7/05/2005

Eminent case of domain poisoning: The Washington (DC) Times, 7/4/05

Commentary

By Mark Steyn

Do you know Nancy Pelosi? Her job is leading the Democratic members of the House of Representatives. They should have asked for references. Here's her reaction to the Supreme Court's recent decision on "eminent domain"
"It is a decision of the Supreme Court," said the Minority Leader. "So this is almost as if God has spoken."

That's not how Abraham Lincoln saw it: "If the policy of the government upon vital questions affecting the whole people is to be irrevocably fixed by decisions of the Supreme Court ... the people will have ceased to be their own rulers."

I'm with Abe. On this Independence Day weekend, the people might wish to give some thought as to how they might reclaim their independence from the godlike Supremes.

Rule by the judicial interpretation of principles is problematic enough for some of us. But rule by the judicial interpretation of lack of principles takes us to dizzying new heights. Last week, in two rulings, the Supreme Court decided that (a) displays of the Ten Commandments are constitutional and (b) displays of the Ten Commandments are unconstitutional.

Don't worry, all nine judges aren't that wacky, just the deciding vote in both 5-4 decisions. That belonged to Stephen Breyer, who nixed the Ten Commandments in Kentucky but gave 'em two thumbs up in Texas. His basis was that the Texas Commandments had been there 40 years and were thus part of "a broader moral and historical message reflective of a cultural heritage," whereas the Kentucky display was newer and "a more contemporary state effort to focus attention upon a religious text is certainly likely to prove divisive."

Really? Not as "certainly likely" to prove divisive as grandfathering the display of some Commandments but not others, so the only way to be sure yours is constitutional is to sue over it. For one thing, Justice Breyer didn't identify the year in which he believes the Commandments ceased to be constitutional -- 1968, 1973?

Or maybe a sliding scale? If you put up the Commandments before 1965, you can have all Ten; between 1966 and 1979, you can have six firm Commandments plus a couple of strong recommendations; from 1980 to 1991, it's two Commandments and a half-dozen lifestyle tips?

To be sure, the Supreme Court took other factors than the year of manufacture into consideration — whether the display was inside or outside, whether it was surrounded by a full supporting cast of religious artifacts or secular knick-knacks, etc. But it's hard to discern any principles here, at least when compared to their one-size-fits-all abortion absolutism.

To the best of my knowledge, Justice Breyer has never claimed you can have a first-trimester abortion in the parking lot, but for the full partial-birth you must be indoors.

A couple of days earlier, the majesty of the law had turned its attention to "eminent domain" — the fancy term for what happens when the government seizes the property of the private citizen. It pays you, of course, but that's not much comfort if you've built your dream home on your favorite spot of land. Most laymen understand the "public interest" dimension as, oh, they're putting in the new Interstate and they don't want to make a huge detour because one cranky old coot refuses to sell his ramshackle dairy farm.

But the Supreme Court's decision took a far more expansive view — that local governments could compel you to sell your property if a developer's proposal would generate greater tax revenue. In other words, the "public interest" boils down to whether or not the government gets more money to spend.

I can't say that's my definition. Indeed, the constitutional conflation of "public interest" with increased tax monies is deeply distressing to those of us who happen to think letting governments access too much dough too easily leads them to create even more useless government programs that enfeeble the citizenry in deeply destructive ways.

Nonetheless, across the fruited domain, governments reacted to the court decision by sending the bulldozers round to idle expectantly on John Doe's front lawn: Newark. N.J., officials moved forward with plans to raze 14 downtown acres and build an upscale condo development; Arnold, Mo., intends to demolish 30 homes, 14 businesses and the local Veterans of Foreign Wars to make way for a Lowe's Home Improvement store and a strip mall developed by THF Realty.

Get the picture? New Hampshire businessman Logan Darrow Clements did. He wants to build a new hotel in the town of Weare, and he's found just the right piece of land — the home of Supreme Court judge David Souter. In compliance with Justice Souter's view of the public interest, Mr. Clements' project will generate far more revenue for Weare than Mr Souter's pad ever could. The Lost Liberty Hotel will include the Just Desserts Bar and a museum dedicated to the loss of freedom in America.

I don't know about you, but the last time I was in Weare, N.H., I couldn't help thinking what the town urgently needs is a good hotel. If it will help the Board of Selectmen in their decision, I personally pledge to take the most expensive suite in the new joint for the first month it's in service. I'll be sluicing plenty of big columnist bucks around town, racking up big New Hampshire Meals Tax payments at Weare's finest restaurants and, along with my fellow guests, doing far more for the local economy than one ascetic, largely absentee bachelor like Justice Souter could. Indeed, under Judge Souter's definition, it would be hard to think of a property doing less for the public interest than his own house. So let's get on with putting his principles into action and with luck his beloved but economically moribund abode will be rubble by the end of the year.

North of Weare, by the way, many Granite State municipalities face problems with land that generates even less revenue than David Souter's. In small North Country towns like Warren, for example, half the land belongs to the White Mountain National Forest, and thus is off the tax rolls. Can the Select Board of Warren force the federal government to make way for a logging camp? Or even for a rusting doublewide for David Souter once he is booted out of Weare?

How does that banned-in-Kentucky Commandment go? "Thou shalt not covet thy neighbor's house, nor his ass." However, if thy neighbor is an ass and thou hast financing for a luxury hotel, covet away.

Lincoln was right about a robed state: a handful of whimsical commissars settling the rights of 300 million citizens is not republican government. This Independence Day, America needs a "new birth of freedom."


The Washington Times: www.washingtontimes.com

In eminent domain cross-hairs: Pasadena (CA) Star-News, 5/4/05

Monrovia officials eye site of auto repair shop for housing development

By Sonya Geis

When Bernard Buller bought an old gas station in Monrovia 22 years ago, the corner lot facing railroad tracks and a cemetery must have seemed like the last place anyone would want to put houses.

But Monrovia has changed. Now, with a decades-long city agenda to upgrade Monrovia's image and property-tax values, and a red-hot housing market, Buller's lot has become a prime development site.

Buller doesn't want to sell his property, at the corner of Duarte Road and California Avenue. But city officials insist they need his lot to improve the whole block. And they're initiating eminent domain proceedings to get it.

The city has been buying property on the block for years, some of it vacant and crime-ridden, Scott Ochoa, Monrovia city manager, said. "We really wrestled with what to do with this property we assembled," he said.

Soon there will be a major development nearby where the Gold Line will stop, he said. Given that, and the need for affordable housing, "all these issues come together in terms of the best use of that land, which is residential home-ownership," Ochoa said. And without Buller's land, "it's not really a usable development site."

The city wants to put in 15 to 25 condominiums on Buller's corner, Ochoa said. They have offered Buller increasing sums for the property, now home to Buller's hobby activities and two tenants, an auto mechanic and a smog-tester. The last offer was $709,000, Ochoa said. Buller wouldn't even consider it.

Buller, 67, lives in San Dimas. He spent his life savings to buy the property in 1981 to have a place to work on cars. He understands the city's position, he said.

"The thing they're thinking of building is very high-gloss, very fancy," he said. With a developer eyeing the site, "they've got Mr. Dollars out there saying, ‘I'm not going to put up housing there and have people looking out their windows at that (junk).' "

Buller says nearby properties the city already acquired were used as drug houses or were magnets for drunken fights on Friday nights.

But he's paid off the mortgage on his property. He relies on his tenants' rent for income. He can't find any other suitable place to work on cars. He just doesn't want to leave.

"I'm dug in there, big time," Buller said. "Everything in this world is not about money. This is my life. This income I have coming in, I need that to live. And what I'm doing with my life is my hobby. I like my life the way it is."

The city will hold a public hearing at a regular City Council meeting Tuesday night at 7:30 in City Hall to initiate eminent domain proceedings on the land.


Pasadena Star-news: www.pasadenastarnews.com

High court eminent domain ruling spurs local worries: Business Journal of Phoenix (AZ), 7/3/05

The U.S. Supreme Court's ruling last week backing up government eminent domain powers in redevelopment cases has Arizona property rights advocates distressed such powers will run amuck to the determent of homeowners and small businesses.

The court decision in a Connecticut property case could help regional redevelopment efforts by taking the federal courts out of the picture for those appealing eminent domain moves.

Greater eminent domain powers could help government entities acquire parcels for Arizona State University's downtown campus, the Tempe Marketplace shopping center and revitalization efforts in south Scottsdale, downtown Glendale and along Grand Avenue in west Phoenix.

That worries property rights supporters in the political and legal realms.

"The decision has put wind in the sails of redevelopment-minded cities and developers who would get into bed with those cities," said Steve Hirsch, a condemnation expert and attorney in Bryan Cave's Phoenix office.

Hirsch said he could see the city of Tempe attempting to use wider eminent domain powers in efforts to acquire parcels for the development of the 1.3-million-square-foot Tempe Marketplace shopping center slated to be built by Vestar Development.

That center is expected to be home to a number of big-box stores (Target, Barnes & Noble, Best Buy) as well as a Harkins Theatres movie complex, but some property owners on the site do not want to sell to the city and developer.

The city of Phoenix also is expected to use eminent domain powers to purchase downtown parcels for an expansion of ASU's downtown campus.

Greater eminent domain and government- taking powers also could help in Phoenix Mayor Phil Gordon's program to redevelop a corridor between the state Capitol and ASU's Tempe campus.

Local property-rights experts point out that the state constitution limits eminent domain powers to public projects, not private ones. That provision played out in the city of Mesa's failed attempt to forcibly acquire a small brake shop and turn the site over for an Ace Hardware store.

"Before the central-planning crowd in Arizona gets too excited about a new tool in their toolbox, they should be reminded that Arizona's founders were far too smart to leave property rights to the federal government." said Steve Voeller, president the Arizona Free Enterprise Club, a conservative advocacy group. "The Arizona Constitution provides us added protection."

Hirsch said he also believes the Mesa case involving Bailey's Brake Shop will protect state property owners from government takings for private developments.

Jay Kaprosy, vice president of the Greater Phoenix Chamber of Commerce, said his business group received a number of calls from small businesses worried about government property powers.

Kaprosy expects to see tightening of eminent domain powers by the Republican-dominated state Legislature next year.

"The decision does not preclude states from placing further restrictions on eminent domain, and it appears likely that the Legislature will take action to clarify Arizona's policies," Kaprosy said.

That could include legislation or a ballot question.

Economic developers and redevelopment supporters welcomed the decision, hoping it will help clear up future eminent domain disputes that may hamstring key projects.

"I feel that the judicious use of condemnation for redevelopment purposes does make sense as an important tool, but past abuses have led to a backlash in Arizona against this," said Scottsdale Economic Vitality Manager David Roderique.

Roderique said he does not expect to see widespread use of eminent domain in Arizona, even after the Supreme Court decision. He also worries that cities lack a comprehensive set of tools to encourage in-fill development or new projects and that it remains easier to build in outlying suburbs with undeveloped land.

John Bowers, director of the Arizona Association for Economic Development, defended eminent domain, saying that without it, key projects won't get built.

"Without the leverage afforded by eminent domain, the last parcels needed for any large projects requiring land assembly will have infinite value, and those projects just won't happen," said Bowers.

The Connecticut case, Kelo v. New London, involved government efforts to forcibly acquire residential properties and turn the land over to pharmaceutical giant Pfizer for a research facility. Pfizer is paying a $1 a year lease on the parcel, and some of the displaced homeowners have lived in the impacted homes for decades.

The court decided by a 5-4 decision that the economic benefit of the Pfizer project is a worthy reason for eminent domain. Conservatives on the court, as well as Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, dissented, arguing the ruling erodes private property rights and the less-influential will get pushed aside in the name of redevelopment.

Raymond Hunter, a partner with the Phoenix law firm Galbut & Hunter, said the Connecticut ruling means that local eminent domain cases will be fought out here in Arizona.

"Local ordinances will continue to apply to local decisions. Local governments are free, if they wish, to make eminent domain more stringent than the 5th Amendment requires," said Hunter. "Thus, eminent domain disputes will continue to be fought and resolved at the state and local level."


Business Journal of Phoenix: http://phoenix.bizjournals.com/phoenix

Property Owner Wins Eminent Domain Battle: Fox News, 7/4/05

The sign at the edge of Romulus, Mich. proclaims: "Industry and its citizens working together." But try convincing cabinet shop owner Ed Hathcock.

"I just cannot imagine how we can give such a broad brush of power to local, municipal government," Hathcock said.

Hathcock's property abuts Detroit's airport where the county had planned a 1,300-acre industrial park. But when Hathcock turned down the county's buyout offer, the local government made a play to take his land to use on the project.

The Supreme Court of the United States' recent ruling that local governments can seize private property for private economic development has put the affected property owners across the country in a fighting mood, but those in favor believe taking property is justified if it suits the public good.

"Our constituents, our citizens are saying: 'We want more opportunity; we want more jobs in the area,'" Wayne County executive Bob Ficano said.

The majority of landowners accepted Wayne County's buyout offer for the industrial park, but Hathcock claims he got a raw deal.

So the county took him to court to seize his land, wielding its power of eminent domain. Hathcock lost in two lower courts but won a ruling last year in Michigan's Supreme Court.

"Every American believes that ... they have sanctity in their land, that holding land is a right and that it's not a right that can be alienated by a politician because he feels he has a better use for it," Hathcock said.

Hathcock's victory reversed two decades of legal precedent in Michigan and made the state's eminent domain laws among the strictest in the nation. For a government to take land from a private property owner, it has to be for public projects only, such as road construction or for parks.

But many in government here say that Hathcock's case undercuts Michigan's ability to lure business.

"The economy now is global. A company says, 'Do I locate in China or do I locate in the Midwest? What are the advantages that I have?' One of the biggest advantages is being able to assemble land," Fiacano said.


Fox News: www.foxnews.com

Rein in Abuse of Eminent Domain: Victoria (TX) Advocate, 9/30/04

Guest Column
By Henry A Miller

A chain of events caused construction of 277 huge transmission towers in Karnes and Goliad counties. In 1998 the Texas Public Utility Commission and electric utilities decided to take private property in order to construct huge transmission lines across the state prior to deregulation taking effect. Commissioners and utilities agreed the only problem facing them was just how contentious land owners might be (Wall Street Journal, 1999). There would be no regulatory problems because the chief regulator, Chairman Patrick Henry Wood, III was in their pocket.

Americans supposedly have property rights protected by State and federal constitutions. Laws and regulations are supposed to govern the taking of property. The law of eminent domain requires a public need.

When your property rights are threatened by a profit making company helped by the government, you can give in or fight. In fighting you are going against all odds. The trend over the last twenty to thirty years has been that when your property rights are threatened you might as well give up because the big and powerful can not be stopped. The courts tended to approve the takings. This has caused those wanting to take your property and the regulators to become lax in following the laws. Why bother, property owners are defeated before the start.

100 or so property owners first knew of the proposed line in July 1999. Most took conventional wisdom and gave up. Some decided to see what could be done. We sought expert legal advice from lawyers that deal in eminent domain and procedures at the PUC. One said it was pointless to practice before the PUC. One said Commissioner Wood made up his mind that the 277 were needed. Wood controlled the other commissioners and was judge and jury in power line matters. Public need is supposed to be the reason that private property is taken.

A short chain of events was to rubber stamp the application. Utilities apply. The charade of following procedures was to happen. Application approved, no one the wiser, no matter what, a done deal. “No matter what” happened, contentious property owners chose to question the process? Two lawyers were found. A principled administrative law judge was assigned.

The utility asked to be ordered to construct the 277. The PUC had the right to do so and avoid a hearing to prove the need. Knowing it was a mere formality; the PUC ordered a hearing where the utility was to prove the line was necessary for the service, accommodation, convenience, or safety of the public. Knowing it was just a part of the charade the utility didn’t bother much in their attempt to prove the need. To the actors’ surprise, Administrative Law Judge Barbara Owens ruled that the utility failed to prove the line was necessary… and recommended the application be denied.

Regulations give the PUC limited rights to overrule the ALJ. Going beyond the limits, Wood overruled the ALJ saying the line was needed to improve market conditions. Market conditions serve the utilities and the power generating companies for their profit.

“When government can take property to give it to private parties, interest groups will try to commandeer that power to enrich themselves. The force of the state becomes a prize to be won in a political contest. Groups which hope to profit from forced redistributions of property will attempt to influence the government to use eminent domain in their favor. But, properly applied, the public use limitation prevents this by making it impossible for interest groups to profit”, Pacific Legal Foundation, in reference to a July 2004 decision by the Michigan Supreme Court said to have national implications. That court reversed a twenty year trend that allowed governments to take from one and give to another in order for the other to make a profit.

The 277 towers symbolize government taking from A and giving it to B so B can profit. Lawyers, Catherine J. Webking and Shannon K. McClendon have taken our case through the administrative hearing, district court, 3rd Court of Appeals, and on August 24 filed with the Texas Supreme Court.

Wallace Jefferson has been appointed Chief Justice, Texas Supreme Court. “He is perfect for the job because he will decide issues based on the law — he has no political agenda whatsoever, and he is not beholden to anyone," Lamont Jefferson(lawyer and brother of Wallace) (San Antonio Express 9/14/04). The same can be said of ALJ Barbara Owens, not so of Chairman Patrick Henry Wood, III.

The Texas Supreme Court now has the opportunity to right a wrong, to force the PUC to follow the law and to take away the utilities’ political prize.

We are therefore hopeful that the 277 towers will come down.

Note: The Texas Supreme Court declined to rule on the case. On April 4, 2005 a request for rehearing was filed at the Supreme Court. The Court has ordered the PUC and the utilities involved to file a response, due 6/29/05, to our filing for a rehearing. The Texas Farm Bureau on 6/29/05 filed an amicus brief in support of our case.



Victoria Advocate: www.thevictoriaadvocate.com

Henry A Miller: hamiller@awesomenet.net

7/04/2005

Eminent domain set to be discussed: (Bowling Green KY) Daily News, 7/3/05

By Jim Gaines

An ordinance that would prohibit Bowling Green from using its eminent domain power to buy property and turn it over to private developers is back on the city commission’s agenda for Tuesday night.

Commissioner Brian Strow proposed the ordinance in January, but it was tabled by a 3-2 vote in anticipation of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling on whether eminent domain could be used for such economic-development purposes.

That court ruling came down June 23, granting governments sweeping latitude in using eminent domain.

Immediately afterward, Strow renewed his proposal to create a new section of city code to assure city property owners that the city won’t use eminent domain as part of its ongoing downtown redevelopment efforts.

Commissioner Brian “Slim” Nash said Friday that he has been in discussions with Strow about the matter.

“But it has really been more of a process discussion, asking him when he would bring it back up,” Nash said.

Strow could not be reached for comment.

Nash said he has studied the complete Supreme Court ruling and has been soliciting input from constituents, asking them to respond by noon Monday.

“As for where I stand now on the ordinance, I have yet to make a decision,” he said.

The proposed ordinance states: “The city, or any agent of the city, shall not use eminent domain, or the threat thereof, to take private property from a private property owner, except in those specific instances herein stated: the building, expansion or maintenance of public buildings, public parks, public utilities, public roads, public bridges and public rights-of-way.”

Mayor Elaine Walker said June 24 that she opposes the ordinance change.

The city’s redevelopment plan was written in part to specifically allow that use of eminent domain, and several of the projects now under way were turned over to private developers. Although none of the land sales for those projects were forced through eminent-domain proceedings, some downtown property owners say the explicit threat of eminent domain makes any negotiations inherently unfair.


Daily News: www.bgdailynews.com

Eminent domain ruling likely won't have local impact: (Michigan City IN) News-Dispatch, 7/3/05

By Jason Miller

A controversial vote by the U.S. Supreme Court last week to make the taking of personal property by local municipalities easier likely won't effect efforts by Michigan City to purchase the Blocksom and Co. property.

"If we're looking at acquiring property for public access or redevelopment, then the decision will have no impact," Mayor Chuck Oberlie said. "The tool is there regardless of that decision."

Last week the Supreme Court ruled 5-4 that local governments may seize people's homes and businesses against the owner's will for private economic development.

The ruling seemingly expanded parameters of the Fifth Amendment, which allows governments to take private property through eminent domain for public use.

Indiana law also allows for the taking of private property for public use if the property or surrounding area is considered a blight on the community.

The city - which wants to tear down the Blocksom factory at the corner of Fifth Street and Michigan Boulevard and redevelop the area - has yet to begin negotiations on the purchase of Blocksom.

In recent months, however, the notion the city might look into taking the property by eminent domain has popped up.

Blocksom President Andy Swann agreed with Oberlie, saying eminent domain is a state issue and could be brought to the table regardless of the court's recent decision.

He didn't know, however, when negotiations might begin.

"We're trying to be cooperative with the (city's) Redevelopment Commission," Swann said of the department responsible for negotiating with Blocksom. "We're going by Indiana law. It may not be an issue for us."

Oberlie has maintained throughout talks about Blocksom that eminent domain should be used only as a last resort. He has said, though, that determining fair value through the courts - which is what eminent domain proceedings accomplish - is sometimes the best option.

"Sometimes it's best to go that route, though, if there is a large sum of money involved," he said. "It assures everyone involved that the process was done properly."

The current process and that approved by the Supreme Court last week both walk a line between maintaining personal property rights and taking them away.

In that light, Oberlie said, the new ruling - which he thinks will likely be appealed and possibly overturned - should be used sparingly because it could force state-level legislators to look more closely at their own statutes.

"I was surprised (by the ruling). The ability to hold private property is pretty sacred in this country," he said. "A public need must be determined. You can't just take someone's house to put up a fireworks stand once a year.

"You have to really figure out what the level is that makes doing it worthwhile."


The News-Dispatch: www.thenewsdispatch.com

Bill would stiffen state law on eminent domain: York (PA) Daily Record, 7/3/05

By State Senator Jeff Piccola

Maybe the members of the Supreme Court are unfamiliar with the saying, “Home sweet home,” or possibly they have never heard that “a family’s home is their castle.” I make these observations in light of the court’s most recent trampling on the deeply cherished values of the American people. Like many in our country, I am outraged at the court’s decision in the case of Kelo v. City of New London.

This case involved a fairly simple set of facts. In a 5-4 decision, the court supported the city of New London, Conn., which seized the homes of an unblighted working class neighborhood, for private developers to construct a riverfront hotel and office complex. The New London homeowners appealed to Connecticut’s Supreme Court, but a divided court ruled against them and they appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Sadly, these homeowners were not to find help at the Supreme Court. Rather, five liberal justices, led by Justice Stevens, decided that they would no longer enforce the Constitutional requirement that government can only take an individuals’ property for a truly public purpose. Instead, the majority of the court decided that they would leave the determination of what is a “public use” solely to the governmental entity taking the property. Talk about the fox guarding the hen house!

Justice O’Connor, writing for the four dissenting justices, stated, “Under the banner of economic development, all private property is now vulnerable to being taken and transferred to another private owner, so long as it might be upgraded.” According to Justice O’Connor, the majority has “effectively delete(d) the words ‘for public use’” from the United States Constitution. This is a frightening and unacceptable situation.

As someone whose 83-year-old mother still resides in the home my father helped design and build 57 years ago, I know the heartfelt feeling one can attach to a home. I do not see the court’s decision as merely a mistaken application of Constitutional law. I view it as an attack on the rights of individuals to be protected from out-of-control and activist courts.

But all is not lost. The United States Supreme Court stated in its decision that state lawmakers have the authority to provide greater protection to property owners than what the court is willing to provide.

Consequently, I am introducing legislation to restore the traditional balance in eminent domain cases for Pennsylvania: Government can take individuals’ private property only when it is absolutely necessary and only for a truly public purpose. Further, in those rare instances where such a taking is necessary, individuals must be fairly compensated.

With the help of the people of our commonwealth and the votes of the lawmakers they have elected, we can protect the cherished values that underlie the saying, “be it ever so humble — there is no place like home.”


York Daily Record: http://ydr.com

Jeffrey Piccola, a Republican who represents parts of northern York County, is the Senate Majority Whip

Eminent domain won't be coming to Fairfield: Fairfield (CA) Daily Republic, 7/3/05

Editorial

Many of our readers may have been following the recent Supreme Court decision in Kelo v. City of New London (Connecticut) eminent domain case. Eminent domain means using government power to acquire property for public purpose without the property owner's consent. Examples of such public purpose have traditionally included highway projects, a school, or water pipelines.

The Supreme Court, in a 5-4 vote, decided taking private, non-blighted property for the purpose of economic development satisfies the "public use" requirement of the Fifth Amendment. The Fifth Amendment provides that private property may only be taken for a public use. In the City of New London case, the property owners challenged the city's condemnation of their properties under the theory that economic development of non-blighted properties violates the public use clause of the Fifth Amendment.

Over the years, many local governments have used the power of eminent domain to help economic development. In the Connecticut case, New London condemned several residential properties, including homes lived in for more than 50 years, to assemble the land for a large development project that included an upscale hotel and conference center, new residences, and retail and office space. The city stated the development would create new jobs and increase the economic base of the city.

Another famous example of economic development condemnation occurred during the 1980s in Poletown County, Mich. Detroit acquired a large portion of a neighborhood to assemble land (more than 400 acres) for a General Motors Assembly Plant.

The Kelo vs. City of New London case doesn't place any new limits on the use of eminent domain by local governments or redevelopment agencies in California. Public agencies in California may only take land for economic development purposes in blighted areas. Legislation in California doesn't grant California cities the authority to condemn property for economic development outside blighted areas.

Eminent domain is only used as a last resort in California. Public agencies usually deal directly with the property owners to ensure they are treated fairly and offered fair market value for their properties. Under all circumstances a property owner must be paid fair market value for his or her property as well as be provided relocation benefits and assistance.

The city of Fairfield has an active economic development and redevelopment program. To date, however, neither the city nor its redevelopment agency has used eminent domain to take a single-family residence. Of the city's five redevelopment project areas, only North Texas Street still has eminent domain power in effect. The North Texas Street Redevelopment Plan specifically excludes occupied single-family residences from eminent domain.

The Fairfield Redevelopment Agency is scheduled to have eminent domain authority in the North PACE area (Regional Center Project Area expansion) for decaying multi-family properties where serious blight and social problems exist. The Kelo vs. City of New London case revolved around the economic development of non-blighted properties. For Fairfield, the PACE area is not a case of economic development per se, but of solving neighborhood decay and "blight" that has resulted in serious issues of public health and safety.


Daily Republic: www.dailyrepublic.com

Officials: Eminent domain a last resort: Rockford (IL) Register Star, 7/3/05

Some Machesney Park residents are feeling the pinch of the government’s power to seize land

By Pat Milhizer

You shouldn’t worry about losing your home to the next big-box store or hotel coming to the Rock River Valley.

Public officials and private developers say eminent domain, a legal maneuver that makes homeowners cringe but can lure more tax dollars for communities, will remain a last resort regardless of a U.S. Supreme Court ruling that bolsters the government’s powers.

But try telling that to Nora St. Germain.

She’s losing her home to a retail development.

“It stinks. I don’t think it’s fair, but there ain’t nothing you can do,” said St. Germain, a 60-year-old Machesney Park resident who stands to lose her mobile home by the end of the year so a retail center can be built near Alpine Road and Illinois 173.

“There is no freedom. This is Grandma’s house, and it ain’t going to be Grandma’s house no more,” she said.

Local governments usually file eminent domain against property owners who won’t give up their land or negotiate a fair price when they’re in the way of new highways, schools, government buildings and other public services.

But new weight has been thrown into the sensitive practice.

A split U.S. Supreme Court ruling June 23 supported the government’s ability to acquire homes for commercial development — such as shopping malls or sports arenas.

The court was asked to decide public-use rights protected by the Fifth Amendment. And it gave local governments the power to decide whether citizens would be better served by private commercial projects that displace landowners.

Homeowners and property rights activists reacted strongly to the ruling — concerned that, essentially, nobody really has control over land.

But despite the new powers given to them by the court, a county economic development director, four local government attorneys and five developers in the Rock River Valley suggest that there won’t be a spike in eminent domain cases.

“The process works in that there’s not just legal controls but political controls,” Rockford city attorney Patrick Hayes said. “If a mayor used this improperly, the public is going to state its opinion at the ballot box.”

Still, a state statute lets local governments use eminent domain for economic development when an area passes state standards to be declared blighted.

“I don’t think it’s going to change a thing,” said Chuck Thompson, president of William Charles Investments. “I don’t think what was done there was anything new.”

“Cities really are using eminent domain less than they did 10, 15 years ago,” Thompson said.

“They’re finding it extremely expensive. ... We, as a private developer, wouldn’t want to go down that road. It would take too much time to use that tool or encourage a city, state or county to use that tool.”

On its face, eminent domain for private projects is a good thing for local officials.

The new developments promise jobs and transactions that pour tax revenue into government coffers.

Nevertheless, state Sen. Steve Rauschenberger, R-Elgin, will introduce a bill this fall that would require the Illinois General Assembly and governor to approve eminent domain cases for private development.

“Economic eminent domain has been used to pressure private-property owners into selling their property for less money than they want to sell it for,” said Rauschenberger, a potential candidate for governor next year. “Taxpayers shouldn’t pay taxes to support a local government and then have that power turned against them.”

So far, Machesney Park paid a total of $137,000 for two single-family homes in the area bounded by Orlando Street, Illinois 173, Story Book Lane and North Alpine Road.

In April, the Village Board passed a resolution 4-2 that authorized eminent domain if negotiations with property owners fail.

The Supreme Court decision has no bearing on Machesney Park’s effort to acquire the remaining 31 properties for an undetermined retail development, according to Village Attorney Tom Green. The village bolstered its effort by designating the area blighted, an issue not addressed in the court’s decision.

The characterization bothers St. Germain’s grandson, 17-year-old Derek Nichol.

Derek and his grandfather rebuilt the home about a decade ago, he said, turning a three-bedroom dwelling into a two-bedroom home so his grandmother could have a larger living room. Since then, they also replaced the floors, windows, bathroom and rebuilt two sheds.

“It took so much to build this. And apparently they just want to come and rip it all out, like it’s garbage,” Nichol said.

Noelia Garza, 57, lives nearby in a four-bedroom, one-story home with a basement. She, too, has to prepare to move by the end of the year.

“To tell you the truth, I didn’t think I was going to spend my whole life in my house, but I wasn’t prepared for this,” said Garza, a machine operator who has lived on Orlando Street for 19 years.

The neighborhood is part of a tax increment financing district Machesney Park created in 1991 to lure retail businesses. The district helps redevelop the area because, after it’s established, any increase in property taxes goes to development efforts within the district instead of funding schools and other taxing bodies.

“Of course, some properties within the area, individually, are OK,” Green said. “But as an area, it saw very little increase in assessed value and has poor infrastructure.”

Forcing somebody out of a well-kept home because they live near what’s been designated a blighted area is part of the problem, Rauschenberger said.

“Blight has been so broadly defined,” Rauschenberger said, “that pristine lakefront in central Illinois has been determined to be blighted.”


Rockford Register Star: www.rrstar.com

Curbing eminent domain abuses: (Hampton Roads VA) Daily Press, 7/3/05

Opinion

By Patrick M. McSweeney

Every now and then, an issue emerges out of nowhere to dominate political conversation for months. The giveaway of the Panama Canal was such an issue in the 1970s.

The new hot issue is government's abuse of the power of eminent domain. A 5-4 decision of the U.S. Supreme Court on June 23 in Kelo v. New London prompted a spontaneous outpouring of disbelief, fear and anger across the country. That decision upheld a municipality's taking of private homes for a development simply because the municipality concluded that it would bring in higher tax revenues when the property was turned over to private businesses.

What so troubled average Americans is that any person's property can now be seized by government simply on the basis of the government's assertion that some vague public purpose will be served by taking the property from one private owner and then selling or leasing it to another private person. The asserted public purpose might be economic development or merely a better-balanced community.

The widespread negative reaction to the Supreme Court's decision in Kelo surprised most Virginia politicians. After all, a state statute already permits localities to condemn private property for any public purpose, which would include economic development and planning for a "more balanced" community. Despite several high profile battles in Virginia over the use and abuse of the eminent domain power, there had been no previous public outcry that would have warned politicians of what would come when the Kelo decision was announced.

In fact, two legislative proposals offered during the 2005 session of the General Assembly to prevent the very result the Kelo decision allows were given short shrift. Both would have narrowed the statutory definition of "public uses" to exclude those that are predominantly for a private purpose.

Now Virginia politicians are scrambling to get to the front of the long column of agitated citizens who are demanding legislative action to reverse the effect of the Kelo decision. These politicians, who had no interest in enacting a statutory fix to the problem just a few months ago, are suddenly outraged by the U.S. Supreme Court's decision.

As a result of the Kelo decision, the public is awakening to a greater threat to private ownership of property than government's use of the condemnation power to acquire land for parks or highways. The public is discovering the insidious collusion between powerful private developers and government officials to benefit both by the exercise of the government's power of eminent domain in circumstances that George Mason, Patrick Henry and other proponents of the Bill of Rights surely thought would be prohibited by the Takings Clause of the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution and similar provisions in state constitutions.

The private developers benefit by gaining the right to obtain property for their developments at a discount price when government officials use their condemnation power instead of bargaining with willing sellers. Government officials benefit in several ways, not the least of which is an enhancement of their power. They can seize the property of their political enemies and transfer it at a bargain price to their political friends and campaign contributors.

What the public response to the Kelo decision has demonstrated is that Americans have a deep, almost primal, desire to own property, which Kelo has put at risk. Politicians shouldn't expect public outrage to subside until they enact corrective legislation.


The Daily Press: www.dailypress.com

Patrick McSweeney, who practices law in Richmond, is former chairman of the Republican Party of Virginia: pmcsweeney@mcbump.com

Don't abuse the power of eminent domain: (New York NY) Newsday, 7/3/05

Opinion

By Ronald H Silverman

The U.S. Supreme Court's recent ruling in favor of local government's right to condemn private property for economic development should be of special concern in this state. Two years ago the Institute for Justice reported that "New York is perhaps the worst state for . . . eminent domain abuse."

Typically, economic development involves transfers of condemned land to private parties, usually businesses. In the New London, Conn., case decided on June 23, property owners claimed that their small city's taking of their land was not for the constitutionally required "public use," but for the use of private parties. The Pfizer drug company had already built a research facility nearby.

The court held that the condemnations were a legitimate part of the city's economic redevelopment plan, and that while the condemned land was not to be open to the public, that didn't matter. The court deferred to the city's judgment that it might be revitalized through job and tax growth produced by having private enterprise on the property.

If the taking of property now requires only a "public purpose" as opposed to the more limited idea of "public use," then the door to eminent domain has opened much wider. And if courts simply trust officials' claims that the public will eventually benefit, then local government could become all too casual or careless in planning condemnations.

Already on Capitol Hill, there is action to check this growing power. On Thursday the House passed a bill denying federal funds to economic development programs that use eminent domain to make way for a profit-making project like a hotel or mall.

Locally, in a case pending in New Cassel, the Town of North Hempstead is trying to condemn a three-bedroom house and land used for the World Bible church to make way for what is described in news reports as a "community center." This would seem to be a legitimate public use. But if the center were privately built, privately owned and operated by the town, there might still be a question about private profit benefits.

In Brooklyn, a private developer intends to build a new arena for the Nets basketball team that will require evictions. This project will bring profits to the team owners. Brooklyn and New York City will benefit from more jobs and taxes.

Government needs to tread carefully. Taking of property by eminent domain can hurt property owners, who lose money on investments and must relocate and sever neighborhood ties. This can be particuarly severe for the elderly and others who have lived in a neighborhood a long time. Persons of color with low or modest incomes and less political clout may be especially vulnerable, while local legislatures may be prone to manipulation by monied private interests.

How do we minimize abuse by local government?

Some states, like Michigan, now forbid takings for economic development where private parties are likely to benefit directly. This is probably too extreme a solution, since some of these takings do add jobs, tax revenues and community amenities.

More judicial scrutiny may help in cases where owners resist a taking. Intermediate kinds of judicial monitoring, especially where there is persuasive evidence of planning mistakes or carelessness, may be a good deterrent. Where a community is not truly distressed or not suffering a long economic decline, a court may discourage takings with obvious private benefits for profit-making businesses. With communities in decline, courts could defer to local solutions to local problems, especially where reasonable planning is used and state monitoring occurs.

There may also be ways to increase the size of the just compensation awards that are required by the "takings clauses" of the U.S. and state constitutions. This is a fair way to spread condemnation costs to a larger tax-paying public, even though not all these costs are compensated for.

Where an affected owner is elderly, or has lived in her property for some time, or has fragile health or conducts a profitable business, these factors, and other reasonably objective ones, may justify larger payments.

If condemnation becomes more expensive, it's likely to be used less often. If that happens, what might take its place in communities worried about present and future job and tax losses, and eventual declines? We may be forced to recall an American tradition. Private enterprise, through private deals and financing, has found imaginative ways to build shopping malls, sports stadiums and even entertainment complexes.

This American way can lead to improved communities, even without the overuse of eminent domain by sometimes despotic and short-sighted governments.


Newsday: www.newsday.com

Ronald H. Silverman is professor of real estate law at Hofstra University School of Law

Eminent domain justified: Branson (MO) Daily News, 7/1/05

By Cliff Sain

Branson's city administrator said he does not feel vindicated by a Supreme Court decision last week that cities can use eminent domain to take property for a private business.

The case has relevance in Branson after the city this year paid $12.8 million for property downtown in order to build a city-owned convention center and a privately owned hotel.

The two are expected to open in April 2007. Two of the property owners would not sell, and the city eventually used its power of eminent domain to take the property owners to court and force them to sell.

"I don't think there's anything to feel vindicated about," Dody said. "We were following legal process. Had the Supreme Court ruled differently, we'd have to abide."

The Supreme Court was sharply divided in its 5-4 decision announced on June 23. In a scathing dissent, Justice Sandra Day O'Connor said the decision bowed to the rich and powerful at the expense of middle-class Americans.

"The specter of condemnation hangs over all property," O'Connor wrote. "Nothing is to prevent the state from replacing any Motel 6 with a Ritz-Carlton, any home with a shopping mall, or any farm with a factory."

Still, legal experts said they didn't expect a rush to claim homes.

"The message of the case to cities is yes, you can use eminent domain, but you better be careful and conduct hearings," said Thomas Merrill, a Columbia law professor specializing in property rights.

Dody agreed, saying the city had no plans to purchase more private property.

"Why would the city do anything differently?" he said.

The closely watched Supreme Court case involved New London, Conn., homeowners.

Justice John Paul Stevens, writing for the majority, said New London could pursue private development under the Fifth Amendment, which allows governments to take private property if the land is for public use, since the project the city has in mind promises to bring more jobs and revenue.

"Promoting economic development is a traditional and long accepted function of government," Stevens wrote, adding that local officials are better positioned than federal judges to decide what's best for a community.

Under the ruling, residents still will be entitled to 'just compensation' for their homes as provided under the Fifth Amendment. The decision also specifically said states had the right to implement restrictions of their own.


Branson Daily News: www.bransondailynews.com

Eminent Domain A New Tool for Business to Use? San Diego (CA) Business Journal, 7/4/05

By Pat Broderick

San Diego businessman Ed Plant is still bitter over losing his land and business to Petco Park.

Predictably, Plant was not heartened when the U.S. Supreme Court recently gave local governments even more authority to seize private property.

“It’s what’s been happening in San Diego already with the (Centre City Development Corp.) the past few years,” said Plant, who owned a cold storage facility in the ballpark’s footprint. “They were just ahead of their time, I guess.”

On June 23, the high court, in a 5-4 split decision, ruled that local governments have the right to take land and, in turn, give it to private developers to spur economic development and tax revenues for the community. The case in question, Kelo v. the city of New London, Conn., involved a group of local homeowners who resisted the taking of their property for commercial development to revitalize the economically depressed East Coast city.

California’s eminent domain law is stricter, requiring that seized property must be designated as blighted. Still, the ruling has stirred mixed reactions among a variety of camps.

Encinitas City Councilman Jerome Stocks on June 29 — alarmed by the ruling — proposed an ordinance that would grant more power to property owners.

Under his plan, Encinitas could not transfer private property to another private owner without first calling for a public vote in a regularly scheduled election, which would need a two-thirds majority to pass. The measure is scheduled to go to the City Council on July 13.

Steven S. Wall, a partner in Luce Forward’s San Diego office and an expert in condemnation and real estate litigation, is especially concerned about the definition of blight.

“In California and San Diego, you will see redevelopment agencies feeling comfortable flexing the power they have under California law to do redevelopment projects, saying, ‘We are able to broadly interpret the word blight, to include inadequate parking, not enough big parcels that can be used for shopping centers or big-box projects,’ ” he said. “ ‘We’re going to redevelop the area, and buy or condemn, and it doesn’t matter whether businesses or homes there are clean or well-kept.’ That is what the decision really means.”

Plant agreed.

“Who is going to be safe?” he said of the ruling. “Basically, all they have to do is say ‘blighted.’ What is the definition of blight? If someone has a home or business, the city can say ‘blighted,’ because it’s not making enough tax revenues. But everything can’t be about revenues going to the government agency. What happened to individual rights?”

Doug Barnhart, the chief executive officer and chairman of the board of the San Diego-based Barnhart Inc., whose firm is among the largest educational facilities builders in the nation, says the ruling will be good for business.

“Yes, I do,” said Barnhart, whose firm recently completed UC Riverside’s digital library. “I’m a Republican and sensitive to property rights. But the problems we have in public facilities in California in general, and San Diego in particular, is ‘not in my neighborhood.’ I think this will work against that. We will be able to put in facilities for the greater public good and locate them where they should be located. Property owners will get fair market value, or they can go to court.

“In any of these things, there is a lot of heartburn,” Barnhart said. “Even with Petco Park, you had some of the companies who relocated not really happy. They’d been there for years and years and years. But now, you’d be hard-pressed to say it wasn’t a benefit.”

Plant doesn’t disagree with that sentiment — up to a point.

“They did a good job Downtown,” said Plant, who continues to run another business, Harborside Refrigerated Services at the 10th Avenue Marine Terminal. “It’s done more for more people in the long run, but I think the city and CCDC isn’t looking for the individual, but the end of the rainbow. I think in the way I was treated, eminent domain has a tendency to be a bully.”

Plant, who contested the seizure of his property in court, ended up with $11 million, although he estimated that his property and business was worth $20 million. Then he was charged $1.6 million to clean up underground storage tanks that, “I didn’t put there” and eventually got about $800,000 of that back. But he was never relocated, said Plant. Instead, he reinvested the money into expanding his Harborside operation, which brings in from 60,000 to 100,000 tons of perishable goods a year. But, said Plant, it hasn’t made up for the demise of his Downtown business and the exodus of some of his customers to new competitors.

“You work most of your life building something, and it’s taken away,” he said. “I had controlled about 80 percent of the market, and now I probably have 30 percent of the market. It derived me a good living, and my property was appreciating Downtown. I planned on putting two high-rises down there. We had people interested.”

There were other ramifications of the seizure, Plant said.

“It messed up my credit rating,” he said. “When you go into eminent domain, the banks go crazy. We had a big moving expense. I am bitter because the CCDC tells half-truths. They tell you they’re going to help you, but in the meantime, they don’t. They just go their merry way. I’m not against the city. I just wish they would have a little more warm and fuzzy feeling for individuals.”

The CCDC is a city-run nonprofit corporation that coordinates redevelopment projects in the Downtown area. David Allsbrook, the manager of contracting and public works for the CCDC, has been involved in many of the city’s major developments, including the venerable Horton Plaza.

“There was a feeling that Ernie Hahn (Horton Plaza developer) wasn’t going to build the center when we were acquiring the property, that we didn’t know what we were doing and wouldn’t get it done,” Allsbrook recalled of the project that is credited with revitalizing the Gaslamp Quarter in the mid-1980s.

“The ballpark is the biggest example of where we had to use our power,” said Allsbrook of another project credited for transforming Downtown.

The Petco Park project resulted in 56 condemnation cases being filed, with all but six settled before trial and one during trial.

“Everybody thinks their property is worth more,” said Allsbrook. “People want to play it out, getting more money. That’s just the way it is.”

Some of the money paid during an eminent domain action is for “loss of good will,” he said.

“You go back and look at tax returns for the previous three years, and you come up with a number of what is the loss of business,” said Allsbrook. “Most businesses will make a claim for loss of good will, and ultimately they get compensated for it.”

While Allsbrook says Plant and all the others affected by the ballpark were treated fairly, he also sympathizes with those targeted through eminent domain.

“Eminent domain is probably the most misunderstood, and is kind of frightening to people,” he said. “We all have property rights, and when we give government that power, it’s a little scary. We’ve always used it as a last resort for projects that have public purposes. Ninety percent of the development has been done without using the power of eminent domain. We have to pay fair market value.”

As for the Supreme Court ruling, Allsbrook said he doesn’t think it will make much difference locally.

“The opinion will have little, if any, impact on how property is acquired in the state,” said Allsbrook. “In California, the law is very clear that in order to take property, it must be in a redevelopment project area.”

But, said Allsbrook, that’s not to say that there is no potential for abuse.

“I would never say that,” he said. “Years ago, National City declared its golf course blighted. They wanted to build a shopping center. That is a stretch, and it was overturned. But the likelihood of it being abused is very small. There are enough checks and balances. When we acquire property, it goes through a community advisory group before it gets to the redevelopment agency.”

No Threat
State Sen. Christine Kehoe, D-San Diego, chairs the Senate committee on local government, which includes redevelopment agencies. She said she doesn’t view the Supreme Court ruling as a particular threat to San Diegans’ property rights.

“California law requires a finding of blight in order to execute eminent domain at the local level,” she said. “You have to go through an open process of public hearings.”

While new development resulting in added taxes would be considered a public benefit, “There world have to be a finding of blight,” Kehoe said. “Simply saying that you would be making more money on a shopping center than a house is not enough. I think that it would have to include areas that are severely underdeveloped or stagnant.

“Where Petco was built, the general area was not experiencing the kind of growth many areas of San Diego were,” she said. “The ballpark became an impetus for spectacular developments — restaurants, hotels, residential. The ballpark is a classic example of how redevelopment should work.”

Kehoe said that, as a homeowner, she feels for the property owners in the New London case.

“I think states that don’t have protections that California has should consider that kind of legislation to protect against local abuses. I think that eminent domain is a tool that should never be abused, and every government body considering eminent domain should be careful to respect private property rights.”

Boon Or Bane?
Jerry Livingston, staff counsel for the Building Industry Association of San Diego, considers the ruling “more of a boon to cities than developers.”

“Rarely do you benefit from this kind of ruling,” he added.

While more doors might now be opened to private developers under the ruling, Livingston said the downside is that those who already have built projects — paying considerable sums for permits and infrastructure improvements — also stand to lose if they’re on the other side. The National Association of Home Builders filed a brief with the Supreme Court in the Kelo case, arguing that a ruling against the property owners could lead to abuses on the part of local governments.

As for local impact, Livingston said, “I don’t know if it will happen immediately in communities here. The right of eminent domain is a two-edged sword for most politicians these days. I think the city will pay close attention to creating redevelopment areas and what the political implications are with eminent domain.”

Pointing to the city’s dire financial straits, Livingston said there could be a temptation “to take advantage of economic development to increase money in city coffers.”

“We will watch what happens at the state level for any proposals to change the redevelopment law,” he said.

But, Kehoe said, for now at least, there is nothing in the pipeline to change the law.

Donna Jones, special counsel in the real estate, land use and environmental practice group for Sheppard Mullin’s San Diego office, has her hand in many of the major projects being developed in the county, including Black Mountain Ranch, a 4,700-acre mixed-use master planned development on the city/county boundary in North County.

“It’s rare that agencies try to condemn property and turn it over to private business,” she said. “I don’t think it will be used routinely. Politicians won’t want to do something where their constituents say, ‘You are in the hands of development,’ but only when it’s necessary and in the community’s best interest.”

The potential for abuse exists, said Jones, especially in San Diego today with so much mistrust of the City Council and government in general.

“Some will be concerned about abuses, that somebody makes a larger contribution, and they decide to do something in favor of that person,” Jones said. “But I trust City Council more than most people. I think they’re trying to do what’s best. They will be careful, knowing that the media will be looking.”

Mitch Mitchell, the vice president of public policy and communications for the San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce, agrees that the ruling will spur more scrutiny against potential abuses.

“Everybody’s saying, ‘Property rights, property rights, property rights,’ ” he said. “We have a lack of land to build on and cities are always going to be looking at more tax opportunities. With all that, there will be scrutiny.

“It’s guaranteed, because of this ruling, that the watchdogs would be more vigilant. In the end, the government will be scrutinized and that public scrutiny is the best check-and-balance you can ask for.”

Attorney Wall added: “The bigger issue here is: What will we see in the way of social changes? Will it encourage redevelopment agencies to go beyond and take a more aggressive stand in the future in terms of a broad definition of public purpose and what is blight? There are challenges. It will come back to taking a hard look at officials elected to public office.”

But the public won’t be the only sector keeping an eye out, predicted Wall.

“The condemnation bar will be watching closely to see what happens,” he said.


San Diego Business Journal: www.sdbj.com

Court's eminent domain decision hailed as victory for cities: St Louis (MO) Post-Dispatch, 7/2/05

By Jim Merkel

A Supreme Court decision handed down last week could influence a number of local cases involving eminent domain.

In a 5-4 vote, the high court upheld the right of a private company in New London, Conn. to take private land for private uses.

In Kelo vs. New London, Conn., the Supreme Court ruled that the city could not take land simply to confer a private benefit on a particular private property. However, the decision said the taking would be executed based on a carefully considered development plan, which would have a public benefit.

The decision pleased [St Louis] Mayor Francis Slay.

"It's very difficult rebuilding an older city with the environmental issues and with the issues of assembling sites for redevelopment to help improve the quality of life for people in our neighborhoods," Slay said.

"The eminent domain has been a good tool for us to acquire property so that we can take older areas and redevelop them into something more positive for the entire city and for the entire region."

But Slay said it's important that officials use good judgment and compassion and only use the tool sparingly when other means of redevelopment aren't working.

One local development that would have been affected by a different decision is the planned Loughborough Commons shopping center at Interstate 55 and Loughbough Avenue. There, 19 homeowners agreed to sell to the developer but a 20th, June Thompson and her son Howard, refused,

Circuit Court Judge Timothy Wilson is now considering whether the Thompsons' home can be taken by eminent domain.

"The decision in the Kelo case takes away an argument that we had as to whether or not this was limited by the U.S. Constitution, said Michael Wolff, the Thompsons' attorney.

But Wolff also argued under a provision in the Missouri Constitution, which he said is more restrictive in allowing the taking of property for private use.

The Missouri Constitution allows the taking of property for blight, "the kind of blight that everybody thinks of," Wolff said. "Our argument is that the Thompsons' neighborhood is not blighted as originally understood back in 1945 (when the rule was originally established)," Wolff said.

"I think the decision from the U.S. Supreme Court is a terrible decision," Wolff said. "What the court is doing is writing out of the Fifth Amendment the term ‘public use.'"

The Fifth Amendment says private property can't be taken for public use without just compensation.

Especially at the local level, the local governments will be more influenced by wealthy members of the electorate, Wolff said.

A different view is held by Alderman Matt Villa, D-11th Ward, who pushed through legislation in the Board of Aldermen calling for Loughborough Commons and allowing eminent domain.

"If eminent domain did not exist, this development would not be going forward," Villa said. "If you did not have the eminent domain tool, one property owner could effectively kill development that is good for the entire region."

Eminent domain should be a tool that's only used in rare circumstances, Villa said. If more than 10 percent of property owners in a redevelopment area are made to sell through eminent domain, that tool shouldn't be used, he said.

If urban areas can't assemble land for development through eminent domain, developers will go to the edge of metropolitan areas, where a single farmer will sell them land, Villa said. This would increase urban sprawl, he said.

"Very little development would get done in the urban areas that are already built out," Villa said.

"Nothing would get developed," Villa said. "That doesn't serve the overall benefit of the city of St. Louis when you have one property owner that can basically say you're not going to do this development."

One landlord who has seen eminent domain used heavily against him is Jim Roos, who runs the landlord management company, Neighborhood Enterprises. Twenty-three apartment buildings managed by the company with 57 units of housing were taken for the Botanical Heights housing development in the McRee Town neighborhood.

Roos said he thinks he knows how the justices came to their decision.

"They've never substantially experienced how eminent domain can be abused. When you start approving eminent domain for private projects, that becomes a mindset for people in government," Roos said.

"People who are a little less popular, a little less affluent then become the ones who are abused by this," Roos said.

Homes of the affluent won't be taken, Roos said. "It's abusing the rights and the benefits of the poor people."


St Louis Post-Dispatch: www.stltoday.com

City forces out 2 downtown businesses: San Francisco (CA) Chronicle, 7/2/05

Action follows high court ruling on eminent domain

By Jim Herron Zamora

Last week's U.S. Supreme Court ruling approving a Connecticut city's plan to take private land by eminent domain may seem far away.

But to John Revelli, whose family has operated a tire shop near downtown Oakland for decades, the implications hit home on Friday.

A team of contractors hired by the city of Oakland packed the contents of his small auto shop in a moving van and evicted Revelli from the property his family has owned since 1949.

"I have the perfect location; my customers who work downtown can drop off their cars and walk back here," said Revelli, 65, pointing at the nearby high- rises. "The city is taking it all away from me to give someone else. It's not fair."

The city of Oakland, using eminent domain, seized Revelli Tire and the adjacent property, owner-operated Autohouse, on 20th Street between Telegraph and San Pablo avenues on Friday and evicted the longtime property owners, who have refused to sell to clear the way for a large housing development.

The U.S. Supreme Court's 5-4 decision last week paved the way for local governments to buy out unwilling property owners, demolish homes and businesses, and turn that land over to new owners for development. Last week's ruling expanded on earlier decisions that allowed agencies to take property only if it is considered "blighted" or run-down.

"The city thinks I cause 'economic blight' because I don't produce enough tax revenue," Revelli said. "We thought we'd win, but the Supreme Court took away my last chance."

The two properties, which total 6,500 square feet, were being forced to move or sell because their businesses are on a larger section of land that is slated for the Uptown Project, a city-subsidized real estate development that is expected to include nearly 1,200 apartments and condominiums.

The project's wedge-shaped lot, just west of the 19th Street BART Station, includes several blocks roughly bounded by 20th Street, 17th Street, Telegraph Avenue and San Pablo Avenue.

Both Revelli Tire and Autohouse, owned and operated by Tony Fung, are on the northern edge of the project in the 400 block of 20th Street, which is also called Thomas L. Berkley Way.

The eviction came as no surprise to Revelli and Fung. The city has designated their block as a redevelopment area for about 20 years. Before approving the Uptown Project last year, the city considered putting in a shopping mall, then an arena for the Golden State Warriors and later a ballpark for the Oakland Athletics.

The decision to build market-rate housing on the site, subsidized by $61 million in city redevelopment funds, is the keystone in Mayor Jerry Brown's plan to revitalize downtown Oakland by putting in homes for 10,000 new residents there.

"This is the part of redevelopment everyone hates," said Hamid Gami, who is coordinating the relocation for Oakland's Community and Economic Development Agency.

"It's tough. They're good people. We've offered them fair compensation, and we hope to come to an agreement. But this is a really important new development. The city has been trying to do this for years. It's good for all of Oakland. It's going to be a great project."

Gami said he hopes to work out a settlement with Revelli and Fung.

The business owners said they clung to hopes that the eminent domain decision might be overturned in court or that they could persuade the city to build the project and leave them alone.

"All those new residents will need someone to work on their cars," said Revelli, who has been working in the shop since he was in third grade helping his dad and uncle. "I don't want their money. I don't want to move. I just want to work right here."

Most of the other businesses closed their doors and left in the past two years. The only other holdout, Chef Edward's Barbeque, is expected to reopen about a block and a half away.

Fung and Revelli said the money offered by the city, about $100 per square foot plus relocation costs, was insufficient, saying the real estate boom has priced them out of nearby properties. They own their properties outright and have operated with low overhead.

"John works alone; I have one technician working with me — that's it," said Fung, who bought his 2,500-square-foot shop in 1993. "The cost of buying or leasing a new site is prohibitive. The money the city offered me does not cover it."

Revelli, who has worked alone for the past 35 years, said no other location is as good as what he is losing.

"My customers are mainly women who work in the offices downtown. They can take BART if they have to leave their cars overnight," Revelli said. "There's really no equivalent location around here."

Both men said Friday that losing their businesses was like losing a piece of themselves.

"I've worked here full time since 1959, and I looked forward to coming to work every day," Revelli said. "I'm not ready to retire, but the city forced me into this. I don't have many options."

Fung, who is in his late 40s and raising his children, said retirement is not an option.

"I'm an immigrant from China, and this has been the fulfillment of my American dream," Fung said. "I worked hard. I played by the rules. But now it's all gone. I've got to start all over."


San Francisco Chronicle: www.sfgate.com

7/01/2005

Never Mind the Kelo, Here's Scott Bullock: Reason Public Policy Institute

An interview with the attorney who argued the landmark eminent domain case, surveying the blight in the wake of the Supreme Court's decision
By Tim Cavanaugh

Reason: Are you surprised by the decision?

Scott Bullock: Well I was surprised. It was rather shocking that a majority of the Supreme Court would permit this type of abuse. We're in an America where, as Justice Sandra Day O'Connor points out, church property can be taken for a Costco, a farm can be turned into a factory, and a neighborhood can be leveled for a shopping mall. Most people cannot believe that this can happen in this country and the Supreme Court gave sanction to that with their decision.

Reason: What did you make of Justice Anthony Kennedy's vote against the plaintiffs?

SB: Yeah, it was surprising. I mean here's a guy who once wrote "individual freedom finds tangible expression in property rights." For him to be in a decision that fundamentally violates the right to own and enjoy your property, I think, is disgraceful.

Reason: Is there any recourse to the plaintiffs now?

SB: There is. There are going to be battles on two fronts. One, we're going to do everything in our power to keep these people in their homes. And we're going to explore all options to do so. But one thing that's coming out of this opinion that's very clear is that people are furious about this. And the anger comes from the left, right, libertarians, and everybody in between. People cannot believe that the court sanctioned something like this. So, I think that the growing grassroots rebellion against this is going to gain momentum. And I think that you'll see litigation about this in state courts, where the battle will largely be, at least for the time being. And you'll see a number of legislative changes though both legislatures and then also through the initiative process, as well. And we'll be there every step of the way to make sure that these abuses stop.

Reason: Given how many frivolous Constitutional amendments get proposed there days, why isn't there a serious movement for an amendment that would more narrowly define eminent domain powers?

SB: There's already discussion of doing so. And, as I said, this is a time to really think big about these issues because it's clear that a narrow majority of the Supreme Court has given the potential for businesses and local governments to work together to take people's land. And I think it was a real wake-up call to people that something has to be done about this. And hopefully we'll see some major changes.

Reason: How is this going to affect lower court decisions in other eminent domain cases, such as the Michigan Supreme Court's reversal of the Poletown decision last year?

SB: What's important to point out is that even the majority admitted that state courts are free to interpret their own provisions in a manner that's more protective of property rights. Thankfully, every state Constitution has prohibitions against private takings and a requirement that takings be for public use. And, only six states have held that economic development condemnations are Constitutional. Nine have held that they are not. And most states have not addressed it.

Reason: States that have ruled in favor include Connecticut, presumably?

SB: Connecticut, Kansas, Maryland, Minnesota, New York and North Dakota: Those are the states that have said that this is acceptable to their state constitutions. Nine states have said that it's not. And then, most states have not addressed it. So, state courts, when this issue comes before them, are free to give greater protections to property owners and hopefully stop this practice in their states.

Reason: Speaking of private economic development, the import of the decision has largely been seen as clearing the way for seizures for private economic development, but that's not really unprecedented. Even railroads were private endeavors. So are we seeing something new here or does this decision just affirm the status quo?

SB: It's very different from something like a railroad. A railroad typically follows a very narrow strip of land. Railroads and utilities are what are known in the law as something called common carriers. So even though they might be privately owned, they're really the equivalent of public bodies because everybody, the public, has an equal right to them. Everybody has a right to the utility line. And they're very tightly controlled by public officials, so they're really the equivalent of public bodies; that's why the court upheld them. Here, we're talking about ordinary private uses of land—taking somebody's home for a Costco, taking Church property to give to another private owner. That's why this opinion is so sweeping and it's so far removed from even what the courts did in the railroad cases, or even in the situations involving blight. Because even in those cases, the government had to show that there was some type of harmful condition to that land before it was justified for condemnation. Here, the court said, whatever land the developers happen to desire is up for grabs.

Reason: The irony is that we're in this period of resurgence for American cities. Most major cities are doing better now than they have in decades, and arguments about urban blight are hard to make. Given yesterday's lifting of the need to prove an area is blighted, how do you expect that to play out?

SB: I think it puts more and more properties up for grabs because here it will be dependent, not on whether or not the property is blighted, but whether it happens to be desired by private parties. So you're going to see people of less economic means, poorer folks, middle class folks who happen to live in the city and live in desirable neighborhoods that are going to be targeted by these types of takings. That's the real travesty of this, and that's one of the strongest points made by Justice O'Connor and Justice Thomas, that this is going to fall hardest on people of limited financial means. And it's going to be to the benefit of the wealthy and the government.

Reason: One of the disheartening aspects of this decision is that two of the four dissenters are not long for the court. Justice William Renquist is pretty ill and Justice O'Connor is said to be close to retiring. Do you have any predictions about how a change in the Supreme Court composition will affect property rights?

SB: Well, I don't know. These things are always hard to predict. Look at Justice Kennedy's track record on property rights. But this is also the case where you could have a member of the court who might be more from the left but come to a very different decision from what some of the more liberal members of this court decided. As I mentioned, there are a number of people who are concerned about civil liberties, concerned about decisions that affect the poor and minorities, who are outraged about this.

One point you hear from some people who are trying to defend this decision is that the government went through a planning process in this case, that this is part of a well-developed plan. The idea that having a plan and going through a planning process protects property owners in any way is completely disconnected from reality. I mean, every development in this country has a planning process. You can't just show up in an open field one day and say, "Well I'm here to build my office park." Everything in this country has to go through a process, has to be announced, has to have hearings; to think that this provides any protection for property owners who face the loss of their homes and small businesses is nonsense. And it shows how some members of this Court and some defenders of this policy don't understand how these things really pan out in the real world.

Reason: Can you give some examples of other eminent domain abuses among the 10,000 cases you guys have cited?

SB: I'll give you one primary example that's brewing in Long Branch, New Jersey right now, where a group of people want to hang on to their working-class beach homes. They've worked very hard to get their modest bungalows along the shore. These houses were purchased by working class folks in Newark and other places, and now many of the elderly residents live there full-time; these are their dream homes. And the City of Long Branch is just proposing taking these people's homes and transferring them to wealthier home-owners. They want to tear them down and build million-dollar condominiums for people right along the shore in northern New Jersey. And so it's a case of taking the property of poorer folks and giving it to wealthier folks, and using it for the same purpose. It's just a transfer of wealth between home owners. It's a classic example of eminent domain abuse and one that I think will be litigated in the very near future.

Reason: Is that going to be a new wrinkle, that the property is going to be used for the same purpose?

SB: Well, possibly. There are a number of ways to challenge these types of takings. And I'm sure there will be many issues that are brought up in that case and some of the other ongoing controversies.

Reason: Where are the real outrages happening? Is New London more typical, or is something like Washington, D.C.'s stadium grab a more characteristic situation?

SB: The problem is that there are so many examples of eminent domain abuse. It's hard to find one that captures it entirely. New London was a classic example of this, but there are several others as well. They typically fall under two categories: One is when the government takes land just simply to produce more tax revenue. That was the situation that was going on in New London. The other thing is what we call the abuse of blight laws. An example of that is a case we were involved in in Lakewood, Ohio, where the government used blight laws simply as a means to an end. They're not really concerned about conditions in the neighborhood; they simply want to have it declared blighted so they can get the property and transfer it to private developers. The criteria that the City of Lakewood used to get the neighborhood declared blighted included such things as that the homes were lacking central air conditioning, didn't have an attached two-car garage, or lacked full bathrooms. It was really a means to an end, and the abuse of blight laws is an ongoing controversy and also encompasses a lot of the examples we point to of eminent domain abuse.


Reason Public Policy Institute: www.rppi.org

Hail Seizers! Reason Public Policy Institute

The New York Times cheers on the land grabbers

By Jacob Sullum

The New York Times welcomed the Supreme Court's recent endorsement of virtually unfettered eminent domain powers as "a setback to the 'property rights' movement." The fact that the Times not only celebrated a defeat for property rights but felt a need to put the phrase in scare quotes speaks volumes about the left-liberal misconceptions that have been brought to the fore by the Court's decision in Kelo v. New London.

According to the Court, the Fifth Amendment, which allows the government to take property "for public use" provided it pays "just compensation," is a license to transfer any parcel of land from its current owner to someone the government thinks will make better use of it. "Under the banner of economic development," noted Justice Sandra Day O'Connor in her dissent, "all private property is now vulnerable to being taken and transferred to another private owner, so long as it might be upgraded—i.e., given to an owner who will use it in a way that the legislature deems more beneficial to the public."

In an editorial headlined "The Limits of Property Rights," the Times called this decision "a welcome vindication of cities' ability to act in the public interest." It said the redevelopment plan at issue in Kelo, which involves leveling the Fort Trumbull neighborhood of New London, Connecticut, to make way for a conference center, restaurants, and shops, "may hurt a few small property owners," but "many more residents are likely to benefit if the city can shore up its tax base and attract badly needed jobs."

The collectivist logic here is worthy of a Soviet central planner: The government decides what "the public interest" is and allocates resources accordingly, without regard to the private plans of the individuals who happen to own those resources. It's OK if people are hurt in the process, because on balance the welfare of the group will improve.

For the Times, acting in the public interest includes reassigning property rights based on the government's determination of which owners will generate the most tax revenue and jobs. In New London, the public interest happens to coincide with the interests of Pfizer, which inspired the city's redevelopment plan when it decided to open a new research facility adjacent to Fort Trumbull. In New York City, the public interest happens to coincide with the interests of The New York Times, which used eminent domain to forcibly obtain the land on which it is building its new headquarters.

Mindful of the appearance that big corporations such as Pfizer and the New York Times Co. use eminent domain for their own ends, the Times cautioned that "eminent domain must not be used for purely private gain." But as O'Connor noted, "nearly any lawful use of real private property can be said to generate some incidental benefit to the public." If the Fifth Amendment requires only that a taking provide some such benefit, she wrote, "the words 'for public use' do not realistically exclude any takings."

The Times, even while mentioning its own abuse of eminent domain, conceded that O'Connor raised "a serious concern." But it called her fears "exaggerated," since "the majority strongly suggested that eminent domain should be part of a comprehensive plan."

So contrary to the alarming reports you may have seen, the government cannot simply force you to sell your home or business, at a price of its choosing, for the convenience of a developer, a big-box retailer, or some other politically influential land grabber. It has to have a plan first. Maybe.

The nonchalance of the Times regarding eminent domain abuse is of a piece with its derogation of property rights, which it sees as inferior to so-called human rights. (Try to imagine the Times running a celebratory editorial on "The Limits of Human Rights.") Yet property rights are human rights: Your ownership of your house stems from your ownership of your body and the fruits of your labor.

In this light, all rights are property rights, without which it would be impossible to exercise, say, freedom of religion or freedom of the press. How free would The New York Times be if people could occupy its offices at will?

Then again, since the owners of the Times have implicitly identified the paper's new digs as a "public use," perhaps they wouldn't mind.


Reason Public Policy Institute: www.rppi.org

Jacob Sullum is a senior editor at Reason and the author of Saying Yes: In Defense of Drug Use

Homeowners Making Way for Government Bulldozers: Reason Public Policy Institute, 6/27/05

The Supreme Court decides property rights aren't rights after all

By Samuel R. Staley

You may think your home is your castle, but the Supreme Court decided it is just on loan from your friendly local government. The government can now bulldoze your home anytime it wants as long as the legally-required number of public hearings are held and politicians have some semblance of a plan for economic development on your land.

That's what any reasonable person reviewing the Supreme Court's recent decision in Kelo v. New London might think. Hundreds of local governments already take private property. The Supreme Court's ruling in the Kelo eminent domain case just gave them the rubber stamp they wanted.

Kelo involves a hardy band of home and business owners in the historic neighborhood of Fort Trumbull in New London, Connecticut. The city, acting through its redevelopment arm, condemned the homes and businesses to make way for new professional office buildings, swanky retail shops, luxury condos and apartments.

The city's "vision" for the neighborhood, local officials hope, will generate more tax revenue. The newer buildings, bigger tax base, and more revenue constituted a "public use" in their eyes - and the Supreme Court agreed.

Eminent domain is not a new government power. It's been around for centuries and is enshrined in the Fifth Amendment to the U.S. Constitution. What's new is the brazenness in which governments use it. Eminent domain is supposed to help governments when they need to provide a public use. In the past, building roads, acquiring land for schools and public buildings, constructing bridges and canals, or providing parks qualified.

In the mid-1980s, that changed when the Michigan Supreme Court allowed the City of Detroit to demolish a close-knit, working class neighborhood called Poletown to make way for a factory. The city condemned the properties, bulldozed the homes, and handed the land over to General Motors to build its plant.

The Michigan Supreme Court reversed its decision in 2004, but the damage was done. The decision unleashed a wave of condemnations, like New London's, that shoved long-time residents and businesses aside in the name of economic development.

"Promoting economic development is a traditional and long accepted function of government," Justice John Paul Stevens wrote in the Court's majority opinion on Kelo.

The Court says public use can now basically be interpreted as any function of government. Indeed, this is exactly what Justice Sandra Day O'Connor fears. "Today nearly all real property is susceptible to condemnation on the court's theory," Justice Sandra Day O'Connor wrote in her strongly-worded opposition to the ruling. "The specter of condemnation hangs over all property. Nothing is to prevent the state from replacing any Motel 6 with a Ritz-Carlton, any home with a shopping mall, or any farm with a factory."

Sound extreme? Consider the words of New London's lead attorney during oral arguments in the case:

Justice O'Connor asked if the city could condemn a Motel 6 and hand the land over to a Ritz-Carlton if the city thought the move would generate more tax revenue.

Wesley Horton, New London's attorney, replied, "Yes, Your Honor. That would be okay."

"So you can always take from A and give to B if B pays more taxes?" asked Justice Antonin Scalia.

"If they are significantly more taxes," said Horton.

A shopping mall or business complex will almost always generate significantly more tax revenue than private homes, meaning we are all at risk.

Sad is it may be, many people ignored eminent domain in the past because it seemed to apply mainly to the poor—removing so-called "urban blight". The poor have always been at a disadvantage because they were renters or couldn't afford attorneys to fight city hall. Now, eminent domain is removing the middle class. Only the rich may be safe from the government bulldozers.

Private property rights were once a hedge against government corruption and abuse. This protection was so essential the Founding Fathers explicitly limited its use to special circumstances - public uses only - and required "just compensation" be provided to homeowners.

Now, there appears to be few "rights" left in private property rights. The U.S. Supreme Court just told every city, county, and state government that they can go after your home to increase revenues. The Court even put it in writing.


Reason Public Policy Institute: www.RPPI.org

Dr Samuel R. Staley (sam.staley@reason.org) is Director of Urban and Land Use Policy at Reason Foundation and co-editor of the book Smarter Growth: Market-Based Strategies for Land-Use Planning in the 21st Century (Greenwood Press). He is also the author of the report "Study: Eminent Domain, Private Property and Redevelopment" — available online at:
www.rppi.org/ps331polsum.pdf.

Legislators Move to Blunt Eminent Domain Ruling: The Washington (DC) Post, 6/30/05

By Mike Allen and Charles Babington

Key leaders of both parties in both chambers of Congress vowed today to use the power of the purse to negate this week's Supreme Court ruling allowing local and state governments to use eminent domain to take private property for economic development purposes.

Bills introduced in the House and Senate would yank federal funds from any city or state project that forced people to sell their property to make way for a project like a hotel or strip mall.

The 5-to-4 Supreme Court decision on Monday, the last day of the term, has sparked an immediate and visceral backlash among conservatives. The response on Capitol Hill was unusual for its speed and bipartisan support, and for the biting language the lawmakers used to criticize the high court.

House Majority Leader Tom DeLay (R-Tex.) said the planned intervention by Congress is part of a broad effort to "assert the responsibility and the authority of the Congress to be a check on the judiciary.

"Times have changed, particularly in the last two to three years," DeLay said during a rare appearance in the studio of the House Radio-TV Gallery. "This Congress is not going to just sit by — idly sit by — and let an unaccountable judiciary make these kinds of decisions without taking our responsibility and our duty given to us by the Constitution to be a check on the judiciary. And this is an example of doing that."

The ruling permits the "taking" of a home or neighborhood, with compensation, for such purposes as the construction of a shopping center. Activists said it has struck such a nerve that it will now be a key issue in convincing conservatives and libertarians to join the confirmation battle when one of the justices steps down.

House Judiciary Committee Chairman F. James Sensenbrenner Jr. (R-Wis.) said he will introduce a Private Property Rights Protection Act that will prohibit any state or municipality from using federal funds for any project in which economic development is used as a justification for exercising eminent domain.

"This decision, in my opinion, has the potential of becoming the Dred Scott decision of the 21st century," Sensenbrenner said. He was referring to the 1857 ruling that affirmed slaves as property without the rights of citizens, and was overturned when the 14th amendment was ratified in 1868.

A committee description said the locality or state would "lose any federal funds that would contribute in any way to the project the property would be taken for." The lead Democratic sponsor is Rep. John Conyers Jr. (Mich.), ranking minority member of the Judiciary Committee, and the committee said at least two other Democrats are co-sponsors.

Sen. John Cornyn (R-Tex.) is introducing a similar measure in the Senate, along with Sen. Bill Nelson (D-Fla.). Their measure — the Protection of Homes, Small Businesses and Private Property Act — relies on the authority of the legislature to regulate the use of federal funds, and declares the view of Congress that "the power of eminent domain should be exercised only 'for public use' " and not "to further private economic development."

Sensenbrenner said at the news conference that the federal government's money "will not be used to finance taking somebody's property from them to build a strip mall or a hotel or something simply because more tax revenue will come in as a result of an improvement." He said the decision, Kelo v. City of New London, "shows that the majority of the court had an utter disrespect for private property."

DeLay said as he left the news conference that he views the legislation as part of the review of congressional oversight of the judiciary that he requested after the death of Terri Schiavo, a Floridian who died March 31 after her feeding tube was removed despite congressional intervention to establish her rights in federal court.

"People are starting to understand what we've been talking about for the last two to three years," he said.

House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi (D-Calif.) said at an earlier news conference that "very central in that Constitution is the separation of powers."

"When you withhold funds from enforcing a decision of the Supreme Court, you are in fact nullifying a decision of the Supreme Court," Pelosi said. "This is in violation of the respect of separation of powers in our Constitution — church and state as well. Sometimes the Republicans have a problem with that, as well."

In opposing a Republican amendment about the issue today, Rep. David Obey (Wis.), ranking Democrat on the House Appropriations Committee, said on the floor today that the decision was "nutty" but that the solution is legislation or a constitutional amendment, not punitive measures.

"The idea that this House, every time we don't like a court decision, should decide that we're not going to allow federal money to be used to enforce that court decision is as nutty as the original court decision in the first place," Obey said. "So I would hope that we would recognize that the Founding Fathers created the system of separation of powers. They created three independent branches of government for a purpose."


The Washington Post: www.washingtonpost.com