostitution. Other than the hotel's owner, the only opponents to the town's decision were the transients using the hotel for nefarious activity. They will not be at the polls come November, but neighbors who sought the closure will be there.

In a more controversial previous taking, the Town of North Hempstead acquired church-owned property to further the town's goal of redeveloping portions of the New Cassel community that the town viewed as blighted. More recently, the town has sought to acquire another New Cassel property owned by an individual but used, in part, for worship.

Woody Guthrie's famous lyric verse "This land is your land, this land is my land" might need to be revised to include the line "unless of course it's needed for a parking lot."


Newsday: www.newsday.com

Brian S Stolar is an attorney with the law firm of Meyer Suozzi English & Klein, Mineola NY

Farm Bureau calls for eminent domain reform: Virginia Farm Bureau Federation, 7/14/05

News release

With the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling on eminent domain, the protection of private property rights has become an issue that has sparked national attention and discussion. Virginia Farm Bureau Federation [VFBF] has been involved in the ongoing dialogue.

“Farm Bureau has a natural interest in the U.S. Supreme Court decision,” said Susan Rubin, assistant director of governmental relations for Virginia Farm Bureau Federation. “Our members have been disproportionately involved in condemnation cases because of the amount of land required for their farming operations.”

Virginia Farm Bureau was at the forefront of eminent domain reform during the 2005 General Assembly session. The organization initiated two bills to tighten the laws regarding rights of property owners in the condemnation process. The bills, sponsored by Del. Terrie L. Suit, R-Virginia Beach, covered landowner issues dealing with right of entry by a condemning authority; and fair compensation in the acquisition process. Both bills overwhelmingly passed in the Senate and House chambers.

“All property owners need to understand eminent domain laws so they can protect themselves and their land,” said VFBF President Bruce L. Hiatt. “Respect for private property rights is a fundamental building block of our nation. Unfortunately, we’ve seen a lot of erosion of those rights.”

VFBF was one of 18 state Farm Bureaus that in early December signed onto a friend-of-the-court brief filed by the American Farm Bureau Federation in Kelo v. City of New London.

“Agricultural land is the livelihood of our farmers and ranchers and important for U.S. food and feed production, but land used this way is not the highest income generator for government bodies,” said AFBF President Bob Stallman. “Tax revenue cannot be the basis for seizing private property.”

Virginia Farm Bureau also serves as a member of the Virginia Housing Commission’s Eminent Domain/Blight Removal/Brownfields Remediation Issues Work Group. The group’s charge includes developing a definition or criteria for the determination of public use; reviewing eminent domain legislation referred to the commission and providing recommendations for action.

“Farm Bureau is aware of the growing interest throughout the state to see changes in Virginia’s laws,” Rubin said. “We support all efforts that increase the rights of property owners and look forward to participating in additional eminent domain reform.”


Virginia Farm Bureau Federation: www.vafb.com

Maplewood Property Owners Continue Fight Against Eminent Domain: KSDK TV5 (St Louis MO), 7/14/05

By Erin O'Neill

Imagine owning your home for years, then one day someone comes along and says you have to sell it. Why? Because a developer wants to build something better in its place. It's called eminent domain and it's happening to property owners in Maplewood.

Last month, the Supreme Court ruled five to four local governments can seize property for private development. Since that ruling, many property owners, like Patricia Trout of Maplewood, are trying to prevent it from happening to them.

"We have spent a lot of time and money fixing it." Trout has lived in the same home on the 4700 block of Hazel for 50 years. "We both graduated from the school district and all of our children did so we have deep roots here and I have my business in my home."

Now Trout may have to move her business and her home. Several developers want her property and the other homes on her side of the street to make way for something better. "It's just very unsettling."

They city is accepting proposals from developers until July 29th. Maplewood City Councilman, Tim Dunn, "In terms of the 29th, we get the proposals in then we'll have to talk about you know what are the scopes of the different proposals."

Then the city council must decide if one is worth knocking down homes and businesses. Dunn says, "I think at that point a city has an obligation to the community to move ahead and if that means eminent domain I think that's a proper use of eminent domain."

Trout is one of several hundred Maplewood residents and business owners who attended a meeting on eminent domain Tuesday night. Trout says they were hoping for answers, but she says that didn't happen. "We've heard conflicting things. Oh they're not going to take your home. Well they might and don't worry about it. You just don't know what."

But Trout does know the the fight isn't over yet. "We may have to wait but we're not just sitting around."

When city council votes on the proposals only a simple majority vote is needed. Meantime, Governor Matt Blunt is forming a task force to study eminent domain laws and recommend ways to protect missouri property owners.


KSDK: www.ksdk.com

Eminent domain: The truth behind the spin: Marblehead (MA) Reporter, 7/15/05

Opinion

By Sean Connolly

Ours is an age of political polarization and shameless media spin. The recent U.S. Supreme Court decision on eminent domain, Connecticut's Kelo case, is a case in point. Of those seething with rabid vitriol in its wake, I'm sure that only a tiny fraction of them - even those in the media - have even read the decision or analyzed it in the context of other takings cases by the U.S. Supreme Court handed down in the last 25 years.

The truth of the matter is this: The high court has been continually expanding the protection of private property rights over the last two decades. In fact, where a governmental action substantially diminishes the value of private property, even where there is no physical taking, the Court has held that a compensable regulatory taking has occurred, for which the property owner must be compensated.

The political spin-masters decry the recent Supreme Court decision as the end of private property rights, hoping that their audiences will not actually review the case for themselves, nor its important preceding decisions. I encourage everyone to do just that, even non-lawyers. There has been an increasing trend toward writing legal opinions in a way the vast majority of people can easily understand, which is a departure from the Olde English ways of jurisprudence whereby only the most learned and elite of society could understand the language of an official legal opinion or document. It is an important development in the democratization of our American legal system.

Having personally devoted substantial time and effort to study and work in this field of takings law, I think it is important for those individuals who do not have this little intellectual niche as one of their specialties in life to have some context within which to understand the recent U. S. Supreme Court eminent domain decision in the Kelo case from Connecticut.

According to the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution, "No person shall be... deprived of life, liberty or property, without due process of law; nor shall private property by taken for public use, without just compensation." The Fifth Amendment is a set of protections for individuals from the federal government, whereas the Fourteenth Amendment confers those same protections on individuals from abuses by the state governments.

The two important issues in a typical takings case are questions of "public use" and "just compensation." In the recent Supreme Court decision, "just compensation" was not even an issue. Anytime there is a physical taking of private property for public use (with extraordinary exceptions for war, natural disasters, etc.), fair market value must be given to the property owner by the government. This is an important balance because, as many of us are aware, governments at the state and local levels are generally pretty tight on discretionary spending allowances. It is a self-checking measure that the exercise of eminent domain powers must be accompanied by a check to the property owner from the government for the full fair market value of the property being taken for a public purpose. Governments simply do not have the money to injudiciously exercise their powers of eminent domain.

"Just compensation" was not even an issue in this recent case eminent domain case - we all know that just compensation is a requirement for the exercise of eminent domain. Unlike the spin-masters would like to have you believe, the government cannot just come in and take your property and give it to someone else because they will pay more taxes than you. Don't believe the hype!

In the recent Supreme Court case, the issue was not the "just compensation" requirement of the Fifth and Fourteenth Amendments to the U.S. Constitution. It dealt exclusively with the issue of "public use," namely: Is there a public purpose for the government's exercise of its eminent-domain powers? Aside from having studied and worked in the eminent-domain field, I also studied and worked in the public and private sectors as a development planner. Planners, in general, view the recent eminent-domain decision as a victory.

The only reason the high court deemed it be a permissible taking was because it was done pursuant to the local comprehensive plan. The court typically will defer to state and local legislative decisions, such as planning and zoning, unless these local legislative decisions are otherwise held to be unconstitutional.

For over a hundred years, the Supreme Court has held that "public use" includes important public purposes, such as environmental protection and economic development. "Public use" does not necessarily mean that every member of the public could use it as he sees fit, such as a public park - there must, however, be a public purpose and a public benefit. Connecticut's Kelo case was a legitimate exercise of the government's eminent-domain powers because it was implemented pursuant to a comprehensive plan for economic development in that community. It was not a willy-nilly local decision to take someone's house and give it to someone they liked better.

Don't be fooled. Read the opinion for yourself (see the Web site of the U.S. Supreme Court). Do not believe the professional spinners who tell you that this is the end of private property rights and that the government can just take your property and give it to some other private citizen. Such a misstatement of law and fact is untrue and is the irresponsible use of power by those with the great luxury of a modern day bully pulpit.

The seventh page of the Supreme Court opinion reads thusly: "[T]he City would no doubt be forbidden from taking [an owner's] land for the purpose of conferring a private benefit on a particular private party. A purely private taking could not withstand the scrutiny of the public use requirement; it would serve no legitimate purpose of government and would thus be void. Nor would the City be allowed to take property under the mere pretext of a public purpose, when its actual purpose was to bestow a private benefit. The takings before us, however, would be executed pursuant to a 'carefully considered' development plan... the City's development plan was not adopted to benefit a particular class of identifiable individuals."

In the closing pages of its 20-page decision, the Supreme Court states as follows: "In affirming the City's authority to take [the owners'] properties, we do not minimize the hardship that [the use of eminent domain] may entail, notwithstanding the payment of just compensation. We emphasize that nothing in our opinion precludes any State from placing further restrictions on its exercise of the takings power."

I have no doubt that the media spinners are going to push for continued public misinformation and confusion on this and other U.S. Supreme Court issues in the weeks and months to come. It will be the springboard for mustering public sentiment in favor an increasing appetite for new conservative justice(s) to fill the imminent opening(s) on the U.S. Supreme Court.

Instead of all of the extremist spinning and misinformation on the opposite ends of spectrum, we would all be well served to have an independent, freethinking, centrist, moderate ascend to the high court. We need a new justice who will be similar to Sandra Day O'Connor in important ways: a centrist jurist who thinks for herself and approaches each case with unbiased sound judgment; not a prejudicial judge who seeks to impose his/her biases and flawed political views upon the rest of us.


Marblehead Reporter: http://www2.townonline.com/marblehead

Sean Connolly, a Marblehead resident, is an attorney