7/10/2005

When using eminent domain, commission should consider housing needs of the poor: Bowling Green (KY) Daily news, 7/10/05

Opinion

By Alan Anderson

The present discussion of the use of eminent domain by the city commission has centered on whether to use this power beyond that for such public purposes as roads, parks, and buildings. This debate needs to take special account of the interests of the citizens most directly affected.

These interests were expressed in the amicus brief submitted in the recent Supreme Court case by a number of groups including the AARP, the National Association for the Advancement of Colored People, the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, and the Hispanic Alliance of Atlantic County.

This brief makes three points: first, that the power of eminent domain historically has been used to target racial and ethnic minorities; second, that takings of property for economic development will disproportionately affect neighborhoods with high concentrations of racial and ethnic minorities and the elderly; and third, that the economic impact of eminent domain on these groups is greater, even different in kind, from its impact on other groups, in part because of the difficulty of these groups in finding adequate replacement housing.

The brief provides extensive documentation for each of these points. According to one report, “between 1949 and 1963, sixty-three percent of all the families displaced by urban renewal were non-white.” In 2004 another scholar estimated that 1,600 African-American neighborhoods had been destroyed by the use of eminent domain to build highways and housing projects.

These concerns are particularly relevant here in Bowling Green, where the city wiped out one African American neighborhood, Jonesville, for the sake of a new WKU football stadium; reduced another black neighborhood, Shake Rag, to half its former size in order to build The Medical Center; and now threatens all but a few blocks of the remainder in the name of downtown redevelopment. The effect of each of these actions has been to reduce the number of affordable housing units in Bowling Green.

The city commission may have left the door open to the broader use of eminent domain in downtown development by the phrase they included in the first reading of the ordinance, “public works.” Surely the redevelopment of a “blighted area” qualifies as a “public work.” Under Kentucky law, eminent domain may be used to clear and redevelop blighted areas. Economic development as a means of removing blight distinguishes our situation from that addressed by the Supreme Court where economic development as an end was the issue.

Therefore, while I personally favor the broader use of eminent domain in downtown redevelopment because I think it is good for the citizens of Bowling Green as a whole, my support comes with a big if – if, and only if, the interests of the present residents of the Downtown Redevelopment District are most strongly protected.

Our religious and political traditions have always affirmed, even favored, the rights of our minorities. Now, and especially in light of our past history, our city commission has the opportunity to go the extra mile in respecting the property rights and interests of minorities and the elderly when they conflict with the city’s public interest.

The city can do this in two ways. First and most immediately, the city should exercise its eminent domain powers only in the most judicious, limited and generous manner.

Second and in the long term, the city should make a major commitment to increase the supply of affordable housing in Bowling Green. Mayor Elaine Walker’s recent efforts to facilitate the purchase of affordable housing are most commendable.

But the more basic problem is the supply of affordable housing. People cannot purchase housing units that do not exist. By the city’s own estimate, we are some 4,000 units short in meeting the demand for affordable housing. The result is that poorer families among us pay 40 percent and 50 percent of their household budgets for housing that it is frequently, at best, marginally livable. Minority, ethnic and elderly households are overrepresented in this group.

I have addressed this issue publicly and proposed solutions for it. I will not repeat that discussion here. Those who are interested will find it in the “Public Presentations” section of the Community Research Service home page at:
www.wku.edu/~alan.anderson/CRS/



Bowling Green Daily News: www.bgdailynews.com

Dr. Alan Anderson is professor and former head of the Department of Philosophy and Religion at Western Kentucky University. A participant in the civil rights movement, he worked with Dr. King in Albany, Ga., and Chicago and is coauthor of the prize-winning “Confronting the Color Line: The Broken Promise of the Civil Rights Movement in Chicago.” The Community Research Service publishes his students’ papers on social ethical issues in the metropolitan development of Bowling Green and Warren County.

Eminent domain rarely used but necessary: South Bend (IN) Tribune, 7/10/05

Point of View

By Matthew C Greller

The recent U.S. Supreme Court decision, Kelo v. City of New London, is good for the residents of Indiana and reaffirms their local elected officials' ability to bring jobs and a vibrant economy to cities and towns.

Eminent domain is a rarely-used government ability provided by the United States Constitution that lets a city or town acquire property with just compensation and relocation expenses provided to property owners. It may be used only for the public good, with stringent review and public input, and in Indiana, the condition of blight must first be found. While government leaders use it only as a last resort, eminent domain has helped leaders elected to serve all members of their community build roads, lay sewer lines and create economic development.

It is important to understand that this decision does not provide "new" or "unprecedented" powers to government. It simply reaffirms that creating jobs and a strong economy is one of the many responsibilities of government, and that eminent domain may be used to provide a strong economy.

Eminent domain gave leaders in Mishawaka, for example, a chance to revitalize the economy, steer their community in a positive direction, and improve the quality of life for residents when they provided a location for the AM General plant.

Imagine that you live in a community that had recently experienced the closure of a major business resulting in the loss of jobs. Imagine that your community is in economic distress, with double-digit unemployment. Now, imagine the opportunity to remedy that distress.

The principle of eminent domain is designed to achieve the greater community good. Without eminent domain, a small group of people could stand in the way of, or demand unreasonable compensation to permit, a project that could lift a neighborhood or an entire community out of economic distress. This is particularly important for communities that need to increase jobs or strengthen property tax bases, where a single project — a factory, a retail and housing center, a business complex — could make the difference between economic recovery or austerity.

Eminent domain usually is not necessary. In the Supreme Court Kelo decision, for example, just 1.5 out of the 90 acres needed for a project was in question. Every other property owner saw the public benefit of the city's project and why the land was needed and agreed to sell.

Displacing residents from their homes is serious business and used only as a last resort by the people elected to lead a community. Cities and towns must have a well-conceived plan for exercise of eminent domain — it cannot be administered in an unjust or haphazard fashion.

Locally, the Indiana Association of Cities and Towns is working with state lawmakers to establish legislation that would protect residents and continue government's ability to work for the public good.

Those who assert that public officials will be newly emboldened by this Supreme Court decision to indiscriminately "seize" property for the economic gain of private interests have a fundamental misunderstanding of local government, and of the intent of local elected officials.

Responsible cities and towns historically have, and will continue to judiciously balance the rights of private property owners with the economic interests of the entire community. To deny local governments the tool of eminent domain is to deny residents the opportunities to survive and flourish, to deny jobs for residents of economically depressed cities and towns, and to deny quality of life to everyone in Indiana.


South Bend Tribune: www.southbendtribune.com

Matthew C. Greller is the executive director of the Indiana Association of Cities and Towns

Odell Named to Eminent Domain Task Force: (claremont NH) Eagle Times, 7/10/05

[New Hampshire] Senate President Tom Eaton, R-Keene, has ordered a committee to study how New Hampshire can strengthen its laws protecting the rights of property owners.

Eaton's request is in response to the U.S. Supreme Court decision that municipalities can use eminent domain proceedings to seize privately owned land for other members of the private sector. The federal ruling is an effort to spur economic development, however, Eaton said in a written statement the implications for landowners are staggering.

"There are legitimate reasons why the government needs to take private property for a public project, such as road widening or flood control," Eaton said in a July 8 announcement. "However, the government should never be allowed to take someone's private property just because it thinks the property could be put to better use by someone else."

District 8 Sen. Bob Odell, R-Lempster, was named to the Senate committee and is charged with developing legislation that could be presented during the next session. Odell said Saturday he expects to begin meeting with the other appointees over the summer.

"Any time you take private property and convey it to another private property owner, it raises some real questions about the rules of the game," Odell said.

In very limited instances Odell said he could see a reason for such a taking, but there would need to be a level of "tremendous importance to the community." Odell predicted the bi-partisan committee will review New Hampshire Supreme Court decisions on eminent domain proceedings, current law and the laws of other states for guidance in its recommendations. Members of the Senate Task Force on Eminent Domain include members of the Senate Energy and Economic Development Committee and the Senate Judiciary Committee.


Eagle Times: www.eagle-times.com

Two Westchester legislators try to limit use of eminent domain: The (Westchester County NY) Journal News, 7/10/05

By Phil Reisman

Have you ever wondered how Westchester's elected officials really feel about the prospect of your business, home or house of worship one day being bulldozed for corporate profit?

You may soon get a chance to find out, and here's how.

A bill designed to keep the county from contributing taxpayers' money to any development project in which eminent domain is used to condemn private property for the benefit of big-business interests is about to be introduced to the Board of Legislators.

The legislation also would prevent the county from exercising its power to seize property except for public works such as roads, bridges or sewage treatment plants.

Co-sponsored by Jim Maisano, R-New Rochelle, and Tom Abinanti, D-Greenburgh, the bill currently exists in rough draft, but Maisano told me he plans to present it at the next board meeting and get it passed this year.

At first blush, this news may not seem significant — unless you happen to live on a block that's targeted for the construction of, say, a hotel, big-box store and supermarket, and the takeover is coming with the full cooperation of your duly elected mayor and council.

But there is a moral as well as legal issue at stake here that transcends immediate threats to any particular neighborhood. That's why the Maisano-Abinanti bill is important. It raises the bar of principle and, as such, presents a test.

It will be interesting to see how many legislators vote for it and whether County Executive Andrew Spano will sign it into law.

"But I'm going to force it," Maisano said. "I'm going to force the issue. I'm going to try to push it."

I've said it before and I will repeat it now: Eminent domain is nothing less than government-sponsored theft when it means seizing the property of ordinary citizens and transferring it to the Donald Trumps of the world. And yet over and over again towns and cities increasingly contend that the "public use" justification of eminent domain outlined under the Fifth Amendment is broad enough to include the supposed benefits to the public (i.e., jobs and taxes) that come with private development.

Whereas in the past, you may have given up your home for a children's hospital, now you may sacrifice it at the altar of a Stop & Shop.

The shameful erasure of much of Port Chester's limited waterfront and the aborted threat to a New Rochelle neighborhood posed by the IKEA furniture chain a few years ago are locally familiar examples of eminent domain abuse that I've railed against in the past.

It's an uphill battle, as evidenced by the U.S. Supreme Court's recent 5-4 vote upholding a plan to demolish waterfront homes in New London, Conn. — some of them owned by families for generations — and replace them with a giant hotel complex.

That was bad news, but it came with a silver lining. The court's decision woke people up.

According to Dana Berliner, senior attorney for the Institute for Justice, a Washington, D.C.-based organization that represented the plaintiffs in the New London case, citizens across the country are outraged and are mobilizing to get their elected officials to change local laws and charters to better protect the rights of property owners.

"I have been overwhelmed by the popular response," she said. "We knew that when the decision came out, because it was so broad, that there was going to be a backlash. There had to be. I mean, the opinion practically said, 'Your home is up for grabs.' So we knew there would be a backlash."

Still, Berliner was surprised by the number of calls, e-mails and letters from legislators as well as from ordinary people of all ages and backgrounds who've never before been politically involved.

"It's completely inspired us to put forth a new effort to change things," she said.

Maisano said he has long been philosophically opposed to eminent domain for private use, but felt his hands were tied in coming up with the proposed legislation until the Supreme Court ruled.

"If the Supreme Court had said it was unconstitutional, that would've totally changed the issue, but they didn't do that," Maisano explained. "So I tried to think of something that was clearly doable without getting into a legal battle with people."

His bill has limits, which Maisano readily admits.

It's hard to imagine a scenario, for instance, in which the county would be in a position to condemn private property for a private developer.

Development proposals are usually initiated on the local level, and the bill doesn't prevent towns from using eminent domain in its most malignant form.

However, the bill's provision to block county funds in such cases is not insignificant. Look no further than the aforementioned Port Chester redevelopment scheme, a court-backed "shock and awe" nightmare of eminent domain in which the county agreed to pay G&S investors about $10 million over 20 years to help build a waterfront promenade.

That kind of outlay won't happen again, if the Maisano-Abinanti bill is passed.

And that depends on you.


The Journal News: www.thejournalnews.com

Flip-flopping In The Muck Of Eminent Domain: The (New London CT) Day, 7/10/05

Opinion

By Steven Slosberg

Eminent domain, political quicksand that it is, has been a gold mine of partisan opportunism, nevertheless.

Last week, state Democrats jumped all over apparent doubletalk on the subject from Congressman Rob Simmons, the district's three-term Republican.

The ammunition for the Democrats was a Simmons' quote from the “Osgood File,” a program aired, at various times during the day, on WCBS 880 AM radio on June 24. That was one day after the U.S. Supreme Court handed down its convulsive 5-4 decision in favor of the City of New London in the lawsuit brought against the city and New London Development Corp. by Susette Kelo and other property owners at Fort Trumbull.

Charles Osgood, doing the reporting and commentating, questioned Scott Sawyer, one of the local lawyers representing the homeowners, and Simmons about what Osgood called a “close but groundbreaking decision for developers” and “a heartbreaking one of the owners of 15 homes in New London.”

The transcript of the show, provided online by CBS, includes this:

Osgood: “Congressman Rob Simmons of Connecticut says it's for the greater good.”

Simmons: “It's gonna be painful for a half-dozen to a dozen people, but we stand to create jobs in that area, literally hundreds of jobs. I think our cities in Connecticut are gonna die if we can't engage in some urban development to generate economic benefits for the citizens of the community.”

The state Democrats, through Leslie O'Brien, executive director of the party organization, then descended on a quote from Simmons' chief of staff, Todd Mitchell, in a story published a week later, on July 2, in The Day:

“Congressman Simmons opposes the use of eminent domain strictly for economic development purposes. Instead, eminent domain should be used in only the most unique circumstances and be limited to a larger public interest.”

Mitchell also said Simmons was confident a national Coast Guard museum still would be developed at Fort Trumbull.

The federal legislation behind establishment of the museum stipulates that no federal funds be expended on planning, construction or maintenance of the museum. A private foundation has been set up to raise money.

However, the location of such a museum, be it in New London or New York or elsewhere, has yet to be determined. A federal law enacted in 2003 merely gives the Coast Guard commandant the authority to establish a museum at or near the Coast Guard Academy. There is no directive to build it in New London.

Responding to the Democrats' accusing Simmons of flip-flopping on eminent domain, Mitchell said: “Rob has never said we have to throw those people out of their homes because it's for the greater good.”

The chief of staff also argued that Simmons' concern for those affected by eminent domain was evidenced in the drafting of that 2003 legislation for establishment of the museum in New London. Simmons introduced the original bill for the museum here, but other members of Congress pushed for the oversight language prohibiting the use of land taken by eminent domain for the museum.

“Simmons made sure the bill addressed the issue of eminent domain,” said Mitchell. “The concerns came from the minority party. Simmons could have easily pushed the original bill through without directly addressing eminent domain. Instead, he worked in a bipartisan manner to craft language agreeable to Democrats' concerns.”

The nuancing does get a bit precious. However eminent domain plays out, ultimately, in New London, it has landed at least one politician, as well as the still-unspecified site of a Coast Guard museum, on a rather slippery slope.


The Day: www.theday.com

Eminent domain bill would protect property: Montgomery (AL) Advertiser, 7/10/05

Alabama Voices

By Jack Venable

To own property is a fundamental American right. Whether it's a home or business, farm or office building, the ability to improve and sell property is the basis of our economy and country, enshrined in our Constitution's Fifth Amendment. In that same amendment there one exception to ownership: eminent domain.

Used properly, eminent domain — taking property for public use — makes sense. If an interstate highway needs to be built, houses and farms often need to be purchased by the government for the right of way. Whether an owner wants to sell or not is outweighed by the public need, and as long as people get fair market value for their homes and land, the greater good is served. Most Americans understand and support this process.

There is a trend in communities across the country for local governments to use eminent domain not for public use, but to aid private economic development projects. Using eminent domain for private concerns is not without precedent in Alabama; condemning land for major projects like railroads and dams has been instrumental in our state's economic development.

Yet now in the name of revitalization and increasing the tax base, governments across the country are using eminent domain to help developers and businesses for things like malls, factories and office parks. Rather than let the market decide the value and control of property and respecting the rights of citizens, local governments now are deciding who should own what on an increasing basis.

In a recent 5-4 ruling, the U.S. Supreme Court upheld this expanded version of eminent domain. Ruling in a Connecticut case where the city of New London took a neighborhood of family homes for a private developer, the court broadened the constitutional meaning of "public use" to mean a "public purpose."

"Promoting economic development is a traditional and long accepted function of government," Justice John Paul Stevens wrote in the ruling. "Clearly, there is no basis for exempting economic development from our traditionally broad understanding of public purpose."

The court ruling is wrong and sets a dangerous precedent for Alabama homeowners and farmers. Under the ruling, there is no stopping a local government from rewarding powerful businesses with tracts of land taken from less well-heeled working people. Under this ruling, if you are less wealthy you have less property rights, and that is not the American way.

In a dissent, retiring Justice Sandra Day O'Connor recognized the pitfalls of expanded eminent domain. "Under the banner of economic development, all private property is now vulnerable to being taken and transferred to another private owner, so long as it might be upgraded," wrote Justice O'Connor. "The specter of condemnation hangs over all property. Nothing is to prevent the state from replacing any Motel 6 with a Ritz-Carlton, any home with a shopping mall or any farm with a factory."

There is a remedy to the court's ruling. The justices put the responsibility of defining eminent domain squarely on the shoulders of the states. I introduced legislation in the 2005 regular session to define what is acceptable for eminent domain and clarify procedures for local governments. The bill made it harder for government to forcibly transfer property from one private owner to another, specifically prohibiting a local government from taking someone's property for a retail development.

The eminent domain bill was a priority of the House Democratic Caucus and passed the House on a 90-1 vote, but the bill got held up in the Senate. I have received encouragement from Gov. Riley and other members of the Legislature to reintroduce the bill; with broad bipartisan support it could come up in the upcoming special session.

Whenever we can get the stronger eminent domain bill before the Legislature, I believe the court's ruling will provide added incentive to get a version of the bill passed.

There is nothing wrong with local governments promoting economic development; it is their job. Yet local governments would be wise to use great restraint in using eminent domain to favor private enterprise. Understanding the difference between public and private use should give clear guidance on its proper use.


Montgomery Advertiser: www.montgomeryadvertiser.com

Jack Venable (D-Tallassee) represents District 31 in the Alabama House of Representatives

Eminent domain limits sought: San Diego (CA) Union-Tribune, 7/10/05

Plan would protect owners, Stocks says
By James Steinberg

The [Encinitas] City Council this week will consider one member's proposal to limit the city's power to take private property.

Councilman Jerome Stocks said he will ask the council Wednesday to direct its staff to draft an ordinance that would so severely restrict the city's use of eminent domain that it would be nearly impossible to use it.

Stocks raised the issue in the wake of a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision that expanded the right of government to condemn private property so a private developer could upgrade a "distressed" neighborhood to enlarge the municipal tax roll.

Eminent domain is the law by which government takes private property for public use, with just compensation for the owner. The Supreme Court expanded the law to allow condemnation to foster economic development.

The case involved 15 homeowners in New London, Conn., who challenged the condemnation of their homes to make way for office space, a hotel, new homes and a pedestrian walk along the Thames River.

In upholding a Connecticut State Supreme Court ruling against the plaintiffs, the U.S. high court's majority said that "public use" was more properly defined as "public purpose," which broadened the law.

"It used to be that taking property by eminent domain was for roads and schools and military bases," Stocks said Friday. "The court's decision expands that right, and we can design a mechanism by which that right cannot be exercised."

Stocks will recommend an ordinance requiring a "greater than two-thirds" public vote in a regularly scheduled election before private property can be condemned and given to another private party to develop.

"In my opinion, it will never happen. Voters will say, if we let them do this (to someone else), it can happen to me," the councilman said.

He said California homeowners are protected against sharp increases in property taxes in a hot real estate market by Proposition 13, which flattens the tax rolls and crimps government revenue, and that, in turn, could spur the condemnation of private property.

"Government doesn't get a pay raise unless a transaction occurs," when the new owner pays a higher property tax, Stocks said.

The only remedy, he said, is to make the eminent domain process "so onerous that it can never go forward."

Stocks said he has received e-mails and telephone calls since he proposed the ordinance two weeks ago, and all have backed his position.

Wednesday's council meeting begins at 6 p.m. in the council chambers at the Encinitas Civic Center, 505 S. Vulcan Ave.

Members of the public who wish to speak on this or any other issue should submit a speakers slip to the city clerk before the item is discussed.


Union-Tribune: www.signonsandiego.com

7/09/2005

Lawmakers oppose eminent domain : The (Syracuse NY) Post-Standard, 7/8/05

Resolutions aimed at limiting OCIDA's power may not be legal, legislative chair says

By Rick Moriarty

Onondaga County Legislator James DiBlasi and Salina Town Councilor Mark Nicotra said Thursday they will introduce resolutions opposing the use of eminent domain against private property needed for the proposed Destiny USA Research and Development Park.

DiBlasi and Nicotra, who are running for re-election this year, said their resolutions also would call for no use of eminent domain condemnation proceedings unless they were approved by an elected body. They said a government body whose members do not have to go before the voters in an election should not have such power.

Robert Congel, the research park's developer, has asked the Onondaga County Industrial Development Agency to use its eminent domain powers to acquire private property he says he needs for the 325-acre park at the southeast corner of Interstates 90 and 81 in Salina. The private land includes 29 businesses, most of which are at the southeast corner of I-81 and Seventh North Street.

The agency has taken no action on the request, with several members saying they opposed using eminent domain and others saying they were concerned that the 29 businesses would be driven out of business if their relocation costs were not completely paid by the developer.

The agency's directors are appointed by the county Legislature. But the agency gets its eminent domain powers and other authority from state law, and most of its actions including condemnations of private property under eminent domain do not require the approval of an elected body.

Nicotra said he will introduce the resolution Monday to the Salina Town Council. DiBlasi said he will introduce it to a legislative committee possibly the planning and economic development committee soon.

They said they were not opposed to the research park itself, just the taking of private property for a private development. Under state law, industrial development agencies can take private land for economic development projects, but must pay the owner the fair market value of the property. The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled that such takings are constitutional even if the land is turned over to a private developer.

"It's just an awful precedence for a private developer to take private property for their own gain," said Nicotra.

He said the resolutions would not be binding on the industrial development agency, but would put town and county elected representatives on the record "for or against" the use of eminent domain for the research park.

Nicotra represents Salina's 4th Ward, which includes the proposed site of the research park.

DiBlasi represents the county's 7th District, which does not include the park site, but does include land on Syracuse's North Side where Congel has talked about building a convention center.

Legislature Chairman Dale Sweetland questioned whether the resolution is necessary in light of the fact the research park project may be dead, at least in Salina.

A Destiny executive, David Aitken, said last week the company pulled all of its personnel off the research park's planning after the industrial development agency refused June 22 to approve an agreement that would have committed the agency to using its eminent domain powers. He would not say if the company would continue pursuing the site, look for another location for the park or drop the project.

Sweetland said there also may be a question about the resolution's legality since the industrial development agency gets its authority from state law. It might have to be framed as a request for the state Legislature to change the law, he said.

OCIDA has threatened to use its eminent domain power twice in the past - for an industrial park and for a waterfront redevelopment project, both in Clay. Both times, it wound up negotiating purchases of the land.


The Post-Standard: www.syracuse.com

Whose domain is eminent? The (Greenville MI) Daily News, 7/8/05

Guest Column

By Arthur M. Compton

If there is anything in our Constitution that with some justification is called a necessary evil, it can probably be found in the Fifth Amendment.

That amendment says, in effect, that governments — such as cities — may seize the property of private citizens as long as (1) the seized property is to be put to public use and (2) the owner shall receive "just compensation." That legal process is known as "eminent domain."

It seems to have been generally agreed, until now, that public use meant to create things like roads and bridges that would be used and owned by the general public.

The term "just compensation" can be argued endlessly without resolution and so probably has had a negative effect on public opinion, which is that the seller, under duress, has been "taken" along with his property.

My only observation of the process at work is the experience of a friend whose home was involved in a highway widening project some years ago in Grand Rapids. Eminent domain descended upon him and made him an offer. His home, an elderly piece of property, had been for sale for some time without success.

The city offer was the best he had so he quickly accepted. Ray feels that he won that transaction. Having seen his new modern home on Hake Street, I'm inclined to agree with him.

What has brought eminent domain to the front page today is the recent decision of the city of New London, Conn., to make, through the use of eminent domain, certain properties available to a development for a privately owned office complex. In time, this will provide an increase in tax revenue for the city.

The New London owners appealed to the Connecticut Supreme Court, contending that tax revenue did not constitute public use. The court disagreed. A later appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court agreed with the lower court.

I dislike the courts' decisions because it seems inappropriate that either private of corporate profit should play a part in eminent domain negotiations. Both courts have stretched the term "use" out of all semblance to that intended originally.

However, commenting on the amendment in its present form, the World Book Encyclopedia says, "In some cases, governments give the power of eminent domain to corporations that intend to use privately owned land for projects that benefit the public."

Possibly it was that precedent that influenced both courts in their New London decisions.


The Daily News: www.thedailynews.cc

Arthur M. Compton is a retired consulting engineer

Legislature steps into eminent-domain battles: In Business Las Vegas (NV), 7/8-15/05

By Alana Roberts

Although the U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled that government bodies can take away private property in the interest of economic development, the Nevada Legislature has made the process more difficult.

The Legislature passed two bills during the recent session that make it more difficult for governmental bodies to take private property. One revises Nevada law so that it requires governmental bodies to meet four out of nine criteria to condemn a piece of property before taking it. The other forces governmental bodies who take land for open space projects to pay the property owners not only for the property but also for "goodwill" costs such as lost business income.

Christina Dugan, director of government affairs for the Las Vegas Chamber of Commerce, said the two bills go a long way toward protecting the rights private property owners have.

"We're very supportive of the two bills passed this session strengthening the eminent domain regulations and the burden government has to meet to take your property," Dugan said. "We're very concerned about that (U.S. Supreme Court) ruling, but we feel some of the legislation passed will help Nevada to prevent what happened in Connecticut."

Dugan said although some companies, particularly larger or more profitable ones, do benefit from land takings, she said it's in every land owner's interest to have their rights protected.

"Allowing too much discretion makes it difficult for businesses to engage in long-term planning, no matter what their size," Dugan said. "At the end of the day, it's about protecting the fundamental rights all businesses have. When you start to erode property rights no one is immune from a taking."

However, James J. Leavitt, an eminent-domain lawyer at the Law Offices of Kermitt L. Waters, said the new Nevada legislation doesn't go far enough to protect property owners from unfair takings. He said the legislation that requires governmental bodies to meet more criteria to condemn private property for public use doesn't allow for the property owner to fight the government's decision in court unless there's a finding of bribery or fraud.

"In my opinion I think that statute is meaningless," Leavitt said. "The government can come forward and say they've met these four criteria and no one can challenge that unless there's a finding of bribery or fraud. That's just silly. What we need... is that the findings by governmental bodies are subject to judicial review."

Leavitt represented the Pappas family in its 11-year eminent-domain fight against the city of Las Vegas. He said his firm is working to start an initiative petition to change the Nevada Constitution to implement a property owners' bill of rights. He said his firm hopes to get the issue on the 2006 general election ballot.

"What that bill of rights would state is that private property could not be taken from one private land owner and given to another to increase the tax base," Leavitt said.

He said the firm doesn't oppose takings that will be used for "true" public use such as for a school or a roadway.

"The hot issue is redevelopment," Leavitt said. "Ninety-nine percent of the time the government takes private property to build a public road or a park. What becomes very disturbing is when they take private property and give it to another private entity."

Doug Kurdziel, an eminent-domain lawyer at Jones Vargas who has represented both land owners and governmental bodies, said the new U.S. Supreme Court ruling doesn't necessarily mean the end of the right to own property. He said the ruling strengthens the court decisions already made on the issue.

"The Constitution is still alive and well," Kurdziel said. "I think it reaffirms what the courts already said. They (property owners) still have the right to say, 'No, not today. This is wrong.' If they do that there's still going to be a judicial decision."


In Business Las Vegas: www.inbusinesslasvegas.com

The Tyranny Of Eminent Domain : (Marin County CA) Monthly Coastal Post, 7/05

The government should not be able to seize property from one
private party and transfer it to another.

By Larry Salzman and Alex Epstein

You do not own your property. That is the meaning of the Supreme Court's June 23 ruling in Kelo v. City of New London, which held that local governments may use the power of eminent domain to transfer private property from one private owner to another in pursuit of "the public interest."

This result ended the hope and the battle of seven property owners - the last remaining of more than 70 families whose homes and businesses were targeted for demolition five years ago by the city of New London, Connecticut, to make room for a 90-acre private development, including offices and a proposed hotel. Susette Kelo, a nurse, and one of the property owners, bought and painstakingly restored a home that initially was so run-down that she needed to cut her way to the front door with a hatchet. After she had achieved her dream home, she was informed by the local government that her home was condemned, and ordered to vacate within 90 days.

What justifies this treatment of Kelo and the other owners, who simply want to be free to live on their own property? The seizures and transfers, the government says, are in "the public interest" - because they will lead to more jobs for New London residents and more tax dollars for the government. A study cited by the dissenters showed that this type of justification was given more than 10,000 times between 1998 and 2002, across 41 states, to use eminent domain (or its threat) to seize private property. The attitude behind these seizures was epitomized by a Lancaster, California, city attorney explaining why a 99¢ Only store should be condemned to make way for a Costco: "99 Cents produces less than $40,000 [a year] in sales taxes, and Costco was producing more than $400,000. You tell me which was more important?"

To such government officials, the fact that an individual earns a piece of property and wants to use and enjoy it, is of no importance - that matters is "the public."

But as philosopher Ayn Rand observed, "there is no such entity as 'the public,' since the public is merely a number of individuals . . . . the idea that 'the public interest' supersedes private interests and rights can have but one meaning: that the interests and rights of some individuals take precedence over the interests and rights of others." In the context of the Kelo case, the idea that "the public interest" trumps private property rights simply means that the desires of some individuals for property they did not earn and cannot get from others voluntarily, trump the rights of those who did earn it and do not want to sell it. Why are their rights trumped? Because some gang with political pull doesn't happen to like how these individuals are using their property.

This is unjust and un-American. America was founded on the principle of individual rights, including the right to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness. What do these rights mean if an individual is not free to remain in and enjoy the house he chooses to build his life around, simply because others could use it to create more jobs or tax revenue? Just as it would be unjust for the government to shut down the printing presses of a newspaper because its reporting is unpopular, so it is unjust for the government to raze a house that an individual has earned, developed, and loves, no matter how many cry that the land should be put to other use.

The Supreme Court's decision against the property owners in Kelo is, in the words of Justice Clarence Thomas from his dissenting opinion, a "far-reaching, and dangerous result." As Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, another of the four dissenting justices, wrote: "all private property is now vulnerable to being taken and transferred to another private owner, so long as it might be upgraded - i.e., given to an owner who will use it in a way that the legislature deems more beneficial to the public - in the process." And as Dana Berliner, an attorney for the owners, argued, this means that no one's property or home is truly safe: "If jobs and taxes can be a justification for taking someone's home or business then no property in America is safe. Anyone's home can create more jobs if it is replaced by a business and any small business can generate greater taxes if replaced by a bigger one."

Property owners beware: the next casualty of "the public interest" might be you.


The Coastal Post: www.coastalpost.com

Larry Salzman is an attorney and Alex Epstein is a fellow at the Ayn Rand Institute in Irvine, Calif. The Institute promotes the ideas of Ayn Rand — best-selling author of Atlas Shrugged and The Fountainhead and originator of the philosophy of Objectivism.

Eminent domain decision surprises officials: Ambler (PA) Gazette, 7/8/05

By Linda Finarelli

The recent U.S. Supreme Court decision expanding a municipality's ability to seize private property for economic development has taken some public officials and land use experts by surprise.

While the power of eminent domain has long been used by government to take land for highways, parks and other public uses, and more recently blighted areas for redevelopment, the June 23 ruling appears to have expanded that power.

In a 4-3 decision, the high court ruled that New London, Conn., could seize a neighborhood through the use of eminent domain and permit a private developer to build a hotel and office space in its place that would generate much higher tax revenues.

"I was shocked by it," said state Rep. Kate Harper, R-61, a land use attorney and former Lower Gwynedd Township supervisor.

The ruling "seems to be an expansion of eminent domain," which goes back to the Magna Carta and is an essential part of the law, permitting government to seize a property for public uses with the property owner getting just compensation, Harper said.

"I've often counseled municipal clients to be careful that [their use of] eminent domain be viewed as a public purpose," she said, "not a substitute of one owner for another with a greater tax potential.

"I think eminent domain can be an important tool for government to use for public purposes, for parks and highways," Harper said. "I recognize [Lower Gwynedd] would not own Penllyn Park without eminent domain," she added, referring to the seven-year fight by Lower Gwynedd to obtain the parkland during Harper's tenure on the township board.

The concern is taking land not for a public purpose, Harper said, and whether the high court's ruling "is a signal that it's OK to replace non-blighted properties to get more tax revenue."

"Urban redevelopment and renewal is an important strategy in our growth," she said, but "we need to make sure areas [seized] on the basis of blight and redevelopment are really blighted."

"It's fundamentally un-American," state Rep. Josh Shapiro, D-153, said of the high court ruling. "This country was founded on the right to property, beliefs, speech. This decision seriously undermines the right to property."

The Connecticut statute talks about acquisition for economic development and redevelopment, but not all states do, noted land use attorney Marc Jonas with Eastburn and Gray in Blue Bell. In Pennsylvania, municipalities have the power to condemn land for public purposes and some redevelopment authorities have the power to seize land for redevelopment in blighted areas.

The Supreme Court's decision presents a possibility for abuse, he said. "In a blighted neighborhood [eminent domain] is a good tool," Jonas said. "In other areas, where you could gain more tax revenue [by seizing property], it could be abused."
Jonas said he has seen an increasing use of condemnation by municipalities "to effect redevelopment or for the common good.

"A number of towns are in sore need of a shot in the arm, but it's one thing to take land for a public purpose and a whole other to flip it into the hands of a private developer," Jonas said.

Pennsylvania courts would not have sanctioned taking non-blighted property and putting it in the hands of a private developer prior to the high court's ruling, he said. "Now it opens the door."

In his opinion, Jonas said, "the court went too far in not really including specific standards to prevent the potential for abuse."

The decision does say that states could weigh in with greater restraints, Jonas noted. To condemn land and put it in the hands of a private developer - "the Legislature could try to plug that hole. I see an opening for the states to rein in on that."

"I would support legislation at the state level to make it difficult, if not illegal, to take [private property] for economic development purposes," Shapiro said.
The decision seems to imply, that if Abington, for example, felt it was necessary to revitalize an area for tax purposes that it could take properties and build a shopping mall, Shapiro said. "I think that's fundamentally wrong.

"I would have a more narrow definition of public use - for roads and bridges and public parks," he said. "For economic development is a real slippery slope."
The ruling has caused "great consternation" in Harrisburg, Harper said July 1, noting a bill limiting eminent domain in the state had been introduced that day.
"My worry is that in the rush to restrict [eminent domain], we might throw out the baby with the bath water; it does have some valid and useful purposes," she said. "We should define the uses for which eminent domain can be put in Pennsylvania ... we need a tighter definition of blight."


Ambler Gazette: www.zwire.com

7/08/2005

Texas gov wants lawmakers to curb eminent domain: Reuters, 7/8/05

By Joan Gralla

Texas Gov. Rick Perry on Friday called on the legislature to curb the state's power to seize land through eminent domain, reacting swiftly to a recent Supreme Court decision that hurt property owners' rights.

The Texas governor called for "limiting the use of eminent domain to take private property for private parties or economic development purposes." He also urged the legislature to support amending the Texas constitution to shore up Texans' rights to own property.

"The Supreme Court's ruling would allow the government to condemn your family's home, bulldoze it and build a new shopping mall or some other kind of economic development project simply to generate more tax revenue," the Republican governor said in a statement.

Last month the governor, aiming to reform school funding, called the legislature back for a special session.

Even before the nation's top court ruled a city can take a home or business that stands in the way of a development project, two states enacted laws to restrict this use of eminent domain, according to Larry Morandi, a director with the Denver-based National Conference of State Legislatures.

Utah and Nevada this year approved the measures before the Supreme Court on June 23 decided that New London, Connecticut, could take 15 properties for a project that would complement a nearby research facility by the Pfizer Inc. drug company.

Only about 10 state legislatures are still in session and could consider ways to protect property owners this year, Morandi said. But he looks for a burst of new bills in January, when about 44 legislatures will return and have a chance to address the Supreme Court's controversial ruling.

The states likely will take one of two approaches: adopting outright bans on using eminent domain to restore blighted areas, or setting tougher standards for determining whether an area is so downtrodden the state should step in and restore it, Morandi said. The second strategy could also include enacting stiffer laws requiring a state to negotiate with property owners before taking their properties, he added.

Utah came close to banning the state from taking land for economic development, while Nevada adopted somewhat less strict curbs, Morandi said.


Reuters: www.today.reuters.com

7/06/2005

WR council ... blocks eminent domain: The (Macon GA) Daily Telegraph, 7/6/05

By Julie Hubbard

[The Warner Robins GA] city council passed a resolution against any form of eminent domain in Warner Robins.

"The City of Warner Robins shall not take private property for future use by another private developer for the sole purpose of economic development or redevelopment," council member Steve Smith read from the resolution that disagrees with the recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling giving city or state governments the power to seize property for redevelopment.

"This kind of thing is not for us," [Mayor Donald] Walker said.


Daily Telegraph: www.macon.com

Legislature may limit eminent domain powers: The Daily Texan (Univ of Texas at Austin), 7/6/05

By Marie Delahoussaye

Legislation that would limit government power to seize private property passed through a state House committee Tuesday at the Capitol.

State Rep. Frank Corte, R-San Antonio, proposed the constitutional amendment as a reaction to a U.S. Supreme Court ruling last month that authorized the taking of private land for private development.

Corte's amendment would prohibit use of eminent-domain seizures, if the primary purpose is economic development.

"The protection of private property dates back to the writing of the Magna Carta in 1215," Corte said. "I intend to take up this call to arms."

Under current Texas law, a governmental entity, such as a city or state may use the power of eminent domain to seize private property for public use.

The University is currently considering using eminent domain to seize property now occupied by Player's hamburger restaurant in order to build a 1,000-car parking garage.

Player's co-owner Carlos Oliveira said he's determined not to sell Player's and doesn't think UT has the right to take it from him.

James Wilson, director of the Campus Real Estate Office, said he's no lawyer, but the parking garage would benefit the public good by improving a public university.

"If a parking garage is not part of the public purpose of running the University of Texas, I don't understand it," Wilson said.

In a press conference last week, Corte referenced the Player's controversy as a case in which eminent domain is being abused. At that point, however, he was unclear whether the language in his proposal would apply to public universities.

The version of his proposal the committee passed Tuesday solved the problem by clarifying that the state, and therefore all public institutions of higher education, are included in the law. However, in order to benefit from the new legislation, Player's would still have to show that the primary purpose of the University's project is "economic development."

Corte's proposal raised questions in committee over how to determine the primary purpose of a project and what constitutes public use.

In the recent decision, the Supreme Court gave explicit authority to the states to define public use but ruled that it can include economic development.

"We may need to go the route of defining public purpose," said Rep. Robert Cook, D-Eagle Lake. Cook said the law needs to be specific to prevent governments from invoking key phrases to justify anything as a public purpose.

While many members agreed the issue would likely require further consideration, they agreed to pass the proposal without delay in hopes that it will be addressed by the whole Legislature during the special session ending later this month.

Gov. Rick Perry said that until public school finance reform is solved, he will not expand the call of the special session to address other issues.

If passed, Corte's constitutional amendment will be up for voter referendum in November.


The Daily Texan: www.dailytexanonline.com

Protesters Target Eminent Domain: (New London CT) Day, 7/6/05

Scores rally against ‘injustice' of events in New London case

By Kate Moran

It might be the law, they said, but that doesn't mean it's right.

Scores of protesters packed the sidewalk, the steps and the wide concrete railings leading up to City Hall on Tuesday evening with a message for the city councilors who were gathering upstairs for their biweekly meeting: they can still discard their plans to remove seven homeowners from the Fort Trumbull neighborhood to make way for a commercial development.

Dissent, voiced in letters to the editor and phone calls to city leaders, had been building in the two weeks since the U.S. Supreme Court validated the city's plan to use eminent domain to promote economic growth, and it coalesced Tuesday when protesters from around New England gathered to say the decision, whatever its legal justification, simply does not sit right with the average person.

“I came because of the injustice of it all,” said Flo Stahl, a resident of Avon. “It's so clear that it's unfair. If it can happen in New London, it can happen anywhere.”

Opponents of eminent domain found a sympathetic ear in state House Minority Leader Robert Ward, the North Branford Republican who plans to introduce legislation during a special session that would forbid governments from seizing property to foster private development. In a speech during the rally, he said the state should adopt a moratorium on all takings until the state can consider the legislation.

Ward said his efforts to curb the eminent domain power had gathered momentum since the public began agitating against the Supreme Court decision. He had gathered signatures from two-dozen legislators who supported the bill, including those of Democrats, such as Steven Mikutel of Griswold, who also spoke at the rally.

Gov. M. Jodi Rell, whose predecessor, John G. Rowland, was instrumental in the Fort Trumbull redevelopment, issued a statement Tuesday in support of a special legislative session in which lawmakers could address public concerns about eminent domain.

“Gov. Rell strongly believes that the rights of homeowners should not be trampled upon in favor of the advancement of economic development interests,” said a spokesman, Adam Liegeot.

Scott Bullock, an attorney for the Institute for Justice, the law firm that represented the Fort Trumbull homeowners, hailed state lawmakers for their bipartisan efforts to curb the reach of government power, a response he said was refreshing during this era of political divisiveness.

The “amazing thing” about the Supreme Court decision, said Bullock, is that it has “met with universal condemnation and outrage from across the nation and across the political spectrum.”

Yet at least one Republican group was trying to leverage the eminent domain issue to tarnish the other party. Common Sense CT, a conservative lobbying group, will begin airing a radio spot today portraying Democrats as in favor of “big business and big government” and against the interests of “people like you and me.”

Such partisanship was not on display at the protest, where participants from as far as Kentucky waved posters, sang folk songs and chanted and clapped in support of the property owners. Police, who corralled protesters behind barricades so they would not block street traffic, estimated their numbers to be several hundred.

They wore tricorner hats and invoked the language of the Constitution to portray the rights of individuals as sacred and superior to the rights of government, which some called tyrannical and out of touch with common people. They also appealed to logic and good sense: the government, they said, did not need the 15 houses at Fort Trumbull when they had nearly 90 other empty acres where developers could build.

“Kelo v. New London never argued against development in the Fort Trumbull area. What we found difficult to understand was why we couldn't be a part of it,” said Susette Kelo, the plaintiff who gave her name to the case. “And this has never been about money, as some people would have you believe. There is no amount of money that could replace our homes and our memories. This is where we chose to settle, and this is where we want to stay. This is America, the home of the free, isn't it?”

After the rally, many of the protesters filed into the council chambers, where they continued to plead with city leaders to remove the threat of eminent domain. None of the council members responded to the criticism except for Deputy Mayor Bill Morse, who clarified a minor point made by one of the protesters.

In an e-mail message Tuesday, the chief operating officer of the New London Development Corp. said the city had adhered closely to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights when it invoked eminent domain to promote economic development.

“What has happened in this particular instance is that the highest court in the land has said that the interpretation of these documents that has existed for many, many years is still valid,” David Goebel wrote. “Nothing the city or NLDC did in carrying out their responsibilities deviated from the rights imposed on citizens. We are a land of laws — laws that must be observed.”


The Day: www.theday.com

Eminent domain cheats owners: Indiana Statesman (Indiana State Univ), 7/6/05

Opinion

By Chuck McDonald

On June 23 the Supreme Court ruled in a 5-4 decision that cities and states may take private homes, businesses and land for its owners and give it to other private companies that could provide the city or state with more tax revenue but the purported tax revenue does not always come to pass often times because big business are given breaks to bring their company to different areas.

The ruling stemmed from a New London, Connecticut case in which city officials want to take home owners' land by using eminent domain to apply to "economic development" because it will increase tax revenue by allowing a 270 million Pfizer research center. The government generally uses the law to condemn slums as well as build highways, parks and other public use facilities. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor wrote in a dissenting opinion, "The court today significantly expands the meaning of public use. It holds that the sovereign may take private property currently put to ordinary private use, and give it over for new, ordinary private use." Justice O'Connor is correct.

The new program's proponents of the new development say the government will use it carefully and not abuse the power. The government can not be trusted. The government is an entity that continually takes more power little by little or in this case large chunks at a time and invades our lives. Once the government usurps power from the people it is never returned. This use of eminent domain sounds like a communist line of thought in that the government distributes resources.

One critic of the new policy, Logan Darrow Clements, suggested to town officials in New Hampshire that Justice David Souter's home be taken to create a hotel to increase tax revenue. Justice Souter joined in the majority of the Supreme Courts decision in favor of the new use of eminent domain.

Congress is also working to prevent abuse by local governments by not allowing government funds to go to private companies that benefit from eminent domain use in a bill sponsored by Republican representative Scott Garrett from New Jersey.

If a private company wants to use land owned by individuals it should be willing to pay for it on its own and not use eminent domain. Property owners are required to be paid market value for their property when a government uses eminent domain. This is sensible when the land will be used for parks, highways, or schools but when a private company wants to use the property the value goes up because the owners know the suitors can pay more and should raise their price. That is part of being in a capitalist society which is the way it should be.

Property owners all over the U.S. should be outraged. Citizens should boycott businesses that take over people's personal property because they want cheap land and the local government wants more tax revenue. As officials get the smell of more money in their noses it is likely to spread to all areas in the U.S.

Congress needs to do more by defining a set of rules to reign in rogue towns that wish to pull private property from owners for other private interests. Ideally states would govern the local eminent domain but since the Supreme Court ruled on the issue Congress will have to create the rules. Property owner's should write their representatives and demand the stop of the eminent theft of their land.


Indiana Statesman: www.indianastatesman.com

Eminent Domain vs Economic Development: KFVS-12 (Cape Girardeau MO), 7/6/05

By Ryan Tate

The United States Supreme Court ruling in the Kelo vs. City of New London case has Heartland politicians wanting to take action.

"I think everybody should be concerned about the Supreme Court's Ruling," Missouri Governor Matt Blunt said.

Last month's ruling gave cities and municipalities the opportunity to take land from private citizens under the Constitution's Fifth Amendment. In the past, leaders could take land under "eminent domain," for the betterment of the community. The court's ruling broadens that scope, stating the land can be taken for "economic opportunity" as well.

"We need to do something in Missouri to protect that most important right of an American, and that is to own a home," Sen. Jason Crowell said. Crowell represents the 29th District in the Missouri Senate.

"We're not going to do it on a whim for a restaurant or hotel, it will have to be a major project for us to consider it," McCracken County Judge Executive Danny Orazine said.

"The folks of Southern Illinois should be ticked off. They need to look at judge candidates who support private property rights," Representative John Shimkus of Illinois said.

Blunt says he developed a task force to review federal and state eminent domain laws to come up with criteria that state and local governments meet before they shift property from private to public use.


KFVS-12: www.kfvs12.com

Eminent domain gets public hearings: Wisconsin Radio Network, 7/5/05

By Jackie Johnson

Eminent domain will soon get even more attention in our state. With so many questions, fears and confusion, Wisconsin Attorney General Peg Lautenschlager has decided to have four public hearings in the state to discuss eminent domain and how homeowners would be affected. Lautenschlager says she's concerned about the definition of the US Supreme Court interpretation of what could be an appropriate public taking. "If not more narrowly defined, [it] really leaves open the door for public corruption because high bidders could, by political favor, attempt to get from government properties which they desire."

Lautenschlager says she wants to have town hall type meetings, with people representing all sides of the issue. "You know many public takings do indeed enhance the public good. But it also, as I said, opens the door for political corruption. It certainly does impede on individual property rights. So I think all of these things need to be discussed and bring people into their government in terms of having their ideas and thoughts be known."

Last week's Supreme Court decision leaves considerable discretion up to the states in terms of defining public purpose on eminent domain laws. Lautenschlager says it pretty much leaves the door wide open for the states to do what they want. State law needs to be clarified one way or another, whether by constitutional amendment or clarifying state statutes. Lautenschlager says she'll consult with attorneys general in other states on the matter. She says she wants to avoid lawsuits based on ill-defined public purposes. No time or dates have been set for the meetings that will be held in Eau Claire, Janesville, Milwaukee and Wausau.


Wisconsin Radio Network: www.wrn.com

House Votes on Eminent Domain: Black Hills (SD) Portal, 7/6/05

Stripping Home Owners of Property Rights Will not be Federally Funded in Spite of Supreme Court Ruling

By Family Research Council

Recently, the House voted to use the spending power of Congress to reign in a Supreme Court ruling in Kelo v. City of New London which strips the property rights of private citizens by granting the government power to seize private homes and transfer it to a private developer.

The House measure, which passed 231-189, denies federal money to any city or state project that used eminent domain to force people to sell their property to make way for more profitable private projects.

"The threat to freedom from the Kelo decision is very real. If a hostile government decides a shopping mall would produce a more profitable tax base than your family home or the family business then the government could grab that land for use by a private developer," says Tony Perkins, President of Family Research Council.

"This instance is exactly why the President needs to promote judges to the Supreme Court who are for a fair judiciary. Allowing private interests to seize homes, non-profit organizations and other businesses is a distinct abuse of power and while, it might be economically beneficial to a specific community, this opportunity for private developers could spell disaster for families and local entrepreneurs."


Black Hills Portal: www.blackhillsportal.com

Your Land Is My Land: The New York (NY) Times, 7/5//05

Op-Ed

By John Tierney

Two questions I'd like to ask candidates for Sandra Day O'Connor's job:
  1. Does the Constitution forbid the government from seizing your home and giving it to someone else?
  2. If you're not sure, would you be willing to tour Pittsburgh before taking this job?

Justice O'Connor had no problem with the first question. Noting that the Fifth Amendment allows property to be taken only for a "public use" like a road, she rejected arguments that it could be given to a developer just because the public could benefit from new jobs and tax revenues. By that logic, she argued in one of her last opinions, no one's home or business would be safe from anyone with a better use in mind for it.

But her side was outvoted, 5 to 4, by justices not inclined to be too literal about the Bill of Rights. They were pragmatists, arguing that land grabs like this had previously been allowed, which is quite right. And that's why I recommend a trip to my hometown to see the long-term effects.

Pittsburgh has been the great pioneer in eminent domain ever since its leaders razed 80 buildings in the 1950's near the riverfront park downtown. They replaced a bustling business district with Gateway Center, an array of bland corporate towers surrounded by the sort of empty plazas that are now considered hopelessly retrograde by urban planners trying to create street life.

At the time, though, the towers and plazas seemed wonderfully modern. Viewed from across the river, the new skyline was a panoramic advertisement for the Pittsburgh Renaissance, which became a national model and inspired Pittsburgh's leaders to go on finding better uses for private land, especially land occupied by blacks.

Bulldozers razed the Lower Hill District, the black neighborhood next to downtown that was famous for its jazz scene (and now famous mostly as a memory in August Wilson's plays). The city built a domed arena that was supposed to be part of a cultural "acropolis," but the rest of the project died. Today, having belatedly realized that downtown would benefit from people living nearby, the city is trying to entice them back to the Hill by building homes there.

In the 1960's, the bulldozers moved into East Liberty, until then the busiest shopping district outside downtown. Some of the leading businessmen there wanted to upgrade the neighborhood, so hundreds of small businesses and thousands of people were moved to make room for upscale apartment buildings, parking lots, housing projects, roads and a pedestrian mall.

I was working there in a drugstore whose owners cursed the project, and at first I thought they were just behind the times. But their worst fears were confirmed. The shopping district was destroyed. The drugstore closed, along with the department stores, movie theaters, office buildings and most other businesses.

You'd think a fiasco like that would have humbled Pittsburgh's planners, but they just went on. They kicked out a small company to give H. J. Heinz more room. Mayor Tom Murphy has attracted national attention for his grand designs - and fights - to replace thriving small businesses downtown and on the North Side with more upscale tenants.

The city managed to clear out shops and an office building to make room for a new Lazarus department store, built with $50 million in public funds, but Lazarus did not live up to its name. It has shut down and left a vacant building. Meanwhile, the city's finances are in ruins, and businesses and residents have been fleeing the high taxes required to pay off decades of urban renewal projects and corporate subsidies.

Yet the mayor still yearns for more acquisitions. He welcomed the Supreme Court decision, telling The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette that eminent domain "is a great equalizer when you're having a conversation with people." Well, that's one way to describe the power to take people's property.

But I think a future Supreme Court justice would have a different view of eminent domain after touring Pittsburgh's neighborhoods, especially those that escaped urban renewal: the old-fashioned business districts with crowded sidewalks and the newly gentrified neighborhoods with renovated homes and converted warehouses. The future justice would quickly see what sets the success stories apart from Gateway Center and East Liberty. No politicians ever seized those homes and businesses for a "better use."

For Further Reading



New York Times: www.nytimes.com

John Tierney: tierney@nytimes.com

Local Florida Agency Sues to Acquire Properties Through Eminent Domain: South Florida Sun-Sentinel, 7/5/05

By Mireidy Fernandez

A Delray Beach, Fla., agency has filed a lawsuit against three Carver Square property owners who have turned down offers to sell their vacant land so the city can build affordable housing in the area.

The eminent domain action, filed Wednesday in Palm Beach County Circuit Court, claims the Community Redevelopment Agency must acquire the seven lots for a redevelopment project.

The CRA has offered to pay owners $33,000 per lot, based on the land's appraised value. None of the owners accepted.

"We've been unable to reach an agreement because they want more money," said Bill Doney, the CRA attorney. "If we can't work it out, we'll try to get a judge to rule that the CRA can get the property."

But the attorney for Harry and Kathleen Webb, who own four of the lots, said his clients don't want to sell. They would like to build houses instead, said Kerry Schwencke, the couple's attorney.

"We have an expert witness that tells us the lots are worth more," he said, noting negotiations continue. The other two lot owners couldn't be reached for comment Thursday, despite attempts by phone.

The vacant land in question is part of a two-block area in the Carver Square neighborhood where the soil is contaminated. For years the site was used as an illegal landfill, upon which homes were built later. The properties are south of West Atlantic Avenue, in the vicinity of the 700 blocks of Southwest Second Terrace and Southwest Second Court, and Southwest Third Street.

Part of the affordable housing initiative includes buying 12 deteriorating homes in Carver Square. The CRA has been negotiating deals for those homes. Out of a total eight vacant lots, the city owns one.

The CRA's legal battle to get the properties came days after the U.S. Supreme Court ruling that extends the rights of governments to seize private property, or use eminent domain, for public use to increase an area's tax base or create jobs. But Doney said there's no connection between that high court's ruling and what the CRA is trying to do.

"It's more of a coincidence," Doney said. "The U.S. Supreme Court's decision deals with economic development as opposed to redevelopment. In Delray, this is more of a blighted area where there are problems with the soil."

In fact, the CRA estimates it will spend about $400,000 to excavate and clean up the contaminated soil, dispose of the debris and replace it with fill. In addition, it would cost the agency $50,000-$60,000 to demolish the 12 homes.

CRA officials have maintained all along the goal is to bring affordable or workforce housing to the city, where land values are increasingly high and fewer people who work here can live here. The median price of a home in Palm Beach County is $390,000, said Joe Gray, CRA assistant director.

"We need to have all the property so we can have an affordable housing project there," said Diane Colonna, CRA executive director.

And the need for affordable housing is immense, said Lamar Shuler, a lifelong city resident who serves on the CRA board.

"We just want to get people into homes and into nice developments and make them feel good ... to get them out of the mentality that they have to live in a slum," he said.

Aside from revamping certain pockets or neighborhoods in the city, the CRA has worked on a plan to restore West Atlantic Avenue, where minorities have historically settled. As redevelopment continues west, people will be displaced, Shuler said, so the CRA is looking to alleviate some of the housing crunch when that happens.

"We want to try to have something in the works so that those that will be displaced will have a place to go," Shuler said.


South Florida Sun-Sentinel: www.sun-sentinel.com

Eminent domain ruling not seen as having impact locally, for now : Jacksonville (NC) Daily News, 7/5/05

By Bernhardt Dotson

While there should be no immediate impact from a recent U.S. Supreme Court decision regarding local governments and property rights, that doesn't mean it will stay that way.

The High Court's decision regarding eminent domain, local governments and property rights won't be an issue until the General Assembly decides to make it one, according to legal experts like David Lawrence with the Institute of Government at the University of North Carolina.

Jacksonville city attorney John Carter agreed.

"The city operates under the jurisdiction of the state," Carter said.

"The matter wouldn't effect us in North Carolina, because the legislature hasn't given local authorities the OK to do anything."

But the ruling does open the door for legislators to possibly change the current state law.

The court ruled that New London, Conn., has the authority to condemn property - with payment or just compensation - in carrying out a development plan to revitalize its economy. The court said that the condemnation was for a public use, and not unconstitutional under the Fifth Amendment.

Current state law outlines nine conditions under which cities and counties can condemn private land, including those to create or expand roads, parks, sewer lines and government buildings. Private development isn't a part of the list.

"This decision is based on Connecticut law, which allows for use of eminent domain for economic development purposes," said S. Ellis Hankins, executive director of the North Carolina League of Municipalities. "North Carolina statutes do not authorize local governments to use eminent domain for general economic development purposes. Therefore, this decision will not change the authority (N.C.) municipalities and counties exercise in this area."

The case, Kelo v. New London, Conn., saw justices vote 5-4 that New London officials could condemn residents' houses and raze them to make way for a private office complex. New London officials argued that private development plans served a public purpose of heightening economic growth that outweighed homeowners' property rights.

The ruling comes amid Jacksonville's talks about a proposed $46 million civic center complex along Marine Boulevard. That proposal - $15 million of which would be the city's share - includes a conference center/hotel and an accompanying privately funded military museum. The proposal is mired in economic and political squabbles, drawing criticism on everything from location to taxpayers' funding of it.

The ruling did help protect some important interests for cities, Hankins said.

"If the Supreme Court had ruled against the city of New London, however, the decision might have raised constitutional concerns about condemnation by our local governments to improve blighted areas and build or expand airports and other public facilities related to economic development," said Hankins.

"We were pleased to see that the court majority decided that the Fifth Amendment leaves room for judicial deference to legislative decisions by local elected officials. It is ironic that the closing of the New London submarine base was proposed while this case was pending, further underscoring the need for reasonable government efforts to help create jobs."

Jacksonville City Councilman George Mainor said he values the rights of property owners. He doesn't foresee much local impact.

"I believe that property rights are important," he said. "From what I understand, I don't think the ruling effects local governments - not in North Carolina anyway."


Daily News: www.jdnews.com

Effort afoot to revisit eminent domain; protesters rally in New London: (NY NY) Newsday, 7/5/05

By Susan Haigh, Associated Press

The top Republican in the [Connecticut] state House of Representatives gathered support Tuesday for a bill that would ban eminent domain for economic development projects.

House Minority Leader Robert Ward, R-North Branford, collected about two dozen signatures from House members, including Republicans and some Democrats. All of them support voting on the legislation during a possible summer session planned in the coming weeks to consider bills vetoed by the governor.

Ward's staff said he needs 76 co-sponsors for the bill to be taken up. But Democratic legislative leaders said they are not certain that would guarantee a debate on the legislation. Some Senate Republicans have also said they want a special session.

Gov. M. Jodi Rell, a Republican, announced Tuesday that she supports Ward's efforts to have the General Assembly call itself back into session to deal with eminent domain. Rell has not said whether she would use her powers to call lawmakers back to the Capitol.

Ward's effort comes in the wake of last month's U.S. Supreme Court ruling that allows New London to seize 15 homes in its Fort Trumbull neighborhood to make way for a private riverfront economic development project. The 5-4 decision broadens the eminent domain power, granting local governments greater rights to seize private property to generate tax revenue.

But the court also ruled that states can restrict that power. At least eight states — Arkansas, Florida, Illinois, Kentucky, Maine, Montana, South Carolina and Washington — already forbid eminent domain for economic development unless it is to eliminate blight.

"We have an obligation as elected officials to protect the rights of property owners and we must act swiftly before more rights are trampled upon to accommodate some developer looking to make a profit," Ward said in a written statement.

Fort Trumbull residents and their supporters rallied Tuesday at New London's city hall to call attention to their case.

About 300 protesters, from as far away as Kentucky, Maryland and New Jersey, gathered in advance of a City Council meeting at which residents asked that the decision to take the property be reversed.

Susette Kelo, whose unsuccessful lawsuit went all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court, said the court's decision "should scare a lot of people."

"Minorities and middle class people will lose their property rights and rich people, too, because there's always somebody richer than you."

The City Council heard comments from residents and others, but took no action Tuesday.

Councilwoman Margaret M. Curtin, who said she's received e-mails from around the United States denouncing her as a communist and a Nazi, defended the actions by city officials.

"The biggest part of this community believes that what we've done is proper," she said.

New London resident Bill Cornish told city officials they should be ashamed.

"Shame. Shame for allowing this eminent domain to continue this long," he said. "Turn this mess around. Let our neighbors live in their homes."

Ward, the Republican leader of the House, had proposed a bill during this year's regular legislative session that would have restricted the use of eminent domain, but the bill died in the Judiciary Committee. Last week, Republicans attempted to resurrect the issue during a special session, but Democrats who control the legislature argued that lawmakers should wait and draft a comprehensive bill during next year's regular session.

"It's certainly an issue we're going to be working on, whether it's in the veto session or not," said House Majority Leader Christopher Donovan, D-Meriden. "I want to hear from the people. I know I want to hear from my constituents. Right now I'm not prepared to vote on it. I need to know more."

Senate President Pro Tempore Donald E. Williams Jr., D-Brooklyn, said he prefers to wait until February, when the next regular legislative session convenes.

"This is no different than what we were addressing during the special session," he said. "It's a very complicated issue that we want to look at as part of the regular committee review process, with due care and consideration, and not be rushed into by a press release."

Ward, an attorney, said his bill is based on months of research by his staff and himself. His proposed changes would strike the section of existing law that allows development agencies, with local approval, to acquire property by eminent domain.

His bill would not affect government's ability to take private property in blighted areas.

"The effect of these changes would be to prevent the unfair taking of private property for the purpose of economic development, while at the same time preserving the rights of municipalities and the state of Connecticut to acquire property under eminent domain for true public use," Ward said in a letter to his fellow House members.


Newsday: www.newsday.com

Lawmakers Move to Mitigate Court’s Eminent Domain Ruling: The NewStandard (Syracuse NY), 7/5/05

by Jessica Azulay

Rare alliances are forming in response to a controversial Supreme Court ruling that the Constitution allows governments to force people to sell their homes to make way for private development projects. Late last week, some conservative lawmakers joined with liberal Democrats to introduce legislation that would deny federal funding to redevelopment projects that acquire land through eminent domain, a policy allowing governments to seize private property for public use.

The Supreme Court last week ruled in Kelo v. New London that local governments have broad authority to determine how "public use" is defined. According to the decision, governments can even condemn privately-owned homes and give the property to private developers if they believe that the public will benefit.

But critics of the 5-to-4 ruling fear that private developers will exercise political and economic clout to pressure lawmakers, while individual homeowners or small businesses will have relatively little influence.

"I worry about these little cities and towns where big, wealthy developers can influence elected officials with large campaign contributions and undermine what public use and eminent domain was meant to be," Representative Maxine Waters (D-California), who co-introduced the legislation in the House, told the San Francisco Chronicle.

The legislative attempt to mitigate the impact of the Supreme Count ruling was joined by Republican Representative Richard Pombo, also of California, and other conservatives who have long promoted the primacy of property rights.

In a first step toward the legislation, the House voted 231-to-189 Thursday in favor of an measure introduced by Representative Phil Gingrey (R-Maryland) ammending an appropriations bill that would bar the departments of Transportation, Treasury, and Housing and Urban Development from providing money "to enforce the judgment of the United States Supreme Court in the case of Kelo v. New London."


The NewStandard: http://newstandardnews.net

Eminent domain case hardly a Trail of Tears: Manchester (CT) Journal Inquirer, 7/5/05

By Chris Powell

Just how far do individual property rights in land go? Connecticut's latest legal controversy was also its first. For the state's aboriginal inhabitants had no conception of individual property rights in land, and so were rudely surprised when the goods they accepted from the European settlers were construed not as simple reciprocations of hospitality but as bills of sale, terminating the rights of the original occupants to the land they had long lived on.

Now the occupants of New London's Fort Trumbull neighborhood are almost as rudely surprised by the U.S. Supreme Court's 5-to-4 approval of the termination of their property rights by the city's power of eminent domain. Indeed, the Fort Trumbull residents and property-rights absolutists across America wail that the court's decision in the case of Kelo v. New London has destroyed property rights everywhere in the name of redevelopment.

Although the New London decision may be closer to the Indian view of property - collective rather than individual ownership of land - than anything since Georgia "redeveloped" the Cherokees into Oklahoma, it's really not likely to change much.

For in holding that the power of eminent domain, recognized in the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution, can be invoked for economic development, rather than just for a public-owned facility, such as a road, parking lot, school, dam or airport, the Supreme Court only reaffirmed earlier decisions. And the high court left state courts free to interpret their own state-constitutional provisions on eminent domain and left states and municipalities free to decide whether to use eminent domain for economic development.

Further, as the Supreme Court's majority noted, if government's taking property was not to be judged in itself a "public use" - but, rather, was to be judged according to the degree of future public use of the property - the courts would be forever deciding which were good uses and bad uses: decisions of policy, and thus best left to the elected agencies of government.

Besides, a determined government might easily get around a more restrictive interpretation of the Fifth Amendment - the interpretation that the Fort Trumbull property owners sought - by first putting seized property to the simplest of traditional public uses (such as a parking lot) for a few years before moving on to use it for economic development.

In fact, even within a more restrictive reading of "public use" (a road, parking lot, school, dam, airport), individual ownership of property in land has never been absolute in the United States.

Since the country's oldest tax may be the property tax, U.S. citizens have never really owned property in land as much as they have rented it from the government. Those who fail to pay their tax are foreclosed upon. Of course the government also claims royalties for any wealth that is removed from the land - oil, gas, minerals, water. Absolutism in property rights in land is less a characteristic of democracy than of feudal states with hereditary privileges.

Yes, there will always be both good and bad economic-development plans: plans with more benefit to the public and plans with more benefit to special interests, such as politically influential developers.

But that is true of everything in government; there is policy that benefits the many and policy that benefits the few. Yet when bad policy is made by the elected agencies of government, democracy can do something about it. When bad policy is made by courts, which are usually unelected, doing something about it can be virtually impossible.

That's why the Supreme Court's decision in the New London case is the last word only in federal constitutional law; it is not necessarily the last word in the city or state. For the Fort Trumbull property owners may still appeal to the City Council and the Connecticut General Assembly.

Besides, in New London the complaint about developers is phony, for the Fort Trumbull property owners would not be the least assuaged if the city were doing the construction work and planning to own the hotel, conference center, housing, and offices it envisions for the land at issue. Government has long used private companies to accomplish its ends.

As much as the property owners may be entitled to sympathy, New London is entitled to more. It is a struggling city of 26,000 with the second-smallest area of Connecticut's 169 municipalities. The average Connecticut municipality has 33 square miles, but New London has only 5½ - most of it built up and much of it rundown.

Yet because of its location, at the mouth of the Thames River, the city has enormous potential. If that potential could be realized, the city might again become prosperous. But because the city is already so built up, this cannot be achieved without changing some property arrangements, without making higher uses of property - and, yes, without some of what is called gentrification.

Paying seven families fair compensation for their property - compensation determined by a court, if they wish; compensation they can spend to acquire other property in the city - isn't going to put anyone out on a new Trail of Tears.


Journal Inquirer: www.journalinquirer.com

Task Force Planned On Eminent Domain Issue: KOTV-6 (Tulsa OK), 7/5/05

A couple of state lawmakers are forming a task force to study eminent domain issues in Oklahoma.

The US Supreme Court ruled last month that local governments can seize people's homes and businesses against their will for private development.

The decision gives cities wide power to bulldoze residences for projects such as shopping malls and hotel complexes in order to generate tax revenue. But it has raised concerns in Oklahoma and elsewhere about private property rights.

State Representative Mark Liotta of Tulsa and Senator Clark Jolley of Edmond are organizing the task force. The Republican lawmakers say they want to develop legislation that will give greater protection to private property owners in the state.


KOTV-6: www.kotv.com

Eminent domain decision affects all: South Bend (IN) Tribune, 7/5/05

Our Opinion

The Supreme Court ruling in favor of the city of New London, Conn. and private developers, and against the rights of private property owners who will now lose their homes, is one that should be viewed with concern by all Americans.

The individual's right to his home and property has always been sacred in American law.

The use of eminent domain by communities seeking to replace blight or make needed public improvements is not new. It has allowed governments to condemn private property and then use it for airports, highways, schools, parks and other improvements deemed to be in the best interests of the community as a whole.

What is new, according to Justice Sandra Day O'Connor in her dissent, is the endorsement of economic development as an appropriate public use.

"The government now has license to transfer property from those with fewer resources to those with more," O'Connor said. "The founders cannot have intended this perverse result."

In Indiana, the subject of eminent domain became an issue before the General Assembly when Rep. David Wolkins, R-Winona Lake, sought to ban state or local governments from condemnation of private property for commercial uses unless the owners had rejected offers of at least 150 percent of assessed value.

Unlike Connecticut, where the city of New London sought to take well-kept homes, Indiana law only allows condemnation in blighted areas. The law also requires that property owners be fairly compensated for their property.

Wolkins' bill, opposed by local governments, was not successful, but the idea behind it is to be the subject of a state study commission.

Justice John Paul Stevens said he found it surprising that the definition of what constitutes a public use had never been defined.

In his majority opinion, Stevens determined that public use should be defined as "public purpose" and said he saw "no basis for exempting economic development from our traditionally broad understanding of public purpose."

He said the plan in New London "unquestionably serves a public purpose."

O'Connor countered: "Under the banner of economic development, all private property is now vulnerable to being taken and transferred to another private owner, so long as it might be upgraded."

In our view, the definition of what is a "public use" ought to be limited to what can be used by the public — a highway, for instance, or a public building.

A private development is not necessarily a public use just because it enhances the tax base.

The decision does not prohibit states from putting their own restrictions on the use of eminent domain powers, as Indiana has done and should continue to do.

There is nothing wrong with eminent domain. It is a tool that every community needs to maintain its viability and rid itself of blighted areas.

It is the potential for misuse that must be guarded against.


South Bend Tribune: www.southbendtribune.com